journeyman wrote:jamesmcdonnell wrote:You are being very presumtuous if you think my only reading about Jeffries is from here, and you are incorrect.
Jeffries was a huge man for his time, but I'm sorry, he wasn't as big as Lewis.
Sonny Liston WAS physically dwarfed by Ali, the crowd and Sonny himself were shocked by the sight, what is your definition of dwarfed? In boxing a height and weight difference of 3 inches and 10-15 lbs can be a hell of a lot.
The evidence shows that the same fighter can be like two different men when only weighing 10-15 lbs more, Tua, Lewis and Bowe all prove this point as at differing weights they fought entirely differently.
I think you are missing the point of this thread, we were discussing whether over a certain size heavyweights get worse rather than better, not whether 6'2" equals big or small, or whether Sonny liston was a 'big man' Of course all heavyweights over 200 lbs are going to be big men. I'm 6'3" and about 190 lbs, and yes Liston would have been physically much bigger than me, hell Johnny Nelson is bigger than me, I'm overweight and out of shape, that's not the point.
It would seem if you scrutinise the records of heavyweight champions, that bigger is not better, the fighters over 6'4" who were great heavyweights, is a very small list. Perhaps that will change in time, but I doubt it. After all, there were men as big as Lewis in boxing 50 years ago, and they were invariably below his class.
Lewis and Bowe are significantly naturally larger men than Liston, Ali, Jeffries et al. That is my point. And the difference is proven when you look at their earliest recorded weights.
i may well be being presumptuous but i can only go on what you write and how you respond to other posts - your own posts do not display much knowledge of jim jeffries therefore that leads me to think you have little knowledge of the man - if you're trying to hide your knowledge, congratulations on a job well done.
and in actual fact, you are the one who keeps comparing fighters to lewis. i actually think you believe lewis to be a much bigger man than he actually is - i've been in the same room as lewis and george foreman and can assure you there is very little difference in size between the two men. that, tho, is a moot point.
there has been a history of 'super' heavies and where you draw the line in defining them is at the centre of this - you obviously take lewis and bowe at 6'5" to be super-heavies, but foreman and jeffries at 6'4" are not - i say that's stupid and am merely highlighting that point for you - the fact that you've yet to respond to my posts with anything approaching a valid contradiction leads me to believe that you have none.
the issue that bennie raises is that the big guys are all out of shape and essentially lesser calibre fighters - my point has always been that essentially i agree with that, but if it's really true then smaller guys with better stamina and technique will prove it by beating the big fellas. they haven't so straightaway life teaches us that bennie's point is an over-simplification.
truth is, bigger is better right now, otherwise a smaller guy would be hw king. and he isn't.
btw, i happen to agree with you about toney and have posted the same repeatedly on this and other sites.
Hang on, your lambasting me for knowing nothing, and yet your lumping Jeffries and Liston in with Foreman. Jeffries was 6'2 not 6'4" Don't mean to be petty, but tracers work both ways. If you're going to criticise me for lack of knowledge, then you should at least get the fundamentals right. Jeffries is listed at between 6'2" and 6'2 1/2 everywhere I've ever read.
It seems we are going nowhere with this, it all comes down to what you consider a 'significant' size difference. I'm willing to concede that Foreman and Lewis are in the same ball park, but not Liston and Jeffries.
As for the creation of a super heavy division, I would be against it for one simple reason, there simply isn't a big enough talent pool as it is, and a super heavyweight division would be a dire division filled with lumbering out of shape apeths gasping for air, dismal...
My major point all along is that really big men, and for me I think that once you get over 6'4" and about 235 lbs you are entering different territory because there are physiological changes which occur in big men to do with reflexes and the weight of the skelton and the like which affect flexibility and agility. My point is that Lewis is remarkable in being pretty agile and fast as well as possessing awesome power at over 240 lbs. Whilst Foreman was a very efficient fighting machine, he didn't have the same sort of agility Lewis had, nor the handspeed. Bowe too had phenomenal handspeed for a huge man, but nothing like the defensive prowess or footwork Lewis had.
As they say, a good bigun beats a good littlun, and a size difference can be very hard to overcome. The little guy needs to be signicantly better than the big guy to overcome those advantages. In the case of Vitali I think he has enough flaws to be overcome by Toney, though Toney may be a little too old, we shall see. He sure needs to stop eating for a while. He looked like Idi Amin in those photographs!
Here's one of The boilermaker in his prime, a tremendous physical specimen, and doesn't he look like a modern fighter with that physique, quite remarkable when you consider there was no weight training or protein shakes/steroids back then, the guy must have been an amazing natural athelete.
PERSONAL DATA
Jeffries was born on April 15, 1875 at Carroll, Ohio. He was the son of Alexis Jeffries, a farmer and minister, and Rebecca Boyer Jeffries. Jim had four brothers and three sisters. In 1881, the family moved to Los Angeles.
Jeffries was a clean-cut man of high moral and ethical standards and fair to all people.
He has been branded incorrectly as a racist because he came out of retirement to fight Jack Johnson and was labeled as the "Great White Hope" by sportswriters. It is often pointed out that he only fought White contenders for the title. But, all the champions at that time did so.
Even Jack Johnson drew the "color line" when he became Champion. The only black man he fought for the title was Jim Johnson, a mediocre boxer, when he was in Europe and needed funds.
As a youth, Jim became involved with wrestling and boxing but put off his career at the request of his mother and father.
Jeffries stood 6-2 1/2 in his fighting prime and in top condition weighed between 206-227 lbs. When not in top condition, Jeffries weighed between 250-280 lbs.
His fight manager was William Brady. There was never a legal contract between the men, simply a handshake. Brady said Jeffries' word was better than a contract.
His trainer for most of his career was Billy Delaney.
Jeffries could run 100 yards in a little more than ten seconds. He could high jump over six feet. Blessed with abnormal physical strength, he was considered a natural phenomenon.
A lover of hunting, he once killed a large deer and carried it on his shoulders nine miles to camp without stopping to rest. Friends who accompanied him had difficulty keeping up with him on the jaunt home.
He married in 1904. He and his wife, Freida, had one daughter, Mary.
In his later years, he trained a few boxers and promoted some fights at Jeffries' Barn.
He was well-liked, spent time with the local people, attended gatherings, and contributed much to his community.
Jeff died in his sleep on March 3, 1953 at Burbank, California.
http://www.cyberboxingzone.com/boxing/jeffries.htm
By way of comparison....
http://www.ibhof.com/ibhftape.htm