BoxRec

expe wrote:

Baby Face Finster wrote:Did anyone besides me notice that after Lee was droppwd for the second time near the end of the first round that the time clock stop for a good 10 seconds at least? If you rewatch the second KD you will notice that when the ref finished his count there were 10 seconds left but the round went on for another 20 seconds. Looks like something shady went down.

I saw him go down but it was after the bell, wasn't scored.

Rewatch it if you can. After the ref finishes his count there is like 10 seconds left but the round goes on for at least another 20 seconds.

Even with the 3 knock downs in the first 3 rounds i still scored the fight a draw. The distinct lack of work rate from rounds 4 onwards cost Quillin the fight. I suppose one or two rounds were hard to split as very little was thrown and i don't think either man can be upset the fight was a draw. Fair result and close judging.

Baby Face Finster wrote:

expe wrote:

Baby Face Finster wrote:Did anyone besides me notice that after Lee was droppwd for the second time near the end of the first round that the time clock stop for a good 10 seconds at least? If you rewatch the second KD you will notice that when the ref finished his count there were 10 seconds left but the round went on for another 20 seconds. Looks like something shady went down.

I saw him go down but it was after the bell, wasn't scored.

Rewatch it if you can. After the ref finishes his count there is like 10 seconds left but the round goes on for at least another 20 seconds.

Seemed fine on the first round knockdown, I meant the second one in that round that some people seem to be scoring, the ref waved it off and called no knockdown. I've already seen a 4 minute round tonight, followed by a 2 minute round that began with a beachball being thrown into the ring, so 10 seconds out doesn't seem much.

Total Punches Landed

Peter Quillin 103 out of 267 , 38,67% Landed
Andy Lee 113 out of 299 , 37,79% Landed

expe wrote:

Aaronide_ger wrote:I had it

1st 10-7 Quillin (2 knockdowns)
2nd 10-9 Quillin
3rd 9-9 Draw (1 shitty knockdown but Lee won the round thus draw)
4th 10-9 Lee
5th 10-9 Quillin
6th 10-9 Quillin
7th 10-8 Lee (1 Knockdown)
8th 10-9 Lee
9th 10-9 Lee
10th 10-9 Quillin
11st 10-9 Lee
12nd 10-9 Lee

112-112 Draw...

2nd knockdown in the first came after the bell and wasn't counted.

Then

1st 10-8 Quillin (1 knockdown)
2nd 10-9 Quillin
3rd 9-9 Draw (1 shitty knockdown but Lee won the round thus draw)
4th 10-9 Lee
5th 10-9 Quillin
6th 10-9 Quillin
7th 10-8 Lee (1 Knockdown)
8th 10-9 Lee
9th 10-9 Lee
10th 10-9 Quillin
11st 10-9 Lee
12nd 10-9 Lee

113-112 ANDY LEE

lou dibella and bible of boxing also had it a draw, as did a ton of other boxing media.
interesting if fightscorecollector chimes in tomorrow with all the media scores on this one

I have no problems with the scores.

Even if Quilin was given a win, it wouldn't change anything. The fight showed AGAIN that he is in a lower league compared to Golovkin's. He can now fight his peers like Murray, Rubio, Geale, etc., possibly at 168 or catch weight.

expe wrote:Seemed fine on the first round knockdown, I meant the second one in that round that some people seem to be scoring, the ref waved it off and called no knockdown. I've already seen a 4 minute round tonight, followed by a 2 minute round that began with a beachball being thrown into the ring, so 10 seconds out doesn't seem much.

You're just not getting what I am saying. At the end of the round Lee got a count and on the clock there was 10 seconds left. Quitting went in for the stoppage and the clock didn't ring until 20 seconds after the ref stopped his count. Please re-watch it and see what I mean. It looked like they gave Quitting extra time to try and get the stoppage win.

is there a RBR for garcia peterson?
i gave 1st to garcia

20-18 Garcia but little happening - could easily be 20-20

Garcia has just edged the first 3 rounds but very little thrown from both fighters. Peterson moving round the ring and Garcia having trouble landing anything of any significance.

I dislike Garcia but Peterson is running a track race in the ring.

crowd booing, deservedly.
peterson is setting his feet occasionally like he is willing to exchange
and then just pulls away without throwing a punch, and when garcia
comes after him he runs without throwing a punch or at most an occasional
defensive jab. too much running

peterson threw a few more punches that 4th round and caught some
clean shots in return. still too much movement without purpose.

i have shutout for garcia after 6

I thought Peterson probably edged the 4th
I gave the 5th and 6th rounds to Garcia

Still very little in terms of action and the crowd rightly getting a bit annoyed.

I can't help but feel as this is a non-title fight it has sort of ruined the occasion

I couldn't really split them in the 7th but would lean towards Garcia.

I've seen far better sparring matches.

Round 8 to Peterson. Much better coming forward and pushing Garcia back and landing some decent punches.

9th and 10th to Peterson. Some nice boxing but way too much showboating. Garcia struggling to land anything decent.

Big round for Peterson in the 11th and Garcia looks like he's struggling.

That is a bit disappointing - I think Lamont Peterson is very unlucky not to come away with at least a draw i had Peterson up by one round. Peterson beat Garcia up in the second half of that fight but 2 judges go with Garcia and one calls it a draw.

Lot of disrespect to two good fighters. Yeah, they don't beat GGG but who does. Exciting fight by two dangerous fighters. Korobov is a amateur legend and definitely someone to fear. Lee found a way. There is a reason Emanuel Steward moved Lee into his home. Booth has added a nice polish to him. Peter has beat some pretty solid dudes and hung tough after being dropped hard. Fair decision. Why not praise, rather than take down?

Good fight. No problem with the scores. Those who thought it a clear Quillin win have an issue scoring boxing matches . .Quillin lost practically every round in the latter half of the fight save one. Both fighters were way too inactive, but Lee at least found a rhythm with his height, reach and (shocker) movement as the fight wore on and landed occasional jabs and pot shots. Both fighters practically forgot the jab and simply tried to set up power shots.

Golovkin clearly a level above these two. Heck, Cotto likely is as well.

diddy wrote:Bunch of crap.

Quillin won that fight.

You. are. an. idiot.

Close fight - I had it a draw.