Page 87 of 92
Re: Hypothetical Match-Up Game
Posted: 19 Jan 2012, 23:09
by AngryGoon38
DetroitHxC wrote:IRLangmaid25 wrote:Under the new rules here is my next contribution.
Wladimir K v Riddick Bowe.
After both fighters start out slow, Bowe quickly realizes Wladimir does not take his punches well and steps on the gas. He floors him twice in the second. Wlad runs for his life in the third, but Big Daddy finishes the show in the fourth. Bowe by TKO 4.
Milton McRory (title run era, before the loss) vs Victor Ortiz (Berto fight)
McCrory busts em up en route 6th rd tko.
"Jerry Quarry vs Oscar Bonevena" Duke it out right after they're respective 1970 losses to Ali. 15 Rounds.
Re: Hypothetical Match-Up Game
Posted: 23 Jan 2012, 13:33
by IRLangmaid25
AngryGoon38 wrote:DetroitHxC wrote:IRLangmaid25 wrote:Under the new rules here is my next contribution.
Wladimir K v Riddick Bowe.
After both fighters start out slow, Bowe quickly realizes Wladimir does not take his punches well and steps on the gas. He floors him twice in the second. Wlad runs for his life in the third, but Big Daddy finishes the show in the fourth. Bowe by TKO 4.
Milton McRory (title run era, before the loss) vs Victor Ortiz (Berto fight)
McCrory busts em up en route 6th rd tko.
"Jerry Quarry vs Oscar Bonevena" Duke it out right after they're respective 1970 losses to Ali. 15 Rounds.
This one is an utter blood bath in my eyes. Both men with balls of steel and chins to go with it. Bbut I expect with Bonavana' superior power he ends cutting and marking up Quarry pretty badly who keeps on coming forward attacking Bonavena's body as Bonvaena goes head hunting, The cuts and broken nose leaves Quarry with a mask of claret for a face but he gamely carries only to be stopped in the later rounds because of all the blood.
Any takers on
Arturo Gatti v Michael Katsidis: 12 rounds at Light-Welter
Re: Hypothetical Match-Up Game
Posted: 24 Jan 2012, 14:44
by m1kee50
I'm going to stick my neck out and say Katsidis on points. I know its a bit of a cliche but I don't see either man getting stopped, too much pride more than anything else. I just think that Katsidis is that little bit tidier when he has to be, little bit faster with his hands, and I think that shows up over the distance.
175lbs Prime for Prime, Archie Moore vs Roy Jones Junior (I think I may have asked this one before), 15 rounds.
Re: Hypothetical Match-Up Game
Posted: 24 Jan 2012, 15:58
by BoxBuzz
@matt___s wrote:I'm going to stick my neck out and say Katsidis on points. I know its a bit of a cliche but I don't see either man getting stopped, too much pride more than anything else. I just think that Katsidis is that little bit tidier when he has to be, little bit faster with his hands, and I think that shows up over the distance.
175lbs Prime for Prime, Archie Moore vs Roy Jones Junior (I think I may have asked this one before), 15 rounds.
Archie Starches Roy in the 6th round. After looking a bit shakey under Roy's assault, he assesses and calibrates himself for Roy's unusual rhythym and gets the Job Done. He wasn't called the mongoose for nothin'.
Joe Frazier comes out to face Jumbo Cummings for the final fight of his career, but inexplicably Jumbo is gone, and aliens transport a Prime Butterbean into the ring to replace Mr Cummings.
What happens on this night?
Re: Hypothetical Match-Up Game
Posted: 25 Jan 2012, 12:40
by AngryGoon38
BoxBuzz wrote:@matt___s wrote:I'm going to stick my neck out and say Katsidis on points. I know its a bit of a cliche but I don't see either man getting stopped, too much pride more than anything else. I just think that Katsidis is that little bit tidier when he has to be, little bit faster with his hands, and I think that shows up over the distance.
175lbs Prime for Prime, Archie Moore vs Roy Jones Junior (I think I may have asked this one before), 15 rounds.
Archie Starches Roy in the 6th round. After looking a bit shakey under Roy's assault, he assesses and calibrates himself for Roy's unusual rhythym and gets the Job Done. He wasn't called the mongoose for nothin'.
Joe Frazier comes out to face Jumbo Cummings for the final fight of his career, but inexplicably Jumbo is gone, and aliens transport a Prime Butterbean into the ring to replace Mr Cummings.
What happens on this night?
Call me crazy but i could actually see this one being good for a couple of rounds.
I see Frazier getting em in the 3rd round.
Marvin Hagler vs Tommy Burns @ 175 15 Rounds
Re: Hypothetical Match-Up Game
Posted: 26 Jan 2012, 06:41
by Goodnight, Irene
Awkward fight no one wants to touch
Hagler didnt rate himself above 160, and thats good enough for me. Burns UD.
Arguello vs. Tszyu at 140
Re: Hypothetical Match-Up Game
Posted: 26 Jan 2012, 09:59
by beaujack
HomicideHenry wrote:Pretty simple this is, make up a hypothetical match-up, and the person below makes their own prediction [please dont go off into a rant as to why and what have you, lets leave that to more serious thread debates] and post their own hypothetical dream match.
First up: JIMMY WILDE vs RINTY MONAGAHN [sorry for any spelling mistakes]

Jimmy Wilde, during his prime and after, was considered the greatest flyweight ever, followed by Pancho Villa...Winner - Wilde
Re: Hypothetical Match-Up Game
Posted: 26 Jan 2012, 12:24
by witherspoon
DetroitHxC wrote:
Andre Berto vs Micky Ward - 145 catch weight, 12 rounds
Berto UD.
Julio Cesar Chavez v Ken Buchanan at LW.
Re: Hypothetical Match-Up Game
Posted: 26 Jan 2012, 15:10
by scallum
witherspoon wrote:DetroitHxC wrote:
Andre Berto vs Micky Ward - 145 catch weight, 12 rounds
.
Berto UD.
Julio Cesar Chavez v Ken Buchanan at LW.
Chavez body attack was to brutal and he secures a late round stoppage.
Greb Vs Hagler
Re: Hypothetical Match-Up Game
Posted: 26 Jan 2012, 15:34
by witherspoon
BarryWashington wrote:witherspoon wrote:DetroitHxC wrote:
Andre Berto vs Micky Ward - 145 catch weight, 12 rounds
Berto UD.
Julio Cesar Chavez v Ken Buchanan at LW.
this would be a good thread. i think ward would be able to damage the body enough and definitely keep himself in the fight.
I agree. That match deserved more than just 'Berto UD'.
Apologies to Detroit, I was so proud to have come up with an original match-up that I totally disregarded the previous.
Re: Hypothetical Match-Up Game
Posted: 27 Jan 2012, 01:39
by AngryGoon38
scallum wrote:witherspoon wrote:DetroitHxC wrote:
Andre Berto vs Micky Ward - 145 catch weight, 12 rounds
.
Berto UD.
Julio Cesar Chavez v Ken Buchanan at LW.
Chavez body attack was to brutal and he secures a late round stoppage.
Greb Vs Hagler
Greb vs Hagler. Great showdown. I'm gonna say Greb by Decision. Great fight,Greb takes everything Hagler has and outworks em nearly every round. That nonstop whirlwind style is like a busier and stronger version of Anterfermo from the 1st fight with Hagler. 8)
Ricky Hatton vs Mickey Ward

Re: Hypothetical Match-Up Game
Posted: 28 Jan 2012, 12:46
by BoxBuzz
I honestly think Ricky is a cut above, and I'm not a Hatton rumpswab by any means. I like Ward a lot and think he gets outpointed in a good scrap.
Here's one.
Renaldo Snipes Vs Tex Cobb....in real time.....you pick the year.
Re: Hypothetical Match-Up Game
Posted: 28 Jan 2012, 12:49
by King Carlos
Some of the calls in this thread make my head hurt.
Re: Hypothetical Match-Up Game
Posted: 28 Jan 2012, 12:53
by BoxBuzz
King Carlos wrote:Some of the calls in this thread make my head hurt.
agreed.....but how about being vulnerable and making a call in the Cobb vs Snipes affair.
Re: Hypothetical Match-Up Game
Posted: 29 Jan 2012, 02:03
by AngryGoon38
I say Cobb by Decisive UD. Overwhelms and withstands whatever onslaught from Renaldo. R. Snipes just simply wasnt good enough a boxer. Ever see his bs decision win over Coetzee ? Snipes wasnt a huge puncher either obviously,not really good enough at anything to overwhelm the Big Tough Country Boy Tex Cobb.
Kostya Tszu vs Nicholino Locche 12 Rounds
Re: Hypothetical Match-Up Game
Posted: 01 Feb 2012, 02:16
by Goodnight, Irene
Tszyu was a smart boxer whose timing and intelligence were too often overshadowed by his punch, but he'd be made to look a whole lot dumber than he was here.
Locche was simply on another plane. He wins a UD.
Hearns VS Gavilan, 15 rnds at 147...
Re: Hypothetical Match-Up Game
Posted: 01 Feb 2012, 18:22
by theone
I automatically thought Hearns wide dec due to Gavilans chin...but Hearns had the power to dent the undentible. Gavilan will be there to be hit and does not have Leonards power to keep Hearns on his heels. Hearns mid rounds tko.
Lets stick with Gavilan...
Gavilan vs Griffith
Re: Hypothetical Match-Up Game
Posted: 03 Feb 2012, 22:15
by AngryGoon38
theone wrote:I automatically thought Hearns wide dec due to Gavilans chin...but Hearns had the power to dent the undentible. Gavilan will be there to be hit and does not have Leonards power to keep Hearns on his heels. Hearns mid rounds tko.
Lets stick with Gavilan...
Gavilan vs Griffith
Gavilan by close decision,whether its a 12 or a 15 rd'er. Very good fight,lots of punches thrown,lots of movement. Two extroadinary busy boxer styles. Gavilan lands slightly more. In a 15 rd'er,likely 145-143 type decision,in a 12 rd'er,115-114.
Gregorio Peralta vs Ruslan Chagaev
Re: Hypothetical Match-Up Game
Posted: 06 Feb 2012, 07:05
by Goodnight, Irene
Peralta for me. Faster, smarter and cuter. That outweighs being outweighed.
Alex Stewart vs. Jimmy Ellis
Re: Hypothetical Match-Up Game
Posted: 09 Feb 2012, 06:40
by Goodnight, Irene
Okay, that match didnt sell.
How about...
Marciano vs PRIME Walcott (Louis bouts).
Re: Hypothetical Match-Up Game
Posted: 09 Feb 2012, 12:40
by IRLangmaid25
Goodnight, Irene wrote:Okay, that match didnt sell.
How about...
Marciano vs PRIME Walcott (Louis bouts).
Marciano, his constant pressure and swarming style keeps Walcott on the back foot throughout the fight and takes a point decision.
Next up
Bob Foster v Roy Jones Jnr. 12 rounds Heavyweight.
Re: Hypothetical Match-Up Game
Posted: 09 Feb 2012, 13:31
by Datsue
IRLangmaid25 wrote:Goodnight, Irene wrote:Okay, that match didnt sell.
How about...
Marciano vs PRIME Walcott (Louis bouts).
Marciano, his constant pressure and swarming style keeps Walcott on the back foot throughout the fight and takes a point decision.
Next up
Bob Foster v Roy Jones Jnr. 12 rounds Heavyweight.
Foster chins Jones, at some point. Sparko.
I shall do G,I's as well: Stewart gets made to look very silly indeed by Young, in a fight only Granberry could love.
Pongsaklek Wonjongkam vs Jorge Arce, back when they should've got it on...
Re: Hypothetical Match-Up Game
Posted: 09 Feb 2012, 13:42
by Goodnight, Irene
Datsue wrote:IRLangmaid25 wrote:Goodnight, Irene wrote:Okay, that match didnt sell.
How about...
Marciano vs PRIME Walcott (Louis bouts).
Marciano, his constant pressure and swarming style keeps Walcott on the back foot throughout the fight and takes a point decision.
Next up
Bob Foster v Roy Jones Jnr. 12 rounds Heavyweight.
Foster chins Jones, at some point. Sparko.
I shall do G,I's as well: Stewart gets made to look very silly indeed by Young, in a fight only Granberry could love.
Pongsaklek Wonjongkam vs Jorge Arce, back when they should've got it on...
Thanks for the effort mate, but it was Ellis, not Young

Re: Hypothetical Match-Up Game
Posted: 09 Feb 2012, 13:46
by Counter-puncher
Goodnight, Irene wrote:Datsue wrote:IRLangmaid25 wrote:
Marciano, his constant pressure and swarming style keeps Walcott on the back foot throughout the fight and takes a point decision.
Next up
Bob Foster v Roy Jones Jnr. 12 rounds Heavyweight.
Foster chins Jones, at some point. Sparko.
I shall do G,I's as well: Stewart gets made to look very silly indeed by Young, in a fight only Granberry could love.
Pongsaklek Wonjongkam vs Jorge Arce, back when they should've got it on...
Thanks for the effort mate, but it was Ellis, not Young

same answer applies

Re: Hypothetical Match-Up Game
Posted: 10 Feb 2012, 00:54
by AngryGoon38
I got one. A real good one.
Ike Ibeaubuchi vs Riddick Bowe
