Page 2 of 4

Posted: 22 May 2006, 03:40
by tigerpomfret
Joe Bugner had everything,and did sod all really,i know danny got his limitations,but the guy got a heart,quiet,gentle guy,fairytails do come true,it would only take 1 punch ,perhaps danny should throw the skelton fight,or put up an awful desplay,THEN he could well be given his title chanceas a walkover,it only takes 1 punch.

Posted: 22 May 2006, 05:20
by nickd
I keep saying it, but Williams is just not that good. He is way overrated by British boxing fans. The guy is a domestic level Heavyweight who has failed at European and World level.

Posted: 22 May 2006, 05:35
by Lorn
Danny as a person I have a lot of time for. As a boxer he went in the S E divs 3 times and never won them , the clues are their if you look.

Posted: 22 May 2006, 05:52
by silkov
tigerpomfret wrote:Joe Bugner had everything,and did sod all really,i know danny got his limitations,but the guy got a heart,quiet,gentle guy,fairytails do come true,it would only take 1 punch ,perhaps danny should throw the skelton fight,or put up an awful desplay,THEN he could well be given his title chanceas a walkover,it only takes 1 punch.
Bugner did a darn sight more than Danny has or is likely to do... I can't see Williams going 12 rounds with Joe Frazier, Ali, Lyle etc....

Posted: 22 May 2006, 06:03
by jamesmcdonnell
Well, he couldn't go 12 with Vitali, so I reckon that's a good call. That fight was like Foreman v Frazier with Ali in the role of Frazier.

Posted: 22 May 2006, 07:56
by Max Molyneux
nickd wrote:I keep saying it, but Williams is just not that good. He is way overrated by British boxing fans. The guy is a domestic level Heavyweight who has failed at European and World level.
Who can you rate at Euro level past him except for Krasniqi and Samil Sam since he beat him?

Virchis couldn't even beat Sprott convincingly yet is EBU mandatory now. :roll:

Posted: 22 May 2006, 08:13
by nickd
Max Molyneux wrote:
nickd wrote:I keep saying it, but Williams is just not that good. He is way overrated by British boxing fans. The guy is a domestic level Heavyweight who has failed at European and World level.
Who can you rate at Euro level past him except for Krasniqi and Samil Sam since he beat him?

Virchis couldn't even beat Sprott convincingly yet is EBU mandatory now. :roll:
Well his record doesn't lie and he has never won the European title he was hammered in 6 rounds by Sam. Until he beats someone at that level then he is not European title standard simple as that as far as I am concerned. Never mind ifs and buts he has to beat the top European guys to be considered in that class and that is something he has never done.

Posted: 22 May 2006, 08:24
by Max Molyneux
nickd wrote:
Max Molyneux wrote:
nickd wrote:I keep saying it, but Williams is just not that good. He is way overrated by British boxing fans. The guy is a domestic level Heavyweight who has failed at European and World level.
Who can you rate at Euro level past him except for Krasniqi and Samil Sam since he beat him?

Virchis couldn't even beat Sprott convincingly yet is EBU mandatory now. :roll:
Well his record doesn't lie and he has never won the European title he was hammered in 6 rounds by Sam. Until he beats someone at that level then he is not European title standard simple as that as far as I am concerned. Never mind ifs and buts he has to beat the top European guys to be considered in that class and that is something he has never done.
Well he's Ko'ed Sprott Twice and Virchis got a gift.

Seriously out of the EBU rating Krasniqi and Samil Sam can only be rated past him.

HEAVYWEIGHTS (over 90,719 kg)

Champ: Paolo VIDOZ (IT) October 1 , 2005
Chall.: Vladimir VIIRCHIS (UA/DE)

EU: Michael SPROTT (GB) EU Champion

Contenders:
1 Luan KRASNIQI (DE)
2 Sinan SAMIL SAM (TR/DE)
3 Danny WILLIAMS (GB)
4 Matt SKELTON (GB)
5 Henry AKINWANDE (GB/AT)
6 Michael SPROTT (GB) EU Champion
7 Alexander DIMITRENKO (UA/DE)
8 Audley HARRISON (GB)
9 Timo HOFFMANN (DE/AT)
10 Roman GREENBERG (IL)
11 Oleg PLATOV (UA/BE)
12 Taras BIDENKO (UA/DE)
13 Richel HERSISIA (NL)
14 Dennis BAKHTOV (RU)
15 Egon ROTH (DE)
16 Rene DETTWEILER (DE/AT)
17 Cengiz KOC (DE/AT)
18 Denis BOYTSOV (RU/DE)
19 Alexey MAZIKIN (UA/DE)


INELIGIBLE

Nikolay VALOUEV (RU/AT) WBA INELIGIBLE
Tomasz BONIN (PL)
Wladimir KLITSCHKO (UA/AT) IBF - WBO

Except for the world title holders and top two and none of them can be favoured or rated past him so really he is European class.

Posted: 22 May 2006, 08:30
by silkov
Its just silly to say that Williams is not Europeon class... Benn and Eubank never fought for the Europeon title... does that mean they weren't Europeon class?...

Posted: 22 May 2006, 09:07
by jamesmcdonnell
Akinwande would probably beat Williams, even at his age.

That's a weak argument, Benn and Eubank were world title holders so obviously were European level.

Williams is European level, but not quite ever the best in Europe. There's the difference.

Eubank and Benn proved they were world class operators.

Posted: 22 May 2006, 09:14
by Max Molyneux
Akinwande would probably beat Williams, even at his age.
By holding him to death? :lol:

Posted: 22 May 2006, 09:18
by jamesmcdonnell
Akinwande was a very good stick and mover, he held like buggery against Lewis because he was mortified of getting sparked out.

Posted: 22 May 2006, 09:21
by Max Molyneux
Mc Call already sparked him out for Lewis. :TU:

Posted: 22 May 2006, 09:25
by jamesmcdonnell
McCall is one guy I would never want to put Williams in with, he would just have smiled when Danny landed and then fired back with his own, bye bye!

Posted: 22 May 2006, 09:26
by Max Molyneux
What about Mc Call when he was suffering and on drugs though?

Both have good chins and can punch. :TU:

Posted: 22 May 2006, 09:28
by nickd
Stick up for Williams all you like guys but fact is he has won a British title and nothing more than that. Yes he beat Tyson but even McBride managed to do that although granted not as emphatically as Williams did but McBride was stopped by Michael Murray! Thats area title level!

Williams is a good domestic operator and nothing more than that.

Posted: 22 May 2006, 09:29
by jamesmcdonnell
Max Molyneux wrote:What about Mc Call when he was suffering and on drugs though?

Both have good chins and can punch. :TU:
McCall's chin is in a class of it's own, I don't think I ever saw a heavyweight who could take a punch like McCall, not in my lifetime. Mercer was pretty close, but McCall never even blinked when Lewis was assaulting him with the big guns.

Posted: 22 May 2006, 09:35
by silkov
I don't see what your problem with Danny is, he's aiming for higher things than the Euro title... the title itself doesn't mean much now, I'm very pleased to see the likes of Sprott, Skelton and Williams fighting for the British title and bringing some life back to the domestic scene... give Danny some credit, he's been in some decent fights and brought interest back to the heavies here... there have actually been articles in the dailys!. If he beats Skelton again he deserves a shot at one of the title holders, why not, ....none of the title holders are so good that Danny hasn't got a chance...

Posted: 22 May 2006, 09:39
by nickd
silkov wrote:I don't see what your problem with Danny is, he's aiming for higher things than the Euro title... the title itself doesn't mean much now, I'm very pleased to see the likes of Sprott, Skelton and Williams fighting for the British title and bringing some life back to the domestic scene... give Danny some credit, he's been in some decent fights and brought interest back to the heavies here... there have actually been articles in the dailys!. If he beats Skelton again he deserves a shot at one of the title holders, why not, ....none of the title holders are so good that Danny hasn't got a chance...
I dont have a problem with him, I just dont think he's as good as a lot of people like to make out. I don't think he's remotely world class. Fair play to him for striving for world titles but someone even suggested he might beat Valuev I really dont see that happening and Valuev isn't particularly great. Good luck to Williams I am just realistic about his limitations.

Posted: 22 May 2006, 09:42
by Max Molyneux
Danny's more skilled than Valuev.

Shifts enough weight and Valuev will lose but would probably get robbed on the cards like Ruiz and Donald. :evil:

Posted: 22 May 2006, 09:58
by nickd
Max Molyneux wrote:Danny's more skilled than Valuev.

Shifts enough weight and Valuev will lose but would probably get robbed on the cards like Ruiz and Donald. :evil:
Valuev doesn't have a lot of skill but Williams already showed against Klitschko he has no idea how to fight a guy much bigger than him simply plodding forward eating jabs and straight rights. Granted Valuev is not as good as Klitschko but he's even bigger. If it ever happens I see Williams losing a wide decision. He's just too immobile to beat a guy that big, Donald did well against Valuev using speed and mobility, there are hippos more mobile than Williams!

As I said before good luck to him but I think Valuev beats him handily.

Posted: 22 May 2006, 15:23
by harrygreb
the poster who mentioned joe bugner was correct. he did have plenty going for him but just didnt produce when it was really needed. excellent european champ when that crown was something worth fighting for, but the level of opposition wasnt great in europe at that time, so its no surprise that bugner ruled like a king.

SILKOV i wouldnt bug you so much if you actually read peoples posts accurately before replying to them. youve done it with me and now youre doing it with other posters. i ask you, please read the posts or it just looks like you are in here for a petty argument

Posted: 22 May 2006, 15:57
by silkov
harrygreb wrote:the poster who mentioned joe bugner was correct. he did have plenty going for him but just didnt produce when it was really needed. excellent european champ when that crown was something worth fighting for, but the level of opposition wasnt great in europe at that time, so its no surprise that bugner ruled like a king.

SILKOV i wouldnt bug you so much if you actually read peoples posts accurately before replying to them. youve done it with me and now youre doing it with other posters. i ask you, please read the posts or it just looks like you are in here for a petty argument
Who am I arguing with?... why don't you try coming on here with some serious boxing views and arguments rather than just talking crap to me all the time and following me around like some stray dog... have you no shame...

Posted: 22 May 2006, 16:27
by Max Molyneux
nickd wrote:
Max Molyneux wrote:Danny's more skilled than Valuev.

Shifts enough weight and Valuev will lose but would probably get robbed on the cards like Ruiz and Donald. :evil:
Valuev doesn't have a lot of skill but Williams already showed against Klitschko he has no idea how to fight a guy much bigger than him simply plodding forward eating jabs and straight rights. Granted Valuev is not as good as Klitschko but he's even bigger. If it ever happens I see Williams losing a wide decision. He's just too immobile to beat a guy that big, Donald did well against Valuev using speed and mobility, there are hippos more mobile than Williams!

As I said before good luck to him but I think Valuev beats him handily.
Vitali was far better than Valuev.

He's slower than Vitali and wouldn't throw enough combinations to wobble Williams like Vitali did.

Plus Danny hits harder than the guys Valuev fought.

Posted: 22 May 2006, 16:34
by nickd
Max Molyneux wrote:
nickd wrote:
Max Molyneux wrote:Danny's more skilled than Valuev.

Shifts enough weight and Valuev will lose but would probably get robbed on the cards like Ruiz and Donald. :evil:
Valuev doesn't have a lot of skill but Williams already showed against Klitschko he has no idea how to fight a guy much bigger than him simply plodding forward eating jabs and straight rights. Granted Valuev is not as good as Klitschko but he's even bigger. If it ever happens I see Williams losing a wide decision. He's just too immobile to beat a guy that big, Donald did well against Valuev using speed and mobility, there are hippos more mobile than Williams!

As I said before good luck to him but I think Valuev beats him handily.
Vitali was far better than Valuev.

He's slower than Vitali and wouldn't throw enough combinations to wobble Williams like Vitali did.

Plus Danny hits harder than the guys Valuev fought.
Combinations? Klitschko was just throwing single shots and 1-2s all night.

You're clutching at straws, Valuev at least has a win at world level over Ruiz whether you agreed with the decision or not. Williams has not beaten anyone close to Ruiz's level. And dont say Tyson.