BoxRec

crusader wrote:6-0 Guerrero. He's looking great so far.

1st time ive seen Guerrero, impressive....if he has the engine to keep katsidis away for 12 even better....

I got it 118-108 RG

reminded me of pacman v margarito, only one winner but the other one was in it till the end ! when the ref took the first point off, i really believe katsidis nearly had him ! good fight though, come on eric....

As far as I'm concerned there was only one correct way to score that fight. One 10-8 round for Guerrero and ten 10-9s, one 10-9 for Katsidis, 1 deduction for Guerrero and 2 for Katsidis. 118-106.

Did you hear katsidis when they touched gloves?
WHAT ARE YOU LOOKING AT!!!

Scottrf wrote:As far as I'm concerned there was only one correct way to score that fight. One 10-8 round for Guerrero and ten 10-9s, one 10-9 for Katsidis, 1 deduction for Guerrero and 2 for Katsidis. 118-106.

but you said "correct" the 2nd should of been 10-8 katsidis, it wasnt because the ref was a dick but it should of been ! there was only one winner but thats not the point.

My god morales looks awful.
First time i've seen him for a few years but talk washed up.

jessi wrote:

Scottrf wrote:As far as I'm concerned there was only one correct way to score that fight. One 10-8 round for Guerrero and ten 10-9s, one 10-9 for Katsidis, 1 deduction for Guerrero and 2 for Katsidis. 118-106.

but you said "correct" the 2nd should of been 10-8 katsidis, it wasnt because the ref was a dick but it should of been ! there was only one winner but thats not the point.

The judges don't get to choose that though. They should all have handed in the same card. I can forgive the 118-107 because they presumably didn't want to give Guerrero a 10-8 without a KD (although it should be, Katsidis was out on his feet), but not the other. I don't criticise cards where chunks of rounds can go either way and so the fight is wider than it 'should' but when every round has one way of scoring I do.

Scottrf wrote:

jessi wrote:

Scottrf wrote:As far as I'm concerned there was only one correct way to score that fight. One 10-8 round for Guerrero and ten 10-9s, one 10-9 for Katsidis, 1 deduction for Guerrero and 2 for Katsidis. 118-106.

but you said "correct" the 2nd should of been 10-8 katsidis, it wasnt because the ref was a dick but it should of been ! there was only one winner but thats not the point.

The judges don't get to choose that though. They should all have handed in the same card. I can forgive the 118-107 because they presumably didn't want to give Guerrero a 10-8 without a KD (although it should be, Katsidis was out on his feet), but not the other. I don't criticise cards where chunks of rounds can go either way and so the fight is wider than it 'should' but when every round has one way of scoring I do.

but thats why its all bollox, because if a judge disagrees stronly with a bad ref decision, they will just adjust other rounds, so im not supprised that scores are diffrent, but i know what you mean.

whos the dick wearing the gimp outfit ?

im on a 10 minute delay, just watched the 1st round, is this going to be a khan v barrera 2 ?

stream? is morales on now?

Making me eat my words now!
C'mon eric!

bynino wrote:stream? is morales on now?

dont know about what stream, but yes on now live on sky

if erik wins this, i guarentee ricky hatton will have ideas about returning

Erik is handling him a lot better than Khan did and with 1 eye lol.

Hagler2002 wrote:Erik is handling him a lot better than Khan did and with 1 eye lol.

i agree, but i think maidana has under estimated him

Nonsesne scoring from Sky

78-75 Madaina

jessi wrote:

Hagler2002 wrote:Erik is handling him a lot better than Khan did and with 1 eye lol.

i agree, but i think maidana has under estimated him

Not at all, people have overrated him based on the fact he stopped Ortiz and ran Khan close.

88-84 Maidaia

whicker wrote:88-84 Maidaia

got it closer than that.

I'm loving this. This is fooking great. Maidana can fight, Morales can box.

I thought there was the possibility that he'd outbox him, at times he looks like stopping him.

97-95 Maidana.

hitman_hatton1 wrote:

whicker wrote:88-84 Maidaia

got it closer than that.

88-84 morales more like

No, seriously- Sky are talking nonsense