Page 2 of 2
Re: Friday OT: all-time Premier League XI
Posted: 15 May 2011, 12:51
by Pat Butcher
The Dark Destroyer wrote:Pat Butcher wrote:yid14 wrote:
Whats the premier league? Gazza's a legend. Not many of these pussies in the 'premier league' can tie his shoe laces. You do know there was football before the premier league.
Don't be daft, Sky invented football in 1992, don't you know anything!
Oh and Gary Neville is no way be the best right back in the last 20 years
Well who is better?
Rob Jones
![[icon_e_biggrin.gif] :D](./images/smilies/icon_e_biggrin.gif)
Re: Friday OT: all-time Premier League XI
Posted: 15 May 2011, 12:52
by hurlock
dennis irwin,jamie carragher.
Re: Friday OT: all-time Premier League XI
Posted: 15 May 2011, 12:56
by banjo
The Dark Destroyer wrote:Pat Butcher wrote:yid14 wrote:
Whats the premier league? Gazza's a legend. Not many of these pussies in the 'premier league' can tie his shoe laces. You do know there was football before the premier league.
Don't be daft, Sky invented football in 1992, don't you know anything!
Oh and Gary Neville is no way be the best right back in the last 20 years
Well who is better?
Dan Petrescu, the best rightback/wingback in the world after Cafu.
Re: Friday OT: all-time Premier League XI
Posted: 15 May 2011, 13:05
by hurlock
gary neville is a prick.
Re: Friday OT: all-time Premier League XI
Posted: 15 May 2011, 13:57
by LeedsLad
Denis Irwin was a better right back than Gary Neville, and a better left back than Ashley Cole.
A genuinely great player.
Re: Friday OT: all-time Premier League XI
Posted: 16 May 2011, 08:17
by DavidPayne
-------------------SCHMIECHAL--------------------
NEVILLE - FERDINAND - STAM - PEARCE
RONALDO - KEANE - GERRARD GIGGS
----------------DROGBA - HENRY-------------------
SUBS
GIVEN - VIERA - VAN NISTLEROY - BERGKAMP - LETISSIER
Re: Friday OT: all-time Premier League XI
Posted: 16 May 2011, 08:42
by Heartbreak_Kid79
G - Schmeical
RB -Neville (Reluctantly)
LB - Cole
CB - Adams
CB - Stam
RW -Ronaldo
LW - Giggs
CM -Keane
CM - Gerrard
F - Shearer
F - Bergkamp
Re: Friday OT: all-time Premier League XI
Posted: 16 May 2011, 08:45
by freddydoesdallas
A lot of people are putting Gerrard in their teams, he's got to be the ultimate example of the problems with the premier league. Complete hype
Re: Friday OT: all-time Premier League XI
Posted: 16 May 2011, 09:23
by doctorboxing
-------------------Schmiecal
-----------Staam---Adams---Hendry
---------------Viera-------Keane
-------Ronaldo-----------------------Giggs
--------------------Cantona
---------------------Henry
SUBS: Seaman, Irwin, Fabregas, Zola, Berkamp, Shearer
Re: Friday OT: all-time Premier League XI
Posted: 16 May 2011, 09:55
by apophenic
CB wrote:freddydoesdallas wrote:For all those out there who don't follow the top few clubs:
Jussi Jaaskilinen
Roland Nilsson Stubbs Radebe Pearce
Kincladze Batty Gary McAllister Froggat
Le Tissier Dion Dublin
5 ex-Cov in there I like it!
PUSB!
8)
Re: Friday OT: all-time Premier League XI
Posted: 16 May 2011, 10:15
by youngrell
doctorboxing wrote:-------------------Schmiecal
-----------Staam---Adams---Hendry
---------------Viera-------Keane
-------Ronaldo-----------------------Giggs
--------------------Cantona
---------------------Henry
SUBS: Seaman, Irwin, Fabregas, Zola, Berkamp, Shearer
Who got the red card?

Re: Friday OT: all-time Premier League XI
Posted: 16 May 2011, 10:18
by stujones
Deadendgeneration wrote:The Dark Destroyer wrote:yid14 wrote:
Whats the premier league? Gazza's a legend. Not many of these pussies in the 'premier league' can tie his shoe laces. You do know there was football before the premier league.
I'm not denying he was a great player. But this thread is for an all time 'premier league XI', it's in the thread title. The PL started in 1992, and he left you for Lazio that year. I just don't think his spells at Middlesbrough and Everton were good enough to put him anywhere near the likes of Scholes, Vieira, Keane etc
Hierro Desailly
Laudrup Gullit Deschamps Djorkaeff
Weah Klinsman
Anyone want to add to my team of great players who didn't play their best football in the premier league but did play in it.
Dino Baggio (seemed to always make world xv sides in the mid/late 90's).
Branco (Brazilian World cup winner played for Middlesborough, briefly)
Nicola Berti (one stage football writers were saying its a toss up between him and Roberto Baggio for the best player in the world tag)
Glenn Hoddle (most underated player in English football IMO - criminally under used at International level)
Bryan Robson (injury and team selection prevented Hoddle and Robson from really gelling at international stage)
Thomas Brolin (I know, but at one stage he was a fabolous player)
Attila Lombardo (Bald eagle from Sampdoria).
Roberto DiMatteo (I'm surprised he never gets a mention in the OP original question - was fantastic for chelsea, truly world class).
Andrei Schevchenko (okay shite for Chelsea, but at one stage looked to be the most complete striker in the world, argueably a better version of Shearer).
Michael Ballack (Complete midfielder in his pomp).
Re: Friday OT: all-time Premier League XI
Posted: 16 May 2011, 10:22
by doctorboxing
youngrell wrote:doctorboxing wrote:-------------------Schmiecal
-----------Staam---Adams---Hendry
---------------Viera-------Keane
-------Ronaldo-----------------------Giggs
--------------------Cantona
---------------------Henry
SUBS: Seaman, Irwin, Fabregas, Zola, Berkamp, Shearer
Who got the red card?


I meant to have Gerrad in the middle of the park as well.
Re: Friday OT: all-time Premier League XI
Posted: 16 May 2011, 10:34
by freddydoesdallas
apophenic wrote:CB wrote:freddydoesdallas wrote:For all those out there who don't follow the top few clubs:
Jussi Jaaskilinen
Roland Nilsson Stubbs Radebe Pearce
Kincladze Batty Gary McAllister Froggat
Le Tissier Dion Dublin
5 ex-Cov in there I like it!
PUSB!
8)
Quite a few from Cov on here
Re: Friday OT: all-time Premier League XI
Posted: 16 May 2011, 13:14
by hurlock
dan petrescu or stev nicols at rb 4 me

Re: Friday OT: all-time Premier League XI
Posted: 17 May 2011, 03:45
by Heartbreak_Kid79
freddydoesdallas wrote:A lot of people are putting Gerrard in their teams, he's got to be the ultimate example of the problems with the premier league. Complete hype
I think the team only needs one ballwinner.... so that would mean keane or Vierra ... not both.
A ball winner and an attacking midfielder
Re: Friday OT: all-time Premier League XI
Posted: 17 May 2011, 13:19
by hurlock
Heartbreak_Kid79 wrote:freddydoesdallas wrote:A lot of people are putting Gerrard in their teams, he's got to be the ultimate example of the problems with the premier league. Complete hype
I think the team only needs one ballwinner.... so that would mean keane or Vierra ... not both.
A ball winner and an attacking midfielder
claude makelel & viera :!:
Re: Friday OT: all-time Premier League XI
Posted: 17 May 2011, 16:58
by Flump
stujones wrote:Deadendgeneration wrote:The Dark Destroyer wrote:
I'm not denying he was a great player. But this thread is for an all time 'premier league XI', it's in the thread title. The PL started in 1992, and he left you for Lazio that year. I just don't think his spells at Middlesbrough and Everton were good enough to put him anywhere near the likes of Scholes, Vieira, Keane etc
Hierro Desailly
Laudrup Gullit Deschamps Djorkaeff
Weah Klinsman
Anyone want to add to my team of great players who didn't play their best football in the premier league but did play in it.
Dino Baggio (seemed to always make world xv sides in the mid/late 90's).
Branco (Brazilian World cup winner played for Middlesborough, briefly)
Nicola Berti (one stage football writers were saying its a toss up between him and Roberto Baggio for the best player in the world tag)
Glenn Hoddle (most underated player in English football IMO - criminally under used at International level)
Bryan Robson (injury and team selection prevented Hoddle and Robson from really gelling at international stage)
Thomas Brolin (I know, but at one stage he was a fabolous player)
Attila Lombardo (Bald eagle from Sampdoria).
Roberto DiMatteo (I'm surprised he never gets a mention in the OP original question - was fantastic for chelsea, truly world class).
Andrei Schevchenko (okay shite for Chelsea, but at one stage looked to be the most complete striker in the world, argueably a better version of Shearer).
Michael Ballack (Complete midfielder in his pomp).
Davor Suker
Robert Prosinecki (ok, he played in the Championship)
Paolo Futre
Jari Litmanen
Re: Friday OT: all-time Premier League XI
Posted: 17 May 2011, 17:42
by stujones
Flump wrote:stujones wrote:Deadendgeneration wrote:
Hierro Desailly
Laudrup Gullit Deschamps Djorkaeff
Weah Klinsman
Anyone want to add to my team of great players who didn't play their best football in the premier league but did play in it.
Dino Baggio (seemed to always make world xv sides in the mid/late 90's).
Branco (Brazilian World cup winner played for Middlesborough, briefly)
Nicola Berti (one stage football writers were saying its a toss up between him and Roberto Baggio for the best player in the world tag)
Glenn Hoddle (most underated player in English football IMO - criminally under used at International level)
Bryan Robson (injury and team selection prevented Hoddle and Robson from really gelling at international stage)
Thomas Brolin (I know, but at one stage he was a fabolous player)
Attila Lombardo (Bald eagle from Sampdoria).
Roberto DiMatteo (I'm surprised he never gets a mention in the OP original question - was fantastic for chelsea, truly world class).
Andrei Schevchenko (okay shite for Chelsea, but at one stage looked to be the most complete striker in the world, argueably a better version of Shearer).
Michael Ballack (Complete midfielder in his pomp).
Davor Suker
Robert Prosinecki (ok, he played in the Championship)
Paolo Futre
Jari Litmanen
Some good calls - I guess you must have Forlan up there also now, and Poborksy.
Edgar Davids - one I forgot.
Patrick Kluviert
Hakan Suker
Faustino Asprilla (I think he was passed his Parma prime when he joined Newcastle)
John Dahl Tommasson - Cannot be so bad to do quite well in Milan.
Karl Heinz Reidle
Winston Borgarde
Wim Jonk
Bryan Roy (I always rated him immensely)
Giovanni van Bronchurst (cannot say I was his biggest fan, but seemed to do a role very well at Barca).
Popescu.
Re: Friday OT: all-time Premier League XI
Posted: 18 May 2011, 03:47
by Heartbreak_Kid79
The Dark Destroyer wrote:stujones wrote:
Faustino Asprilla (I think he was passed his Parma prime when he joined Newcastle)
He was only about 25 when he moved to Newcastle. He was a massive waste of talent.
Newcastle had Shearer, Ferdinand, Beardsely and Asprillia at the same time.... its not viable to play 4 forwards at the same time, which is why Tino was more of a squad player.
Some of the stuff he did was unbelievable, but he was never an out and out goalscorer who was going to get a goal every 2 games
Re: Friday OT: all-time Premier League XI
Posted: 18 May 2011, 05:41
by stujones
Perhaps it was the different pace of the two leagues in general, but Asprilla looked so quick at Parma. For my money, for one brief period at Parma he would have made a world 11.
It was his final season at Newcastle when he came more to his own - Ferdinand and Beardsley were gone and it was just really Shearer and Rush who they had available - oh and Tommasson and Guivarch of course. So Aspilla, didn't have the support but did alot of good stuff individually.
Re: Friday OT: all-time Premier League XI
Posted: 18 May 2011, 08:53
by Heartbreak_Kid79
stujones wrote:
It was his final season at Newcastle when he came more to his own - Ferdinand and Beardsley were gone and it was just really Shearer and Rush who they had available - oh and Tommasson and Guivarch of course. So Aspilla, didn't have the support but did alot of good stuff individually.
Almost right. I'm a Newcastle fan by the way!
Asprilla signed halfway through 95-96 when Newcastle had a good lead over Man Utd in the title race, some thought that Asprillias inclusion upset the balance of the team as Newcastle ended up 2nd.
Shearer signed that summer, here we had the 4some of Shearer, Ferdinand, Tino & Beardsley for 96-97 season
This was Tinos only full season.
In summer 97 Shearer got injured, Ferdinand and Beardsley left.... and in came Tomasson and an ageing Rush.
Tino hit his famous hat trick against Barcelona in Sept '97, but only scored 2 league goals and didn't play again after xmas.
Guivarch was signed in 1998 and never played with Tino