I am definitely going to have to check out some of these fights.

Floyd Mayweather vs. Conor McGregor (8-26-2017)

R1: 10-9 McGregor
R2: 10-9 McGregor
R3: 10-9 McGregor
R4: 10-9 McGregor
R5: 10-9 Mayweather
R6: 10-9 Mayweather
R7: 10-9 Mayweather
R8: 10-9 Mayweather
R9: 10-9 Mayweather
R10: Mayweather wins by TKO

Floyd Mayweather vs. Manny Pacquiao (5-02-2015) R1: 10-9 Mayweather R2: 10-9 Mayweather R3: 10-9 Mayweather R4: 10-9 Pacquiao R5: 10-9 Mayweather R6: 10-9 Pacquiao R7: 10-9 Mayweather R8: 10-9 Mayweather R9: 10-9 Mayweather R10: 10-9 Pacquiao R11: 10-9 Mayweather R12: 10-9 Mayweather 117-111 Mayweat...

I watched and scored Ellis' title defense of the WBA title in Stockholm, Sweden against Floyd Patterson last night. It was Ellis’ first defense of the WBA title after winning the WBA tournament and would be the last fight for Ellis before Frazier and the unification of the division in February of 1...

Floyd Patterson vs Jimmy Ellis 1. Ellis 2. Patterson 3. Ellis 4. Patterson 5. Patterson 6. Patterson 7. Patterson 8. Ellis 9. Ellis 10. Patterson 11. Ellis 12. Ellis 13. Patterson 14. Patterson 15. ? In the 15th round the broadcast fades out, and I don't get to see the conclusion of the bout or the...

Deontay Wilde r with a record of 44-4-1 with 43 KO's. 13 Championship fights with an 11-2 (10 KO's) record in World Title bouts. He has 5 quality wins His total score comes to 221 points Strangely 7 of Deontay Wilder's wins I can't find any video of. Odd for a fighter in the modern era. With his vi...

David Tua vs Monte Barrett 2 1. Barrett 2. Barrett 3. Barrett 4. Barrett 5. Barrett 6. Barrett 7. Tua 8. Barrett 9. Barrett 10. Tua 11. Tua 12. Tua 10-8 (Barrett knocked down in the final minute, and barely survives the 12th round) 115-112 Monte Barrett I am going to have to get to a fight today.

Reading the back and forth here regarding the 10 point scoring system, I've been inspired to try out an alternative system. Seamus is absolutely right, too often you end up with a clear, dominant round scored the same as a round that could have gone either way. I think it was Casablanca who suggest...

Tommy Hearns vs. Iran Barkley I (6-06-1988)

R1: 10-9 Hearns
R2: 10-9 Hearns
R3: Barkley wins by TKO

Muhammad Ali vs Joe Frazier 2 January 28, 1974 Round 1: Ali Round 2: Ali Round 3: Ali Round 4: Ali Round 5: Ali Round 6: Ali Round 7: Frazier Round 8: Ali * Round 9: Ali Round 10: Frazier Round 11: Ali * Round 12: Ali I never realized how comfortably Ali controlled this one. Mostly shutting down Fr...

Joe Frazier vs. Joe Bugner (7-02-1073) R1: 10-9 Bugner R2: 10-9 Bugner R3: 10-9 Frazier R4: 10-9 Frazier R5: 10-9 Frazier R6: 10-9 Frazier R7: 10-9 Frazier R8: 10-9 Frazier R9: 10-9 Frazier R10: 10-8 Frazier (knockdown) R11: 10-9 Frazier R12: 10-9 Frazier 118-109 Frazier Was very close in the first ...

gilgamesh wrote: ↑01 Apr 2026, 16:40 It's fine. I just don't see the point the give them 9 extra points when you could just keep it simple and say. They won the round. 1 point to 0.

Simplicity is generally best.

It just allows for knockdowns and point deductions.

I think I probably score more even rounds than most and I've heard commentators say you shouldn't be judging a fight if you're doing that, but I completely disagree with them, because contrary to what they may claim, it has a very long history in the sport. I score rounds even if I just can’t tell ...

Speaking of which (The Rounds system being used in Ali vs Frazier 2 made me think of this) what do you guys think would be the ideal way to score a fight? I don't wanna get too far off topic here, but since this thread is about our scorecards it kinda is the topic. To me the most common sense way t...

Kid Gavilan vs. Carmen Basilio (9-18-1953) R1: 10-9 Gavilan R2: 10-8 Basilio (knockdown) R3: 10-9 Gavilan R4: 10-9 Basilio R5: 10-9 Basilio R6: 10-9 Gavilan R7: 10-10 Even R8: 10-9 Gavilan R9: 10-9 Basilio R10: 10-9 Gavilan R11: 10-9 Gavilan R12: 10-9 Basilio R13: 10-9 Gavilan R14: 10-9 Gavilan R15:...

Muhammad Ali vs Joe Frazier 2 January 28, 1974 Round 1: Ali Round 2: Ali Round 3: Ali Round 4: Ali Round 5: Ali Round 6: Ali Round 7: Frazier Round 8: Ali * Round 9: Ali Round 10: Frazier Round 11: Ali * Round 12: Ali I never realized how comfortably Ali controlled this one. Mostly shutting down Fr...

Just looking back through the thread now to see what great fights from the ‘30’s through the ‘60’s have already been scored by others. Some great fights missing.

Michael Dokes vs Jimmy Young 1. Dokes 2. Dokes 3. Dokes 4. Dokes 5. Young 6. Young * 7. Dokes 8. Dokes 9. Young 10. Dokes 97-93 Dokes Young had lost a little step here, but was still a difficult man to hit cleanly as Dokes found out. If you get a chance to check out Jimmy Young vs. Ossie Ocasio, le...

Indeed. I record that bout as a victory for Lewis. I had it 10 rounds to 2 for Lennox Lewis. He was absolutely the undeniable winner of that bout, and there's no argument that could've been made for any other result. A fight like Schulz-Foreman you don’t overturn the result of though, I presume? A ...

It means you're in the minority on that fight, and I think everyone else's opinion overrules yours. A bad decision which I simply don’t understand is Lewis-Holyfield I. *That* was not a good draw decision. At all. Many which are called robberies are really not though. They were just close fights th...

It means you're in the minority on that fight, and I think everyone else's opinion overrules yours. A bad decision which I simply don’t understand is Lewis-Holyfield I. *That* was not a good draw decision. At all. Many which are called robberies are really not though. They were just close fights th...

In cases where the overwhelming majority disagrees with the result I do, but it would have to be a truly indefensible robbery, not a close call that could've reasonably went either way. I feel like I've answered this question 8 times already. You would need to specify every case in which a decision...

Are you overturning results in fights in which you disagree with the result, such as in Pacquiao-Bradley I and Mayweather-Castillo I? In cases where the overwhelming majority disagrees with the result I do, but it would have to be a truly indefensible robbery, not a close call that could've reasona...

Are you overturning results in fights in which you disagree with the result, such as in Pacquiao-Bradley I and Mayweather-Castillo I?

I just watched it. What a vicious fight between two huge punchers for their weight level. Here was my card: Humberto Gonzalez vs. Michael Carbajal I (3-13-1993) R1: 10-9 Gonzalez R2: 10-8 Gonzalez (knockdown) R3: 10-9 Gonzalez R4: 10-9 Carbajal R5: 10-8 Gonzalez (knockdown) R6: 10-9 Carbajal R7: Ca...