Page 5 of 5

Re: What's the biggest robbery you've seen in boxing?

Posted: 12 May 2016, 21:58
by Kalan
Ruthless-RKO wrote:Roy Jones Jr. getting DQ'd against Griffin. Yes Griffin had a game plan, but I've seen worse in the boxing ring. DQ was too much. If it wasn't for that, RJJ would have gone 50-0 before losing to Tarver.
Roy hit Griffin twice when he was clearly on his knees.. Griffin was simply a fast thinker and did something very smart. It worked - although it was dishonest as Hell.. So if you're getting trashed... and you take a knee... and your opponent hits you twice.. and you pretend you're out.. It makes sense to give it a try because you're in the process of getting bombed out - so a point deduction on your opponent does you no good.

Andre Dirrell may have actually been knocked out by Arthur Abraham when he slipped to his knee. That is I think he was. I'm not sure. But Abraham didn't think so. He said "He's a good actor." ... Abraham took a full cut and caught Dirrell on the chin but AD's head swiveled with the shot.

Re: What's the biggest robbery you've seen in boxing?

Posted: 12 May 2016, 23:04
by SaadOffTheDeck
:lol:

Jones hit Montell 1,000 times harder than Abraham 'hit' Dirrell. You're hilarious.

Re: What's the biggest robbery you've seen in boxing?

Posted: 13 May 2016, 03:37
by TooEasy12
It probably wasn't the worst ever, but Chudinov-Sturm 2 was a disgrace.

Re: What's the biggest robbery you've seen in boxing?

Posted: 13 May 2016, 11:36
by PredatorHayds
TooEasy12 wrote:It probably wasn't the worst ever, but Chudinov-Sturm 2 was a disgrace.
He clearly win the 2nd one. I thought the 1st one was close and actually had Sturm nicking it.

Re: What's the biggest robbery you've seen in boxing?

Posted: 13 May 2016, 11:42
by crusader
PredatorHayds wrote:
TooEasy12 wrote:It probably wasn't the worst ever, but Chudinov-Sturm 2 was a disgrace.
He clearly win the 2nd one. I thought the 1st one was close and actually had Sturm nicking it.
Absolutely no way Sturm should've won the first. How the fornicate did you end up with him ahead?

Re: What's the biggest robbery you've seen in boxing?

Posted: 13 May 2016, 11:45
by PredatorHayds
crusader wrote:
PredatorHayds wrote:
TooEasy12 wrote:It probably wasn't the worst ever, but Chudinov-Sturm 2 was a disgrace.
He clearly win the 2nd one. I thought the 1st one was close and actually had Sturm nicking it.
Absolutely no way Sturm should've won the first. How the eff did you end up with him ahead?
He did his usual step on the gas for the last minute trick.
I had it close and wasn't shouting robbery when it went to Chudinov.
Need to check my scorecard but I think I had it around 115-113.

Re: What's the biggest robbery you've seen in boxing?

Posted: 14 May 2016, 07:41
by SportsRatings
Syntax Error wrote:
PredatorHayds wrote:
Ricky_ wrote:Pulev only getting a split vs chisora :lol:
Worst scorecard of the year.

I thought Del-Boy won 2 rounds tops.

Loved how when Chisora put his hands up on the final bell Pulev burst out laughing.
:lol: :lol:

That was funny.

Chisora must have thought he'd try his luck. :lol:


That would make a great thread of its own -- the most ridiculous case of a boxer holding up the "I WON" hands at the end of a fight he clearly lost. I know I've seen it many times but can't recall the specific fights.

Re: What's the biggest robbery you've seen in boxing?

Posted: 14 May 2016, 09:02
by Perseus
For me the worst was Holyfield-Lewis 1.
I was a big fan of Holyfield and that fight being declared a draw was a disgrace.

A lesser known one that comes to mind is William Joppy vs Julio Cesar Green 1. Green was given a hometown decision in a fight Joppy clearly won. Don King set up a rematch which Joppy won with ease then set up a trilogy nobody wanted to see by having a third fight that was not competitive and won easily by Joppy.
Same path as the Paquiao/Bradley trilogy but below the mainstream radar.

Re: What's the biggest robbery you've seen in boxing?

Posted: 14 May 2016, 18:02
by Keko
Like a Boss wrote:
Rexob wrote:RJJ Olympics! :o
Biggest ever. Roy would have had to brutally KO Park Si-hun to get a draw. When it went the distance he had no chance :TU:
:evil: big scam

Re: What's the biggest robbery you've seen in boxing?

Posted: 14 May 2016, 20:13
by Like a Boss
Keko wrote:
Like a Boss wrote:
Rexob wrote:RJJ Olympics! :o
Biggest ever. Roy would have had to brutally KO Park Si-hun to get a draw. When it went the distance he had no chance :TU:
:evil: big scam
Huge!

Re: What's the biggest robbery you've seen in boxing?

Posted: 14 May 2016, 20:24
by SaadOffTheDeck
Kalan wrote:
Ruthless-RKO wrote:Roy Jones Jr. getting DQ'd against Griffin. Yes Griffin had a game plan, but I've seen worse in the boxing ring. DQ was too much. If it wasn't for that, RJJ would have gone 50-0 before losing to Tarver.
Roy hit Griffin twice when he was clearly on his knees.. Griffin was simply a fast thinker and did something very smart. It worked - although it was dishonest as Hell.. So if you're getting trashed... and you take a knee... and your opponent hits you twice.. and you pretend you're out.. It makes sense to give it a try because you're in the process of getting bombed out - so a point deduction on your opponent does you no good.

Andre Dirrell may have actually been knocked out by Arthur Abraham when he slipped to his knee. That is I think he was. I'm not sure. But Abraham didn't think so. He said "He's a good actor." ... Abraham took a full cut and caught Dirrell on the chin but AD's head swiveled with the shot.
Jones hit Griffin 100 times harder than art's little slap on the faker. I have faith that someday you'll type something correct.

Re: What's the biggest robbery you've seen in boxing?

Posted: 14 May 2016, 22:21
by Cutman Scabbers
G.McClellan wrote:
fistic mystic wrote:De La Hoya -vs- Trinidad (ODLH was robbed, the worst I have ever seen)


Marvin Hagler v Ray Leonard was the first robbery I witnessed. It's still in my top 2.

I thought so too when I watched it live.

But when I watched it years later, with the sound off, I thought, "well, Leonard won that."

Re: What's the biggest robbery you've seen in boxing?

Posted: 14 May 2016, 22:30
by babyjesus
casamayor vs santa cruz late 2000's. santa cruz dominated and that was that. i should've lost 270 and instead won a 100

Re: What's the biggest robbery you've seen in boxing?

Posted: 15 May 2016, 01:22
by G.McClellan
Cutman Scabbers wrote:
G.McClellan wrote:
fistic mystic wrote:De La Hoya -vs- Trinidad (ODLH was robbed, the worst I have ever seen)


Marvin Hagler v Ray Leonard was the first robbery I witnessed. It's still in my top 2.

I thought so too when I watched it live.

But when I watched it years later, with the sound off, I thought, "well, Leonard won that."
The only people who are convinced Leonard won that fight are his PR team and those they managed to convince. I wonder which category you fall under?

Re: What's the biggest robbery you've seen in boxing?

Posted: 15 May 2016, 03:14
by Cutman Scabbers
G.McClellan wrote:
Cutman Scabbers wrote:
G.McClellan wrote:

I thought so too when I watched it live.

But when I watched it years later, with the sound off, I thought, "well, Leonard won that."
The only people who are convinced Leonard won that fight are his PR team and those they managed to convince. I wonder which category you fall under?

Neither. I really, really wanted Hagler to win that fight.

Re: What's the biggest robbery you've seen in boxing?

Posted: 15 May 2016, 04:24
by Kootenay47
Ike Quartey vs Vernon Forrest was a robbery . Clearly Quartey won the fight .

Re: What's the biggest robbery you've seen in boxing?

Posted: 15 May 2016, 08:18
by Perseus
Kootenay47 wrote:Ike Quartey vs Vernon Forrest was a robbery . Clearly Quartey won the fight .
:TU:
Good call. Had forgotten that one until you posted it.

Re: What's the biggest robbery you've seen in boxing?

Posted: 15 May 2016, 14:22
by Tanzio
Like a Boss wrote:
Keko wrote:
Like a Boss wrote:
Biggest ever. Roy would have had to brutally KO Park Si-hun to get a draw. When it went the distance he had no chance :TU:
:evil: big scam
Huge!
Gigantuos! :KO:

Re: What's the biggest robbery you've seen in boxing?

Posted: 16 May 2016, 12:15
by SaadOffTheDeck
G.McClellan wrote:
Cutman Scabbers wrote:
G.McClellan wrote:

I thought so too when I watched it live.

But when I watched it years later, with the sound off, I thought, "well, Leonard won that."
The only people who are convinced Leonard won that fight are his PR team and those they managed to convince. I wonder which category you fall under?
I hate Leonard more than Satan and I think he won that fight.

Re: What's the biggest robbery you've seen in boxing?

Posted: 16 May 2016, 12:23
by Syntax Error
G.McClellan wrote:
Cutman Scabbers wrote:
G.McClellan wrote:

I thought so too when I watched it live.

But when I watched it years later, with the sound off, I thought, "well, Leonard won that."
The only people who are convinced Leonard won that fight are his PR team and those they managed to convince. I wonder which category you fall under?
Categorically untrue.

I've always thought Leonard edged that fight & nobody convinced me to think it.

It was close, but I thought Hagler peed the fight away by arsing about, cursing & trying to make out he was 'the man' rather than just concentrating on putting some hurt on Leonard.

I believe that deep down, Marvin knows this & that is why he is so bitter today, almost a staggering 30 years later.

Re: What's the biggest robbery you've seen in boxing?

Posted: 16 May 2016, 12:51
by SaadOffTheDeck
Leonard clearly won the first four rounds.