Round-by-Round: Dillian Whyte vs. Dereck Chisora II - 22 December 2018

[skanksta]

"What you like" again. Edwards is winning @ AM boxing, Rosales @ Pro.
I'll say Edwards on ring-generalship - he's sticking to his gameplan while CR is a little frustrated.

28-30 CE

but wouldn't blame anyone for having 30-27 either way.

[skanksta]

Edwards clearly - he's boxing beautifully.

37-40 The Wee Cheesy Penis Pecker !

[gilgamesh]

Whether he wins or not Edwards is definitely showing that he is indeed much more prepared for this level than he was for the Casimero fight. He's doing well.

I got it even after 4. The 4th was very good for Charlie.

[ewenhay]

"What you like" again. Edwards is winning @ AM boxing, Rosales @ Pro.
I'll say Edwards on ring-generalship - he's sticking to his gameplan while CR is a little frustrated.

28-30 CE

but wouldn't blame anyone for having 30-27 either way.

It should never be about "what you like". Judges are paid to make decisions based on clear criteria.

[skanksta]

Edwards is pulling away with back-foot boxing for me, but it's close and Rosales is clearly the more powerful.
50-46 Wee Pecker.

[skanksta]

"What you like" again. Edwards is winning @ AM boxing, Rosales @ Pro.
I'll say Edwards on ring-generalship - he's sticking to his gameplan while CR is a little frustrated.

28-30 CE

but wouldn't blame anyone for having 30-27 either way.

It should never be about "what you like". Judges are paid to make decisions based on clear criteria.

Yeah, but it's not an exact science is it - do you prefer numerous accurate light punches or a few harder blows ?

[MightyWarrior]

Clearly I have no idea what I’m talking about, impressive from Edward here

[jamamb]

i have it even

10-10
10-9 ed
10-9 ros
10-9 ed
10-9 ros

i dont really see edwards pulling away. at least in the 3rd and 5th he was overly negative, ros defo won the 5th imo

[Neil Gee]

Edwards is pulling away with back-foot boxing for me, but it's close and Rosales is clearly the more powerful.
50-46 Wee Pecker.

. I still have it even. I gave Rosales round 5&3

[jamamb]

ya same for me, no way imo did edards win the 5th

[ewenhay]

"What you like" again. Edwards is winning @ AM boxing, Rosales @ Pro.
I'll say Edwards on ring-generalship - he's sticking to his gameplan while CR is a little frustrated.

28-30 CE

but wouldn't blame anyone for having 30-27 either way.

It should never be about "what you like". Judges are paid to make decisions based on clear criteria.

Yeah, but it's not an exact science is it - do you prefer numerous accurate light punches or a few harder blows ?

Numerous accurate light punches. The odd flash shot shouldn't win a round if the fighter has been outboxed the rest of the round.

If that was the case lighter hitting punchers would be as well hanging up their gloves.

[skanksta]

I'm going to give CR a round. Close again, but he seemed to put a dent in CE.
59-56 Wee Pecker.

[skanksta]

It should never be about "what you like". Judges are paid to make decisions based on clear criteria.

Yeah, but it's not an exact science is it - do you prefer numerous accurate light punches or a few harder blows ?

Numerous accurate light punches. The odd flash shot shouldn't win a round if the fighter has been outboxed the rest of the round.

If that was the case lighter hitting punchers would be as well hanging up their gloves.

I tend to agree, but US judges don't do they ?
"The Hurt Business" and all that.

[ewenhay]

Yeah, but it's not an exact science is it - do you prefer numerous accurate light punches or a few harder blows ?

Numerous accurate light punches. The odd flash shot shouldn't win a round if the fighter has been outboxed the rest of the round.

If that was the case lighter hitting punchers would be as well hanging up their gloves.

I tend to agree, but US judges don't do they ?
"The Hurt Business" and all that.

I'm not having a go at you. This "what you like" stuff just encourages shit scoring.

Last time I checked "what you like" wasn't on the list of scoring criteria for judges.

[jamamb]

edwards holding more in the 7th. is he bleeding?

[jamamb]

Numerous accurate light punches. The odd flash shot shouldn't win a round if the fighter has been outboxed the rest of the round.

If that was the case lighter hitting punchers would be as well hanging up their gloves.

I tend to agree, but US judges don't do they ?
"The Hurt Business" and all that.

I'm not having a go at you. This "what you like" stuff just encourages poo scoring.

Last time I checked "what you like" wasn't on the list of scoring criteria for judges.

the list of criteria also doesnt really suggest that clearly more light blows should be favoured over fewer heavy ones

[jamamb]

macklins gone full edwards, no way imo did he win the 5th or 7th

[jamamb]

8th for rosales, edwards maybe feeling it a bit or bothered by the cut. macklin probably gave that to edwards too

[Neil Gee]

Definitely give R the 8th. He landed harder and as often if not more than Edwards.

[skanksta]

87-85 Edwards

[jamamb]

9th to rosales too, mightve hurt edwards a bit, edwards has faded a bit the last few rounds

[Neil Gee]

Can't be bothered working it out on the 10 point must. R one point ahead.

[gilgamesh]

I got Edwards up 6-3

Rosales has had his moments, but Edwards has had a lot more of him. He's fighting great. If he can keep it up for the last 3 rounds he should have this, but Rosales is gonna be dangerous every step of the way so he can't let up.

[skanksta]

96-95 CR won the 10th

[BobD'Mello]

96-95 CR won the 10th

You think? Thought he barely landed in that round.