Page 2 of 2

Posted: 07 Apr 2006, 13:10
by Arsenal
Although I don't rate Collins as one of the best and in his prime I think Benn beats him, I don't think Benn would have stopped him. Collins was only knocked down once I think. He only lost to 3 great boxers in McCallum, Johnson and Kalambay but thats why I don't rate him highly. He beat a past it Benn and Eubank and when he stepped up to people who were in or near their primes (the 3 above) he lost. I don't think he ever beat a great fighter in thier prime and for that reason I wouldn't have him as the top SM/

Posted: 07 Apr 2006, 13:13
by JC
knockout wrote:
J wrote:Marcel cerdan deserves a mention.
yes he does, but at what weight... the guy was a menace from flyweight to heavyweight :TU:
I think you're thinking of Georges Carpentier there knockout.

Posted: 07 Apr 2006, 13:20
by knockout
J-C wrote:
knockout wrote:
J wrote:Marcel cerdan deserves a mention.
yes he does, but at what weight... the guy was a menace from flyweight to heavyweight :TU:
I think you're thinking of Georges Carpentier there knockout.
:oops: :oops: yes i am!!!!!