1887-11-16 (133lbs) Jem Carney drew 74 (finish) Jack McAuliffe, Atlantic Hotel, Westerly, Rhode Island, USA
1887-11-16 (133lbs) Jem Carney drew 74 (finish) Jack McAuliffe, Atlantic Hotel, Westerly, Rhode Island, USA. Referee: Frank Stevenson. Held in a stable attached to the hotel and six miles from Boston, Massachusets, the fight was contested in skin-tight gloves under MoQ Rules. Despite being down three times in the first round, Carney (128) pulled himself together and started to make the body his target. From the 28th session McAuliffe (130½) started to go to ground to avoid punishment and from the 70th he was knocked down repeatedly. Following the fight, Carney (128), who had McAuliffe (130½) down and out at the time of the stoppage (due to the ring being broken into by McAuliffe’s supporters), had a clear claim to the 133lbs title.
The fight had lasted for four hours, 56 minutes and the referee suggested a postponement of up to a week for the bout to be resumed. However, while Carney was in good condition, a couple of days later McAuliffe was under medical care and in no condition to fight on, leaving the Englishman robbed of the decision.