BoxRec

You need help.

my list


1.Vic
2.Geale
3.Katsidis
4.Mundine
5.Ndou
6.Dib
7.Medley
8.Soliman
9.Kickett
10.Pittman

Liver Crusher wrote:my list


1.Vic
2.Geale
3.Katsidis
4.Mundine
5.Ndou
6.Dib
7.Medley
8.Soliman
9.Kickett
10.Pittman

How can Geale be so high?

It can't be from natural talent. Because if it was on talent, we know who would be top.

And if its based on wins its Vic.

And if its based on will its Kat.

?

Hey Ultimate boxa2

Can you answer these questions:

How old are you?
You fight?
What gym or area of sydney you from?
Do you stir up people on line :) but wouldnt do it to there face?

Liver Crusher wrote:Hey Ultimate boxa2

Can you answer these questions:

How old are you?
You fight?
What gym or area of sydney you from?
Do you stir up people on line :) but wouldnt do it to there face?

24

A few amateur fights but got injured, so now im just doing training. Still love the sport.

Im actually from Melbourne. Im moving back down there in a couple of weeks for work. In melbourne i have my own gym, so i just train there.

No i don't just stir people up on the internet. And if i have a belief in boxing, i will say it to someones face.

This is a short list of what i stand for in the sport:

1. Calzaghe and Kessler are the best fighters from MW to LHW.
2. Vic is our P4P #1.
3. Mundine needs to fight a big fight soon.
4. Katsidis is a warrior.
5. Pavlik is a flawed fighter, and its only an amount of time until he looses.
6. I don't rate Froch highly.
7. I think Taylor will do a number on Lacy.
8. Manny Pacquaio isn't my P4P #1.
9. Nonito Donaire and Linares are the two most naturally gifted young and coming fighters i have seen.
10. I don't like seeing robberies. I don't like watching wars. I would rather watch a technically gifted fighter fighting, then two guys with more will than skill.

I don't just go on the net to stir things up. I try to say it how it is. I'll admit a lot of the time im wrong. But i guess everyones wrong, as we all have different interpretations of the sport.

And people shouldn't take these things personally. This is boxing. And if i bag out a pro boxer, like Froch. Im not saying hes a crap fighter. Im saying i don't rate him on the world scene. And i respect everything he has done to get where he is.

Ultimateboxa2 wrote:

Liver Crusher wrote:Hey Ultimate boxa2

Can you answer these questions:

How old are you?
You fight?
What gym or area of sydney you from?
Do you stir up people on line :) but wouldnt do it to there face?

24

A few amateur fights but got injured, so now im just doing training. Still love the sport.

Im actually from Melbourne. Im moving back down there in a couple of weeks for work. In melbourne i have my own gym, so i just train there.

No i don't just stir people up on the internet. And if i have a belief in boxing, i will say it to someones face.

This is a short list of what i stand for in the sport:

1. Calzaghe and Kessler are the best fighters from MW to LHW.
2. Vic is our P4P #1.
3. Mundine needs to fight a big fight soon.
4. Katsidis is a warrior.
5. Pavlik is a flawed fighter, and its only an amount of time until he looses.
6. I don't rate Froch highly.
7. I think Taylor will do a number on Lacy.
8. Manny Pacquaio isn't my P4P #1.
9. Nonito Donaire and Linares are the two most naturally gifted young and coming fighters i have seen.
10. I don't like seeing robberies. I don't like watching wars. I would rather watch a technically gifted fighter fighting, then two guys with more will than skill.

I don't just go on the net to stir things up. I try to say it how it is. I'll admit a lot of the time im wrong. But i guess everyones wrong, as we all have different interpretations of the sport.

And people shouldn't take these things personally. This is boxing. And if i bag out a pro boxer, like Froch. Im not saying hes a crap fighter. Im saying i don't rate him on the world scene. And i respect everything he has done to get where he is.

thanks for the lowdown. About the above, i think it would be much more accurate to say that you "try to say it as you see it".

My list as of the 28/08/08

Darchinyin
Katsidis
Mundine
Geale
Meehan
Kickett
Zappavigna
De Mori
Dib

Cant honestly give a top ten list,but thier are other good fighters.

Soliman
Humono
Pitman
Lovett
Bika
Gostelow
Tuasa

I'm glad people are posting lists after the vote

Marlin wrote:I'm glad people are posting lists after the vote

however it is nice to get the interest, even if it is belated.

Do we need a vote on anyone after the fights last night?

Marlin wrote:Do we need a vote on anyone after the fights last night?

Lenny Zappa.

don't think so mate, level of opposition doesn't warrant moving up.

If Zappa cant be in the list because of level of opponents then Mundine shouldnt be on there

oh, the innocence of youth.

unleash06 wrote:oh, the innocence of youth.

Anyone from victoria shouldn't take part in list...as they are not normal

my list was in on time.....

Auzzie001 wrote:If Zappa cant be in the list because of level of opponents then Mundine shouldnt be on there

Zappa's fought no-one decent fair dinkum!!

Get over it

Liver Crusher wrote:Zappa's fought no-one decent fair dinkum!!

Get over it

Yet you put Medley in your P4P list.. Hes a good fighter but he has been fighting cab drivers too..

cab drivers?? bulls&$t.

Liver Crusher wrote:cab drivers?? bulls&$t.

Fine maybe not cab drivers but they arnt world class fighters, 9-8 isnt exactly a great record and that was his latest fight..

Auzzie001 wrote:

Liver Crusher wrote:cab drivers?? bulls&$t.

Fine maybe not cab drivers but they arnt world class fighters, 9-8 isnt exactly a great record and that was his latest fight..

hey thanks for running that Marlin, my computers been dead for a while now

No worries mate, what doyou think of thye list?