Page 2 of 2

Re: Are there any examples of a pro returning to the ring after a brain injury incurred in the ring?

Posted: 29 Mar 2016, 14:22
by Cyclops
littlepug wrote:Edwin Valero
A shining example there

Re: Are there any examples of a pro returning to the ring after a brain injury incurred in the ring?

Posted: 29 Mar 2016, 14:32
by Old bones Ian
John Lowey was the boxer I was thinking of, failed a medical here in 1991, think it was a possible cyst as the problem. He then tried to get his license back but failed. So went to America and made a comeback fighting and losing in title bouts against Kennedy McKinney and Eric Morales.

http://boxrec.com/boxer/6442

Re: Are there any examples of a pro returning to the ring after a brain injury incurred in the ring?

Posted: 29 Mar 2016, 14:36
by Sklar
Stuarty30 wrote:
Sklar wrote:What did Blackwell do before he started fighting?
Was he not on the unlicensed circuit for a while? Don't know if it was bare knuckle or that. Something rings a bell but can't remember the specifics.
Yes, I mean before that. Does he have a trade or other vocational skills?

Re: Are there any examples of a pro returning to the ring after a brain injury incurred in the ring?

Posted: 29 Mar 2016, 14:39
by Stuarty
Sklar wrote:
Stuarty30 wrote:
Sklar wrote:What did Blackwell do before he started fighting?
Was he not on the unlicensed circuit for a while? Don't know if it was bare knuckle or that. Something rings a bell but can't remember the specifics.
Yes, I mean before that. Does he have a trade or other vocational skills?
Ahh apologies :TU: Not sure about that but he's young an seems a bright enough boy so I'm sure he could do anything he wanted.

Re: Are there any examples of a pro returning to the ring after a brain injury incurred in the ring?

Posted: 29 Mar 2016, 16:32
by Junker
Not in this country but Jermain Taylor actually suffered a minor subdural haematoma against Arthur Abraham, was eventually relicensed to box on and won the IBF middleweight title.
After that things went tits up pretty seriously.

Re: Are there any examples of a pro returning to the ring after a brain injury incurred in the ring?

Posted: 29 Mar 2016, 17:45
by rpms
Possibly the end of his Brother Dan's career too,can't imagine him carrying on after this.

Re: Are there any examples of a pro returning to the ring after a brain injury incurred in the ring?

Posted: 29 Mar 2016, 22:52
by ClivePatrickLyons
Cholo_cws wrote:There was the Filipino guy that Katsidis fought several years ago. Can't recall his name. Csar something I think.

Czar Amonsot was his name and he is world rated by some today........ I recently watched Ali fight Holmes and it was criminal :evil:

Re: Are there any examples of a pro returning to the ring after a brain injury incurred in the ring?

Posted: 30 Mar 2016, 07:44
by PredatorHayds
Junker wrote:Not in this country but Jermain Taylor actually suffered a minor subdural haematoma against Arthur Abraham, was eventually relicensed to box on and won the IBF middleweight title.
After that things went tits up pretty seriously.
Luckily fighting on didn't seem to effect his mental health :brick:
Whoever licensed Taylor after Abraham should be ashamed of themselves.

Re: Are there any examples of a pro returning to the ring after a brain injury incurred in the ring?

Posted: 30 Mar 2016, 07:53
by Oiky
Stuarty30 wrote:
Sklar wrote:
Stuarty30 wrote:
Was he not on the unlicensed circuit for a while? Don't know if it was bare knuckle or that. Something rings a bell but can't remember the specifics.
Yes, I mean before that. Does he have a trade or other vocational skills?
Ahh apologies :TU: Not sure about that but he's young an seems a bright enough boy so I'm sure he could do anything he wanted.
i know his brother dan is a bricklayer so nick might have some experience in brickwork but yeah he does seem like a clued up person so god bless and good luck in what ever he choses to do

Re: Are there any examples of a pro returning to the ring after a brain injury incurred in the ring?

Posted: 30 Mar 2016, 07:55
by Stuarty
Oiky wrote:
Stuarty30 wrote:
Sklar wrote:
Yes, I mean before that. Does he have a trade or other vocational skills?
Ahh apologies :TU: Not sure about that but he's young an seems a bright enough boy so I'm sure he could do anything he wanted.
i know his brother dan is a bricklayer so nick might have some experience in brickwork but yeah he does seem like a clued up person so god bless and good luck in what ever he choses to do
His brother Dan is a journeyman isn't he?

Re: Are there any examples of a pro returning to the ring after a brain injury incurred in the ring?

Posted: 30 Mar 2016, 08:26
by Offal
Joe Mesi suffered a brain bleed in his fight with Jirov, he wanted to continue with his career and was in search of a state that would give him a license (most had rightly banned him) He then suffered another brain bleed while moving some heavy furniture and sensibly he decided against returning to the ring. (NB: he didn't get whacked on the head, just the strain of lifting caused the injury to bleed again)

Once your brain/skull is damaged in ANY way, it's insanity to consider fighting again.

Re: Are there any examples of a pro returning to the ring after a brain injury incurred in the ring?

Posted: 30 Mar 2016, 08:38
by Boxing Writer
Joe Mesi, Czar Amonsot and Jermain Taylor all returned to the ring after brain bleeding. Interesting that none of them lost since suffering their brain injuries: Mesi is 7-0 since Jirov fight, Amonsot is 13-0-2 since Katsidis fight and Taylor is 5-0 since Abraham fight. Taylor is also the first boxer to win major world title after suffering serious brain injury.

Re: Are there any examples of a pro returning to the ring after a brain injury incurred in the ring?

Posted: 30 Mar 2016, 11:26
by Oiky
Stuarty30 wrote:
Oiky wrote:
Stuarty30 wrote:
Ahh apologies :TU: Not sure about that but he's young an seems a bright enough boy so I'm sure he could do anything he wanted.
i know his brother dan is a bricklayer so nick might have some experience in brickwork but yeah he does seem like a clued up person so god bless and good luck in what ever he choses to do
His brother Dan is a journeyman isn't he?
yeah he boxes, but is also a bricklayer

come to think of it, i think i remember reading somewhere that at 18 before he turned pro he had a bricklaying apprenticeship himself

Re: Are there any examples of a pro returning to the ring after a brain injury incurred in the ring?

Posted: 30 Mar 2016, 11:30
by palooka
Boxing Writer wrote:Joe Mesi, Czar Amonsot and Jermain Taylor all returned to the ring after brain bleeding. Interesting that none of them lost since suffering their brain injuries: Mesi is 7-0 since Jirov fight, Amonsot is 13-0-2 since Katsidis fight and Taylor is 5-0 since Abraham fight. Taylor is also the first boxer to win major world title after suffering serious brain injury.
Didn't Taylor begin to behave impulsively and violently after his injury?

Re: Are there any examples of a pro returning to the ring after a brain injury incurred in the ring?

Posted: 30 Mar 2016, 14:23
by Junker
He pleaded guilty last year to 9 charges. Pretty mad stuff, firearms, threatening women and children etc. I think sentencing is in April. There were reports he could get as much as 50 years.

Re: Are there any examples of a pro returning to the ring after a brain injury incurred in the ring?

Posted: 30 Mar 2016, 14:25
by palooka
Junker wrote:He pleaded guilty last year to 9 charges. Pretty mad stuff, firearms, threatening women and children etc. I think sentencing is in April. There were reports he could get as much as 50 years.
If I were looking at 50 years I'd jump off a bridge.

Re: Are there any examples of a pro returning to the ring after a brain injury incurred in the ring?

Posted: 30 Mar 2016, 22:25
by davie
Hopefully we wont have to worry about whether he gets a license or not
because when he makes a full recovery, he realises it isn't worth the risk and does something else with his life.

Re: Are there any examples of a pro returning to the ring after a brain injury incurred in the ring?

Posted: 31 Mar 2016, 09:43
by gb
I think that Oscar Larios had suffered one before he fought Manny.

Re: Are there any examples of a pro returning to the ring after a brain injury incurred in the ring?

Posted: 31 Mar 2016, 09:49
by Rexob
Stuarty30 wrote:
Oiky wrote:
Stuarty30 wrote:
Ahh apologies :TU: Not sure about that but he's young an seems a bright enough boy so I'm sure he could do anything he wanted.
i know his brother dan is a bricklayer so nick might have some experience in brickwork but yeah he does seem like a clued up person so god bless and good luck in what ever he choses to do
His brother Dan is a journeyman isn't he?

61 fights at 23 years old thats going some to be fair and Ive never heard of him before.

Re: Are there any examples of a pro returning to the ring after a brain injury incurred in the ring?

Posted: 31 Mar 2016, 09:54
by Stuarty
Rexob wrote:
Stuarty30 wrote:
Oiky wrote: i know his brother dan is a bricklayer so nick might have some experience in brickwork but yeah he does seem like a clued up person so god bless and good luck in what ever he choses to do
His brother Dan is a journeyman isn't he?

61 fights at 23 years old thats going some to be fair and Ive never heard of him before.
Yeah he must love a scrap! I'd only heard of him because he was meant to fight my mate before he packed it in. He ended up fighting Kris Carslaw a couple years back too.

Re: Are there any examples of a pro returning to the ring after a brain injury incurred in the ring?

Posted: 31 Mar 2016, 10:04
by ttornado
Jermain Taylor
An MRI revealed the reason Taylor's short-term memory was misfiring: a minor subdural hematoma, or brain bleed, the primary cause of death in boxing. Taylor's case wasn't fatal, but the doctors gave him what felt like its own kind of death sentence. "They said with the type of concussion I had, you can never fight again -- ever," he says.

Re: Are there any examples of a pro returning to the ring after a brain injury incurred in the ring?

Posted: 31 Mar 2016, 10:18
by jamesmcdonnell
Junker wrote:He pleaded guilty last year to 9 charges. Pretty mad stuff, firearms, threatening women and children etc. I think sentencing is in April. There were reports he could get as much as 50 years.
There's some evidence to suggest that repeated concussions cause not only brain injuries, but changes in brain function. There's been a lot of high profile cases in the U.S of American footballers who develop wild mood swings and violent outbursts.

Taylor certainly didn't seem like a violent thug earlier in his career. Though of course, I don't have an intimate knowledge of him.

Re: Are there any examples of a pro returning to the ring after a brain injury incurred in the ring?

Posted: 31 Mar 2016, 14:16
by Oiky
Stuarty30 wrote:
Rexob wrote:
Stuarty30 wrote:
His brother Dan is a journeyman isn't he?

61 fights at 23 years old thats going some to be fair and Ive never heard of him before.
Yeah he must love a scrap! I'd only heard of him because he was meant to fight my mate before he packed it in. He ended up fighting Kris Carslaw a couple years back too.
definitely loves a scrap :box:

Re: Are there any examples of a pro returning to the ring after a brain injury incurred in the ring?

Posted: 01 Apr 2016, 10:14
by Tuan_Jim
Kid Akeem is the most infamous and horrifying example of this. Happened in Africa, naturally.