Page 2 of 3

Re: p4p biggest puncher in british boxing ? thoughts ?

Posted: 21 Nov 2012, 09:06
by Chambers2
Naz IMO

Herbie Hides got to be up there......Wayne Alexander, Haye

Re: p4p biggest puncher in british boxing ? thoughts ?

Posted: 21 Nov 2012, 09:07
by Chambers2
Naz IMO

Herbie Hides got to be up there......Wayne Alexander, Haye

Re: p4p biggest puncher in british boxing ? thoughts ?

Posted: 21 Nov 2012, 09:11
by danconnollyeire
vxrandall wrote:game of trumps?

KO percentages

Jones 77% at Welter
Benn 73% at Middle/SMW
Hamed 84% at Feather

P4P - Prince is strong.
Haye's must be high

Re: p4p biggest puncher in british boxing ? thoughts ?

Posted: 21 Nov 2012, 09:17
by danconnollyeire
... also gotta love 'Enry's 'ammer and Hatton left hook to the body for banging shots

John H. Stracey could hit rather hit

Re: p4p biggest puncher in british boxing ? thoughts ?

Posted: 21 Nov 2012, 09:30
by Teddy's Toupee
palooka wrote:Paul Ryan could hit so could Crawford Ashley.
:doh:

Re: p4p biggest puncher in british boxing ? thoughts ?

Posted: 21 Nov 2012, 10:18
by Ratchet Exits Nu
Hamed.

He did not need to wind up his punches and could kncok you down and out with short shots.

No doubt in my mind... Hamed.

Re: p4p biggest puncher in british boxing ? thoughts ?

Posted: 21 Nov 2012, 12:53
by hurlock
Has to be naz for me!!

Alexander,evatt,Mickey Hughes

Haye at cruiser

Re: p4p biggest puncher in british boxing ? thoughts ?

Posted: 21 Nov 2012, 13:04
by elephant man
Bob Fitzsimmons :OhYes:

Re: p4p biggest puncher in british boxing ? thoughts ?

Posted: 21 Nov 2012, 13:33
by Andrew
Right now surely David Price the power in that right hand is frightening.

Re: p4p biggest puncher in british boxing ? thoughts ?

Posted: 21 Nov 2012, 15:51
by gp.
orbtastic wrote:Benn's drop in KO % coincided with his move up to super middle, where he'd already changed style considerably and also faced better opposition, broadly speaking.

Colin Jones could hit but he faced Geography teachers from Ghent in some fights so it's hard to gauge, the same with Pat Barrett - Their KOs dried up when they faced top level guys but it's somewhat disingenuous to criticise Jones for not knocking out the likes of McCrory and Curry.

Well, Colin Jones was not at all a good boxer. The punch was pretty much the only thing he had.

Of course, he was nowhere near as likely to land that punch as the likes of Naseem Hamed. But is being able to land a punch part of this discussion? If not then Jones has to be up there because I can't recall many other people who got as far as he did relying solely on a punch with as limited boxing skills as he possessed.

Re: p4p biggest puncher in british boxing ? thoughts ?

Posted: 21 Nov 2012, 17:10
by 80/20
:bow:
G0mez wrote:
80/20 wrote:Wayne Alexander?
Its not Wayne but I like that Gomez ! :lol:



Hi Wayne :D

Re: p4p biggest puncher in british boxing ? thoughts ?

Posted: 21 Nov 2012, 21:11
by Coco
gp. wrote:
orbtastic wrote:Benn's drop in KO % coincided with his move up to super middle, where he'd already changed style considerably and also faced better opposition, broadly speaking.

Colin Jones could hit but he faced Geography teachers from Ghent in some fights so it's hard to gauge, the same with Pat Barrett - Their KOs dried up when they faced top level guys but it's somewhat disingenuous to criticise Jones for not knocking out the likes of McCrory and Curry.

Well, Colin Jones was not at all a good boxer. The punch was pretty much the only thing he had.

Of course, he was nowhere near as likely to land that punch as the likes of Naseem Hamed. But is being able to land a punch part of this discussion? If not then Jones has to be up there because I can't recall many other people who got as far as he did relying solely on a punch with as limited boxing skills as he possessed.
Jones was a good enough to win the ABAs in the amateurs as well as being the youngest to represent GB in the Olympics.
You clearly underestimate his boxing ability. It is impossible to compete at that level without it.

Re: p4p biggest puncher in british boxing ? thoughts ?

Posted: 22 Nov 2012, 02:02
by hurlock
Alvin slick miller.

Kevin lueshing could dig.

Ensley Bingham.

Howard Eastman

Michael ayers

Michael Gomez

Re: p4p biggest puncher in british boxing ? thoughts ?

Posted: 22 Nov 2012, 03:37
by forcefraser
George groves

Re: p4p biggest puncher in british boxing ? thoughts ?

Posted: 22 Nov 2012, 05:06
by Chambers2
Delete (I can't read properly)

Re: p4p biggest puncher in british boxing ? thoughts ?

Posted: 22 Nov 2012, 15:08
by gp.
Coco wrote:
gp. wrote:
orbtastic wrote:Benn's drop in KO % coincided with his move up to super middle, where he'd already changed style considerably and also faced better opposition, broadly speaking.

Colin Jones could hit but he faced Geography teachers from Ghent in some fights so it's hard to gauge, the same with Pat Barrett - Their KOs dried up when they faced top level guys but it's somewhat disingenuous to criticise Jones for not knocking out the likes of McCrory and Curry.

Well, Colin Jones was not at all a good boxer. The punch was pretty much the only thing he had.

Of course, he was nowhere near as likely to land that punch as the likes of Naseem Hamed. But is being able to land a punch part of this discussion? If not then Jones has to be up there because I can't recall many other people who got as far as he did relying solely on a punch with as limited boxing skills as he possessed.
Jones was a good enough to win the ABAs in the amateurs as well as being the youngest to represent GB in the Olympics.
You clearly underestimate his boxing ability. It is impossible to compete at that level without it.
Everything is relative of course. For a man who competed at that level, he was not at all a good boxer.

Re: p4p biggest puncher in british boxing ? thoughts ?

Posted: 22 Nov 2012, 16:24
by CiganoBoxer
If its pound 4 pound then Naz smokes them all ...thats a fact i am afraid :bag:
In fact didnt Emanuel Stewart a few years ago say in an interview to one of the leading Magazines that when ask to re sight who was the hardest puncher he eva held the mits for ,he answered "Naseem Hamed no question !

Re: p4p biggest puncher in british boxing ? thoughts ?

Posted: 22 Nov 2012, 16:46
by Teddy's Toupee
Ovill McKenzie

Re: p4p biggest puncher in british boxing ? thoughts ?

Posted: 22 Nov 2012, 17:11
by BobbyG

Re: p4p biggest puncher in british boxing ? thoughts ?

Posted: 22 Nov 2012, 17:58
by dr_devious
elephant man wrote:Bob Fitzsimmons :OhYes:
Yes, and Jimmy Wilde and Jock Mcavoy

Re: p4p biggest puncher in british boxing ? thoughts ?

Posted: 22 Nov 2012, 18:47
by vxrandall
mrpedigree wrote:If its pound 4 pound then Naz smokes them all ...thats a fact i am afraid :bag:
In fact didnt Emanuel Stewart a few years ago say in an interview to one of the leading Magazines that when ask to re sight who was the hardest puncher he eva held the mits for ,he answered "Naseem Hamed no question !
This!

P4P.

Stats and legendary trainers corroborate. Naz punched like a mule kicks. Take a bow son!

Re: p4p biggest puncher in british boxing ? thoughts ?

Posted: 22 Nov 2012, 19:35
by CiganoBoxer
vxrandall wrote:
mrpedigree wrote:If its pound 4 pound then Naz smokes them all ...thats a fact i am afraid :bag:
In fact didnt Emanuel Stewart a few years ago say in an interview to one of the leading Magazines that when ask to re sight who was the hardest puncher he eva held the mits for ,he answered "Naseem Hamed no question !
This!

P4P.

Stats and legendary trainers corroborate. Naz punched like a mule kicks. Take a bow son!
:bag: :bag: :bag:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A1cKhkux4kU

Re: p4p biggest puncher in british boxing ? thoughts ?

Posted: 23 Nov 2012, 00:46
by ERIC GUY
mickey hughes v gary jacobs?

Re: p4p biggest puncher in british boxing ? thoughts ?

Posted: 23 Nov 2012, 02:46
by Deserter
gp. wrote:The punch was pretty much the only thing he had.
coco. wrote:Jones was a good enough to win the ABAs in the amateurs as well as being the youngest to represent GB in the Olympics.
You clearly underestimate his boxing ability. It is impossible to compete at that level without it.
gp. wrote:Everything is relative of course. For a man who competed at that level, he was not at all a good boxer.
:roll: His punch was the only thing he had, yet he battled to a 12-round draw with McCrory for the world title and his only significant loss was to Donald Curry, then regarded as the among the world's best p4p? :shame:

Re: p4p biggest puncher in british boxing ? thoughts ?

Posted: 23 Nov 2012, 03:17
by forcefraser
Freddie Flintoff