1951-09-26 Sandy Saddler w rtd 9 (15) Willie Pep, Polo Grounds, Manhattan, NYC, New York, USA - WORLD
1951-09-26 Sandy Saddler w rtd 9 (15) Willie Pep, Polo Grounds, Manhattan, NYC, New York, USA - WORLD. Referee: Ray Miller. In what was one of the dirtiest brawls ever seen in a championship contest, Saddler (125½) kept his hold on the title when Pep (125) retired at the end of the ninth round after being warned by the referee that if the holding and wrestling did not stop he would call the fight off. Right from the start the signs had been ominous and in the second round Pep was dropped by a wicked left to the body for a count of ‘eight’ and had his right eye damaged. But Pep came back to box beautifully at times before the fight degenerated into a free-for-all with Saddler twice wrestled to the floor, in the fifth and eighth, and both men and the referee finding themselves on the canvas in the sixth. The general feeling was that Saddler’s body work, especially in round nine, was just too much for Pep and that the fight would possibly have been all over in the tenth if Pep had continued.
Following the sordid affair, the NYSAC acted quickly by suspending both boxers for violating the rules, but by the end of October they lifted the suspension that had placed on the champion on the grounds that he was more sinned against than sinner.
Prior to Saddler being called up for the Army in May 1952, the NBA and EBU agreed on an eliminator between Ghana’s Roy Ankarah and Ray Famechon to find his next championship opponent. Having beaten Ankarah on points over 15 rounds at the Ice Rink, Nottingham, England on 9 June 1952, due to the champion’s enforced absence Famechon was then selected to meet the winner of a selection of fights that were deemed by the NBA and the NYSAC to be a tournament after it was decided to appoint an ‘interim’ champion. The men selected were Tommy Collins, Glen Flanagan, Gene Smith, Percy Bassett, Federico Plummer and Pep.
Despite some of the matches being above the weight, Collins (who stopped Pep in the sixth on 30 June at The Garden, Boston, Massachusetts) and Flanagan (who outpointed Smith over ten rounds at Griffith Stadium, Washington DC on 2 July) moved on to the next stage along with Bassett and Plummer, who had drawn byes. The semi-final stage, if you could call it that, saw Collins (124¾) outpoint Flanagan (125¾) over 15 rounds at The Garden, Boston on 25 August, while Bassett (129) and Plummer (132) drew over ten rounds at the Colon Arena, Panama City, Panama a day earlier.
Bassett then went forward as the American representative after Plummer sustained a broken jaw in their contest and was unavailable, and Collins declined to meet him on the grounds that it was no longer sensible for him to fight at 126lbs. He was duly crowned as the ‘interim’ champion on 9 February 1953 at the Sports Palace, Paris, France when he stopped Famechon in the third, but after forcing Lulu Perez to retire in the 11th on 25 June 1954 he lost the ‘title’ to Teddy Davis on 26 November 1954, when going down on points over 12 rounds. The last two fights which took place at Madison Square Garden, Manhattan, NYC, confirmed that Davis was first in line for Saddler.