BoxRec

1. Darchinyan
2. Mundine
3. Geale
4. Katsidis
5. Zappa
6. Dib
7. Bika
8. Asiku
9. Meehan
10.Soliman

Ok here's mine:
1.Geale
2.Geale
3.Geale
4.Geale
5.Geale
6.Geale
7.Geale
8.Geale
9.Geale
10.Geale

Liver Crusher wrote:If Geale isn't number 1 im gonna crack it!!!!!!!!!!!

He lost to another Australian fighter, you are being ridiculous.

Liver Crusher wrote:Ok here's mine:
1.Geale
2.Geale
3.Geale
4.Geale
5.Geale
6.Geale
7.Geale
8.Geale
9.Geale
10.Geale

Should number ten at least be Geale southpaw???

1. Vic Darchinyan
2. Anthony Mundine
3. Micheal Katsidis
4. Daniel Geale
5. Sakio Bika
6. Lenny Zappa
7. Billy Dib
8. Sam Soliman
9. Kali Meehan
10. Willie Kickett

only one change. I wish they were more active.

Liver Crusher wrote:If Geale isn't number 1 im gonna crack it!!!!!!!!!!!

you are fair dinkum joking aren't you?

I would give Geale a highest ranking as 3, I do believe he is a world class fighter but needs to beat a few world class oppositon.

Mine:

1. Vic Darchinyan
2. Michael Katsidis
3. Anthony Mundine
4. Daniel Geale
5. Danny Green
6. Sakio Bika
7. Billy Dib
8. Kali Meehan
9. Sam Soliman
10. Leonardo Zappavigna

1. Vic Darchinyan
2. Michael Katsidis
3.Sakio Bika
4.Lenny Zappavigna
5.Anthony Mundine
6.Daniel Geale
7.Danny Green
8.Jamie Pittman
9. Billy Dib
10.King Davidson

Marlin wrote:

Liver Crusher wrote:If Geale isn't number 1 im gonna crack it!!!!!!!!!!!

He lost to another Australian fighter, you are being ridiculous.

even if he beat mundine...vic is still number 1

BUT he lost to mundine, how could he possible be higher than mundine? that makes no sense at all.

your geale-luvin is making u not see clearly and rationally

1. Vic Darchinyan
2. Anthony Mundine
3. Daniel Geale
4. Micheal Katsidis
5. Sakio Bika
6. Danny Green
7. Lenny Zappa
8. Sam Soliman
9. Willie Kickett
10. Billy Dib

The fists 22nd edition top 15 P4P.

1. Darchinyan
2. Mundine
3. Bika
4. Geale
5. Katsidis
6. Zappavigna
7. Meehan
8. Ndou
9. soliman
10. Dib
11. Medley
12. Awad
13. Pittman
14. Kickett
15. Steve Wills

Boxrec top 15 P4P

1 Mundine
2. Green
3. Geale
4. Bika
5. Katsidis
6. Dib
7. Omotoso
8. Ganoy
9. Vea
10. Ndou
11. Taylor
12. Bell
13. Dawson
14. Zappavigna
15. Kickett

Very interesting.

Hounddawgs top 15

1. Darchinyan
2. Green ( very biased he's my favorite fighter, but is exciting to watch)
3. Mundine (only because of the w against Geale)
4. Geale ( I'd have it the other way round if the Judges wern't such bitches)
5. Bika
6. Katsidis
7. Zappavigna
8. Omotoso
9. Dibb
10. Soliman (too inactive)
11. Meehan (Too inactive)
12. Ndou
13. Dawson
14. Kickett
15. Asiku

Honorable mentions Leapai, Demori and Medley

A awful lot of variation from 6 through 15, but i guess it's a sign of the depth that Australia is finally producing.

Yes Im only joking

Geale 3.

I dont rate Katsidis much.

Hounddawg wrote:The fists 22nd edition top 15 P4P.

1. Darchinyan
2. Mundine
3. Bika
4. Geale
5. Katsidis
6. Zappavigna
7. Meehan
8. Ndou
9. soliman
10. Dib
11. Medley
12. Awad
13. Pittman
14. Kickett
15. Steve Wills

Boxrec top 15 P4P

1 Mundine
2. Green
3. Geale
4. Bika
5. Katsidis
6. Dib
7. Omotoso
8. Ganoy
9. Vea
10. Ndou
11. Taylor
12. Bell
13. Dawson
14. Zappavigna
15. Kickett

Very interesting.

Hounddawgs top 15

1. Darchinyan
2. Green ( very biased he's my favorite fighter, but is exciting to watch)
3. Mundine (only because of the w against Geale)
4. Geale ( I'd have it the other way round if the Judges wern't such bitches)
5. Bika
6. Katsidis
7. Zappavigna
8. Omotoso
9. Dibb
10. Soliman (too inactive)
11. Meehan (Too inactive)
12. Ndou
13. Dawson
14. Kickett
15. Asiku

Honorable mentions Leapai, Demori and Medley

A awful lot of variation from 6 through 15, but i guess it's a sign of the depth that Australia is finally producing.

so boxrec doesnt recognise vic as ozzie?

adamheight wrote:

Hounddawg wrote:The fists 22nd edition top 15 P4P.

1. Darchinyan
2. Mundine
3. Bika
4. Geale
5. Katsidis
6. Zappavigna
7. Meehan
8. Ndou
9. soliman
10. Dib
11. Medley
12. Awad
13. Pittman
14. Kickett
15. Steve Wills

Boxrec top 15 P4P

1 Mundine
2. Green
3. Geale
4. Bika
5. Katsidis
6. Dib
7. Omotoso
8. Ganoy
9. Vea
10. Ndou
11. Taylor
12. Bell
13. Dawson
14. Zappavigna
15. Kickett

Very interesting.

Hounddawgs top 15

1. Darchinyan
2. Green ( very biased he's my favorite fighter, but is exciting to watch)
3. Mundine (only because of the w against Geale)
4. Geale ( I'd have it the other way round if the Judges wern't such bitches)
5. Bika
6. Katsidis
7. Zappavigna
8. Omotoso
9. Dibb
10. Soliman (too inactive)
11. Meehan (Too inactive)
12. Ndou
13. Dawson
14. Kickett
15. Asiku

Honorable mentions Leapai, Demori and Medley

A awful lot of variation from 6 through 15, but i guess it's a sign of the depth that Australia is finally producing.

so boxrec doesnt recognise vic as ozzie?

Nope still consider him Armenian, isn't he an Australian citizen? Anyone know what Darchy claims?

Hounddawg wrote:
Nope still consider him Armenian, isn't he an Australian citizen? Anyone know what Darchy claims?

as always Vic claims he will knock them out

toppity wrote:

Hounddawg wrote:
Nope still consider him Armenian, isn't he an Australian citizen? Anyone know what Darchy claims?

as always Vic claims he will knock them out

That's all that counts. 8)

Bump.

Time for an update, or wait for Vic to fight, or even a bit longer?

Did the Mundine v Geale fight alter things?

I'll leave it up to Marlin to call it.

At the first sign of whinging I turfed it...

shame

thunderdownunder might still want to give it a whirl...

Hey Marlin i realize i was 1 of the whingers, but is there any chance you want to take this back up? It would be rather interesting to see peoples opinions.

Anyone want to take this up? i guess Marlins silence is his answer, doesn't seem like a big job except for the occasional disagreement .

I don't like whingers...

Why don't you give it a go mate?

why dont we just post our top ten P4P list every so often and just compare and discuss without all the work of collating lists and posting results??