BoxRec

DannyMCR wrote:Khan

British ATG.

Others need to step up.

Killer Blow wrote:Fury at number one is a joke. He never even defended his belts. Both Frampton and Degale should be above him.

It's not a joke at all.

nitro5912 wrote:Fury hasn't fought in a year and is now banned
Khan has fought once in 2016

How can they be so high?

Because they have very strong records and it takes time for them to fall down the rankings when they are so proven.

nitro5912 wrote:How is Murray so high given he got battered by groves.

Because Groves is very good and losing to him isn't that bad.

Horse wrote:

Killer Blow wrote:Fury at number one is a joke. He never even defended his belts. Both Frampton and Degale should be above him.

It's not a joke at all.

Definitely a Fury fan.

cocobongo wrote:Normally don't grumble too much at these lists but few things on this one I don't agree with

I know Clev "beat" Brahmer but that performance doesn't warrant jumping 8 places I had him 1 down when Brahmer pulled out

I had Braehmer ahead by one as well, but Cleverly was probably the favourite to win at that stage.

Callum Smith hasn't beaten anyone as good as Braehmer yet and Haskins almost lost to Hall recently, so I thought he deserved to be above those two, considering the rest of his record as well.

cocobongo wrote:Eggington should not be above Bradley Skeete I know Horse will compare their two outings vs Gavin as the marker but Skeete absolutely stood Eggington on his head a few months ago

Skeete out boxed Eggington, but he ran away far too much. I think his performance is a little overrated.

Beating Gavin was enough for Eggington to re-enter the rankings. If Skeete had done anything worthwhile in the 8 months since he beat Eggington then he would still be ahead of him, but he didn't.

cocobongo wrote:Fury will need to drop should either or both Degale beat Jack and Frampton beat LSC again

I'm a big Khan fan but he's prob to high given his activity

Frampton will overtake him if he wins. DeGale has a good chance if he wins as well.

Khan will drop when those below him start beating decent opponents again.

Horse wrote:Any comments/criticisms of the British Top 30 P4P list are very welcome.

Genuine question. Have you ever changed the rankings after comments/criticisms?

Horse wrote:

garethhop wrote:How can Eggington be above Skeete given what the gulf in class between them which was shown earlier in the year?

Because Skeete has done very little since then and Eggington has beaten Gavin.

I also didn't rate Skeete's performance against Eggington as highly as most people did.

Perhaps you will have to rethink that now, given you now rate Eggington more highly, no?

keithmoonhangover wrote:

Horse wrote:Any comments/criticisms of the British Top 30 P4P list are very welcome.

Genuine question. Have you ever changed the rankings after comments/criticisms?

No

15. (23.) Nathan Cleverly
16. (15.) Callum Smith

I reckon Smith could fight Cleverly tomorrow at LHW, come in at 168lbs and probably stop him!

Frampton should be no1. The rest is a bit meh. Horses lists are usually pretty good but they're getting a bit tedious the last few months because of his stubbornness and unwillingness to move certain fighters who he favours. Step it up Horse

Horse wrote:

DannyMCR wrote:Khan

British ATG.

Others need to step up.

Now I know for certain you're a troll.

keirw wrote:I don't mind fury staying at number one, the top spot is there for the taking and its up to guys like Frampton, Degale, Brook etc to take it, not the other way around.

Good to see Eggington and Walsh re enter, but I do wonder why Haye was above them in the first place given the standard of his last 2 opponents.

I gave Haye the benefit of the doubt given his record.

Killer Blow wrote:Definitely a Fury fan.

He beat Klitschko. He deserves to be No. 1.

davie wrote:Perhaps you will have to rethink that now, given you now rate Eggington more highly, no?

No.

davie wrote:I reckon Smith could fight Cleverly tomorrow at LHW, come in at 168lbs and probably stop him!

I don't.

Horse wrote:

davie wrote:I reckon Smith could fight Cleverly tomorrow at LHW, come in at 168lbs and probably stop him!

I don't.

You're wrong

Horse wrote:

davie wrote:Perhaps you will have to rethink that now, given you now rate Eggington more highly, no?

No.

No
I mean
Yes
I mean
Ah, fornicate you

davie wrote:

Horse wrote:

davie wrote:Perhaps you will have to rethink that now, given you now rate Eggington more highly, no?

No.

No
I mean
Yes
I mean
Ah, eff you