Calzaghe or Hatton in the history books?

[lvlarc]

Calzaghe > Hatton

[Dioufy]

Calzaghe was still in his prime when he faced Jones. Regardless of Jones' inadequacies, I still didn't see signs of Calzaghe slipping.

The first round was a sign that he was slipping. His punch resistance was going.

I disagree. Calzaghe was always decked with shots he didn't see. The Hopkins KD wasn't heavy and the Jones KD was done with Jones' forearm. Perhaps if being decked is signs of your chin going then what about the Salem and Mitchell KD's?