How does Brook do against May or Pac?

[gazza8]

He gets beaten

Close topic!

[Tomasino]

Brook gets completely befuddled by Floyd and possibly stopped if Floyd feels like it. If Manny gets tagged good then he stops Kell by round 8. If Kells lazy and lays back it's a UD win like Clottey for Pacman.

[ajwesty13]

not to well i am afraid his best chance is v pac that might be closer but MW is like a ghost

[whiskey]

Hopefully Kell's Tenerife episode has given him the long term wake-up call that his dedication to his craft needed.

He's a solid A-class welterweight.

But in Floyd & Manny, we're talking AAA class.

Boxers of their calibre don't generally slip into second gear and go on a 'retirement run' of fights, where they get picked off by the young guns. They exit at the top of the sport.


(Unless your name is Mosely and you've been taken to the cleaners through a divorce court)

[SFW]

Kell is a huge welterweight, with skills, a good boxing brain, and like someone said great timing. Floyd and Pac circa 2008-09 would definitely beat him in their own way, 2015 that is a much different proposition I'm not so sure either would have a huge edge. I'm 100% all American, the yanks typically disregard guys too much I'm not one of em. I knew Calzaghe was gonna mop the floor with Lacy and I even bet on Hatton over Zstyu what a glorious day.

Kell has some issues, conditioning may be one could move his head more i think too, but he is a tough tough out for anyone at 147.

[ClivePatrickLyons]

Against May no good losses every round Against Pac not much better :

[Pugilist-specialist]

Paulie Malignaggi rates Brook, Khan and Thurman above Floyd and Manny.

[expe]

Paulie Malignaggi rates Brook, Khan and Thurman above Floyd and Manny.

Paulie's on drugs then if he seriously believes that.

[SMALL AXE1]

Stop Pac. Loses points to floyd.

[danamba7]

Paulie Malignaggi rates Brook, Khan and Thurman above Floyd and Manny.

Paulie's on drugs then if he seriously believes that.

He did say that but I think he just meant Brook, Khan and Thurman are the future, Floyd and Manny haven't got long left.

[Pugilist-specialist]

Paulie Malignaggi rates Brook, Khan and Thurman above Floyd and Manny.

Paulie's on drugs then if he seriously believes that.

He did say that but I think he just meant Brook, Khan and Thurman are the future, Floyd and Manny haven't got long left.

No he didn't pal - here's his quotes;
http://www1.skysports.com/boxing/news/1 ... malignaggi