HOF nomination: Pete Herman

[Crease]

Pete Herman: (Managed by Armageto)

Unified Honours:
Unified the WBC & WBA Titles: (Week 17)

Individual Titles:
X1 Time WBC Champion: (Week 11)
X1 Time WBA Champion: (Week 17)
X1 Time IBF Champion: (Week 21)

Pete "Kid Herman" Herman 25(5)-7(3)-8

Week 1- W8 Rafael Marquez TKO
Week 2- D10 George Dixon
Week 3- W10 Christian Mijares UD
Week 4- W10 Mike Oliver UD
Week 5- W8 Manuel Ortiz TKO
Week 6- W12 Wilfredo Gomez UD (WBO Title Eliminator)
Week 7- D15 Guillermo Rigondeaux (WBO Title)
Week 8- L15 Guillermo Rigondeaux II SD (WBO Title)
Week 9- W10 Tomoki Kamdea UD
Week 10-W10 Joseph Agbeko UD
Week 11- W15 Jeff Fenech TKO (WBC Title)
Week 12- W15 Jeff Chandler MD (WBC Title)
Week 13- W15 Poonsawat Kratingdaenggym UD (WBC Title)
Week 14- W15 Terry McGovern UD (WBC Title)
Week 15- W15 Erik Morales MD (WBC Title)
Week 16- W9 Ruben Olivares TKO (WBC Title)
Week 17- W15 George Dixon II UD (WBC/WBA Titles)
Week 18- W15 Carlos Zarate SD (WBC/WBA Titles)
Week 19- L8 Eder Jofre TKO (WBC/WBA Titles)
Week 20- W2 Spider Gallagher KO
Week 21- W15 Sixto Escobar SD (IBF Title)
Week 22- D15 Guillermo Rigondeaux III (IBF Title)
Week 23- W15 Panama Al Brown SD (IBF Title)
Week 24- L15 Manny Pacquiao KO (IBF Title)
Week 25- D Eder Jofre II
Week 26- L7 Jimmy Carruthers DQ (MDT Tourney)
Week 27- W12 Manny Pacquiao II UD (MDT Tourney)
Week 28- W12 Christian Mijares II UD (MDT Tourney)
Week 29- W10 Marco Antonio Barerra MD
Week 30- L10 Wilfredo Gomez II MD
Week 31- D10 George Dixon III
Week 32- D12 Jimmy Carruthers II
Week 33- W10 Juan Manuel Lopez UD
Week 34- W12 Manny Pacquiao III MD
Week 35- D15 Terry McGovern II (Super Six Tourney)
Week 36- L3 Manny Pacquiao IV TKO (Super Six Tourney)
Week 37- L15 Eric Morales II SD (Super Six Tourney)
Week 38- W15 Panama Al Brown II MD (Super Six Tourney)
Week 39- D15 Eder Jofre III (Super Six Tourney)
Week 40- W12 Guillermo Rigondeaux IV MD

(Special thanks to Mr Armageto for keeping his record updated)

[Crease]

There won't be a poll this time round, it will just be Managers from the Bantamweight season expressing their votes through typing it in messages. That way, it will avoid the vote getting sabotaged.

YES..................................................NO
Frilla.............................................Crease
Armageto.....................................Techno89
Fist of legend................................DMA1987
BoxBuzz....................................................
BoxBully....................................................

[Crease]

Pete had a good start to the season, but he was not able to maintain it throughout the season. And ultimately, whilst he deserved his place in The Super Six, he did finish last in it.

It's a definite NO for me.

[BoxBuzz]

A good effort, but he never faced Barry.

[Techno89]

I Vote No

['Frilla]

Yes.

[armageto]

I vote yes

[Crease]

A good effort, but he never faced Barry.

Is that a yes or a no, Buzz? I don't want to leave any room for ambiguity.

[DMA1987]

No

[Fist of Legend]

Im voting yes, he was pretty much the only top dog other than Jofre all season. I also think we're making it too hard to get into the Hall these days, Herman had a great season and if he got the nod in the draw against Jofre in the final super six match he would have been tied for first instead of finishing last. I think he belongs in the BRSHOF.

[BoxBuzz]

Well I'm changing my vote to yes.

AND I think rules need to stop changing for random and reactive reasons.

Unless there is a rule that says I can't change my vote.

Then I ask that the rule be overruled.

['Frilla]

Im voting yes, he was pretty much the only top dog other than Jofre all season. I also think we're making it too hard to get into the Hall these days, Herman had a great season and if he got the nod in the draw against Jofre in the final super six match he would have been tied for first instead of finishing last. I think he belongs in the BRSHOF.

My thoughts exactly.

[Crease]

if he got the nod in the draw against Jofre in the final super six match he would have been tied for first instead of finishing last.

Such is the margins of victory and defeat in the ultimate baptism of fire that we call The Super Six.

If IFS and BUTS were candy and nuts etc....

[Crease]

I also think we're making it too hard to get into the Hall these days

I don't mind it being ultra selective. The Great Mr Kevo himself once said that he believed only 1 fighter per season should be entered in to The Hall.

[Crease]

2 days to go before the voting/counting stops and the thread is locked.

[BoxBully]

yes

[Crease]

Thread is locked. Discussion is closed. Herman is in.

[Crease]

Congratulations to Pete Herman & Mr Armageto.