Ant Evans wrote:
Fedor is a great talent, but he has been fighting has-beens and freaks for 4 years and counting now. Penn and GSP are two fo the 4 best pound-for-pound fighters on the planet, fighting each other,
Fedor is the MMA version of racing driver Michael Andretti. Andretti won IndyCar title 8 times, was unbeatable, but when he stepped into the big league - F1 - he was completely out of his depth. He soon realised that beating a few aged F1 has-beens in Indycar was one thing, beating the current F1 racers - in their prime, race in race out - was beyond him. I would love to see what Fedor could do in UFC, but lot of people - Kevin Iole, Dave Meltzer and others - are asking why the alleged best won't go to where he can fight the best.
And if you think Arlovski (KO'd 5 times before Saturday), Slyvia (beaten by four guys currently in UFC), freak Hong Man Chi (nuff said) and faded _middleweight_ Matt Lindland (KO'd by one punch at middleweight Saturday) represent better opposition than GSP's last opponents: Josh Koscheck, Matt Hughes, Matt Serra, Jon Fitch and now BJ Penn or Penn's last opponents: Jens Pulver, Joe Stevenson, Sean Sherk and next up GSP you must has shares in Fedor.
Firstly BJ Penn is my favourite MMA fighter - I love his style, attitude and ability levels but fortunately I am not blinkered by who employes me. 8)
Take a look at the opinions on this video - even guys like GSP and Shogun Rua agree you and your boss are wrong!
http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x85a1f ... ller_sport
As regards Fedor's opposition -
Arlovski - ex UFC champ and still highly rated by independent polls
Sylvia - another former UFC champ who lost his UFC champ to Couture over 5 rnds. Fedor walked through him.
Hong Man Choi - despite his freakish appearance he is a difficult opponent due to sheer mass and athletic ability (relative to his size)
Lindland - Olympic Silver medailist who was Nr 1 or 2 in the world at 185 at the time of his loss to Fedor
As regards the other fighter's
GSP
Josh Koscheck - good wrestler but badly exposed by the brutal muay thai of Thiago Alves after his loss to GSP
Matt Hughes - yesterday's man. At one time near unbeatable but on the slide and inactive by the time GSP beat him for the second time.
Matt Serra - nice guy but a weak champ. A Cinderella Man of MMA
Jon Fitch - another great wrestler without the dimensions to threaten GSP
BJ Penn
Jens Pulver - a dangerous and worthy opponent .. at UFC 35. He was out of his weight class (natural bantam) and out of his league against a more mature BJ Penn
Joe Stevenson - exposed by Kenny Florian
Sean Sherk - drugs cheat will always sully his achievements, much like Shane Mosley in boxing. Too short to box with Penn.
Anyone can critique the level of opposition (which has been good throughout all 3 men's careers in all honesty) but only a UFC employee could denigh that Fedor isn't in the running for the title of MMA's best fighter.
I look forward to UFC 94 as I do all the UFC events - they are great shows, with generally good levels of matches (although too many TUF alumini getting chance after chance recently..) but your blinkered and skewed summary of the facts needs revising IMO
And whilst on the subject of MMA -
RIP Helio Gracie
He is a bit before your time Ant but trust me, Helio and his boys
built that house 