close 
Please wait...

Tommy O'Toole

W L D
12 1 1
10 KOs 0 KOs
last 6


bouts 14
rounds 69
KOs 11%
 
global ID 54911
birth nameFrancis O'Toole
born 1886-12-17
death date1971-01-25 / age 84
debut1905-02-04 / age 18
divisionfeatherweight
height5′ 4½″   /   164cm
residence
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA

newspaper decisions
bouts rounds won lost drawn
95 500 53 14 14

Career Record

date lbs opponent lbs
record 
location
result 
rounds
1913-03-14
Eddie O'Keefe13 3 2
Nonpareil A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
LNWS6/6
 L 
NWS
6/6
  
(Newspaper decision in favor of O'Keefe from the Philadelphia Record, Philadelphia Public Ledger, and Philadelphia Inquirer)
1913-01-27
Eddie Moy12 1 2
Olympia A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
LNWS6/6
 L 
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision in favor of Moy from the Philadelphia Public ledger.
1912-11-15
Gene Delmont3 2 1
Nonpareil A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
DNWS6/6
 D 
NWS
6/6
  
Both the Philadelphia Record and the Philadelphia Item judged this fight to be a draw.
1912-10-19
Stanley Scully4 2 0
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
The Philadelphia Record and the Philadelphia Item both gave their newspaper decision in favor of O'Toole.
1912-09-07
Frankie Fleming17 3 4
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision from the Philadelphia Item and the Philadelphia Record, both in favor of O'Toole.
1912-06-05
123Johnny Kilbane27 3 6
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
LNWS6/6
 L 
NWS
6/6
  
referee: Jack McGuigan
(Philadelphia Inquirer) The Philadelphia Item and the Philadelphia, as well as the Inquirer, reported that Kilbane was the winner.
1912-05-17
128Bobby Scanlon1282 1 0
Nonpareil A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision from the Philadelphia Item as in favor of O'Toole
1912-05-10
Jimmy Toland2 1 0
Nonpareil A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision in favor of O'Toole from the Philadelphia Item.
1912-03-30
Billy Marchant11 0 0
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision in favor of O'Toole from both the Philadelphia Item and the Philadelphia Record.
1912-03-09
Billy Marchant11 0 0
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
O'Toole won the newspaper decision given by both the Philadelphia Item and the Philadelphia Record.
1912-02-16
Tommy Houck6 2 1
Nonpareil A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
O'Toole won the newspaper decision according to both the Philadelphia Item and the Philadelphia Inquirer. Houck did not fight Young Nitchie on this date, as was shown here previously.
1911-12-22
Danny McCabe5 1 0
Nonpareil A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
O'Toole won the newspaper decision from the Philadelphia Inquirer, Philadelphia Record, and Philadelphia Item.
1911-12-18
Gene McGovern18 10 7
American A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision in favor of O'Toole from the Phildelphia Item.
1911-11-30
Johnny Dundee4 0 0
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
DNWS6/6
 D 
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision in both the Philadelphia Item and the Philadelphia Record was a draw, however O'Toole took counts of "nine" in both rounds 4 and 6.
1911-11-10
Benny Kaufman21 2 3
Nonpareil A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision from the Philadelphia Item was in favor of O'Toole. The Philadelphia Record scored this fight as even.
1911-09-05
Jimmy Toland2 1 0
Douglas A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
LNWS6/6
 L 
NWS
6/6
  
O'Toole floored for a short count in the second round. (Philadelphia Item) This was a big upset.
1911-08-22
Bobby Reynolds3 1 0
Douglas A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
Philadelphia Record for O'Toole--Philadelphia Item had the fight even.
1911-08-08
Tommy O'Dare5 0 0
Douglas A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision in favor of O'Toole from both the Philadelphia Record and the Philadelphia Item.
1911-02-08
122Digger Stanley12259 8 7
American A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
DNWS6/6
 D 
NWS
6/6
  
referee: Jack O'Brien
The Philadelphia Record gave its newspaper decision to Stanley, but the Item preferred O'Toole.
1911-01-07
Johnny Kilbane19 2 4
American A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
DNWS6/6
 D 
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision from the Philadelphia Item was a draw between Kilbane and O'Toole.
1911-01-02
Joe Coster4 1 1
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
LNWS6/6
 L 
NWS
6/6
  
Coster won the newspaper decision given by the Philadelphia Record. The Philadelphia Item had it as a draw.
1910-10-29
Young Jack O'Brien7 5 1
Central A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W DQ5/6
 W  
DQ
5/6
  
Result from the Philadelphia Record.
1910-05-20
Boyo Driscoll2 3 2
Nonpareil A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision in favor of O'Toole from both the Philadelphia Item and the Philadelphia Record.
1910-05-06
Patsy Kline15 2 2
Nonpareil A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
LNWS6/6
 L 
NWS
6/6
  
1910-03-19
Tommy Rawson Sr12 3 11
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
O'Toole won the newspaper decision according to both the Philadelphia Item and the Philadelphia Record.
1910-02-26
Philadelphia Pal Moore11 0 2
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
LNWS6/6
 L 
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision from the Philadelphia Record was "draw." However the Philadelphia Item saw Moore as the winner.
1910-02-05
Billy Allen15 2 8
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
DNWS6/6
 D 
NWS
6/6
  
The Philadelphia Inquirer's newspaper decision was "draw." Both the Philadelphia Record and the Philadelphia Item considered O'Toole to be the winner.
1910-01-15
Billy Allen14 2 8
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
LNWS6/6
 L 
NWS
6/6
  
(Philadelphia Inquirer) The Philadelphia Record also gave its newspaper decision to Allen.
1909-12-25
Charlie Griffin20 9 2
Nonpareil A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
O'Toole won the newspaper decision (Philadelphia Inqurer). The Philadelphia Record and the Philadelphia Item also had O'Toole as the winner.
1909-11-09
Jimmy Walsh29 8 12
Armory, Boston, Massachusetts, USA
DPTS12/12
 D 
PTS
12/12
  
referee: Dick Fleming
Boston Journal 10 November 1909
1909-09-25
Patsy Kline14 2 2
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
O'Toole won the newspaper decision from both the Philadelphia Item and the Philadelphia Record.
1909-09-14
Abe Attell56 5 14
Armory, Boston, Massachusetts, USA
LPTS12/12
 L 
PTS
12/12
  
referee: Charlie White
World Featherweight Title
Both fighters weighed in at 122 at 6 o'clock (Philadelphia Inquirer).
1909-09-06
Yankee Schwartz7 1 2
West End A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision from both the Philadelphia Item and the Philadelphia Record was in favor of O'Toole.
1909-06-25
Nathan Ehrlich4 1 0
Nonpareil A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision from both the Philadelphia Item and the Phladelphia Record in favor of O'Toole.
1909-06-19
Ad Wolgast121½39 1 8
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
Both the Philadelphia Record and the Philadelphia Item said that O'Toole won.
1909-04-20
Al Delmont59 8 32
Armory, Boston, Massachusetts, USA
W PTS12/12
 W  
PTS
12/12
  
1909-03-20
Joe Bowker27 6 1
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W KO2/6
 W  
KO
2/6
  
referee: Jack McGuigan
As Jem Bowker of England (Philadelphia Inquirer). Result also as given in the Philadelphia Record and Philadelphia Item.
1909-03-12
Johnny Allen19 6 0
Nonpareil A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decisions from the Philadelphia Item and Philadelphia Record. both in favor of O'Toole.
1908-12-09
Owen Moran42 5 3
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
LNWS6/6
 L 
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision in favor of Owen Moran.
1908-10-30
Harry Baker7 6 0
State A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
The Philadelphia Record favored O'Toole and the Philadelphia Item called it a draw.
1908-09-19
Frankie Neil17 7 3
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
O'Toole won the newspaper decision of both the Philadelphia Item and the Philadelphia Record.
1908-05-02
Tommy Devlin9 0 0
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
DNWS6/6
 D 
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision from the Philadelphia Item in favor of a draw.
1908-04-03
Kid Beebe16 11 5
Ontario A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
O'Toole won the "newspaper decision" per the Philadelphia Item and the Philadelphia Record.
1908-03-23
Teddy Maloney9 0 0
West End A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
O'Toole was judged the winner by both the Philadelphia Item and the Record. A previous BoxRec editor said that O'Toole was said to be from Gray's Ferry, which is correct, but Gray's Ferry is a section of Philadelphia.
1908-01-31
Percy Cove11 4 2
Ontario A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision from the Philadelphia Item and the Philadelphia Record was in favor of O'Toole.
1907-12-21
125Grover Hayes12534 1 4
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
DNWS6/6
 D 
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision from the Philadelphia Item was called even.
1907-11-23
Tommy O'Keefe6 2 0
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision in favor of O'Toole from both the Philadelphia Item and the Philadelphia Record.
1907-10-19
Owen Moran39 5 1
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
LNWS6/6
 L 
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision in favor of Moran from both the Philadelphia Item and Philadelphia Record.
1907-06-01
Harry Baker7 5 0
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
DNWS6/6
 D 
NWS
6/6
  
Both the Philadelphia Item and the Philadelphia Record called this fight a draw.
1907-05-04
Freddie Weeks6 0 1
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
Both the Philadelphia Record and the Philadelphia Item voted that O'Toole was the winner of the newspaper decision.
1907-04-17
Abe Attell42 4 10
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
Both fighters weighed in at 122lbs. Philadelphia Inquirer, Philadelphia Item, Philadelphia Record all gave the newspaper decision to O'Toole.
1907-02-23
Harry Baker2 0 0
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
LNWS6/6
 L 
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision of the Philadelphia Item was in favor of Baker.
1907-01-12
Darkey Haley8 6 3
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
The Philadelphia Inquirer called it a draw, but the Philadelphia Item gave it to O'Toole (close).
1906-11-10
Eddie Kelly17 5 11
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
DNWS6/6
 D 
NWS
6/6
  
(Philadelphia Inquirer 12-9-1906)
1906-09-06
Joe Thiel9 0 0
Broadway A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
LNWS6/6
 L 
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision from the Philadelphia Item in favor of Thiel.
1906-06-08
Ike Bradley40 10 3
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
1906-05-23
Eddie Kelly17 5 11
Tuxedo A.C., Essington, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS20/20
 W  
NWS
20/20
  
The Philadelphia Item called O'Toole the winner.
1906-04-21
Johnny Dwyer1 1 0
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision from the Philadelphia Item, in favor of O'Toole.
1906-03-24
Johnny Dwyer1 1 0
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision from the Philadelphia Item in favor of O'Toole.
1906-03-05
Harry Forbes77 11 24
Washington S.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision for O'Toole from New York Morning Telegraph, Boston Globe, and the Philadelphia Item. Weigh-in at 120 lbs at 3 PM.
1906-01-27
Jimmy Walsh24 3 9
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
LNWS6/6
 L 
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision in favor of Walsh from the Philadelphia Item.
1906-01-01
Griff Jones37 5 5
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision from the Philadelphia Item and Philadelphia Inquirer, both in favor of O'Toole.
1905-12-16
Rouse O'Brien25 4 5
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper deccision from the Philadelphia Item. This was a clear win for O'Toole.
1905-11-30
Kid Murphy19 5 6
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision from the Philadelphia Item favor of O'Toole.
1905-11-20
Harry Decker14 2 1
Washington S.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision from the Philadelphia Item was ub favor of O'Toole.
1905-11-11
Willie Moody7 0 0
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
O'Toole won the newspaper decision given by the Philadelphia Item.
1905-10-27
Young Crosta7 4 0
Richmond A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
O'Toole won the newspaper decision of the Philadelphia Item.
1905-10-07
Tommy Langdon10 1 0
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision from the Philadelphia Item in favor of O'Toole.
1905-09-29
Tommy 'Young' Kilpatrick12 2 0
Kensington A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision of the Philadelphia Item was in favor of O'Toole, who won decisively.
1905-09-23
Jimmy Walsh23 3 9
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
DNWS6/6
 D 
NWS
6/6
  
According to the Philadelphia Item, this was a "torrid 6-round draw."
1905-09-04
Jimmy Walsh23 3 9
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision in favor of O'Toole and from the Philadelphia Item.
1905-08-25
Willie Gibbs7 1 0
Kensington A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
DNWS6/6
 D 
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision in favor of a draw between O'Toole and Gibbs from the Philadelphia Item
1905-08-21
Kid Egan5 3 3
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision in favor of O'Toole from the Philadelphia Item.
1905-07-28
Jack Langdon2 0 0
Kensington A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision in favor of O'Toole from the Philadelphia Item.
1905-06-24
Willie Moody7 0 0
Richmond A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
DNWS6/6
 D 
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision from the Philadelphia Item was "draw." It was a "hectic" fight, at 115 lbs. (Both men gained weight as their careers proceeded.)
1905-04-07
Jack Langdon2 0 0
Kensington A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
DNWS6/6
 D 
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision in favor of a draw from the Philadelphia Item.
1905-03-24
Danny Dougherty25 8 9
Knickerbocker A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
Philadelphia Record reported a win for Dougherty. Philadelphia Inquirer reported a win for O'Toole. The Philadelphia Item also had O'Toole winning.
1905-02-25
Young Kelly7 7 0
Richmond A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W TKO6/5
 W  
TKO
6/5
  
Result is from the Philadelphia Item.
1905-02-23
Young Kelly7 6 0
Broadway A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W TKO5/6
 W  
TKO
5/6
  
Result from the Philadelphia Item was in favor of O'Toole.
1905-02-18
Willie Gibbs7 0 0
Richmond A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision in favor of O'Toole, from the Philadelphia Item.
1905-02-06
Tommy 'Young' Kilpatrick10 0 0
Kensington A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision from the Philadelphia Item in favor of O'Toole.
1905-02-04
Griff Jones35 4 5
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision from the Philadelphia Item was in favor of O'Toole.
1905-01-27
Kid Hogan1 0 0
Frankford A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision in favor of O'Toole from the Philadelphia Item.
1905-01-14
Willie Gibbs7 0 0
National A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision in favor of O'Toole from the Philadelphia Item.
1905-01-07
Tommy 'Young' Kilpatrick10 0 0
Richmond A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
Newspaper decision from the Philadelphia IUtem was in favor of O'Toole.
1904-12-23
Tommy 'Young' Kilpatrick10 0 0
Frankford A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
LNWS6/6
 L 
NWS
6/6
  
Kilpatrick was judged winner by the Philadelphia Item in a big upset.
1904-12-17
Joe O'Hara5 6 0
Richmond A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W NWS6/6
 W  
NWS
6/6
  
O'Toole had the better of it according to the Philadelphia Item.
1904-12-16
Johnny McCaffreydebut
Manhattan A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W KO4/6
 W  
KO
4/6
  
O'Toole stopped McCaffrey according to the Philadelphia Item.
1904-12-09
Rox Maguire2 4 0
Manhattan A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W TKO2/6
 W  
TKO
2/6
  
Result from the Philadelphia Item was in favor of O'Toole. Maguire was billed as "Young Rox Maguire."
1904-11-19
Tommy McGovern2 1 0
Richmond A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
DNWS6/6
 D 
NWS
6/6
  
A draw for O'Toole and McGovern from the Philadelphia Item.
1904-11-12
Jimmy McCaffrey0 3 0
Richmond A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W TKO3/6
 W  
TKO
3/6
  
From the Philadelphia Item.
1904-10-22
Tommy McGovern2 0 0
Richmond A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W KO1/6
 W  
KO
1/6
  
The Philadelphia Item reported that O'Toole was a quick winner over McGovern.
1904-10-15
Kid Mallon0 1 0
Richmond A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W KO1/6
 W  
KO
1/6
  
From the Philadelphia Item.
1904-10-08
Johnny Murray0 2 0
Richmond A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W KO1/6
 W  
KO
1/6
  
Result from the Philadelphia Item.
1904-09-24
Kid Scanlondebut
Richmond A.C., Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
W TKO3/6
 W  
TKO
3/6
  
This may have been O'Toole's professional debut.
W
Win
L
Loss
D
Draw
N
No Contest
S
Scheduled/Pending
 event
 tape
 bout
 Encyclopaedia
verified
unverified
unsanctioned