1888-01-25 McHenry Johnson w disq 4 (finish) George Godfrey, Boulder County, Colorado, USA
1888-01-25 George Godfrey w rsc 4 (finish) McHenry Johnson, Colorado, USA. Contested in four-ounce gloves about 15 miles from Denver, after two tame rounds Godfrey almost knocked Johnson senseless in the third and then continued to pound the latter around the ring at will. In the fourth Godfrey was again completely on top with Johnson unable to do much about it other than hold on for dear life. Told to break by the referee Godfrey continued to pound away, eventually knocking Johnson to the floor with a right to the jaw. Although Johnson, who had been down three times, was comprehensively beaten his seconds claimed a foul and too much surprise the referee went along with it. Later, however, the Club Committee overruled the decision saying that Godfrey was the rightful winner.
On 14 May 1888, Godfrey challenged John L. Sullivan, who refused point blank. Following that, the Boston Police News stated that Godfrey had every right to the ‘black’ title.