Page 2 of 2
Re: Was Sugar Ray Robinson really the best of all time?
Posted: 22 Aug 2010, 06:53
by Scrap
I always thought Gainsford wasnt His manager.
Re: Was Sugar Ray Robinson really the best of all time?
Posted: 22 Aug 2010, 06:56
by palooka
Scrap wrote:I always thought Gainsford wasnt His manager.
Was Robinson self managed? Did Gainsford have another role?
Re: Was Sugar Ray Robinson really the best of all time?
Posted: 22 Aug 2010, 07:03
by bennie
Robinson used to enjoy 'screwing' promoters. He is the only fighter in history who repeatedly turned the tables.
Re: Was Sugar Ray Robinson really the best of all time?
Posted: 22 Aug 2010, 07:14
by Scrap
Its something as I say that I wondered for years. When people who I respect told me He was connected to the mob,. my 1st impression was fornicate off. But the story wouldnt go away. The people involved so Im told worked for Mob, why would He mainline at the Garden in the 40s if He wasnt connected. A good freind of mine who visits Canasota every year told me of a story, of Him talking to the Mobs accountant who was drinking with Him, then an old man. Now my mate is a big Robinson Fan. But I asked Him if He believed what the guy had told Him, His reply was yes. Im wondering if I should put this up,
Re: Was Sugar Ray Robinson really the best of all time?
Posted: 22 Aug 2010, 07:42
by bennie
Scrap wrote:Its something as I say that I wondered for years. When people who I respect told me He was connected to the mob,. my 1st impression was fornicate off. But the story wouldnt go away. The people involved so Im told worked for Mob, why would He mainline at the Garden in the 40s if He wasnt connected. A good freind of mine who visits Canasota every year told me of a story, of Him talking to the Mobs accountant who was drinking with Him, then an old man. Now my mate is a big Robinson Fan. But I asked Him if He believed what the guy had told Him, His reply was yes. Im wondering if I should put this up,
The mob didn't always control fighters - or fights - as much as generated. One fighter remarked of his manager, "He was connected to the mob but just got on with making the best matches for me."
Don King is the mob and we've seen him lose a few.
Re: Was Sugar Ray Robinson really the best of all time?
Posted: 22 Aug 2010, 07:53
by Scrap
Bennie little bit different then than now. Its believed Don has connections, He isnt the Mob. The Maxim fight was interesting, at Lightheavy Maxim struggling at the weight. Robinson Hydrated, same day weigth in.

Re: Was Sugar Ray Robinson really the best of all time?
Posted: 22 Aug 2010, 11:04
by tonyevs
Sugar Ray Robinson was superb. A real superstar of his time. Just watch the old fight footage of him. He was a real dynamite puncher who looked to get the KO. This is something that surprised me after reading so much about him .. I always kinda expected a sweet boxing elusive type..
Greb, by all accounts, was a swashbuckling threshing machine, who once warmed up gave no let up .. offence once again was the best defence. He did however avoid the top black fighters when need be ... but certainly not to the extent you would have expected from a top white fighter of that time. Buisiness was buisiness and he had bills to pay...
Charley Burley has been mentioned in regard to Ray Robinson. That would have been a fine match-up

sadly Robinson. much like Henry Armstrong, seen too much risk to tangling with Burley.
History books often overlook guys that `the greats` avoided.
Re: Was Sugar Ray Robinson really the best of all time?
Posted: 22 Aug 2010, 11:08
by the truth
robinson was one of the best of all time, if ur talking about full career then yes he was, if ur talking about fighters at their peak fighting each other then roy jones jr is the best fighting machine ever at his peak in the mid 90s
Re: Was Sugar Ray Robinson really the best of all time?
Posted: 22 Aug 2010, 11:14
by stevieb_8006
Henry Armstrong would have to be considered. SRR IS prob the best, but boxing suffers from nostalgia more than most other sports. Its like an unwritten rule Ali is "the greatest" cos every other kunt has said so. frustrates the fornicate out of me, maybe best heavyweight (but you could still make a case for others)
Re: Was Sugar Ray Robinson really the best of all time?
Posted: 22 Aug 2010, 11:21
by iamasadlittleboy
No mention of Langford?
Re: Was Sugar Ray Robinson really the best of all time?
Posted: 22 Aug 2010, 19:30
by Scrap
I rate Ezzard Charles Higher, His resume is unbelievable. Never more than a Lightheavy, and from 48 Boxed with MS which He died from. Beat Burley twice as a 19 year old, He had a few pounds over Burley [6ib] . Beat great fighters and gave weight, pure class, never had an easy road.
Re: Was Sugar Ray Robinson really the best of all time?
Posted: 23 Aug 2010, 07:39
by Poncey
stevieb_8006 wrote:Henry Armstrong would have to be considered.
Had he beaten Fritzie Zivic, I would agree with you.
Re: Was Sugar Ray Robinson really the best of all time?
Posted: 23 Aug 2010, 11:49
by DazBoxingFan
He's the best
Re: Was Sugar Ray Robinson really the best of all time?
Posted: 23 Aug 2010, 16:26
by DazBoxingFan
King Geedorah wrote:DazBoxingFan wrote:He's the best
Cheers!
Ah, you meant Robinson, thought I was finally getting some Boxrec forum props. Bugger.
Haha
Re: Was Sugar Ray Robinson really the best of all time?
Posted: 24 Aug 2010, 08:50
by Phenomenal-Nutrition
Scrap wrote:Its something as I say that I wondered for years. When people who I respect told me He was connected to the mob,. my 1st impression was fornicate off. But the story wouldnt go away. The people involved so Im told worked for Mob, why would He mainline at the Garden in the 40s if He wasnt connected. A good freind of mine who visits Canasota every year told me of a story, of Him talking to the Mobs accountant who was drinking with Him, then an old man. Now my mate is a big Robinson Fan. But I asked Him if He believed what the guy had told Him, His reply was yes. Im wondering if I should put this up,
Robinson carried fighters for the MOB so they could bet on the UD, its rumoured he carried Henry Armstrong, but it may have also been Armstrong was his hero. Once he accidently KO'd someone he was supposed to carry and was apparently bricking it

Re: Was Sugar Ray Robinson really the best of all time?
Posted: 24 Aug 2010, 18:45
by southace
Yes.
You can make a case for many boxers but when it's said and done Sugar Ray Robinson was peerless. an artisan of his trade.
I was once in a room and heard Sugar Ray Leonard call Floyd Mayweather the best of all time but i think he was just being kind, or paid.
Re: Was Sugar Ray Robinson really the best of all time?
Posted: 25 Aug 2010, 08:29
by jamesmcdonnell
Robinson or Armstrong for me.
Armstrong's record is unbelievable. He never weighed in anywhere near the Welter limit despite being Welterweight champ. He absolutely destroyed all his challengers at the weight too.
Re: Was Sugar Ray Robinson really the best of all time?
Posted: 25 Aug 2010, 18:48
by Jon Saxon
Jones Jnr at his peak could never be beaten (other than a DQ) by any fighter.
No one was ever as good as Jones.
Re: Was Sugar Ray Robinson really the best of all time?
Posted: 26 Aug 2010, 07:01
by Captain Hook
Behave mate, fornicating hell..
He's tainted his legacy considerably since Ruiz.
Robinson is the best of all time at any weight.
Re: Was Sugar Ray Robinson really the best of all time?
Posted: 26 Aug 2010, 07:17
by Poncey
MachoMan09 wrote:optimum pugnator
I had him as a Transformer. He was shit.
Re: Was Sugar Ray Robinson really the best of all time?
Posted: 26 Aug 2010, 09:25
by Captain Hook
:)