BoxRec

Grant wrote:yep 21 seems like the right spot. I heard he made a million dollars from the Shane Mosley fight. Why do you think that he still fights?

If he could afford it I would love to read about him in 20 years time having settled down and taking it easy, but somehow..................

Whatever he made from the Mosely fight he spent on a fairly well publicised cocaine habit

should we make this a monthly thing? like the pommy's do over in their forum

thunderfromdownunder wrote:should we make this a monthly thing? like the pommy's do over in their forum

Not a bad idea but I'm not sure if there are really enough fighters / fights between our top guys to make it worth while...

Perhaps a p4p list more like the one sock runs on the current scene would be better?

I assume you are putting your hand up to run it... :)

I think a lot of you must of been smoking re-jigging your lists and dropping Vic Darchinyan down to three.

He is easily our best p4p fighter. I cant believe this bullshit where the guy loses one fight and justs gets written off by just about everyone.

Anyone that Mundine fights of any quality he loses to, and Katsidis although he is tough, will get KO'd against quality opposition. The philipino that he last fought was ranked over 50 in the world and was hitting Katsidis constantly! I see that certain individuals are calling out Manny Pacquio for Katsidis!!! PLEASE!!!

Vic Darchinyan is the undisputed P4P australian fighter, I think he will show the world this in his next few fights.

Vic Darchinyan is the undisputed P4P australian fighter, I think he will show the world this in his next few fights.

LOL then Victor Oganov is the super-duper undisputed P4P Aus fighter ever!
Put that in ya undies and smoke it!

xxl wrote:Vic Darchinyan is the undisputed P4P australian fighter, I think he will show the world this in his next few fights.

Mate I think Vic is good and he will bounce back but with all due respect it won't be hard to look good against a bloke Hussy Hussien stopped in three rounds a few years ago... Vic still needs a big fight.

Marlin wrote:I assume you are putting your hand up to run it... :)

i would like to.....give me a few days and i will begin

mundine
katsidis
briggs
darchinyan
green
pittman
soliman
dib
dawson
bika

Pittman above Soliman p4p What has Pittman done to be ahead of Soliman in your opinion?

list wasnt in any real order aside from top 4
but i still think pittman is in top 10

Question - How do you define P4P?

BoxRec's P4P - Australia with some (?):

1 Anthony Mundine 826
2 Vic Darchinyan 685 (Armenia?)
3 Danny Green 551
4 Michael Katsidis 530
5 Sakio Bika 524 (Cameroon?)
6 Paul Briggs 517
7 Daniel Geale 420
8 Daniel Dawson 338
9 Kali Meehan 314
10 Hussein Hussein 310

Meehan not in your lists?

Thanks for running that computerrank.

It's not far off how I'd have it now. I probably wouldn't have Maheen or Hussy Hussien though...

ben k wrote:

Grant wrote:Where does Shannon Taylor rate?

Although he is long past his best and his decision to continue fighting is somewhat strange I still believe if people are going to consider Big Bob then Taylor must be in the mix somewhere.

I put him in at 21, I will go through my list as i only took 15 minutes to do it and relist them.

i would hav ben crampton in front of taylor,maybe that match up will happen soon,thats the word

January 2008

1. Anthony Mundine 30-3
2. Vic Darchinyan 29-1
3. Micheal Katsidis 23-0
4. Danny Green 25-3
5. Sakio Bika 25-3
6. Daniel Geale 18-0
7. Sam Soliman 35-10
8. Lovemore N'dou 46-9
8. Ben Rabah (if he chooses to fight again) 24-3
9. Paul Briggs 26-3
10. Daniel Dawson 29-1

Paul Briggs is fallin down the list wat is he doin anyway mabey he should go do mma he was a would kickboxing champ

might be a good time to update the list fellas? bit of a shake up with green and briggs retiring

You're right that does put a big hole in the rankings. I'll have a think and whack up a list later...

Alright, here goes. This is a bit of a work in progress...

Katsidis
Darchinyan
Bika
Geale
Ndou
Meehan
Dawson
Medley
Asiku
Porky

I haven't put Meehan in previously however after thining about it he is at least overseas fighting and the win over TOS is one of the best by an Aussie for a while...

Marlin wrote:Alright, here goes. This is a bit of a work in progress...

Katsidis
Darchinyan
Bika
Geale
Ndou
Meehan
Dawson
Medley
Asiku
Porky

I haven't put Meehan in previously however after thining about it he is at least overseas fighting and the win over TOS is one of the best by an Aussie for a while...

no mundine again marlin? hey i think he's a choad too, but atm as sad as it is, he's argubally the best we got

my post got wiped.

Got the have Mundine in, like him or not (top 3)

Also is it worth going to top 15?

Other that need to be considered

DeMori
Soliman
St Clair?
Dib
Kickett
D. Browne?
H Hussien

question mark over a couple. Lovin Porky being in there.

Katsidis
Mundine
Darchinian
Geale
Briggs
Bika
Dawson
Medley
Soliman
Kickett
Stclair

ben k wrote:Katsidis
Mundine
Darchinian
Geale
Briggs
Bika
Dawson
Medley
Soliman
Kickett
Stclair

which Briggs, with Paul all but retired. Surely you don't mean Nathan Briggs big fella

toppity wrote:Other that need to be considered

DeMori
Soliman
St Clair?
Dib
Kickett
D. Browne?
H Hussien

I am a huge Soliman fan but he hasn't beaten anyone lately, the same can be said for St Clair, Hussy is past it and the other aren't ready yet...

You gona post your list topp?