Why are injuries so much more frequent in boxing?

Post Reply
Deserter
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 6473
Joined: 04 Sep 2003, 10:01

Why are injuries so much more frequent in boxing?

Post by Deserter »

Now let me state from the outset that there's no hidden agenda here, I'm just genuinely perplexed at the situation. The most obvious comparison is with MMA due to the prolonged nature of the preparation and its intensity, but to best of my knowledge fighters dropping out of bouts due to injury is far less frequent in that combat sport.
Obviously I know some of the injury claims are ficticious and related instead to politics, but even given that it still seems disproportionate.
I'd genuinely be interested in hearing people's theories as to why....
Last edited by Deserter on 04 Sep 2010, 11:37, edited 1 time in total.
orbtastic
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 12549
Joined: 05 Dec 2006, 11:22

Re: Why are injuries so much more frequent in boxing?

Post by orbtastic »

The Barker hip injury is on-going, isn't it? It existed a while ago and he thought it might get better but it's not...but he was quoted only this week [in BN] saying no, i'm sick of the injury rumours, it's doing my head...well rumours often exist for a reason.

Rhodes is back injury? I've no idea if it's legit or how long-standing it is.

Often an injury is cited for a pull-out, if something better is on the horizon, or there's some issue over purse/money etc.

As a promoter, you don't really want to be saying yeah here's this attractive looking bill, the biggest in 10 years in the UK - Come buy tickets for it and watch it for 15 quid a pop on SBO...but by the way, two of the fights might not happen. What promoter would do that in reality?

I'm not sure what to make of it. I would guess Barker's is legit, but the whole Barker denying it directly via BN/Flexen only this week is a bit off.

Rhodes..dunno, he seems pretty direct and genuine and is usually pretty frank when interviewed. I guess time will tell.

Both are vacating titles they won, they won't be doing that without some sort of financial incentive or basically, because they have no choice? FW needs those titles to keep the bill afloat.
bennie
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 15244
Joined: 15 Nov 2002, 09:53

Re: Why are injuries so much more frequent in boxing?

Post by bennie »

Chris Finnegan once said that a fighter feels every little twinge in training. Perhaps the modern game is to blame. A fighter can be brought back every which way - call it the Patrick Mullings syndrome - so why take the risk.
exittored
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 1565
Joined: 19 Apr 2008, 19:40

Re: Why are injuries so much more frequent in boxing?

Post by exittored »

Deserter wrote:Now let me state from the outset that there's no hidden agenda here, I'm just genuinely perplexed at the situation. The most obvious comparison is with MMA due to the prolonged nature of the preparation and its intensity, but to best of my knowledge fighters dropping out of bouts due to injury is far less frequent in that combat sport.
Obviously I know some of the injury claims are ficticious and related instead to politics, but even given that it still seems disproportionate.
I'd genuinely be interested in hearing people's theories as to why....
The simple answer as to why mma fighters don't get injured in training as much is because steroids, peds and HGH are part of their culture which enables them to train harder and longer without their body breaking down as much.

Although some boxers do use PED's the vast majority of them don't so their bodies will feel it much more and therefore be more liable to training injuries.
Spud
Heavyweight
Heavyweight

Re: Why are injuries so much more frequent in boxing?

Post by Spud »

Deserter wrote:Now let me state from the outset that there's no hidden agenda here, I'm just genuinely perplexed at the situation. The most obvious comparison is with MMA due to the prolonged nature of the preparation and its intensity, but to best of my knowledge fighters dropping out of bouts due to injury is far less frequent in that combat sport.
Obviously I know some of the injury claims are ficticious and related instead to politics, but even given that it still seems disproportionate.

I'd genuinely be interested in hearing people's theories as to why....
To answer the question in the thread title - Its the honourable and easiest way to get out of a fight - I state that not to question the courage of a fighter - but sometimes the promoter might discover his fighter has an injury which will subsequently mean a fight does not take place and then spookily a title fight or higher profile fight or a fight which suits the promoter more is matched elsewhere.

Another answer is - boxing politics

Call me a cynic - but its quite close to the truth :TU:
Deserter
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 6473
Joined: 04 Sep 2003, 10:01

Re: Why are injuries so much more frequent in boxing?

Post by Deserter »

exittored wrote:
Deserter wrote:Now let me state from the outset that there's no hidden agenda here, I'm just genuinely perplexed at the situation. The most obvious comparison is with MMA due to the prolonged nature of the preparation and its intensity, but to best of my knowledge fighters dropping out of bouts due to injury is far less frequent in that combat sport.
Obviously I know some of the injury claims are ficticious and related instead to politics, but even given that it still seems disproportionate.
I'd genuinely be interested in hearing people's theories as to why....
The simple answer as to why mma fighters don't get injured in training as much is because steroids, peds and HGH are part of their culture which enables them to train harder and longer without their body breaking down as much.

Although some boxers do use PED's the vast majority of them don't so their bodies will feel it much more and therefore be more liable to training injuries.
Is that honestly the case? I genuinely don't know and have to profess to a level of naivety in this regard.
SweetLikeSugar
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 376
Joined: 24 Aug 2010, 15:37

Re: Why are injuries so much more frequent in boxing?

Post by SweetLikeSugar »

exittored wrote:
Deserter wrote:Now let me state from the outset that there's no hidden agenda here, I'm just genuinely perplexed at the situation. The most obvious comparison is with MMA due to the prolonged nature of the preparation and its intensity, but to best of my knowledge fighters dropping out of bouts due to injury is far less frequent in that combat sport.
Obviously I know some of the injury claims are ficticious and related instead to politics, but even given that it still seems disproportionate.
I'd genuinely be interested in hearing people's theories as to why....
The simple answer as to why mma fighters don't get injured in training as much is because steroids, peds and HGH are part of their culture which enables them to train harder and longer without their body breaking down as much.

Although some boxers do use PED's the vast majority of them don't so their bodies will feel it much more and therefore be more liable to training injuries.
That's a very sweeping statement there fella. All MMAists are on PEDs? Wow, I didn't know that! Nor did I know that they stop you feeling pain.

My guess is that because Dana White has the monopoly on MMA, his UFC fighters are afraid to pull out of fights for fear of losing their contract and subsequent huge paycheques. If you're cut from the UFC - which White will do in a heartbeat of he thinks you're bullshitting an injury - then the only way is downhill. I have mixed feelings about White but one of the things I like about his corparation is that he makes the best fight the best.
SweetLikeSugar
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 376
Joined: 24 Aug 2010, 15:37

Re: Why are injuries so much more frequent in boxing?

Post by SweetLikeSugar »

Deserter wrote:
exittored wrote:
Deserter wrote:Now let me state from the outset that there's no hidden agenda here, I'm just genuinely perplexed at the situation. The most obvious comparison is with MMA due to the prolonged nature of the preparation and its intensity, but to best of my knowledge fighters dropping out of bouts due to injury is far less frequent in that combat sport.
Obviously I know some of the injury claims are ficticious and related instead to politics, but even given that it still seems disproportionate.
I'd genuinely be interested in hearing people's theories as to why....
The simple answer as to why mma fighters don't get injured in training as much is because steroids, peds and HGH are part of their culture which enables them to train harder and longer without their body breaking down as much.

Although some boxers do use PED's the vast majority of them don't so their bodies will feel it much more and therefore be more liable to training injuries.
Is that honestly the case? I genuinely don't know and have to profess to a level of naivety in this regard.
There is no evidence to my knowledge (and I'm willing to be proved wrong here) that the use of PEDs is less likely to cause injury.
Asterix
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 7128
Joined: 02 Nov 2007, 10:42

Re: Why are injuries so much more frequent in boxing?

Post by Asterix »

Maybe it's because losing means so much more today than it used to? In the past you'd probably fight with injuries, providing you still could fight. Today, you'd probably not fight if you were only 70% because you'd have a lot more chance of losing. I dont know. Just offering a suggestion.
SweetLikeSugar
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 376
Joined: 24 Aug 2010, 15:37

Re: Why are injuries so much more frequent in boxing?

Post by SweetLikeSugar »

Asterix wrote:Maybe it's because losing means so much more today than it used to? In the past you'd probably fight with injuries, providing you still could fight. Today, you'd probably not fight if you were only 70% because you'd have a lot more chance of losing. I dont know. Just offering a suggestion.
Yeah that's what I was trying to get at in comparison to the UFC. There aren't many 0s in MMA records and so I think fighters in that sport are more eager to take fights if they aren't 100%, knowing that there marketibilty won't take such a huge hit if they lose.
1southpaw
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 858
Joined: 28 Apr 2007, 14:23

Re: Why are injuries so much more frequent in boxing?

Post by 1southpaw »

Spud wrote:
Deserter wrote:Now let me state from the outset that there's no hidden agenda here, I'm just genuinely perplexed at the situation. The most obvious comparison is with MMA due to the prolonged nature of the preparation and its intensity, but to best of my knowledge fighters dropping out of bouts due to injury is far less frequent in that combat sport.
Obviously I know some of the injury claims are ficticious and related instead to politics, but even given that it still seems disproportionate.

I'd genuinely be interested in hearing people's theories as to why....
To answer the question in the thread title - Its the honourable and easiest way to get out of a fight - I state that not to question the courage of a fighter - but sometimes the promoter might discover his fighter has an injury which will subsequently mean a fight does not take place and then spookily a title fight or higher profile fight or a fight which suits the promoter more is matched elsewhere.

Another answer is - boxing politics

Call me a cynic - but its quite close to the truth :TU:

so who could they fight in this country that is a bigger name ???
superpunchout
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 142
Joined: 28 Feb 2009, 21:25

Re: Why are injuries so much more frequent in boxing?

Post by superpunchout »

Asterix wrote:Maybe it's because losing means so much more today than it used to? In the past you'd probably fight with injuries, providing you still could fight. Today, you'd probably not fight if you were only 70% because you'd have a lot more chance of losing. I dont know. Just offering a suggestion.
That makes sense. You need look no further than Kelly Pavlik to see the commercial damage losses are capable of inflicting. At one point he was being mooted as the heir apparent to the likes of Monzon and Hagler but now after only 2 defeats, he's languishing in no mans land and there are even some who suggest that his best days are already behind him.
Post Reply