BoxRec

Hounddog wrote:Did everyone see asiku' last fight, i dont think he won,call me crazy but when you knocked down and countered punched and wobbled for 4 rounds, and win only the last 2 rounds,you lose the fight, at least thats the way we use to add when i went to school.
But anyway what do i know, i think kickett should still stay, maybe Asiku v Kickett, however i probally doubt that will happen.

Yeah i agree Asiku looked shit in his last fight, Dont think anyone watched it mate. If they did he wouldnt be at 10

At least Asiku has fought some good fighters... oh and he wasn't KO'd in the first round of his last fight.

gerry wrote:i support these fighters but are they australian or do we claim them as our best cause im sure if ghana, new zealand, cameroon and armenia did one they would have their fighters on there list

If a fighter chooses to move here, build his career here and take citizenship I think it is fair enough to have them in our p4p list...

so is casamayor american

Marlin wrote:At least Asiku has fought some good fighters... oh and he wasn't KO'd in the first round of his last fight.

I agree Kickett out, Cant put action in though as he hasnt looked good for a long time, Its like puting Hussy or Taylor in because they were good 3 years ago.

Zappa might get in if he beats Browne but at this stage he really hasn't fought anyone. McCullen had a good win over Cottrell but again that is about it...

I see were your coming from Marlin, I just thought it should be on recent form. Then if we start that then a lot of the list will be off as a few havnt fought anyone decent in a long time.

gerry wrote:so is casamayor american

I'm pretty sure he's Cuban.

Willie beat Brown comfortably, and depends on whose opinion you go with he has a W against St Claire, but it does seem as though St Claire cant buy a win at the moment.
Who is Jackson' most important win?

Hounddog wrote:Willie beat Brown comfortably, and depends on whose opinion you go with he has a W against St Claire, but it does seem as though St Claire cant buy a win at the moment.
Who is Jackson' most important win?

Thats why i put McCullen for my vote at 10, He beat Cottrell who is a tough bastard and has fought some real good fighters.

Ok, this one was a bit tricky and didn't really get many votes, anyway the results are:

Kickett - Off List

Mundine - No Change

Ndou - No Change

Bika - Up to #4

There was a two way tie for who enters at 10 so I have decided to leave it vacant until Zappa fights Browne on Friday and we can reconsider then...


The Official Australian Boxing Forum P4P Rankings
As voted by forum members.

1. Vic Darchinyan
2. Michael Katsidis
3. Anthony Mundine
4. Sakio Bika
5. Daniel Geale
6. Lovemore N'dou
7. Sam Soliman
8. Kali Meehan
9. Billy Dib
10. Vacant

Didn't take long for this sanctioning body to hit controversy. No 10. Vacant :P

As I said, two way tie mate. I was going to have a vote on the two of them but thought it might be best to wait until Zappa fights Browne

Marlin wrote:As I said, two way tie mate. I was going to have a vote on the two of them but thought it might be best to wait until Zappa fights Browne

i understood I think we should have a vote on whether or not we should have a vote. only joking of course

toppity wrote:

Marlin wrote:As I said, two way tie mate. I was going to have a vote on the two of them but thought it might be best to wait until Zappa fights Browne

i understood I think we should have a vote on whether or not we should have a vote. only joking of course

:P

Zappa...Zappa...Zappa...Zappa

Zappa has to be in there somewhere

Zappa at ten.

Alright we'll start it here. Where do you want Zappa in the rankings? Does Geale move?

I vote Zappa in at #9

Geale - No Change

Zappa at 9.

Geale - no change.

zappa-10
geale almost deserves to drop spots after hes effort

I kinda forgot about Geale I guess we should vote on him as well...
Edit your post if you want to vote on him.

shes right mate
probably shouldnt vote him down after a win, no matter how unimpressive

Hounddog wrote:Zappa at ten.

as above

Geale no change