Page 2 of 2

Re: Interesting amateur results Shawn Porter Beat Usyk

Posted: 02 Jun 2020, 13:15
by Greg Nicholas
orbtastic wrote: 28 May 2020, 10:11 I know Brahmer beat Hatton by stoppage in the ams. I'm assuming down at light welter.
Welter. Rick shouldn't of moved up. Big fast hard hitting rangey southpaw. Dropped him

Re: Interesting amateur results Shawn Porter Beat Usyk

Posted: 02 Jun 2020, 13:16
by Greg Nicholas
jameswilson wrote: 02 Jun 2020, 09:14 Probably fairly well known but Gerald McClellan beat Roy Jones Jr.
Best amateur fight Emanuel Steward ever saw. Total war they say. 1988 Golden Gloves.

Re: Interesting amateur results Shawn Porter Beat Usyk

Posted: 02 Jun 2020, 15:09
by Deserter
Greg Nicholas wrote: 02 Jun 2020, 13:16
jameswilson wrote: 02 Jun 2020, 09:14 Probably fairly well known but Gerald McClellan beat Roy Jones Jr.
Best amateur fight Emanuel Steward ever saw. Total war they say. 1988 Golden Gloves.
Great breakdown of it here by John Scully:
http://www.spam.com/news/article18324.html

Re: Interesting amateur results Shawn Porter Beat Usyk

Posted: 02 Jun 2020, 16:26
by Cyclops
Deserter wrote: 02 Jun 2020, 15:09
Greg Nicholas wrote: 02 Jun 2020, 13:16

Best amateur fight Emanuel Steward ever saw. Total war they say. 1988 Golden Gloves.
Great breakdown of it here by John Scully:
http://www.spam.com/news/article18324.html
It wasn't filmed, then?

Re: Interesting amateur results Shawn Porter Beat Usyk

Posted: 02 Jun 2020, 21:27
by Greg Nicholas
Cyclops wrote: 02 Jun 2020, 16:26
Deserter wrote: 02 Jun 2020, 15:09

Great breakdown of it here by John Scully:
http://www.spam.com/news/article18324.html
It wasn't filmed, then?
Steward before he died said he had film of it!

Re: Interesting amateur results Shawn Porter Beat Usyk

Posted: 03 Jun 2020, 03:18
by dapug
Jason Rowland beat Robin Reid

Re: Interesting amateur results Shawn Porter Beat Usyk

Posted: 03 Jun 2020, 03:29
by bripez
I once read about a thread in here involving Paul Smith when he used to post

Apparently he was arguing with someone (who’da thought eh?) who then said that they beat Smith 4 times as an amateur

After an exchange of pm’s it then came out that it was true - it must be years old but it would be good if someone could find the thread

Re: Interesting amateur results Shawn Porter Beat Usyk

Posted: 03 Jun 2020, 05:48
by Ketchel
If I remember right Damaen Kelly beat Paul Ingle.

Wayne McCullough stopped Arturo Gatti in a round.

Re: Interesting amateur results Shawn Porter Beat Usyk

Posted: 03 Jun 2020, 05:51
by Deserter
Shhhh wrote: 03 Jun 2020, 05:24
Deserter wrote: 02 Jun 2020, 15:09

Great breakdown of it here by John Scully:
http://www.spam.com/news/article18324.html
Nothing there. Also John scullly is obsessed with Roy Jones. That’s all he talks about. And how he used to spar with him and how amazing he was. He used to write some stuff in Boxing Monthly. Every time he use to slip in Roy Jones and the fact he sparred with him. It was a bit gay
Boxrec must have an issue with Fight hype to change that link to 'spam', so reprinting here for those who are interested. Can't comment on your views of Scully, but I'm sure others will find this a good read as I did:

As told by John Scully - I remember when Roy Jones and Gerald McClennan fought, and to be honest with you, there are very few people in the world who can say they were actually there, and the ones that were there, only about half of them were watching it. They had 3 rings going at the same time and I'm guessing less than 100 people on the face of the earth even saw that fight. Gerald won the fight; 3-2 split! Roy had won nationals two years in a row and he was going for his third, and he was looking good up until the semifinals and he lost to Gerald. I remember something interesting from that fight. About 3 weeks later after the fight, all of us was at Sugar Ray Leonard's training camp before the Olympic Trials. Gerald was there, Roy was there, I was there; a lot of the top amateurs was there. I remember specifically Gerald wouldn't spar because he said his jaw was still messed up from his fight with Roy. That always stayed with me. He couldn't spar and he didn't spar anybody that whole camp because his jaw was messed up from the fight.

It was a great fight though and the decision was legitimate. It was a good back and forth fight. A lot of people get on Roy about boxing too much and being careful, but when Roy wanted to dig down and fight, he could. I remember I was fighting that day. I was gonna fight like two fights later and I was supposed to be loosening up, but the fight was so good. Hell, I remember I had my gloves on and was suited up, but I actually sat there and watched that fight because it was so good. I remember Roy was on the ropes for a lot of the fight, especially in the 2nd round. Gerald had him pinned to the ropes, but Roy was giving just as much as he got off the ropes. He was bombing Gerald with combinations. It was definitely...I would say in my life, it was probably...certainly top 5 amateur fights I've ever seen; maybe even top 3. It was a war. Anybody that was there will tell you that it was a fight. Roy didn't box. Roy was a great boxer as an amateur. Speed was his thing, just like as a pro. I don't know if Gerald made him fight or if he chose to fight, but he fought.

The thing that stood out to me about that fight is the way Roy would explode off of the ropes. I'm talking it looked like 6, 7, 8, or 9 shots...bang, bang, bang, bang, bang...right off the ropes. Gerald was right there with him, it's just Roy's explosiveness and speed was more apparent than Gerald's at the time. And I tell you what gets lost over the years. No one ever mentions this because they probably don't realize it or it never even occurs to them, but Gerald actually lost the next day to Ray McElroy. I'm assuming Ray was a good fighter because he had beaten Gerald before, but Ray had actually lost to Roy twice. So it's kind of funny that Roy beat Ray, Ray beat Gerald, and Gerald beat Roy. But I'm sure that fight with Roy took something out of him because it should have been the finals in terms of the level of competition that it was and level of excitement. It was definitely a war.

Everyone wanted to see Roy and Gerald fight as pros and if they would have fought, honestly, you know I love Gerald, but I think Roy is one of the smartest fighters out there and he knows how to beat a style. He's not trying to impress people and show his toughness. I gotta tell a quick little side bar that would illustrate exactly what I mean, and I always tell this story about Roy Jones because it illustrates his mentality. If you remember when Terry Norris was on a knockout spree for awhile in the early 90's. Terry fought Simon Brown and he went for the knockout and Simon decimated him. That was a vicious knockout. Simon worked Terry Norris. What was impressive is Terry Norris came back in the rematch and put on a boxing display; to me, an all-time great boxing display. He toyed with Simon in the rematch. I was excited about it because I love to see fighters come back from a loss and beat the guy who beat 'em, especially when they had to make great adjustments in the rematch.

So the next day, we were in training camp in New Jersey and Roy was out there. I can tell you it must've been '94 because Roy was getting ready to fight Thomas Tate. I went to Roy the next day and I say, "Wow, that was crazy. Did you see the fight last night?" I'll never forget, his exact words on cue was, "I wouldn't have had to fight Simon Brown twice because I know how to beat him." That always stuck with me. He never would have fell into the trap of trying to knock Simon out or anything like that. He would have beat Simon the way that Terry did the second time. He would have done that the first time and I'll never forget that. That was his exact words. If Roy and Gerald would have fought as pros, Roy would have never looked to make this a war or fan-friendly or anything. The name of the game is win. People gotta realize, even though it was early in his career, Gerald got beat early by some good technical boxers in Dennis Milton and Ralph Ward; two fights in a row. The thing about those guys were they had boxing ability, and very few people had boxing ability like Roy. When he wanted to get on his toes and not get hit, he wasn't going to get hit. So for my money, I would have to go with Roy by decision as a pro.

Re: Interesting amateur results Shawn Porter Beat Usyk

Posted: 03 Jun 2020, 05:59
by Deserter
Shhhh wrote: 03 Jun 2020, 05:54
Deserter wrote: 03 Jun 2020, 05:51
Boxrec must have an issue with Fight hype to change that link to 'spam', so reprinting here for those who are interested. Can't comment on your views of Scully, but I'm sure others will find this a good read as I did:

As told by John Scully - I remember when Roy Jones and Gerald McClennan fought, and to be honest with you, there are very few people in the world who can say they were actually there, and the ones that were there, only about half of them were watching it. They had 3 rings going at the same time and I'm guessing less than 100 people on the face of the earth even saw that fight. Gerald won the fight; 3-2 split! Roy had won nationals two years in a row and he was going for his third, and he was looking good up until the semifinals and he lost to Gerald. I remember something interesting from that fight. About 3 weeks later after the fight, all of us was at Sugar Ray Leonard's training camp before the Olympic Trials. Gerald was there, Roy was there, I was there; a lot of the top amateurs was there. I remember specifically Gerald wouldn't spar because he said his jaw was still messed up from his fight with Roy. That always stayed with me. He couldn't spar and he didn't spar anybody that whole camp because his jaw was messed up from the fight.

It was a great fight though and the decision was legitimate. It was a good back and forth fight. A lot of people get on Roy about boxing too much and being careful, but when Roy wanted to dig down and fight, he could. I remember I was fighting that day. I was gonna fight like two fights later and I was supposed to be loosening up, but the fight was so good. Hell, I remember I had my gloves on and was suited up, but I actually sat there and watched that fight because it was so good. I remember Roy was on the ropes for a lot of the fight, especially in the 2nd round. Gerald had him pinned to the ropes, but Roy was giving just as much as he got off the ropes. He was bombing Gerald with combinations. It was definitely...I would say in my life, it was probably...certainly top 5 amateur fights I've ever seen; maybe even top 3. It was a war. Anybody that was there will tell you that it was a fight. Roy didn't box. Roy was a great boxer as an amateur. Speed was his thing, just like as a pro. I don't know if Gerald made him fight or if he chose to fight, but he fought.

The thing that stood out to me about that fight is the way Roy would explode off of the ropes. I'm talking it looked like 6, 7, 8, or 9 shots...bang, bang, bang, bang, bang...right off the ropes. Gerald was right there with him, it's just Roy's explosiveness and speed was more apparent than Gerald's at the time. And I tell you what gets lost over the years. No one ever mentions this because they probably don't realize it or it never even occurs to them, but Gerald actually lost the next day to Ray McElroy. I'm assuming Ray was a good fighter because he had beaten Gerald before, but Ray had actually lost to Roy twice. So it's kind of funny that Roy beat Ray, Ray beat Gerald, and Gerald beat Roy. But I'm sure that fight with Roy took something out of him because it should have been the finals in terms of the level of competition that it was and level of excitement. It was definitely a war.

Everyone wanted to see Roy and Gerald fight as pros and if they would have fought, honestly, you know I love Gerald, but I think Roy is one of the smartest fighters out there and he knows how to beat a style. He's not trying to impress people and show his toughness. I gotta tell a quick little side bar that would illustrate exactly what I mean, and I always tell this story about Roy Jones because it illustrates his mentality. If you remember when Terry Norris was on a knockout spree for awhile in the early 90's. Terry fought Simon Brown and he went for the knockout and Simon decimated him. That was a vicious knockout. Simon worked Terry Norris. What was impressive is Terry Norris came back in the rematch and put on a boxing display; to me, an all-time great boxing display. He toyed with Simon in the rematch. I was excited about it because I love to see fighters come back from a loss and beat the guy who beat 'em, especially when they had to make great adjustments in the rematch.

So the next day, we were in training camp in New Jersey and Roy was out there. I can tell you it must've been '94 because Roy was getting ready to fight Thomas Tate. I went to Roy the next day and I say, "Wow, that was crazy. Did you see the fight last night?" I'll never forget, his exact words on cue was, "I wouldn't have had to fight Simon Brown twice because I know how to beat him." That always stuck with me. He never would have fell into the trap of trying to knock Simon out or anything like that. He would have beat Simon the way that Terry did the second time. He would have done that the first time and I'll never forget that. That was his exact words. If Roy and Gerald would have fought as pros, Roy would have never looked to make this a war or fan-friendly or anything. The name of the game is win. People gotta realize, even though it was early in his career, Gerald got beat early by some good technical boxers in Dennis Milton and Ralph Ward; two fights in a row. The thing about those guys were they had boxing ability, and very few people had boxing ability like Roy. When he wanted to get on his toes and not get hit, he wasn't going to get hit. So for my money, I would have to go with Roy by decision as a pro.
Thanks. The usual John scully Roy Jones blow jobbing article then
Don't be such a prick mate. You'd already made your point, move on and let others enjoy the read if they want.

Re: Interesting amateur results Shawn Porter Beat Usyk

Posted: 03 Jun 2020, 06:07
by Deserter
Shhhh wrote: 03 Jun 2020, 06:05
Deserter wrote: 03 Jun 2020, 05:59
Don't be such a prick mate. You'd already made your point, move on and let others enjoy the read if they want.
Fuk me that’s a bit aggressive I said thank you. Is lockdown gettin to ya? 😂😂😂
I took the "thanks" to be a highly sarcastic one given what you followed it with. If that wasn't the intention then apologies :TU:

Re: Interesting amateur results Shawn Porter Beat Usyk

Posted: 03 Jun 2020, 06:12
by Deserter
Shhhh wrote: 03 Jun 2020, 06:09
Deserter wrote: 03 Jun 2020, 06:07
I took the "thanks" to be a highly sarcastic one given what you followed it with. If that wasn't the intention then apologies :TU:
Sorry I meant thanks for making the effort of copying it :TU: no idea why boxrec blocked the URL I was a bit suspicious to see a boxing site called spam.com 😂 It’s a shame there’s not that fight on video.
Now I feel really bad... :doh: :lol:

Re: Interesting amateur results Shawn Porter Beat Usyk

Posted: 03 Jun 2020, 16:48
by ERIC GUY
Greg Nicholas wrote: 02 Jun 2020, 21:27
Cyclops wrote: 02 Jun 2020, 16:26
It wasn't filmed, then?
Steward before he died said he had film of it!
yes it was filmed

Re: Interesting amateur results Shawn Porter Beat Usyk

Posted: 04 Jun 2020, 00:20
by Greg Nicholas
ERIC GUY wrote: 03 Jun 2020, 16:48
Greg Nicholas wrote: 02 Jun 2020, 21:27
Steward before he died said he had film of it!
yes it was filmed
Where is it!!

Re: Interesting amateur results Shawn Porter Beat Usyk

Posted: 05 Jun 2020, 13:52
by dookus
Shhhh wrote: 03 Jun 2020, 06:14
Deserter wrote: 03 Jun 2020, 06:12
Now I feel really bad... :doh: :lol:
Lol 😂 no worries....l didn’t make myself clear. I have bit of an anti scully issue lol 😂 I was a bit hurt but I’m well over that now 😀TBH lockdown is severely effecting me.... my depression is getting out of control....
Churchill (though it sounds like a boxing quote): "when you're going through hell, keep going"

Re: Interesting amateur results Shawn Porter Beat Usyk

Posted: 05 Jun 2020, 15:24
by ERIC GUY
Greg Nicholas wrote: 04 Jun 2020, 00:20
ERIC GUY wrote: 03 Jun 2020, 16:48
yes it was filmed
Where is it!!
I dont know, would people pay for it

Re: Interesting amateur results Shawn Porter Beat Usyk

Posted: 06 Jun 2020, 01:56
by Greg Nicholas
ERIC GUY wrote: 05 Jun 2020, 15:24
Greg Nicholas wrote: 04 Jun 2020, 00:20

Where is it!!
I dont know, would people pay for it
100%

Re: Interesting amateur results Shawn Porter Beat Usyk

Posted: 03 Nov 2020, 18:25
by ICEMAN JOHN SCULLY
margaret thatcher wrote: 28 May 2020, 11:43 Sven '34 tried, 34 failed' Ottke beat Chris Byrd
Ottke also beat Michael Moorer

Re: Interesting amateur results Shawn Porter Beat Usyk

Posted: 03 Nov 2020, 19:08
by littlepug
ICEMAN JOHN SCULLY wrote: 03 Nov 2020, 18:25
margaret thatcher wrote: 28 May 2020, 11:43 Sven '34 tried, 34 failed' Ottke beat Chris Byrd
Ottke also beat Michael Moorer
Nice result for Ottke, don’t know what Moorer did in the ams but imagine he was a handful

Re: Interesting amateur results Shawn Porter Beat Usyk

Posted: 03 Nov 2020, 21:14
by ICEMAN JOHN SCULLY
Michael was a top amateur....won the U.S. Championships at 156 in 1986

Re: Interesting amateur results Shawn Porter Beat Usyk

Posted: 03 Nov 2020, 22:51
by coghaugen11
Mark Breland beat Chris Eubank.