Search found 288 matches

by marcianofan
08 Mar 2026, 20:31
Forum: Record Queries & Updates
Topic: Fight Date/Details Clarification from 1929
Replies: 1
Views: 1458

Fight Date/Details Clarification from 1929

The fight record for Buddy Schlereth shows a 7-8-29 fight with Tut Seymour. The source is Ring Magazine, but there's a note on the entry that says "date needs verification." Here's a newspaper story that should clarify the correct date as July 16. https://www.newspapers.com/article/st-loui...
by marcianofan
08 Mar 2026, 20:06
Forum: Record Queries & Updates
Topic: Duplicate Fighter Profile and ambiguous result, plus additional fight
Replies: 0
Views: 2661

Duplicate Fighter Profile and ambiguous result, plus additional fight

There are currently two profiles in the database for a 1920s fighter called "Wop" Stonum. One is under that name (https://boxrec.com/en/box-pro/1060963), while another is under just his last name (https://boxrec.com/en/box-pro/772291). The second profile has one fight listed against Young ...
by marcianofan
25 Feb 2026, 00:30
Forum: Record Queries & Updates
Topic: Incorrect Result for Clifford Schlereth vs. Tony Soldano, 3-12-1930
Replies: 0
Views: 2270

Incorrect Result for Clifford Schlereth vs. Tony Soldano, 3-12-1930

Please update the database to reflect a points win rather than a points loss for Clifford "Buddy" Schlereth. I'm guessing the headline saying he "almost won despite a hand injury" was the source of the confusion. However, the intent was I think that he was expected to win by knoc...
by marcianofan
31 Jan 2025, 20:50
Forum: Rating Queries
Topic: Unofficial ranking of Excluded Bridgerweight etc.
Replies: 1
Views: 10071

Unofficial ranking of Excluded Bridgerweight etc.

First let me renew my (and many other members') suggestion that the rankings should stop excluding Bridgerweights per se, but instead rank them as Heavyweights or, if appropriate, Cruiserweights. I don't disagree with what I assume is the implicit stance that bridgerweight is not a legitimate divisi...
by marcianofan
30 Mar 2024, 20:22
Forum: Rating Queries
Topic: Ratings - please read before commenting
Replies: 723
Views: 287573

Re: Ratings - please read before commenting

Hi- I try to get a look at the rankings each week before the fights take place so that I can take note of them, but I was a bit late today and a few of the fighters I was interested in had already fought. Can someone please tell me the rankings of the following fighters immediately prior to their fi...
by marcianofan
12 May 2023, 23:08
Forum: Current Scene
Topic: Was Ellis Zorro Top-50 Ranked Before today?
Replies: 3
Views: 301

Was Ellis Zorro Top-50 Ranked Before today?

Hi Everybody- very random narrow question to follow: I always try to capture the rankings of top-50 fighters right before they fight, but I was a bit late doing so this week, and the Ellis Zorro-Hosea Burton fight had already happened by the time I looked. The rankings update more or less immediatel...
by marcianofan
29 Jul 2022, 16:55
Forum: Record Queries & Updates
Topic: Suggestions for BoxRec
Replies: 361
Views: 1107697

Re: Suggestions for BoxRec

I've gotta say I'm really surprised at the extended silence about all these issues. Usually when there's a controversy about an update, they'll discuss it with us and either tweak it or defend the decisions.

In this case the site was brutally butchered, and it's like the comms are in lockdown.
by marcianofan
22 Jul 2022, 22:36
Forum: Record Queries & Updates
Topic: Suggestions for BoxRec
Replies: 361
Views: 1107697

Re: Suggestions for BoxRec

I love that upcoming fights now display the current ranking of each fighter.

Unfortunately nearly every other change that's been made seems almost as if it was designed specifically to frustrate everything I come here to do.
by marcianofan
22 Jul 2022, 22:32
Forum: Rating Queries
Topic: Ratings - please read before commenting
Replies: 723
Views: 287573

Re: Ratings - please read before commenting

Yeah....I like the fact that it shows current rankings for fighters in upcoming fights on the schedule now, as that saves me clicks in not having to click on every 15-0 figher to see if they've earned a decent ranking. I don't like that ratings points have been scrubbed (looked at a fight involving ...
by marcianofan
10 Apr 2022, 15:54
Forum: Record Queries & Updates
Topic: Incorrect details for DuBois-Mendouo
Replies: 0
Views: 229

Incorrect details for DuBois-Mendouo

On this fight: https://boxrec.com/en/event/745702/2155346 the fight details claim Mendouo was dropped in the first round, but says nothing about a second round KD. I thought I might have been going crazy in that I didn't remember a first round knockdown immediately after the fight. Went back and wat...
by marcianofan
15 Jan 2022, 17:27
Forum: Record Queries & Updates
Topic: Suggestions for BoxRec
Replies: 361
Views: 1107697

Re: Suggestions for BoxRec

all guys ranked as bridgers by wbc should be rated as hws here, my opinion FYI Bilal Laggoune is no longer ranked at Bridger. Should he not be back in the rankings now at cruiser? Ditto for Isaac Chamberlain. Jerry Forrest is also out of the rankings, so he should be back at HW, along with Alexande...
by marcianofan
15 Jan 2022, 17:17
Forum: Record Queries & Updates
Topic: Suggestions for BoxRec
Replies: 361
Views: 1107697

Re: Suggestions for BoxRec

Strongly disagree with your idea. You're basing a significant portion of what separates one fighter from another (especially at a mid-level) on winning title fights. First, I think it's nonsensical to base someone's objective value on something as subjective as even a high-level alphabet title. But ...
by marcianofan
04 Dec 2021, 12:11
Forum: Record Queries & Updates
Topic: Suggestions for BoxRec
Replies: 361
Views: 1107697

Re: Suggestions for BoxRec

Regarding Bridgerweight and Forrest. It isn't a ratings issue - it is politics. Just look at his points in his record. The points are Heavyweight points. Could you expand on the political problem to help us understand? Is it that you would offend the WBC by calling their Bridgerweight top contender...
by marcianofan
03 Dec 2021, 20:58
Forum: Rating Queries
Topic: Ratings - please read before commenting
Replies: 723
Views: 287573

Re: Ratings - please read before commenting

This thread is only the right place for discussing issues and ideas regarding the ratings algorithm. The right place for discussing issues with weight divisions and politics is here https://boxrec.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=1&t=94835 Thanks. I did actually try to post there first, but it is show...
by marcianofan
03 Dec 2021, 20:52
Forum: Rating Queries
Topic: Ratings - please read before commenting
Replies: 723
Views: 287573

Re: Ratings - please read before commenting

Regarding Bridgerweight and Forrest. It isn't a ratings issue - it is politics. Just look at his points in his record. The points are Heavyweight points. Could you expand on the political problem to help us understand? Is it that you would offend the WBC by calling their Bridgerweight top contender...
by marcianofan
03 Dec 2021, 20:46
Forum: Rating Queries
Topic: Ratings - please read before commenting
Replies: 723
Views: 287573

Re: Ratings - please read before commenting

The Bridgerweight thing makes zero sense. Rank them as Heavyweights. The end. Yeah that would probably simplify it even more. I mean I do think a guy like Bilal Laggoune who is pretty clearly a cruiserweight ought to be a cruiserweight, but if you don't want to get in the business of scrutinizing e...
by marcianofan
03 Dec 2021, 20:40
Forum: Rating Queries
Topic: Ratings - please read before commenting
Replies: 723
Views: 287573

Could inactivity standards be made adjustable?

I doubt this is the first time this has ever been brought up, but the increased inactivity from COVID (even though it's close to being back to normal) got me thinking: Would it be reasonably plausible to implement an option to view the rankings with different inactivity standards applied? So in othe...
by marcianofan
03 Dec 2021, 20:18
Forum: Rating Queries
Topic: Ratings - please read before commenting
Replies: 723
Views: 287573

Re: Jerry Forrest

It's probably been a while since he beat anyone decent, but he just got draws vs. Zhang and Hunter and still isn't ranked. Does he need to have a win before he's ranked? Jerry Forrest presents himself as #16 WBC Bridgerweight. Bridgerweights (neither Heavyweight nor Cruiserweight) cannot be ranked ...
by marcianofan
13 Nov 2021, 15:35
Forum: Record Queries & Updates
Topic: Suggestions for BoxRec - Archived
Replies: 682
Views: 360237

Re: Suggestions for BoxRec

Boxrec always shows the age in the boxer profile, if the date of birth is known. I just did a quick check. Yes, I found the age listed in many cases. But in many other instances, there was no age or DOB. This is in contrast to the way that Boxrec's system worked in the past, when age and DOB were a...
by marcianofan
03 Oct 2021, 11:10
Forum: Record Queries & Updates
Topic: Incorrect Result
Replies: 0
Views: 194

Incorrect Result

I was just watching this Azteca-broadcasted fight from 2017, and the result (RTD at 3:00 of Rd 3) is incorrect. https://boxrec.com/en/event/745119/2139222 It was a TKO at 1:26 of round 3 (and a bad stoppage, in my view). I think the last time I found one of these, I had to post a private video on yo...
by marcianofan
19 Mar 2021, 23:17
Forum: Record Queries & Updates
Topic: Jerry Forrest active but not ranked?
Replies: 4
Views: 419

Re: Jerry Forrest active but not ranked?

DrDuke wrote: ↑06 Mar 2021, 14:12 That's because of f*cking wbc. Boxrec can't rank the fighters, who are ranked by the wbc' bunch of idiots as bridgerweights.
Why can't boxrec rank him? Do they have a contract with the WBC?
by marcianofan
06 Mar 2021, 13:59
Forum: Record Queries & Updates
Topic: Jerry Forrest active but not ranked?
Replies: 4
Views: 419

Jerry Forrest active but not ranked?

Hi- on the profile for Heavyweight Jerry Forrest (who just fought last weekend), he has no ranking. He's listed as active, but still no ranking. I've also looked over the Heavyweight top-100, and he's not listed. I noticed this before his fight with Zhang this past weekend, also, and he wasn't ranke...
by marcianofan
05 Oct 2020, 18:13
Forum: Current Scene
Topic: Ratings - please read before commenting - Archived
Replies: 4495
Views: 603977

Re: Ratings - please read before commenting

computerrank wrote: ↑05 Oct 2020, 08:06 @marcianofan, I will send you a PM, when I will be back home next week.
Great thanks- I promise I don't intend to ask regularly.
by marcianofan
02 Oct 2020, 22:11
Forum: Current Scene
Topic: Ratings - please read before commenting - Archived
Replies: 4495
Views: 603977

Re: Ratings - please read before commenting

Hi computerrank, I normally make a list of fights involving top-50 fighters in certain divisions before they happen and the ranks of the fighters at the time, but I fell asleep this weekend and didn't get around to it in time. If you get a chance, would you mind telling me the rankings of the follo...