Page 2 of 2
Re: British Top 30 P4P March 2009
Posted: 03 Mar 2009, 13:50
by Horse
danfoster wrote:i'd have thought that ryan rhodes should be in there, definitely
done a lot more than mcloskey than appleby for my money but only an opinion
Rhodes is ranked at No.23 in the list.
danfoster wrote:i also think that enzo is very lucky to be as high as number 8 - i just feel that he is a very overrated boxer with few quality wins
I can see your point, if he doesn't fight any quality opposition soon then he will be making his way down the list.
Re: British Top 30 P4P March 2009
Posted: 04 Mar 2009, 06:15
by whiteboy
Herbie Herbie Herbie
Anyone ranked that high by WBC in their division should be in this?
Re: British Top 30 P4P March 2009
Posted: 04 Mar 2009, 12:08
by Horse
Ted wrote:Is Brian Magee not Irish?
I don't know. Is he?
banjo wrote:Horse will say no because he holds the British title
Yes, something like that.
Re: British Top 30 P4P March 2009
Posted: 04 Mar 2009, 12:30
by Horse
metropol wrote:Ted wrote:thats weird logic, but rogan has the commonwealth - where does that put him?
Ssssssshhhhhh, Were keeping him fo sho . I suppose the the amount of tri colors on display may of been a hint to horse.
Yes, the amount of Irish flags strongly influenced my decision.
metropol wrote:Ive been over this with the equine one and i think we just had to agree to disagree although various arguments were put forward by different people as to why some on his list were Irish and had not been acknowledged as so .
Now that Rogan has the Irish notation next to his name, my policy for recognising a boxer as Irish seems inconsistent.
So, from next month I will recognise all Irish fighters as Irish even if they have gone down the British title route.
Re: British Top 30 P4P March 2009
Posted: 05 Mar 2009, 14:04
by Horse
whiteboy wrote:Herbie Herbie Herbie
Anyone ranked that high by WBC in their division should be in this?
If Hide wins his fight against Siproshvili this month then I will strongly consider entering him next month.
Re: British Top 30 P4P March 2009
Posted: 05 Mar 2009, 14:10
by stujones
Horse wrote:whiteboy wrote:Herbie Herbie Herbie
Anyone ranked that high by WBC in their division should be in this?
If Hide wins his fight against Siproshvili this month then I will strongly consider entering him next month.
Why? Siproshvilli isn't exactly great? So why fighting a guy with a 15-4 record worthy of giving another fighter a ranking?
Also - what about Dean Francis' draw the other week? Why hasn't that pushed him down futher?
Re: British Top 30 P4P March 2009
Posted: 05 Mar 2009, 15:20
by Horse
stujones wrote:Why? Siproshvilli isn't exactly great? So why fighting a guy with a 15-4 record worthy of giving another fighter a ranking?
It would not just be Siproshvili, it would also be based on the other fighters Hide has been beating recently. I thought you would approve of Hide's inclusion.
stujones wrote:Also - what about Dean Francis' draw the other week? Why hasn't that pushed him down futher?
I don't move fighters up or down based on a draw.
Re: British Top 30 P4P March 2009
Posted: 05 Mar 2009, 15:46
by craigjenkins05
so fanbase now dictates how good a fighter is and how far he should go does that mean we will be seeing rogan v vitali klitschko by the end of the year?
Re: British Top 30 P4P March 2009
Posted: 05 Mar 2009, 16:14
by Horse
craigjenkins05 wrote:so fanbase now dictates how good a fighter is and how far he should go
A large fanbase helps to get the right training and opponents that will make a fighter better. It also has a large impact on how far the fighter will go in their career.
craigjenkins05 wrote:does that mean we will be seeing rogan v vitali klitschko by the end of the year?
I doubt it.
Re: British Top 30 P4P March 2009
Posted: 05 Mar 2009, 17:27
by craigjenkins05
doubt it ye me too but rogan has everyone behind him khan isnt a fighter he is a product fighter a man who is 35 and is probably going to be a stone lighter on fight night wont be a great achievment
Re: British Top 30 P4P March 2009
Posted: 05 Mar 2009, 18:56
by stujones
Horse wrote:stujones wrote:Why? Siproshvilli isn't exactly great? So why fighting a guy with a 15-4 record worthy of giving another fighter a ranking?
It would not just be Siproshvili, it would also be based on the other fighters Hide has been beating recently. I thought you would approve of Hide's inclusion.
stujones wrote:Also - what about Dean Francis' draw the other week? Why hasn't that pushed him down futher?
I don't move fighters up or down based on a draw.
Hang on, I think both decisions are a bit strange. Fighters like Jennings were getting condemed for not fighting anyone decent recently. Herbie has, but doesn't get ranked.... he then is scheduled to fight an average fighter and will get a ranking. A double standard there... this is a ticking over fight, just as Jennings' has been doing.
So if say Joe makes a comeback, looks rusty and scores a 12 round draw to Tony Dodson. Joe remains at #1 and Dodson remains out of the top 30?
Re: British Top 30 P4P March 2009
Posted: 05 Mar 2009, 20:05
by Horse
craigjenkins05 wrote:doubt it ye me too but rogan has everyone behind him khan isnt a fighter he is a product fighter a man who is 35 and is probably going to be a stone lighter on fight night wont be a great achievment
It would still be a good achievement. You don't seem to think much of Khan, but his record is as good or better than many other fighters on the list.
Re: British Top 30 P4P March 2009
Posted: 05 Mar 2009, 20:37
by Horse
stujones wrote:Hang on, I think both decisions are a bit strange. Fighters like Jennings were getting condemed for not fighting anyone decent recently. Herbie has, but doesn't get ranked....
Hide's recent opposition is at roughly the same level as Jennings's, he has just fought more of them.
stujones wrote:he then is scheduled to fight an average fighter and will get a ranking. A double standard there... this is a ticking over fight, just as Jennings' has been doing.
Hide has been beating a series of decent opposition recently, his next opponent seems just about good enough for me to allow Hide into the list for, if Hide beats him. The win would just be an excuse to enter Hide after he had beaten a number of decent fighters.
Jennings entered the list in similar circumstances. Where is the double standard?
stujones wrote:So if say Joe makes a comeback, looks rusty and scores a 12 round draw to Tony Dodson. Joe remains at #1 and Dodson remains out of the top 30?
Yes. I would take the draw into consideration in future decisions regarding the two fighters, but no immediate change.
Re: British Top 30 P4P March 2009
Posted: 06 Mar 2009, 08:07
by stujones
Hide hasn't been beating a series of good opposition. He beat Ruidger May who I think was good enough to justify a top 30 ranking. The rest since May have been poor.
Jennings beat Takaloo, who was regarded at the number #1 in the UK at the time (after beating Magee) and has won a series of decent "ticking" over fights since then..... Minter etc.
Re: British Top 30 P4P March 2009
Posted: 06 Mar 2009, 09:59
by Horse
stujones wrote:Hide hasn't been beating a series of good opposition. He beat Ruidger May who I think was good enough to justify a top 30 ranking. The rest since May have been poor.
I didn't say good, I said decent. He beat Nasyrov who was 19-0 and Ehikhamenor who went on to do the Cruiserweight Contender series. That opposition seems to be at about the level of a lower member of the top 30 and I think he deserves consideration if he wins his next fight.
stujones wrote:Jennings beat Takaloo, who was regarded at the number #1 in the UK at the time (after beating Magee) and has won a series of decent "ticking" over fights since then..... Minter etc.
Takaloo was only seen as the number one by some. I did not see him as the number one. Is Minter much/any better than some of the guys Hide has been beating recently?
Re: British Top 30 P4P March 2009
Posted: 06 Mar 2009, 13:29
by paddyavh
No A-Force

Re: British Top 30 P4P March 2009
Posted: 06 Mar 2009, 14:53
by Horse
paddyavh wrote:No A-Force

No.