Modern Day "All-Time Heavyweight" Tournament

Collins2000
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 4175
Joined: 06 May 2002, 06:13

Post by Collins2000 »

IrishRufusMurphy wrote:It's two days away from RAHMAN vs MASKAEV, I am hoping some people would give their own opinions as to who they think would win this upcoming fight---and when the fight happens we will compare your predictions, the computers predictions to the actual outcome. :TU:
You won't get many people on here willing to make a prediction that can actually be tested. They aren't going to risk ruining their 100% record of correctly picking fantasy fights. I'd love to see the 'experts' who can call any fantasy fight with no fear of failure try some real fight picking. It can be a humbling experience...

Who is the favourite? I think this is a fight where you can make a case for either man.

Having said that, I think Rahman can win. Probably on points. I know Maskaev KO'd him last time but I think Hasim can keep his chin out of trouble this time and box his way to a clear victory. That's my pick then; Rahman on points.

What was your pick by the way?

:o
HomicideHenry
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 18722
Joined: 08 Sep 2005, 00:43

Post by HomicideHenry »

My prediction is that, when Rahman and Makaev fought the first time, neither man was in condition---but Maskaev knocked Rahman out. Now both men are in better condition---I think Maskaev is hungry and really wanting to pay his dues, Rahman wants to avenge the kayo loss years before.

But Rahman is starting to talk, trash talk, like he did with Lennox Lewis. This is undoubtedly Rahman's biggest fight since his rematch with Lewis, and I don't think Rahman for one reason or another can handle the huge hype around the show. Rahman is one of the most hot and cold fighters I have ever seen, one fight he is great, the next lackluster.

Maskaev, on the other hand, always gives 110% on every fight, the losses he has had by and large were from lucky shots---freak occurences, most of the fights he was KO'd in he was winning on points.

I think if a man is determined enough, wants it bad enough, think that he can't be beaten....is ever dangerous, for he has confidence in his abilities.

I go with Maskaev.
Ambling Alp
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 3627
Joined: 15 Jul 2005, 22:31

Post by Ambling Alp »

IrishRufusMurphy wrote:That's a new story :o never heard that one, considering neither man knew the outcome of the fight until January 20th, 1969. Marciano had already been killed in a plane crash months before the computer fight ever was released, so...dunno how that would have came about.

I do know that Ali had knocked Marciano's wig off two times, after Marciano had told him to quit, and Ali did it again and Marciano hit Ali with a body shot so viscous that Ali doubled over and fell to the canvas. Marciano challenged Ali right then and there to a real fight if Ali was game, but Ali apologised and Marciano needed a while to calm down.

Now I know one of Marciano's brothers said on a SPORTS CENTURY episode about Marciano, that Rocky told them that he thought Ali was a good fighter, but in his prime he would have killed Ali. A few of Marciano's other friends were also quoted that Marciano wasn't really impressed by Ali's skills, that he did feel that Ali was fast, but didn't think that Ali was 'the greatest'.

I know also that Marciano was quoted before the computer fight years before that he never thought he'd see the day that the HW division would have a Sugar Ray Robinson (in reference to Ali), but I guess when Marciano actually got himself into decent shape and sparred those 70 rounds with Ali, his opinion changed.
Can you show a us a picture or some video of Ali being knocked down by Marciano's body punch or a film of it? A lot people would like to see that.
theone
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 1655
Joined: 13 Sep 2005, 17:12

Post by theone »

Can you show a us a picture or some video of Ali being knocked down by Marciano's body punch or a film of it? A lot people would like to see that.
Yeah sounds like bullsh*t to me. I'll believe it only if i see it. Its most likely a myth perpertrated to enhance the Marciano legend.
theone
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 1655
Joined: 13 Sep 2005, 17:12

Post by theone »

but I guess when Marciano actually got himself into decent shape and sparred those 70 rounds with Ali, his opinion changed.
They didnt spar. They acted like they were fighting. Big difference.
HomicideHenry
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 18722
Joined: 08 Sep 2005, 00:43

Post by HomicideHenry »

I don't believe there is any film of the body shot that dropped Ali. From the eye witness accounts of Murray Woroner, Ferdie Pacheco and Angello Dundee, this is how the body shot happened:

Ali was dancing around, Marciano was crouching trying to get inside, Ali threw a high jab, knocking Marciano's wig off his head. They stopped filming and readjusted the wig. Marciano was embarassed and said "He did that on purprose, he has no respect for me at all." They reassured him that it was an accident, and filming continued.

Ali again threw a jab and again the wig went flying. Marciano yelled out "Don't you do that again!" as they stopped filming and refitted his wig. Filming continued, and whether it was just an accident or Ali was just clowning nobody knows, but again there was a jab and again the wig went flying---Marciano didn't hesitate and hit Ali with a viscous body shot, doubling him over and dropping him. Filming was stopped.

Marciano had to be calmed down, as he was literally pissed off, and even so much as called Ali out right then and there to turn it into a real fight if Ali was game. Only until after Ali apologised did Marciano calm down, and filming again proceeded.

Now what is true, at least by Ali's own admission, is that Marciano beat him to the body so badly that he was bruised and had welts all over his rib cage and his elbow was even injured---as Marciano beat on Ali's arms---and even asked for a few extra dollars and a few days off.

Ali in his own autobiography was quoted that "My whole body ached, and ours wasn't even a real fight," and he was surprised that even at 46 years old, how hard it was to land a solid punch on Marciano, and that he couldn't imagine how a prime Marciano must have been, because Marciano was so strong and powerful a hitter, even at 46 years old.

The 'real' body shot must have ended up on the cutting room floor; you must remember that all the reels of the film and copies, except for one, was destroyed after the SUPERFIGHT was shown in theatres and on WIDE WORLD OF SPORTS in 1970, so if there ever was film of it, it's been long gone.
HomicideHenry
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 18722
Joined: 08 Sep 2005, 00:43

Post by HomicideHenry »

Speaking of fights...RAHMAN vs MASKAEV is tonight :box:

I can't wait to see the outcome, and see if the computer program me and Ezzard been using is any at all accurate---as the simulator has chosen Maskaev to win over Rahman (though Ezzard's computer was using rankings from 2002-2003, not the present day).

Even if Maskaev doesn't win by KO like the computer says, just winning over Rahman would show to alot of people in this forum that possibly the simulator I been using for this tournament is good enough to make a good outcome of any fight.

If Maskaev loses, at least the computer did pick Rahman to win at least once in a best two out of three---I am excited, and will keep my fingers crossed, but I won't let my hopes up on this venture. But I do hope the computer is right, so it can give this tournament some manner of legitimacy.

I will post the outcome of the fight as soon as it happens. :TU:
Collins2000
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 4175
Joined: 06 May 2002, 06:13

Post by Collins2000 »

IrishRufusMurphy wrote:Speaking of fights...RAHMAN vs MASKAEV is tonight :box:

I can't wait to see the outcome, and see if the computer program me and Ezzard been using is any at all accurate---as the simulator has chosen Maskaev to win over Rahman (though Ezzard's computer was using rankings from 2002-2003, not the present day).

Even if Maskaev doesn't win by KO like the computer says, just winning over Rahman would show to alot of people in this forum that possibly the simulator I been using for this tournament is good enough to make a good outcome of any fight.

If Maskaev loses, at least the computer did pick Rahman to win at least once in a best two out of three---I am excited, and will keep my fingers crossed, but I won't let my hopes up on this venture. But I do hope the computer is right, so it can give this tournament some manner of legitimacy.

I will post the outcome of the fight as soon as it happens. :TU:

whoa! hang on. You keep saying it was using old rankings. Is that so if it is wrong you can blame that? Plus you have allowed it to pick BOTH Maskaev and Rahman. How can it be wrong when it has picked both?????

I asked you to run it once and put up the result. That was Maskaev KO2 Rahman. That's the predicted result I am judging it on.

My pick is Rahman W12.

PS Notice how none of the alleged experts or alleged historians dare to have a go?

:TU:
HomicideHenry
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 18722
Joined: 08 Sep 2005, 00:43

Post by HomicideHenry »

I can't really blame the computer no, for using rankings from 2002-2003, because that is what was available for Ezzard's computer---so the fight is judging Rahman vs Maskaev by 2002-2003.

Myself I have said before that since that time other than Rahman getting a belt by default, I don't think either man's opponents have been better than the others---with possibly Rahman's bout with James Toney, a blown up Middleweight turn Cruiserweight now campaigning as a HW.

On a best two out of three the computer picked Maskaev to win by KO anywere from the 2nd to the 9th rounds---so that's what I am judging by. But irregardless if there is a kayo or not, if Maskaev wins this fight, it should show to me that the computer was accurate enough to pick a winner.

And yes, I think it is somewhat hilarious that really none of the more 'expert' posters have yet to give their opinions on this, because I believe by and large none of them want to look like they are wrong---they want to say that I was wrong in using a computer to pick who moved on in the tournament, that the computer picked one over another, and judge me on that----but they don't want to look foolish by saying out right who they think would win, because their is the chance that they would be wrong and my method and the computer was right.

But the key word is CHANCE. Nothing is definate. :TU:
HomicideHenry
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 18722
Joined: 08 Sep 2005, 00:43

Post by HomicideHenry »

OLEG MASKAEV WINS BY KO IN 12 ROUNDS!!! :TU:


Oleg Maskaev (32-5, 25 KOs) won the WBC world heavyweight championship with a twelfth round knock out of defending champion Hasim Rahman (41-5-2, 33 KOs) Saturday night at the Thomas & Mack Arena in Las Vegas. Rahman pressed the action early on and wobbled Maskaev early in round four, but Maskaev had some good connects later in the same round. Maskaev continued to land good shots in the fifth, but seemed bothered by referee Jay Nady's warning for holding. Round six was marked by Nady's almost continuous admonitions to Maskaev for holding. Maskaev seemed to be tiring in the eighth as Rahman starting landing his hard jab consistantly to set up his best round in the fight up to that point. Although the 37-year-old Maskaev seemed like he might be wilting after round nine, he came out throwing in the tenth, outworking "The Rock" for much of that round and also in the eleventh. Maskaev dropped Rahman with a right hand in the twelfth, then dropped him again to win by KO at 2:17! The bout was billed as "America's Last Line of Defense" and with the win, Maskaev completed a clean sweep of the major heavyweight titles by fighters born in the former Soviet Union, although Oleg is now a U.S. citizen.


The best two out of three method prevails!!! :box:

Out of Ezzard's simulator predictions, his one that said Maskaev would win in round 9 was the most similar to the actual fight---saying both men would be wobbled or dropped---and as well as the prediction that Rahman would win by KO in the 5th, as in the actual fight Rahman did shake up Maskaev in rounds four and five.

The computer may not have been correct in chosing the round...but it did chose Maskaev and how he would win, by KO. :P
Collins2000
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 4175
Joined: 06 May 2002, 06:13

Post by Collins2000 »

IrishRufusMurphy wrote:OLEG MASKAEV WINS BY KO IN 12 ROUNDS!!! :TU:


Oleg Maskaev (32-5, 25 KOs) won the WBC world heavyweight championship with a twelfth round knock out of defending champion Hasim Rahman (41-5-2, 33 KOs) Saturday night at the Thomas & Mack Arena in Las Vegas. Rahman pressed the action early on and wobbled Maskaev early in round four, but Maskaev had some good connects later in the same round. Maskaev continued to land good shots in the fifth, but seemed bothered by referee Jay Nady's warning for holding. Round six was marked by Nady's almost continuous admonitions to Maskaev for holding. Maskaev seemed to be tiring in the eighth as Rahman starting landing his hard jab consistantly to set up his best round in the fight up to that point. Although the 37-year-old Maskaev seemed like he might be wilting after round nine, he came out throwing in the tenth, outworking "The Rock" for much of that round and also in the eleventh. Maskaev dropped Rahman with a right hand in the twelfth, then dropped him again to win by KO at 2:17! The bout was billed as "America's Last Line of Defense" and with the win, Maskaev completed a clean sweep of the major heavyweight titles by fighters born in the former Soviet Union, although Oleg is now a U.S. citizen.


The best two out of three method prevails!!! :box:

Out of Ezzard's simulator predictions, his one that said Maskaev would win in round 9 was the most similar to the actual fight---saying both men would be wobbled or dropped---and as well as the prediction that Rahman would win by KO in the 5th, as in the actual fight Rahman did shake up Maskaev in rounds four and five.

The computer may not have been correct in chosing the round...but it did chose Maskaev and how he would win, by KO. :P

Having my money on Rahman to win on points added to the excitement. I was willing the big bag of shit to hang on in round 12 or at least throw a punch as gay jay was bending over backwards to allow him to stay in the fight.

Exciting fight but little or no skill on show.

Rahman drops down to be a contender for worst heavyweight 'champ' ever...

I think we need to test the computer a couple more times, Rufus. :TU:
HomicideHenry
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 18722
Joined: 08 Sep 2005, 00:43

Post by HomicideHenry »

lmao....and still there are critics, even after the computer picked the winner of the Maskaev/Rahman bout, and how he would win.

This don't surprise me a bit. Maybe the computer needs to be tested against other fights as well...but the challenge was said to prove the accuracy of the computer (by picking an exact winner) in an upcoming fight, which was Maskaev vs Rahman.

My method of 'best two out of three' with the simulator proved to be accurate enough to determine a winner of a fight, I accepted that challenge, and I thank Ezzard for helping immensely with this.

This gives legitimacy to this computerised tournament, in my eyes anyways. I am quite happy with the results.
HomicideHenry
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 18722
Joined: 08 Sep 2005, 00:43

Post by HomicideHenry »

If we do test the computer a few more times, I have a few requests:

1.) That Ezzard do the simulations, but I want the simulator to be updated to more current rankings like mine is (because I don't want people accusing me of trickery)

2.) No fights between fighters from different weight classes; such as James Toney vs Samuel Peter---because I want this to simply be legit HW's facing eachother. It will be unfair and would confuse the computer, as to have Toney beating all these great fighters in lower weights on his resume, while Peter has only faced one real HW contender, get what I mean?

How about the upcoming Wladimir Klitschko vs Shannon Briggs, and Nicolay Valuev vs Monte Barrett fights? I know they kind of far off in dates and all and anything can happen in that amount of time. :-?

Or does anyone else have any suggestions?
HomicideHenry
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 18722
Joined: 08 Sep 2005, 00:43

Post by HomicideHenry »

I guess everyone is tired of this tournament and all :-?


I guess we can do the last two matches, based solely on the computer simulator. Those matches are: Muhammad Ali vs Rocky Marciano, Muhammad Ali vs Joe Louis; even though Marciano beaten Louis in this tournament, but rather than have criticism I will have Louis entered in as well against finalist Ali.
Ambling Alp
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 3627
Joined: 15 Jul 2005, 22:31

Post by Ambling Alp »

IrishRufusMurphy wrote:I don't believe there is any film of the body shot that dropped Ali. From the eye witness accounts of Murray Woroner, Ferdie Pacheco and Angello Dundee, this is how the body shot happened:

Ali was dancing around, Marciano was crouching trying to get inside, Ali threw a high jab, knocking Marciano's wig off his head. They stopped filming and readjusted the wig. Marciano was embarassed and said "He did that on purprose, he has no respect for me at all." They reassured him that it was an accident, and filming continued.

Ali again threw a jab and again the wig went flying. Marciano yelled out "Don't you do that again!" as they stopped filming and refitted his wig. Filming continued, and whether it was just an accident or Ali was just clowning nobody knows, but again there was a jab and again the wig went flying---Marciano didn't hesitate and hit Ali with a viscous body shot, doubling him over and dropping him. Filming was stopped.

Marciano had to be calmed down, as he was literally pissed off, and even so much as called Ali out right then and there to turn it into a real fight if Ali was game. Only until after Ali apologised did Marciano calm down, and filming again proceeded.

Now what is true, at least by Ali's own admission, is that Marciano beat him to the body so badly that he was bruised and had welts all over his rib cage and his elbow was even injured---as Marciano beat on Ali's arms---and even asked for a few extra dollars and a few days off.

Ali in his own autobiography was quoted that "My whole body ached, and ours wasn't even a real fight," and he was surprised that even at 46 years old, how hard it was to land a solid punch on Marciano, and that he couldn't imagine how a prime Marciano must have been, because Marciano was so strong and powerful a hitter, even at 46 years old.

The 'real' body shot must have ended up on the cutting room floor; you must remember that all the reels of the film and copies, except for one, was destroyed after the SUPERFIGHT was shown in theatres and on WIDE WORLD OF SPORTS in 1970, so if there ever was film of it, it's been long gone.
This is mostly BS.
First of all, he is twisting Ferdie Pacheco's version. Pacheco talked about the Marciano-Ali movie in his book "A View From the Corner", p. 90, Carol Publishing Group, Copyright 1992.
He said that Ali took the whole thing as a joke, while Marciano was serious. Once in awhile, while filming, Marciano would in the heat of the moment get excited and go all out. "At one point, Ali went down to one knee after a body shot and we had to call time". Ali hadn't been expecting the blow; Marciano had unwittingly sucker-punched him,and felt bad about it".

There was no mention whatsoever of Ali knocking Marciano's toupee off or Marciano being mad at Ali about anything.

Also IrishrufusMurphy statement that Ali in own autobiography was quoted that "My whole body ached and ours wasn't even a real fight" simply isn't true.
In Ali's autobiography he doesn't say anything like that at all. He barely mentions the Marciano film in passing and doesn't say anything specific about it except to say that it was phony.

The Ali-Marciano film was made for entertainment. (There were various endings. Sometimes Ali wins, sometimes Marciano) This wasn't a real fight, or even sparring. It's obvious that punches are pulled, and that they are overreating to what the other guy is doing. It's almost universally recognized as something not to be taken seriously.
HomicideHenry
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 18722
Joined: 08 Sep 2005, 00:43

Post by HomicideHenry »

Well Dundee admits to the wig episode and in some issues of Ring Magzine throughout the years it quotes Ali as saying:

"My whole body ached and ours wasn't even a real fight."

There were several witnesses: Woroner, Pacheco, Dundee mainly who stated that Ali was doubled over and dropped with a body shot, and that Ali even asked for a few extra dollars and time to take off because of the body punching Marciano did to Ali [mainly elbow injuries] because Marciano beat Ali on the arms repeatedly throughout the contest.

Mind you the ring had to have been 16x16 because Rocky always fought in smaller rings, and possibly because he was older and slower and being in a 24x24 ring like Ali was used to would have made Marciano look awful on film. That's why you see Ali throwing a helluva lot more punches than he normally would in the computer fight than he did in actual fights.

I ain't saying Ali took a shot from Marciano and dropped to the canvas while he was prepared to take such a shot---but Marciano did warn him to not knock his wig off anymore and when Ali did it again, Marciano didn't even hesitate and let loose. For a man 14yrs inactive and had to lose 60 pounds and facing an Ali who 2yrs prior was in his prime and still had the Frazier, Foreman, Norton fights ahead of him is saying something.

Marciano on the computer fight looked pretty good, though they was following a script from the NCR-315 computer. There were times in that film where both Ali and Marciano do throw hard connecting shots at eachother [Marciano when Ali was on the ropes and in corners and Ali when he would get away and whip viscous fast shots at Marciano].

I have reviewed the fight over and over, and if you have that suspension of disbelief, you have to think, if a 45yr old Marciano could move that good show or not, imagine the prime Marciano actually going full-tilt on Ali, because there were times in the film where I know Marciano would have did more to Ali, but didn't because it wasn't in the script.

Call it BS if you want, and say that the computer fight was crap, but irreagrdless whether they were acting and pulling punches in places, it was the two men in there sparring and if Marciano could move in on Ali that good at that stage in life...it would be an AWESOME fight.
Ambling Alp
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 3627
Joined: 15 Jul 2005, 22:31

Post by Ambling Alp »

I'm calling some of your earlier comments BS.
Your quote that you claim was in Ali's autobiography was completely bogus. (now you are saying that it was in "some issues of Ring Magazines)
Pacheco's account wasn't at all like you described it.
There is no reason to believe the rest of your unsubstantiated claims.

As for the clip from the Ali-Marciano film, you say that "There were times in that film that both ali and Marciano do throw hard connecting shots at each other".
Are you that naive? Marciano was throwing wild roundhouse punches that you could see coming a mile away. He wouldn't have thrown those type of punches in a real fight. Ali wouldn't be hit hit by these kind of punches.
Ali clearly wasn't throwing serious punches. (He hardly used his right hand at all) He didn't even try to hit Marciano in the face at all. It's obvious that he is aiming for Marciano's gloves.

As for your comment "Call it BS if you want and say that the computer fight was crap, but irregardless wether they were acting and pulling punches in places, it was the two men in there sparring and if Marciano could move in on Ali that good at that stage in life.. it would be an awesome fight".
Wow. There is no question that they were acting and pulling punches.
They weren't SPARRING. They were ACTING. Marciano could move in on Ali because Ali wasn't hitting Marciano in the face (or using lateral movement) because it was a FILM.
It's mind-boggling that someone would take this film seriously.
HomicideHenry
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 18722
Joined: 08 Sep 2005, 00:43

Post by HomicideHenry »

The quotes of Ali on Marciano [in the RING MAGAZINE] articles can be found in:

1- THE RING EXTRA February 2005

Look under the article FROM CORBETT TO DE LA HOYA, NOBODY LIKES IT TO THE BODY, page 44 is the beginning of the article and the Marciano reference that Ali was quoted from is on page 48.

It states as follows:

After sparring for the benefit of their 1969 "computer fight", Muhammad Ali was astonished by Marciano's bodypunching. Ali said. "My whole body ached, and ours wasn't even a real fight."

In Ali's autobiography THE GREATEST Ali is quoted that Marciano was alot harder to hit than he would have thought and that Ali could only imagine how strong Marciano was in his prime.

Go to this website dedicated to Marciano and it has these same quotes and numerous other quotes from people associated with Marciano, some with more adequate information and dates:

http://www.geocities.com/Colosseum/Arena/1047/Rock.html
TheOneIsHere2008
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 1181
Joined: 01 Jul 2008, 12:09

Re:

Post by TheOneIsHere2008 »

Muhammad Ali liked and respected Marciano...He always called him "Champ" and went to his funeral...He wasn't going to try to hurt a forty six year old man, fifteen years or so removed from his last fight, when they were making a movie-computer simulation ...
Crease
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 16865
Joined: 13 Oct 2005, 10:19

Re: Modern Day "All-Time Heavyweight" Tournament

Post by Crease »

I just knew this was going to happen...

Everytime someone does a "All-Time Heavyweight Tournament", if Rocky Marciano and Muhammad Ali end up fighting, this whole "Wig Story2 is brought up...

The probem is that there is no conclusive evidence to back it up, I knew that Murray Woroner (who was quite neutral throughout the sparring) said that the Wig Episdoe was real, that Ali was crumpled on his knees and that Aii did ask for more currency to resume the session...

Sadly, there are people in this forum who just will not refuse to accept the fact that this is a remote possiblity which could have very well happened... So believe me guys, this is not going to be resolved... Probably 3 months down the line, It will be mentioned again...

Now, I for one, believe that it may very well have happened... It sound like the kind of thing Ali and Marciano would do or behave.... Rocky was very concerned about his reputation before going into this session, whereas Ali always liked ot think of himself as "The Greatest".... (And he became even more vocal after his 1st loss to Frazier)... Personally, I believe even an Old Marciano could ahve hurt Ali...
p4p1
Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Posts: 5854
Joined: 23 Apr 2007, 07:43

Re: Modern Day "All-Time Heavyweight" Tournament

Post by p4p1 »

reading far to much into the bodyshot thing if it is true when was the last time ali took bodyshots or did body conditioning and when your not foing it regularly there is a massive diffference
Post Reply