BoxRec

Give me his top 5 wins and then let's give a mark out of 10 for each opponent on the night he fought them. Be interesting to see what people think and how opinions differ.

cfang wrote:

cfang wrote:

The Revival wrote:
Hit the nail on the head Saad.

Yes Im with Saad on this. I can't sand Floyd and have been praying for him to lose for years..but he doesn't. He's beaten everyone pretty much. It could be argued he should have fought manny before manny started looking beatable - other than that the names on his resume are tremendous. DLH, Moseley, Manny P, JMM, Canelo, Cotto, Castillo, Corrales, Hatton, Maidana - He's one of the greatest fighters of all time and would give anyone around his weight class in history hell. He's just almost impossible to hit cleanly and punches with more venom than his record would suggest. Everyone thinks they can just charge in there and rough him up - but it just doesn't happen as he's sooo hard to hit and then punishes fighters for their mistakes. A truly exceptional fighter on all levels......still cant stand him tho lol

how do you think he'd do against
hearns/leonard/duran?

i could imagine he makes duran look
ordinary, maybe hearts too, but i think
leonard finds a way ...

Ezzard wrote:Give me his top 5 wins and then let's give a mark out of 10 for each opponent on the night he fought them. Be interesting to see what people think and how opinions differ.

The biggest names that he beat were probably:
Pacquiao, de la hoya,Mosley,Marquez, and then probably Cotto.

Out of 10, Pac was almost shot, maybe 5 or 6 of 10 of what he used to be.
DLH was maybe 8.
Mosley about 6.
Marquez about 7.
Cotto (not a great fighter even during his prime) maybe 8 or 9.

For those that like to pretend the stages of his opponents career doesn't matter, how about we do that with everybody?

Lets pretend that Joe Louis, Ezzard Charles, Archie Moore and Jersey Joe Walcott were all in their primes when Marciano beat them. That mean that Marciano beat 3 different opponents that are arguably in the Top 10 PFP All time, and another win over a great fighter.
With this great logic, you would pretty much have to conclude that Rocky Marciano was the greatest fighter whoever lived.

Ezzard wrote:Give me his top 5 wins and then let's give a mark out of 10 for each opponent on the night he fought them. Be interesting to see what people think and how opinions differ.

Edit: weird, it didn't post my bold. Not that anyone will bother with my hankesque novel. LOL.

Pretty futile exercise, Floyd's level of hate generates virtually zero objectivity. I mean there are several people in this thread that think he isn't an atg! A number is hard to craft since he's made so many very good/great fighters look pedestrian. The guy faced the best in the world for over a decade and they all were shot, cherry picked, off night, etc..?

I'll list his top 5 for me(minus the number and not in order) along with my reasoning. I'll also save his 'fans' some time and offer their rebuttal for them.

Actually, can't really narrow it down to 5. I'm not one for novels, but I'll go ahead and write one up. I wish he would have lost as much as anyone, but, much like Leonard. I have to acknowledge greatness. While I rate ray over Floyd, he's not far from that tier.

By no means am I suggesting these were all great opponents, but they're all part of the story. Pro and con. Some of the lesser talked about victories counter the long standing opinions against him. The biggest misconception is that he has no balls. Whenever he's had the occasion to nut up in a fight, he never failed to.

Genaro Hernandez

Very solid champion, I don't think he's HOF material but he may make it one day. Huge step up in class and from the first bell Floyd demonstrated that the step up wasn't in his corner. Beautiful combination punching and defense led to a corner stoppage. Later paid for his funeral to show he isn't entirely classless.

Rebuttal: Like many of these, too far down the line for the detractors to even acknowledge.

Angel manfredy

Not overly significant, but for younger fans that weren't around at the time this was considered a big test. Angel had dismantled gatti and while the prevalent thought was Floyd by decision he rolled in the ring with his rarely unveiled mean streak and demolished a guy who seemed durable if nothing else.

Rebuttal: bum

Diego Corrales

This is the perfect example of the blind criticism aimed at Floyd. Hindsight makes all of these guys out of his league(and they were) but who the hell else is he supposed to fight? Two unbeaten belt holders in the top 10 of the mythical p4p rankings is now a bullshit fight(reoccurring theme). This was the only fight he entered as an underdog and he put on one of the greatest performances in ring history. Defense, offense, power, ring generalship, killer instinct. Check in every box.

Rebuttal:Diego was elsewhere worried about his prison sentence, weight drained and uninspired. Not to mention, he was never at Floyd's level.

Carlos Hernandez

Hello adversity! Very scrappy fighter, only relevant because he fought half the fight with one hand. Pretty tough display for a pussycoward.

Rebuttal:Bum


Jesus Chavez

This was one of his more entertaining fights. I loved Chavez and he brought a ton of pressure to Floyd for really the first time. He showed the ability to dig in and fight back when someone showed they didn't give a fornicate about his skills. The skill levels were too much for Jesus and he got punished into submission. This is the kind of guy that fills up a resume like Chavez. Good solid opponent, not a world beater, but nobody to mock.

Rebuttal: Bum


Jose luis Castillo x2

One of my all time favorites and a borderline top 25-30 Lightweight. For the record, I thought Castillo edged this one. I also count good losses in a resume(no idea why everyone doesn't). This isn't the type of decision where I would just ignore the official result because it was a complete robbery. Two great fighters in a close fight. The main thing to take away is the cherry picking coward decided to give Jose an immediate rematch and conclusively prove who the better fighter was. Odd behavior for a guy that wouldn't sign to fight anyone of worth. Isn't it? No credit for fighting him, no credit for re-matching him, just no credit for anything.

Rebuttal: Castillo was robbed in the first fight and Floyd ran in horror in the second.

Demarcus Corley

Yeah, yeah, go ahead and laugh. Just another sign of his mental fortitude. Corley was the first guy to ever hurt him and he was kicking Corley's ass before the end of the round.

Rebuttal: Bum(all these 'bums' are belt holders.


Arturo Gatti

We all should have known that Gatti wasn't ever able to compete at this level, but there were a ton of fans convincing themselves that Arturo had the size and balls to slay the devil. Strangely, Gatti was intimidated before the fight ever happened. mainly significant because it was when he first began on PPV.

Rebuttal:Gatti was a punching bag, Floyd hit him with a cheap shot and he cherry picked Gatti instead of challenging Tszyu(who was out injured and had to fight Sharmba when he returned)


Zab Judah

I must admit, Zab fought much better than I expected. The 'knockdown', hand speed and shenanigans late did nothing to alter Floyd's focus. When his normal style wasn't dominant, he switched gears and walked his man down. Yet another sign that he could do everything in a ring.

Rebuttal: Zab was a mental midget who never deserved the fight after losing his previous one(valid). At the time, Floyd was 'exposed' to many.


Carlos baldomir

Lame fight, still did a good number. Significant because this was when he broke from Arum. Seems Floyd wanted to fight Oscar delahoya for 20 million and Arum told him it was a pipe dream. This was for the lineal title after all, though in modern times that and a quarter will get you a nickel imo. However, many of the lineal trumpeters were steamed at Floyd for not fighting the big bad margarito. Fact: Floyd fighting Margarito makes him resign with Arum and potentially costs him several hundred million dollars.

Rebuttal: He cherry picked the lineal title(LOL), ran the whole fight and ducked margarito.


Oscar DelaHoya

I actually won a contest doing a rbr prediction for this fight. 9-3 Floyd and he wins a SD. Heading in Oscar was the one, for many, too big and tough for Floyd. He was coasting down the stretch, Oscar had nothing for him. Early jab success was taken away with counter right hands. That's why Oscar stopped throwing it!

This was the birth of 'Money'. Hell yes he was the B side, but he generated a million more buys than anyone else Oscar fought.

Rebuttal:These can range from oscar won, oscar was shot, Floyd was afraid of a rematch, etc...


Ricky hatton

Undisputed, undefeated Jr Welterweight Champion vs Undisputed, undefeated Welterweight champion with both universally considered in the top 5 p4p? Yay, right? Ummmmm, not now. Floyd tried to fight Ricky at 140, but Hatton declined. The 7 pounds probably helped Ricky more than Floyd anyway, as he drained much more to make weight. Decent fight, great performance ended with a check hook.

Rebuttal: Hatton was a caveman who was forced to fight out of his natural division(LMAO). Floyd should have fought him sooner.


JMM

I would hope since this is BOTP, we all can appreciate a Lightweight champion moving up to fight the recognized top Welterweight? Anyway, Marquez showed he could handle the weight by beating manny twice here. This is one of the more overlooked performances in history, no ring rust and impeccable timing against an ATG. The whole weight fiasco is on marquez, all he had to do was turn down the money and Floyd would have had to cut the two pounds.

Rebuttal: Marquez was a blown up Lightweight and Floyd cheated to cut weight. Amusingly, the one thing I suspect that nobody talks about is I have an inkling that Floyd joined the PED world during his retirement to come back and clean up the sport. The gains from that stuff don't evaporate nearly as quickly as most fans think.


Shane Mosley

Welterweight Champion coming off one of his best wins. Two top 5 p4p fighters. Shane clearly had lost a step by now, doesn't make it the wrong fight to make. If he didn't make it, it would loom large on his 'ducking' list. Floyd was hurt the worst of his career in this one, and, again, by the end of the same round he was walking Shane down and whipping his ass. Anybody remember years earlier when Floyd challenged Shane and Mosley had a loose tooth? Or when Floyd wanted to fight him at 135 and Shane rightfully pursued Oscar instead? Yeah, didn't think so.

Rebuttal: Shane was a broken down fighter, Floyd cherry picked the lineal title(again LOL) and he should have fought him earlier. From this point on, you can just add ducked Pacquaio to all of these.


Miguel Cotto

I anticipated a good fight, and we got one. Cotto is a sure fire HOF fighter who had the size advantage. Floyd stood his ground and showed off his countering in a fight that was worth the money(a rarity, but that doesn't matter in terms of resume. Another fighter Floyd wanted to fight at 140, but Arum determined Miguel wasn't ready.

Rebuttal: FLoyd should have fought him at 140, Margarito ruined Cotto


Canelo Alvarez

Giving up 20 pounds to a prime, undefeated, Jr Middleweight? Big challenge? This is the guy, right? LOL, how anyone thought Alvarez had a chance is beyond me. He's not a pressure fighter and nobody in history is beating Floyd in a slow paced countering fight. Does that mean it isn't a big feather in his cap to completely tame the beast?

Rebuttal: Floyd made him drain 2 pounds and Canelo was too green. If he fought him NOW! Oh boy, Canelo would teach him a lesson.


Marcos maidana x2

A bigger, and closer, version of the Chavez fight. Marcos was another I don't give a fornicate if I look foolish at times, I'm winging. Again, even at the older age, Floyd responded with sharp counter-punching to clearly win imo. That being said, it was his second closest fight and he again delivered an immediate rematch that he won comprehensively.

Rebuttal:Don't hear too much on this one, lets say Floyd should have hit Maidana's face with his gloves more.


manny Pacquaio

fornicate both of these guys for this taking so long. Both were past their best, but still among the best in the world. Floyd clowned him. I'm sure if Pac would have knocked him out everyone would have acknowledged that Floyd was on the downside? LMAO

Rebuttal: Manny was hurt, manny was shot, Floyd ducked him for 40 years, he's the antichrist and the one guy who was always supposed to be the one was just another one.



Conclusion ATG, no matter how you cut it. Other than Ali and Holyfield, I can't think of many that you can't offer a single name that they 'should' have fought. Irrational navigating can sully most any resume. Guys like Grandberry can pick apart Ali's opposition much like people do Floyd's. Don't be a Grandberry, give the man his due.



Rebuttal: fornicate Floyd, he's a cherry picking coward that never fought anybody

Really good post, mate

great post saad

SaadOffTheDeck wrote:

Ezzard wrote:Give me his top 5 wins and then let's give a mark out of 10 for each opponent on the night he fought them. Be interesting to see what people think and how opinions differ.

Edit: weird, it didn't post my bold. Not that anyone will bother with my hankesque novel. LOL.

Pretty futile exercise, Floyd's level of hate generates virtually zero objectivity. I mean there are several people in this thread that think he isn't an atg! A number is hard to craft since he's made so many very good/great fighters look pedestrian. The guy faced the best in the world for over a decade and they all were shot, cherry picked, off night, etc..?

I'll list his top 5 for me(minus the number and not in order) along with my reasoning. I'll also save his 'fans' some time and offer their rebuttal for them.

Actually, can't really narrow it down to 5. I'm not one for novels, but I'll go ahead and write one up. I wish he would have lost as much as anyone, but, much like Leonard. I have to acknowledge greatness. While I rate ray over Floyd, he's not far from that tier.

By no means am I suggesting these were all great opponents, but they're all part of the story. Pro and con. Some of the lesser talked about victories counter the long standing opinions against him. The biggest misconception is that he has no balls. Whenever he's had the occasion to nut up in a fight, he never failed to.

Genaro Hernandez

Very solid champion, I don't think he's HOF material but he may make it one day. Huge step up in class and from the first bell Floyd demonstrated that the step up wasn't in his corner. Beautiful combination punching and defense led to a corner stoppage. Later paid for his funeral to show he isn't entirely classless.

Rebuttal: Like many of these, too far down the line for the detractors to even acknowledge.

Angel manfredy

Not overly significant, but for younger fans that weren't around at the time this was considered a big test. Angel had dismantled gatti and while the prevalent thought was Floyd by decision he rolled in the ring with his rarely unveiled mean streak and demolished a guy who seemed durable if nothing else.

Rebuttal: bum

Diego Corrales

This is the perfect example of the blind criticism aimed at Floyd. Hindsight makes all of these guys out of his league(and they were) but who the hell else is he supposed to fight? Two unbeaten belt holders in the top 10 of the mythical p4p rankings is now a bullshit fight(reoccurring theme). This was the only fight he entered as an underdog and he put on one of the greatest performances in ring history. Defense, offense, power, ring generalship, killer instinct. Check in every box.

Rebuttal:Diego was elsewhere worried about his prison sentence, weight drained and uninspired. Not to mention, he was never at Floyd's level.

Carlos Hernandez

Hello adversity! Very scrappy fighter, only relevant because he fought half the fight with one hand. Pretty tough display for a pussycoward.

Rebuttal:Bum


Jesus Chavez

This was one of his more entertaining fights. I loved Chavez and he brought a ton of pressure to Floyd for really the first time. He showed the ability to dig in and fight back when someone showed they didn't give a eff about his skills. The skill levels were too much for Jesus and he got punished into submission. This is the kind of guy that fills up a resume like Chavez. Good solid opponent, not a world beater, but nobody to mock.

Rebuttal: Bum


Jose luis Castillo x2

One of my all time favorites and a borderline top 25-30 Lightweight. For the record, I thought Castillo edged this one. I also count good losses in a resume(no idea why everyone doesn't). This isn't the type of decision where I would just ignore the official result because it was a complete robbery. Two great fighters in a close fight. The main thing to take away is the cherry picking coward decided to give Jose an immediate rematch and conclusively prove who the better fighter was. Odd behavior for a guy that wouldn't sign to fight anyone of worth. Isn't it? No credit for fighting him, no credit for re-matching him, just no credit for anything.

Rebuttal: Castillo was robbed in the first fight and Floyd ran in horror in the second.

Demarcus Corley

Yeah, yeah, go ahead and laugh. Just another sign of his mental fortitude. Corley was the first guy to ever hurt him and he was kicking Corley's ass before the end of the round.

Rebuttal: Bum(all these 'bums' are belt holders.


Arturo Gatti

We all should have known that Gatti wasn't ever able to compete at this level, but there were a ton of fans convincing themselves that Arturo had the size and balls to slay the devil. Strangely, Gatti was intimidated before the fight ever happened. mainly significant because it was when he first began on PPV.

Rebuttal:Gatti was a punching bag, Floyd hit him with a cheap shot and he cherry picked Gatti instead of challenging Tszyu(who was out injured and had to fight Sharmba when he returned)


Zab Judah

I must admit, Zab fought much better than I expected. The 'knockdown', hand speed and shenanigans late did nothing to alter Floyd's focus. When his normal style wasn't dominant, he switched gears and walked his man down. Yet another sign that he could do everything in a ring.

Rebuttal: Zab was a mental midget who never deserved the fight after losing his previous one(valid). At the time, Floyd was 'exposed' to many.


Carlos baldomir

Lame fight, still did a good number. Significant because this was when he broke from Arum. Seems Floyd wanted to fight Oscar delahoya for 20 million and Arum told him it was a pipe dream. This was for the lineal title after all, though in modern times that and a quarter will get you a nickel imo. However, many of the lineal trumpeters were steamed at Floyd for not fighting the big bad margarito. Fact: Floyd fighting Margarito makes him resign with Arum and potentially costs him several hundred million dollars.

Rebuttal: He cherry picked the lineal title(LOL), ran the whole fight and ducked margarito.


Oscar DelaHoya

I actually won a contest doing a rbr prediction for this fight. 9-3 Floyd and he wins a SD. Heading in Oscar was the one, for many, too big and tough for Floyd. He was coasting down the stretch, Oscar had nothing for him. Early jab success was taken away with counter right hands. That's why Oscar stopped throwing it!

This was the birth of 'Money'. Hell yes he was the B side, but he generated a million more buys than anyone else Oscar fought.

Rebuttal:These can range from oscar won, oscar was shot, Floyd was afraid of a rematch, etc...


Ricky hatton

Undisputed, undefeated Jr Welterweight Champion vs Undisputed, undefeated Welterweight champion with both universally considered in the top 5 p4p? Yay, right? Ummmmm, not now. Floyd tried to fight Ricky at 140, but Hatton declined. The 7 pounds probably helped Ricky more than Floyd anyway, as he drained much more to make weight. Decent fight, great performance ended with a check hook.

Rebuttal: Hatton was a caveman who was forced to fight out of his natural division(LMAO). Floyd should have fought him sooner.


JMM

I would hope since this is BOTP, we all can appreciate a Lightweight champion moving up to fight the recognized top Welterweight? Anyway, Marquez showed he could handle the weight by beating manny twice here. This is one of the more overlooked performances in history, no ring rust and impeccable timing against an ATG. The whole weight fiasco is on marquez, all he had to do was turn down the money and Floyd would have had to cut the two pounds.

Rebuttal: Marquez was a blown up Lightweight and Floyd cheated to cut weight. Amusingly, the one thing I suspect that nobody talks about is I have an inkling that Floyd joined the PED world during his retirement to come back and clean up the sport. The gains from that stuff don't evaporate nearly as quickly as most fans think.


Shane Mosley

Welterweight Champion coming off one of his best wins. Two top 5 p4p fighters. Shane clearly had lost a step by now, doesn't make it the wrong fight to make. If he didn't make it, it would loom large on his 'ducking' list. Floyd was hurt the worst of his career in this one, and, again, by the end of the same round he was walking Shane down and whipping his ass. Anybody remember years earlier when Floyd challenged Shane and Mosley had a loose tooth? Or when Floyd wanted to fight him at 135 and Shane rightfully pursued Oscar instead? Yeah, didn't think so.

Rebuttal: Shane was a broken down fighter, Floyd cherry picked the lineal title(again LOL) and he should have fought him earlier. From this point on, you can just add ducked Pacquaio to all of these.


Miguel Cotto

I anticipated a good fight, and we got one. Cotto is a sure fire HOF fighter who had the size advantage. Floyd stood his ground and showed off his countering in a fight that was worth the money(a rarity, but that doesn't matter in terms of resume. Another fighter Floyd wanted to fight at 140, but Arum determined Miguel wasn't ready.

Rebuttal: FLoyd should have fought him at 140, Margarito ruined Cotto


Canelo Alvarez

Giving up 20 pounds to a prime, undefeated, Jr Middleweight? Big challenge? This is the guy, right? LOL, how anyone thought Alvarez had a chance is beyond me. He's not a pressure fighter and nobody in history is beating Floyd in a slow paced countering fight. Does that mean it isn't a big feather in his cap to completely tame the beast?

Rebuttal: Floyd made him drain 2 pounds and Canelo was too green. If he fought him NOW! Oh boy, Canelo would teach him a lesson.


Marcos maidana x2

A bigger, and closer, version of the Chavez fight. Marcos was another I don't give a eff if I look foolish at times, I'm winging. Again, even at the older age, Floyd responded with sharp counter-punching to clearly win imo. That being said, it was his second closest fight and he again delivered an immediate rematch that he won comprehensively.

Rebuttal:Don't hear too much on this one, lets say Floyd should have hit Maidana's face with his gloves more.


manny Pacquaio

eff both of these guys for this taking so long. Both were past their best, but still among the best in the world. Floyd clowned him. I'm sure if Pac would have knocked him out everyone would have acknowledged that Floyd was on the downside? LMAO

Rebuttal: Manny was hurt, manny was shot, Floyd ducked him for 40 years, he's the antichrist and the one guy who was always supposed to be the one was just another one.



Conclusion ATG, no matter how you cut it. Other than Ali and Holyfield, I can't think of many that you can't offer a single name that they 'should' have fought. Irrational navigating can sully most any resume. Guys like Grandberry can pick apart Ali's opposition much like people do Floyd's. Don't be a Grandberry, give the man his due.



Rebuttal: eff Floyd, he's a cherry picking coward that never fought anybody

Thanks bro, while I'd much rather wax poetically about Hearns, Evander or Morales. It astounds me how little rub Floyd gets in forums such as this. I expect it in CS, but in a historically based forum, he's earned his place.

Tomasino wrote:

man wrote:

elmersalsa wrote:WTKO 11 Diego Corrales
W12 Saul " Canelo" Alvarez
WTKO8 Genaro " Chicanito" Hernandez
WTKO6 Juan Manuel Marquez
W12 Jose Luis Castillo (II)...Proved that he was the better man in the rematch
WTKO2 Angel "El Diablo" Manfredy
W12 Shane Mosley
W12 Marcos Maidana

funny list though ...

I remember him brutally finishing Marquez in the 6th round. Was an incredible night of boxing. On this night, no man could have beaten the great Pretty Boy. Even the great Roberto Duran would have farted and turned his back, wailing 'No Mas!'

Tomasino wrote:

man wrote:

elmersalsa wrote:WTKO 11 Diego Corrales
W12 Saul " Canelo" Alvarez
WTKO8 Genaro " Chicanito" Hernandez
WTKO6 Juan Manuel Marquez
W12 Jose Luis Castillo (II)...Proved that he was the better man in the rematch
WTKO2 Angel "El Diablo" Manfredy
W12 Shane Mosley
W12 Marcos Maidana

funny list though ...

I remember him brutally finishing Marquez in the 6th round. Was an incredible night of boxing. On this night, no man could have beaten the great Pretty Boy. Even the great Roberto Duran would have farted and turned his back, wailing 'No Mas!'

You guys must be confused. Mayweather didn't stop Juan Manuel Marquez. He stopped Arturo Gatti in 6. Juan Manuel Marquez lasted the distance. Lost every round basically, and got dropped, but lasted the distance.

Your sarcasm detector is malfunctioning.

Ambling Alp II wrote:

Ezzard wrote:Give me his top 5 wins and then let's give a mark out of 10 for each opponent on the night he fought them. Be interesting to see what people think and how opinions differ.

The biggest names that he beat were probably:
Pacquiao, de la hoya,Mosley,Marquez, and then probably Cotto.

Out of 10, Pac was almost shot, maybe 5 or 6 of 10 of what he used to be.
DLH was maybe 8.
Mosley about 6.
Marquez about 7.
Cotto (not a great fighter even during his prime) maybe 8 or 9.

For those that like to pretend the stages of his opponents career doesn't matter, how about we do that with everybody?

Lets pretend that Joe Louis, Ezzard Charles, Archie Moore and Jersey Joe Walcott were all in their primes when Marciano beat them. That mean that Marciano beat 3 different opponents that are arguably in the Top 10 PFP All time, and another win over a great fighter.
With this great logic, you would pretty much have to conclude that Rocky Marciano was the greatest fighter whoever lived.

I can live with your numbers.

I think Cotto is more a 6. I didn't mean out of 10 for how prime they are... I mean factor how good they were out of 10 but taking into consideration the time in their career and best weight class. Cotto at his peak was probably a 7 maybe almost 8. Pac was a 10 at feather in 2003.

man wrote:

cfang wrote:

cfang wrote:

Yes Im with Saad on this. I can't sand Floyd and have been praying for him to lose for years..but he doesn't. He's beaten everyone pretty much. It could be argued he should have fought manny before manny started looking beatable - other than that the names on his resume are tremendous. DLH, Moseley, Manny P, JMM, Canelo, Cotto, Castillo, Corrales, Hatton, Maidana - He's one of the greatest fighters of all time and would give anyone around his weight class in history hell. He's just almost impossible to hit cleanly and punches with more venom than his record would suggest. Everyone thinks they can just charge in there and rough him up - but it just doesn't happen as he's sooo hard to hit and then punishes fighters for their mistakes. A truly exceptional fighter on all levels......still cant stand him tho lol

how do you think he'd do against
hearns/leonard/duran?

i could imagine he makes duran look
ordinary, maybe hearts too, but i think
leonard finds a way ...

Makes the Hands of Stone look ordinary? Have you ever seen the great Roberto Duran fight in his prime?

To me, the great Floyd Mayweather, Jr is the second best fighter of the last 50 years behind the great Roberto Duran. The second best fighter that I have seen in my lifetime. He does not get the respect due for some reason. But how can a man that beat almost every top notch significant fighter of his era should not be in the top 10 atg consideration is beyond my comprehension. To me, he got to be in the top 10, without a doubt.

He just didn't just win the fight. He dominated the fighters he was in the ring with. The most dominating fighter that I have ever seen since the great Pernell Whitaker.

The ones he avoided and the ones he cherry picked.

elmersalsa wrote:

man wrote: i could imagine he makes duran look
ordinary, maybe hearts too, but i think
leonard finds a way ...

Makes the Hands of Stone look ordinary? Have you ever seen the great Roberto Duran fight in his prime?

floyd's biggest weapon IMO is that he manages
to always know where the opponent's hands are.
this enables him to hardly ever get hit clean (except
for one punch against shane) and that means power
does not impress him very much.

duran was a powerful pressure fighter, which is
exactly what floyd deals best with. as much as i
love duran, floyd beats him. the only comparable
win on duran's win list is ray, who chose to brawl
instead of outsmart in their first one.

one thing needs to be said as well and seems
to be overlooked by critics. while the heavies
were a total disaster in the early 2ooos, almost
everyone agreed that the lower weight classes
were unusually talent rich. reality is floyd could
dominate a strong field for a decade. he is an
elite all time fighter.

The best opponent (at the time he fought them which Mayweather backers keep overlooking) was a past it DLH and he didn't look that good in that fight.
Compared to the real legends of the sport-Big friggin deal.

At the end of the day, it comes down to this.

man wrote:

elmersalsa wrote:

man wrote: i could imagine he makes duran look
ordinary, maybe hearts too, but i think
leonard finds a way ...

Makes the Hands of Stone look ordinary? Have you ever seen the great Roberto Duran fight in his prime?

floyd's biggest weapon IMO is that he manages
to always know where the opponent's hands are.
this enables him to hardly ever get hit clean (except
for one punch against shane) and that means power
does not impress him very much.

duran was a powerful pressure fighter, which is
exactly what floyd deals best with. as much as i
love duran, floyd beats him. the only comparable
win on duran's win list is ray, who chose to brawl
instead of outsmart in their first one.

I guess we got two different set of eyes.