1892-02-20 (110lbs) Tim Murphy drew 4 Bob Cunningham, Williamsburg Grand Army Hall, Brooklyn, NYC, New York, USA
20 February (110lbs) Tim Murphy drew 4 Bob Cunningham, Williamsburg Grand Army Hall, Brooklyn, NYC, New York, USA. Referee: Johnny Eckhardt. In a match made at 110lbs, despite Murphy, who was claiming the title at that weight regardless of having no record to speak of and this being a mere four rounder, out to the world at the final bell the referee and the judge could not decide on a winner and a draw was announced. Cunningham later claimed that the referee had told him it would have been more than his life was worth to have counted Murphy out, while the latter regarded the punch in question as being a foul blow. Regardless of events, Cunningham never really built on the performance and appears not to have put in a title claim. Some historians had claimed that the fight took place on 17 March 1890, but recent research shows 20 February to be the correct date.
Due to fight Tommy Spider Kelly on 24 September at the Athletic Club, Manhattan, NYC for the American 115lbs title, Murphy failed to go ahead after Kelly came in over the weight. The bout was cancelled and Murphy claimed the title by forfeit, but was never really considered.