Page 2 of 2

Re: How To Score A Pro Boxing Match

Posted: 29 Mar 2017, 12:24
by world ranked
I've never seen a round I couldn't give to someone. That 10-10 round scoring is bollocks.

Re: How To Score A Pro Boxing Match

Posted: 29 Mar 2017, 13:01
by punchoutsb
world ranked wrote:I've never seen a round I couldn't give to someone. That 10-10 round scoring is bollocks.
Same here. A 10-10 round is one where both fighters stand in their corners and don't move for 3 minutes.

Re: How To Score A Pro Boxing Match

Posted: 29 Mar 2017, 15:15
by fanman
world ranked wrote:I've never seen a round I couldn't give to someone. That 10-10 round scoring is bollocks.
.... hopkins taylor round 1? .... However i agree, find a winner for each round. Many fights are close and could go either way. If it goes 12 and there isnt dominance then its kind of a draw and just go with the ringside judges, doesnt matter, there can be a rematch.

Re: How To Score A Pro Boxing Match

Posted: 29 Mar 2017, 17:53
by Lennox
Stuarty30 wrote:I very seldom sit and write down what I think round for round. I just basically pick who I think was the better at the end of the round and keep score in my head then at the end I'll generally have an opinion on who's won. That's my prerogative as a fan though. I don't have a system I just pick what I like, what I feels working, who's pressuring, who's landed the more eye catching shots? It must be a hard job but some of the score cards we get seem to me to be beyond human error. Some of em are inexcusable.
Nothing wrong in that for fun but it is exactly how not to score a fight. YOU need to count and you need to really concentrate on exactly what is effective and what is not. I think if you did that you would get a different result.

Re: How To Score A Pro Boxing Match

Posted: 30 Mar 2017, 03:12
by Stuarty
Lennox wrote:
Stuarty30 wrote:I very seldom sit and write down what I think round for round. I just basically pick who I think was the better at the end of the round and keep score in my head then at the end I'll generally have an opinion on who's won. That's my prerogative as a fan though. I don't have a system I just pick what I like, what I feels working, who's pressuring, who's landed the more eye catching shots? It must be a hard job but some of the score cards we get seem to me to be beyond human error. Some of em are inexcusable.
Nothing wrong in that for fun but it is exactly how not to score a fight. YOU need to count and you need to really concentrate on exactly what is effective and what is not. I think if you did that you would get a different result.
I have done that before but not during a live fight. I'll rewatch it. I've got to say counting punches doesn't really mean much. You're never gonna see everything even watching on tv. It's a very subjective sport. It all comes down to preference a lot of the time.

Re: How To Score A Pro Boxing Match

Posted: 04 Apr 2017, 17:19
by world ranked
fanman wrote:
world ranked wrote:I've never seen a round I couldn't give to someone. That 10-10 round scoring is bollocks.
.... hopkins taylor round 1? .... However i agree, find a winner for each round. Many fights are close and could go either way. If it goes 12 and there isnt dominance then its kind of a draw and just go with the ringside judges, doesnt matter, there can be a rematch.
first fight or second one?