Page 2 of 2
Posted: 25 May 2004, 15:22
by stujones
J wrote:stujones wrote:1. Tszyu
2. Mayweather
3. Mitchell
4. Gatti
5. Harries
6. Hatton.
7. Cotto.
8. Urkal.
9. Corley.
10. Leijla
11. Sparaforda.
12. N dou.
13. Dorrin.
14. Bojado
15. Branco
16. Pinto.
17. Vince Phillips.
18. Tackie.
19. Witter.
20. Hurtado.
20.
briliant list mate i agree with almost every placing. though could be argued Weiss is top 20? petty small thing but agree with the top ten especially.
Yes, bit of an oversight there. I think I would place Weiss below Pinto and shift everyone down.
Posted: 25 May 2004, 20:47
by Blue
Hatton in the top ten... 
...give me a freaking break! 
Posted: 26 May 2004, 03:57
by knightshadeau
After one fight in 140 lb division, Floyd Mayweather ranks a number one or two in most of your minds, huh?? Wonder where you place him after one fight in the Super Middle weight division?
Posted: 26 May 2004, 04:33
by J
Posted: 26 May 2004, 04:34
by Kilburn
After seeing Harris last night my updated list is as follows:
1. Zoo
2. Cotto
3. Judah
4. Mitchell
5. Harris
6. N'Dou
7. Mayweather
8. Gatti
9. Hatton
10. Urkal
Posted: 26 May 2004, 07:29
by Matchfixer
Who exactly has Cotto beaten to rank so highly?
(N'dou comments are not allowed)
Mayweather has had only one fight at this level (admittedly he beat Corley)
Posted: 26 May 2004, 07:56
by Kilburn
I constructed my list on a "who I think beats who" basis.
Posted: 26 May 2004, 10:45
by Southpaw Stylist
Constructed on talent, it's
Mayweather
Cotto
Judah
Tszyu
Mitchell
Posted: 26 May 2004, 10:46
by Kilburn
Kind of like a P4P list eh? I think I'd have to agree.
Posted: 26 May 2004, 10:47
by Southpaw Stylist
Kind of, except Cotto, Judah and Mitchell aren't P4P'ers.
Posted: 26 May 2004, 10:48
by REAL_DEAL
what do you expect from Dark Blue
Posted: 26 May 2004, 11:07
by Kilburn
Southpaw Stylist wrote:Kind of, except Cotto, Judah and Mitchell aren't P4P'ers.
Just out of interest, lets see your P4P top 10. Don't expect to see mine as I can never be arsed to sit and ponder for long enough.
Posted: 26 May 2004, 11:15
by Southpaw Stylist
Nor can I.
I don't like making P4P lists, cos no-one ever fights anyone.
If it was based on who fights who, then someone like Erik Morales, Juan Marquez or Manny Pacquiao would be top.
