Page 2 of 3

Re: Referee for Froch v Groves

Posted: 24 May 2014, 06:10
by Final round
expe wrote:
Final round wrote:
Parson Cross wrote:Charlie Fitch - subject to approval by the IBF and the Board.
Hasn't reffed a World title in 18 months.
I'm unfamiliar with the name ,Which was the last WT he reffed?
Cotto-Trout, December 2012. This will be his 7th world title world fight, relatively inexperienced, refereed 221 professional fights since his debut in April 2001. Seems a bit of an unusual appointment, but if both sides have agreed then I can't see many problems arising from it, if he's been handpicked by Matchroom without Groves' consent, I have no doubt that he will kick up a fuss about it.
Cheers Expe. I watched Cotto fight but can't picture the ref which is probably a good thing

Re: Referee for Froch v Groves

Posted: 24 May 2014, 10:21
by Finn
brian13 wrote:
Finn wrote:Failing that, smogger has been reffing in europe recently.
And Froch has gave out regularly about the way he reffed the Ward fight. Froch's side would not approve Smoger.
Shame that Smoger is one of the best refs going.

Re: Referee for Froch v Groves

Posted: 25 May 2014, 08:27
by Sweet P
Pat Russell. Should get the job.
He is the best Ref I've worked with. He is the best Ref on the IBF roster in my opinion.

Re: Referee for Froch v Groves

Posted: 25 May 2014, 09:22
by palooka
Viktor Vaughn wrote:Foster wasn't a problem, they should have known that he hovers then steps in and worked on something for if and when Groves got ragged and appeared in trouble. Groves fought well, but it wasn't exactly a strategically sound performance once he'd picked up those early rounds. Froch will box better next time, Groves needs to adjust as things develop or risk losing again in similar circumstances.
I imagine it's hard enough to come up with a game plan to beat the world class fighter throwing punches at you without needing a game plan for the referree.

Re: Referee for Froch v Groves

Posted: 25 May 2014, 15:48
by palooka
Viktor Vaughn wrote:
palooka wrote:
Viktor Vaughn wrote:Foster wasn't a problem, they should have known that he hovers then steps in and worked on something for if and when Groves got ragged and appeared in trouble. Groves fought well, but it wasn't exactly a strategically sound performance once he'd picked up those early rounds. Froch will box better next time, Groves needs to adjust as things develop or risk losing again in similar circumstances.
I imagine it's hard enough to come up with a game plan to beat the world class fighter throwing punches at you without needing a game plan for the referree.
It's not a separate game plan, just good awareness.
I understand what you are saying and feel that a boxer shouldn't have to have a referee and their tendencies in their mind in a world title bout when someone is trying to knock their block off.

Re: Referee for Froch v Groves

Posted: 26 May 2014, 06:48
by Finn
Personally i think although stopped early it was the best result possible, it has now lead to a mega fight rematch. Groves and Froch will be making some serious cheddar out of this and its great for boxing in general and especially in Britain. Every casual sports fan in the country is talking about this fight.

I also think if the fight hadnt been stopped early groves would have been stopped shortly after and he wouldnt be getting this extra payday and opportunity to fight to a different game plan.

I expect froch to jump on groves from the outset and rough him up early to take that early advantage away.

Re: Referee for Froch v Groves

Posted: 27 May 2014, 08:47
by The Law

Re: Referee for Froch v Groves

Posted: 27 May 2014, 10:36
by rio
This fight was made for steve smoger. Guarentee if hes the ref it will have a conclusive ending with not a bit of controversy, he does not stop fights early and gives a fighter enough chance to fight his way back

Re: Referee for Froch v Groves

Posted: 27 May 2014, 10:48
by lefty
Should of given Kenny Bayless the gig. I think he's possibly the best referee out there. Smoger is also good in terms of letting fights go on but sometimes lets them go on too long and you have the opposite where a fighter can end up seriously hurt.

Re: Referee for Froch v Groves

Posted: 27 May 2014, 10:57
by rio
columbo wrote:Should of given Kenny Bayless the gig. I think he's possibly the best referee out there. Smoger is also good in terms of letting fights go on but sometimes lets them go on too long and you have the opposite where a fighter can end up seriously hurt.
True about smoger but if you ask both fighters which way they would want it to go I think they would both prefer to be out cold than stopped early and this is a fight than demands a conclusive ending.

Re: Referee for Froch v Groves

Posted: 27 May 2014, 11:19
by lefty
rio wrote:
columbo wrote:Should of given Kenny Bayless the gig. I think he's possibly the best referee out there. Smoger is also good in terms of letting fights go on but sometimes lets them go on too long and you have the opposite where a fighter can end up seriously hurt.
True about smoger but if you ask both fighters which way they would want it to go I think they would both prefer to be out cold than stopped early and this is a fight than demands a conclusive ending.
True but then if a fighter ends up really seriously injured ie Mclellan or worse then you'll get people going ballistic that it was stopped too late. It's a pretty impossible job really. Saying that though, some of the british referee type early stoppages are pretty scandalous.

Re: Referee for Froch v Groves

Posted: 27 May 2014, 11:54
by expe
Bit more here about both sides concerns - http://www.telegraph.co.uk/sport/others ... uling.html

McCracken comes across as very arrogant in that article, only one side of the story of course, but to claim that you can't call Carl Froch dirty because he's been an ambassador for the sport is plain arrogant for me.

Re: Referee for Froch v Groves

Posted: 27 May 2014, 12:17
by jameswilson
columbo wrote:Should of given Kenny Bayless the gig. I think he's possibly the best referee out there. Smoger is also good in terms of letting fights go on but sometimes lets them go on too long and you have the opposite where a fighter can end up seriously hurt.
I'd be very surprised if Bayless wasn't offered the fight if he was able to take it. Someone mentioned on here he only seems to referee fights in Nevada which gives me an inkling he may not have a passport.

Re: Referee for Froch v Groves

Posted: 27 May 2014, 12:24
by lefty
jameswilson wrote:
columbo wrote:Should of given Kenny Bayless the gig. I think he's possibly the best referee out there. Smoger is also good in terms of letting fights go on but sometimes lets them go on too long and you have the opposite where a fighter can end up seriously hurt.
I'd be very surprised if Bayless wasn't offered the fight if he was able to take it. Someone mentioned on here he only seems to referee fights in Nevada which gives me an inkling he may not have a passport.
Yeah could be that. That or he just doesnt like travelling to referee fights which could also be a possibility I guess.

Re: Referee for Froch v Groves

Posted: 27 May 2014, 12:47
by rf
boxfan3 wrote: We have great refs who don't get noticed because they just get in there referee and get the job done without any problems. I would go for Steve Gray, Marcus McDonald, Micheal Alexandra, Victor Loughan. very rare you see any of these making mistakes. All good refs who would not let us down. .
Wasn't it Marcus McDonnell that bottled it when it came to counting khan out against Limond ?

Re: Referee for Froch v Groves

Posted: 27 May 2014, 13:47
by jonny
rf wrote:
boxfan3 wrote: We have great refs who don't get noticed because they just get in there referee and get the job done without any problems. I would go for Steve Gray, Marcus McDonald, Micheal Alexandra, Victor Loughan. very rare you see any of these making mistakes. All good refs who would not let us down. .
Wasn't it Marcus McDonnell that bottled it when it came to counting khan out against Limond ?
Yes but he is a good ref

Re: Referee for Froch v Groves

Posted: 27 May 2014, 19:52
by fightscorecollector
DougieCampbell wrote:Victor Louglin is one of the best referees in the World.
My pick as the best ref in the UK.

Re: Referee for Froch v Groves

Posted: 28 May 2014, 08:50
by Bennyblanco
Whats ian john lewis upto this weekend?

Re: Referee for Froch v Groves

Posted: 28 May 2014, 08:52
by palooka
Bennyblanco wrote:Whats ian john lewis upto this weekend?
I just swallowed my tea down the wrong hole you son of a bitch :cry:

Re: Referee for Froch v Groves

Posted: 28 May 2014, 12:12
by Final round
palooka wrote:
Bennyblanco wrote:Whats ian john lewis upto this weekend?
I just swallowed my tea down the wrong hole you son of a bitch :cry:
Your arsehole ? you deviant

Re: Referee for Froch v Groves

Posted: 29 May 2014, 04:29
by ILikeBeer
Final round wrote: Your arsehole ? you deviant
Don't knock it until you try it. :OhYes:

Re: Referee for Froch v Groves

Posted: 29 May 2014, 14:35
by palooka
:salut: :OhYes:

Re: Referee for Froch v Groves

Posted: 29 May 2014, 14:59
by Datsue
Final round wrote:
palooka wrote:
Bennyblanco wrote:Whats ian john lewis upto this weekend?
I just swallowed my tea down the wrong hole you son of a bitch :cry:
Your arsehole ? you deviant
:lol:

Though that does raise the question of how palooka types whilst holding the funnel & tube...

Re: Referee for Froch v Groves

Posted: 29 May 2014, 15:00
by palooka
I just swallowed my tea down the wrong hole you son of a bitch :cry:[/quote]

Your arsehole ? you deviant[/quote]

:lol:

Though that does raise the question of how palooka types whilst holding the funnel & tube...[/quote]

I've rigged a contraption up :o

Re: Referee for Froch v Groves

Posted: 31 May 2014, 06:17
by Final round
Datsue wrote:
Final round wrote:
:lol:

Though that does raise the question of how palooka types whilst holding the funnel & tube...
:lol: :OhYes: