BoxRec

Perseus wrote: ↑23 Apr 2023, 07:29 Who is Shirley?

Adislav123 is the biggest one !

lazboy wrote: ↑23 Apr 2023, 05:45 I’ll be surprised if Garcia can recover from this mentally.

He seemed ok

CompuBox Stats

Hopefully now RG will do more of his talking in the ring. He reminds me of Rolly R. I'm sure a few million teenaged girl fans are crying now.

Tank needs to continue his journey towards the top. Him vs Shak S. next would be awesome. Good fight for both. Good start. The better man won.

When you're asked if you think your the face of boxing and then you keep saying you are the face of boxing..

You're not the face of boxing.

Ruthless-RKO wrote: ↑23 Apr 2023, 11:01 When you're asked if you think your the face of boxing and then you keep saying you are the face of boxing..

You're not the face of boxing.

Canelo is still the face of boxing. Tank has a long way to go to get there and he probably never will unless he beats a couple of Haney, Stevenson, Loma etc which is a big ask.

skanksta wrote: ↑23 Apr 2023, 07:02 Some after-timing here Shirley..?

Nope. Said it all before the fight.

Counter-puncher wrote: ↑23 Apr 2023, 11:30

skanksta wrote: ↑23 Apr 2023, 07:02 Some after-timing here Shirley..?

Nope. Said it all before the fight.

Me too.

DrDuke wrote: ↑12 Aug 2022, 02:14 Davis wins. Both are bangers, but Davis' defense is more polished, while Garcia tends to attack with his chin being opened. Davis will catch Garcia at some point. Probably it will be a repetition of the Romero fight.

Over/under was 1:30 of round 7. time of KO was 1:44-I went with the over; whew !

WestEndRiot wrote: ↑23 Apr 2023, 04:27

skanksta wrote: ↑23 Apr 2023, 00:18 Those cards are shocking and should be investigated- not again boxing !

Glad they didn’t matter.

I really like those cards. Garcia was clearly winning R2 for 2 minutes, Tank didn't land a single punch. Garcia was aggressive, landed a few and Tank kept jumping in and holding.

It is unusual for it not to be 10-8, but I feel 10-9, or even 10-10 is a more fair reflection, and I'd like to see it more often

Even if Garcia was clearly winning the second round despite the knockdown, shouldn't it be scored 9-9? Or if he was cleeeaaarly winning 9-8? Where the hell did that 10-10 come from?

JackSprocket wrote: ↑23 Apr 2023, 12:53

WestEndRiot wrote: ↑23 Apr 2023, 04:27

skanksta wrote: ↑23 Apr 2023, 00:18 Those cards are shocking and should be investigated- not again boxing !

Glad they didn’t matter.

I really like those cards. Garcia was clearly winning R2 for 2 minutes, Tank didn't land a single punch. Garcia was aggressive, landed a few and Tank kept jumping in and holding.

It is unusual for it not to be 10-8, but I feel 10-9, or even 10-10 is a more fair reflection, and I'd like to see it more often

Even if Garcia was clearly winning the second round despite the knockdown, shouldn't it be scored 9-9? Or if he was cleeeaaarly winning 9-8? Where the hell did that 10-10 come from?

Barring a point deduction, atleast one guy has to get 10 points. A drawn round is 10-10, not 9-9.

joshj909 wrote: ↑23 Apr 2023, 13:14

JackSprocket wrote: ↑23 Apr 2023, 12:53

WestEndRiot wrote: ↑23 Apr 2023, 04:27

I really like those cards. Garcia was clearly winning R2 for 2 minutes, Tank didn't land a single punch. Garcia was aggressive, landed a few and Tank kept jumping in and holding.

It is unusual for it not to be 10-8, but I feel 10-9, or even 10-10 is a more fair reflection, and I'd like to see it more often

Even if Garcia was clearly winning the second round despite the knockdown, shouldn't it be scored 9-9? Or if he was cleeeaaarly winning 9-8? Where the hell did that 10-10 come from?

Barring a point deduction, atleast one guy has to get 10 points. A drawn round is 10-10, not 9-9.

A drawn round in this case would be a 10-9 round.

joshj909 wrote: ↑23 Apr 2023, 13:14

JackSprocket wrote: ↑23 Apr 2023, 12:53

WestEndRiot wrote: ↑23 Apr 2023, 04:27

I really like those cards. Garcia was clearly winning R2 for 2 minutes, Tank didn't land a single punch. Garcia was aggressive, landed a few and Tank kept jumping in and holding.

It is unusual for it not to be 10-8, but I feel 10-9, or even 10-10 is a more fair reflection, and I'd like to see it more often

Even if Garcia was clearly winning the second round despite the knockdown, shouldn't it be scored 9-9? Or if he was cleeeaaarly winning 9-8? Where the hell did that 10-10 come from?

Barring a point deduction, atleast one guy has to get 10 points. A drawn round is 10-10, not 9-9.

I'm pretty sure I've seen rounds with multiple knockdowns officially scored 8-7 or something like that...

JackSprocket wrote: ↑23 Apr 2023, 12:53

WestEndRiot wrote: ↑23 Apr 2023, 04:27

skanksta wrote: ↑23 Apr 2023, 00:18 Those cards are shocking and should be investigated- not again boxing !

Glad they didn’t matter.

I really like those cards. Garcia was clearly winning R2 for 2 minutes, Tank didn't land a single punch. Garcia was aggressive, landed a few and Tank kept jumping in and holding.

It is unusual for it not to be 10-8, but I feel 10-9, or even 10-10 is a more fair reflection, and I'd like to see it more often

Even if Garcia was clearly winning the second round despite the knockdown, shouldn't it be scored 9-9? Or if he was cleeeaaarly winning 9-8? Where the hell did that 10-10 come from?

I do agree that there should be more 10-10s (for nothing rounds - esp R1s) and 10-8s given a little more generously AND more 9-9s and whatnot - rather than the automatically brain-free 10-8...,
But TWO 10-9s AND a 10-10 is "WTF - is this cheating..?"

DrDuke wrote: ↑23 Apr 2023, 12:20

Counter-puncher wrote: ↑23 Apr 2023, 11:30

skanksta wrote: ↑23 Apr 2023, 07:02 Some after-timing here Shirley..?

Nope. Said it all before the fight.

Me too.

DrDuke wrote: ↑12 Aug 2022, 02:14 Davis wins. Both are bangers, but Davis' defense is more polished, while Garcia tends to attack with his chin being opened. Davis will catch Garcia at some point. Probably it will be a repetition of the Romero fight.

Well fair play to both of you, but Tank was the favourite. I didn't see (m)any saying, "This fight is 66/33 in the betting but it really should be 92/8" (like it was after 4 mins).

IKSRTFO wrote: ↑23 Apr 2023, 13:55

joshj909 wrote: ↑23 Apr 2023, 13:14

JackSprocket wrote: ↑23 Apr 2023, 12:53
Even if Garcia was clearly winning the second round despite the knockdown, shouldn't it be scored 9-9? Or if he was cleeeaaarly winning 9-8? Where the hell did that 10-10 come from?

Barring a point deduction, atleast one guy has to get 10 points. A drawn round is 10-10, not 9-9.

A drawn round in this case would be a 10-9 round.

I'm not sure about that. If I'm not mistaken, a knockdown doesn't automatically prompt a point taken off the boxer knocked down, it just usually does. So a draw is still a 10-10. 10-9 would be a close round as each boxer had their dominant spells with Garcia dominating for 2 minutes while Tank scored the knockdown.