Re: Ray Robinson's resume!
Posted: 12 Mar 2009, 13:42
Do you know when that was published seems an old assumption. Or is that the whole paper
Not for a minute am I suggesting that he got where he got on physicality alone - but he did seem to have an ability to set an inhuman pace which nobody else seemed to be able to match.Terence wrote:Armstrong had talent. He was not just a threshing machine. He could do mad shit like block, parry and slip punches, he did not 'defend' by running around in wide circles. Imagine boiling down his pace and putting it into 12-round fights. He would dominate his chosen division.
Yes indeed, where does it end? It doesn't end, that's what makes the best P4P in history such a great debate! Make no mistake, Ray Robinson is right up there with the very best. IMO, he's the best P4P in history, with Armstrong a close second!Emerson Poncey Name Ghent wrote:...and Robinson considered Armstrong as the GOAT. Where does it end?!The Law wrote:Even Ali considers Robinson as the greatest pound for pound fighter ever.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FGHhtS7PKGA
Would love to see some full fights of his. Only ever seen really poor quality grainy clips.Terence wrote:Got some on tape, some on DVD, I think, and some on the PC. Will have to dig around as I am not sure what I have as highlights and what I have in full, if anything.jamesmcdonnell wrote:Not for a minute am I suggesting that he got where he got on physicality alone - but he did seem to have an ability to set an inhuman pace which nobody else seemed to be able to match.Terence wrote:Armstrong had talent. He was not just a threshing machine. He could do mad shit like block, parry and slip punches, he did not 'defend' by running around in wide circles. Imagine boiling down his pace and putting it into 12-round fights. He would dominate his chosen division.
Have you got any of armstrong's fights terrence?
Did not think you were saying he is just a thresher. His physical gifts were a big help but he also had great ability to close the ring down, mix his shots between body and head, and cannily avoid the incoming shots. In many ways he is a lot like Aaron Pryor (although people think that is a crazy comparison) as his threshing style makes many people overlook the fact that he closed down the range quickly, always seemed to be on top off the other guy and had great shot selection. No point thrashing away if you are hitting gloves, Aaron and Pryor had the knack of landing the right shots at the perfect moments.
Great little boxers. Both game as they come also, not sure what fight it was but I am sure I read that Armstrong, like Holmes in the Norton fight, once swallowed a whole lot of his own blood to win a fight, may have been one of his 3-titles at one time fights.
Plus, a few witnesses say he was unlucky not to add a portion of the middleweight title to his list, as he pushed Ceferino Garcia, himself a decent fighter, close for the Californian portion of the title.
A bit of their welterweight title fight is included below:
http://video.google.com/videosearch?q=c ... &ct=title#
Resting heart rate as I understand it is recorded when you are asleep or prone.Scrap wrote:Was that measured laying down or stood up Ian
Burley fought and beat far better fighters than Robinson, hes a WW who beat Archie Moore, arguably the best LHW ever, this win alone is way better than any of Robinsons, he also beat other men who beat Moore, fought 3 of the best HWs of the 40s including HW champ Ezzard Charles, proved to be the best of the Black Dynamite Crew who didn't fight at HWEmerson Poncey Name Ghent wrote:I disagree about Burley. Purely as only one video exists of him ever fighting so he's just to hard to guage.Phenomenal-Nutrition wrote:Resume wise he has some very good names, but he didn't face the best of his times, avoided the very best WW/MW of his era in Charles Burley and the black dynamite crew, which were basically all the top black fighters who were excluded from title fights etc. Burley fought far far better opposition than Robinson, but didn't always win. Robinson also didn't face Cerdan the other top WW/MW of his time, but that was no fault of his own as Cerdan died
Sure, Futch said he was the greatest never to win a championship, so that's a statement to respect. But He wasn't tested at the level of Basilio, De Marco, Zale and Graziano level. So we'll never know. I've always felt we buy in to the mysticism of Burley. He lost to a prime Zivic at a weight he seemed more natural at based upon his record only.
La Motta destroyed Cerdan, so based upon the A beat B beat C theory, it's null and void. For me, Cerdan was an over-protected fighter that was exposed when he fought at the very top.
I strongly disagree Burley fought even better opposition, let alone far, far, better. So we'll respectfully agree to disagree.![]()
I agree that the 40s, 50s and early 60s are such a hard era to guage because of the Mob involvement from Bunny, et al.
I have the fight mate (all beit monchrome highlights shaded with animation because that's all that's available, if someone claims to have a better version of the fight please let me know and you'll receive funds for a sharesy). He did destroy him.Phenomenal-Nutrition wrote:Lamotta did not destroy Cerdan either