Page 1133 of 1796

Re: Classic American West Coast Boxing

Posted: 27 Jul 2010, 19:38
by raylawpc
Rick Farris wrote:
kikibalt wrote:Murray: Dempsey was the meanest
By Jim Murray
Special to ESPN.com

Editor's note: This column originally appeared in the Los Angeles Times on November 17, 1965.

There are all kinds of ways to get ready for a heavyweight championship fight. You work on what you need.

Joe Louis used to practice going to the farthest neutral corner. Gene Tunney practiced running for his life, Floyd Patterson should practice getting up and Muhammad Whatisname should practice shutting up.

Lots of fighters practice hooks to the head but Gene Fullmer used to practice hooks with the head. Rocky Marciano threw so many punches in so many directions he just had to make sure he didn't hit the referee -- or the ring posts.

ESPN Classic
SportsCentury will profile Jack Dempsey on Friday, August 10 at 8 and 11 p.m. ET.
But Jack Dempsey was the only champion who practiced the same way the early Christians did -- as if his opponent had a mane and claws and would not only fight him but eat him. Dempsey even fought a punching bag as if it might open fire at any time. Sparring partners limped out of town on every bus. A newspaper man climbed into the ring with him once as a gag, and a colleague had to write the fellow's story for a few days afterwards while he took nourishment through a straw. "Dempsey fought you," a battered spar-mate once confided, "as if the two of you were on a ledge 20 stories up and it was either him or you."

The man who can best testify to the terrible tornadic frenzy of the Dempsey attack is a tall, graceful, New Orleans-born Irishman named Marty Burke.

Martin Burke, now 70 and still blondhaired, is known around the sound stages of Hollywood as the father of 20th Century Fox's television star, Paul Burke ("12 O'Clock High") but he was known around the gyms and barges of New Orleans' "Irish Channel" section as "The Turk," the best left-hook artist who ever came out of bayou country.

Marty's book, if he writes it, is going to be called "1,000 Rounds with Jack Dempsey, or Did You Think I Got This Ear Answering the Telephone?" If you doubt Dempsey's punch, Marty will take your hand and press into what once was a chest bone, but what is now a depression deep enough to hide letters. Dempsey did that with a single hook. Marty forgets what kind of punch it was that used to break his nose regularly.

Marty began to train with Dempsey well before the Dempsey-Willard fight. The two of them toured the tank towns of New Jersey and Pennsylvania where Dempsey's manager, Doc Kearns, posted a ritual $500 fee for anyone who could go the route against the tigerish Dempsey. Doc used to post himself behind the curtain with a bung starter in case any of the tank palookas got lucky, but Marty recalls the few who squared off against Dempsey went out on a stretcher. Marty had to take up the slack and keep the show going.

One night, when his nose looked like a pomegranate and his ear had grown so far it looked like a second head, Marty mildly suggested to Dempsey that he take off a day to heal. "Oh," soother Dempsey, "I'll take it easy with you, Turk -- just a few body taps." The first part of his body Dempsey tapped was his nose -- with one of the hardest rights he ever threw. "Jack just didn't know the meaning of 'take it easy' when he got into the ring. You had to be alert out there or you'd find yourself looking around for your head."

One time, Marty sparred six rounds in one week with Dempsey, and then fought 15 with Gene Tunney for the American light-heavyweight championship. "The six rounds with Dempsey were worse than the whole 15 with Tunney." In fact, Burke says, his tow fights with Tunney -- he lost both -- were easier than any single vaudeville fight with Dempsey with 16-ounce gloves.

Marty's next-hardest fight was with Harry Greb. "He hit me so often, I actually turned around to see who was helping him. With Greb, it was a good thing he couldn't hit hard because he hit often. With Dempsey, it was a good thing he didn't hit often because he hit hard."

At 6 feet 3 inches, Marty had altitude going for him in most fights. Also, he presented a slim target. He weighed as little as 154 when he first began to tour with Dempsey. He fought George Godfrey, on of the great Negro fighters of the '20s, only after the boxing commission told him to put on four more pounds on the afternoon of the fight. Marty spent the rest of the day draining down bootleg ale and Guinness Stout. He not only made the weight, he almost made the drunk tank. This was the first time they ever had to give a fighter a shower BEFORE the fight. Marty showed up at 175 pounds, singing "Mother Machree." Godfrey, a two-bottle man himself, just looked jealous.

Marty even won the fight. At 220 and cold sober, Godfrey was no match for him, and this was at a time when all the ranking heavyweights were ducking behind the color line and keeping Godfrey, known variously as the "Baron of Leiperville" or the "Leopard of Leiperville" and other alliterations, at bay. In time, Godfrey came up to Marty after the bout and allowed, "Turk, you're the first fighter I met in a long time didn't ax me to handcuff myself."

After Dempsey, Burke didn't see any need to ask anybody to handcuff himself. In fact, he was the first to know it when Dempsey began to lose it all. "I told him before the Tunney fight, 'Jack, you know you can't fight anymore. Tunney shouldn't lose a round.'" It turned out, Tunney didn't. Not even the one he was knocked down in for 14 seconds in the second fight.

Marty drifted around the fight game for several more years after that -- or until he got knocked out in one round by Young Stribling. "Five years before, Stribling couldn't have hit me with a handful of birdseed."

Back in New Orleans, Marty opened a French Quarter saloon so tough the shore patrol used to walk it in platoon strength. Some of Marty's last fights were with longshoreman half his age and twice his weight and one night when business was good, Marty sat down after he had stacked a few customers in a neat pile outside the front door, and reached in his mouth and extracted three teeth by hand which had already been loosened by fists.

He spoke in a lisp as he inspected the bloody molars. "I wonder," he questioned, "how Dempsey missed these?"

This column originally appeared in The Los Angeles Times. Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved.

Jim Murray, the long-time sports columnist for the Los Angeles Times, won the Pultizer Prize for commentary in 1990. He died Aug. 16, 1998.

Jim Murray is the finest sports writer I ever read.
They used to run Jim Murray's column in the Daily Oklahoman (or as we used to call it - the Daily Disappointment). It was the only decent sportswriting to appear in that rag. I missed it when we moved to St. Louis. I also used to really like Arthur Daley in the NYTimes.

Re: Classic American West Coast Boxing

Posted: 27 Jul 2010, 19:51
by Rick Farris
Motown thru the eyes of Calvin . . .


When I arrived in Detroit, I was introduced to a local studio Teamster who would be driving our 40' production van that was packed with lighting equipment and cable. The man's name was Calvin, a slender, elderly black man who was on the quiet side, choosing his words carefully when engaging in conversation, rarely speaking unless spoken to.

Something drew me to Calvin. I suspected he was a sports fan, always wearing a Detroit Tigers baseball cap. I had a feeling that Calvin just might be a boxing fan. I rarely tell people that I used to be a boxer, but somebody on my crew will usaully let it be known. One day, I approached Calvin and made the comment, "You know, Detroit has one helluva boxing history. Some great fighter's came out of the Motor City." Calvin's eyes widened and a smile came to his face. "Yes it was. Joe Louis was from Detroit."

I wanted Calvin to know that my knowledge of Detroit's boxing history went deeper than Tommy Hearns and Emmanuel Steward's top-notch Kronk stable of a few years back. I asked Calvin if he knew of the Brewster Recreation Center, where Louis began boxing and our driver immediatly came to life. "I used to swim at the Brewster Center when I was a kid, and it's still there today."

I shared my knowledge of Brewster, and how when Joe Louis was boxing amateur, there was this small kid who used to carry the future Brown Bomber's gym bag for him. That young boy's name was Walker Smith, and he would one day become the great Sugar Ray Robinson. I also told him of trainer Eddie Futch, and how he and Louis would train together, and how Futch claimed the greatest pure boxer he ever saw was former light-heavy contender, Holman Williams. Futch claims that he would rather watch Holman Williams shadow box than watch others fight.

We talked of Futch's 60's-70's welterweight, Hedgeman Lewis, who came from Detroit to make a big name for himself in L.A. And we talked of Henry Hank, and others.

However, Calvin and I shared an interest in another Detroit product beyond boxers, and that was Motown Records, founded by another California Boxing Hall of Famer, Berry Gordy Jr.

"I'm gunna take you around Detroit to a few places off the beaten path, and show you where Berry Gordy and many of his future music legends came from. I'll show you where it all started, places you won't read about, places that only we in the neighborhood know", our driver promised me. Calvin had grown up less than two blocks from the home where Berry Gordy had lived as a child, right off of 12th Street. Today that neighborhood is like an overgrown ghost town, burned out and boarded up, a sad memory of better days in Detroit.

On my only day off while in the Motor City, Calvin kept his word and picked me up at the Motor City Hotel-Casino, where our crew was lodged. A few minutes later we were parked in front of the Brewster Recreation Center, and he pointed toward one of the building's windows. "That's where the boxing gym was, that's where all the best of Detroit worked out back in the day", Calvin told me. "I don't know what is in the room today, but it ain't boxing no more." The Center was closed that Sunday, so I was unable to look in.

About fifteen minutes later we were in front of the home where Berry Gordy grew up. Today it's pretty run down, over grown with plants, looking as if the grass had not been cut in decades, and it hadn't been. The house next door had partially burned down several years back, and was just left abandoned, charred remains crumbling around a brick chimney and cement front porch. The house on the otherside was boarded up. "That's just a crack den today", Calvin explained. "These drug addicts find shelter in these abandoned houses during the winter when it's bitter cold outside. The make a fire to keep warm and often end up burning the place down."

We moved on down 12th Street to "Berry Gordy Jr. Avenue", and we turn left. A few blocks down the road we come to a small, well maintained wooden building with a big sign out front, "Hitsville U.S.A." Calvin smiled proudly and pointed to the building. "That is where Berry Gordy started Motown Records, that was his first recording studio. That's where the Surpemes, Smokey Robinson, Marvin Gaye, The Temptations, Stevie Wonder, The Four Tops,and all the rest got there start."

I mentioned to Calvin that I'd heard Gordy sold the Motown label a few years back for a conservative $100 million (It had greater value, I'd heard?). Calvin began to laugh, "That ain't bad, considering he started it all with an original investment of $500."

Today "Hitsville U.S.A. is a museum honoring the Motown legends, however, it was closed on the day we passed by."

As we drove away, Calvin pointed at an old hospital on a corner, "That's where Aretha Franklin's father worked as a doctor, he delivered my younest sister, came right to our house and delivered Geraldine right on sofa in the den."

We drove on, and as Calvin relived his memories of the Motor City, I just sat and listened. It was a special day in my life, it was a day of history, the good history of a town that's best days are behind it.

I truly loved my 15 days in Detroit. I did the lighting on the pilot for ABC's new tuesday night police drama, "Detroit 1-8-7". I could have stayed on thru April, and completed the following 22 episodes, but I was not looking forward to spending months filming outside thru the Detroit winter. I was offered a Tom Hanks-Natalie Portman feature film, "Parthanon", which will begin production in two weeks in L.A. where we will film for four months, followed by a six-week location in Greece. It was an offer too good to refuse.

I liked my brief stay in the Motor City, and I pray for the City and it's people. The City and State of Michigan are bankrupt, and there is little hope for the future in the eyes of many. I'll keep my fingers crossed for the Motor City, where I have a great new friend in Calvin.


-Rick Farris

Re: Classic American West Coast Boxing

Posted: 27 Jul 2010, 22:04
by Chuck1052
Jim Murray was a fine sportswriter, but his column contained some factual errors when the subject was boxing at times. For instance, he once wrote that Fidel La Barba was a fair featherweight as a professional fighter, but nothing about La Barba being a world champion and an all-time great as a flyweight. In a column about Tony Zale, Murray wrote that the former middleweight was a boxer-type during an early period of his career. Despite having some ring skills, Zale never would have been mistaken for Willie Pep at any time during his career.

- Chuck Johnston

Re: Classic American West Coast Boxing

Posted: 27 Jul 2010, 22:27
by Randyman
Rick Farris wrote:
kikibalt wrote:Murray: Dempsey was the meanest
By Jim Murray
Special to ESPN.com

Editor's note: This column originally appeared in the Los Angeles Times on November 17, 1965.

There are all kinds of ways to get ready for a heavyweight championship fight. You work on what you need.

Joe Louis used to practice going to the farthest neutral corner. Gene Tunney practiced running for his life, Floyd Patterson should practice getting up and Muhammad Whatisname should practice shutting up.

Lots of fighters practice hooks to the head but Gene Fullmer used to practice hooks with the head. Rocky Marciano threw so many punches in so many directions he just had to make sure he didn't hit the referee -- or the ring posts.

ESPN Classic
SportsCentury will profile Jack Dempsey on Friday, August 10 at 8 and 11 p.m. ET.
But Jack Dempsey was the only champion who practiced the same way the early Christians did -- as if his opponent had a mane and claws and would not only fight him but eat him. Dempsey even fought a punching bag as if it might open fire at any time. Sparring partners limped out of town on every bus. A newspaper man climbed into the ring with him once as a gag, and a colleague had to write the fellow's story for a few days afterwards while he took nourishment through a straw. "Dempsey fought you," a battered spar-mate once confided, "as if the two of you were on a ledge 20 stories up and it was either him or you."

The man who can best testify to the terrible tornadic frenzy of the Dempsey attack is a tall, graceful, New Orleans-born Irishman named Marty Burke.

Martin Burke, now 70 and still blondhaired, is known around the sound stages of Hollywood as the father of 20th Century Fox's television star, Paul Burke ("12 O'Clock High") but he was known around the gyms and barges of New Orleans' "Irish Channel" section as "The Turk," the best left-hook artist who ever came out of bayou country.

Marty's book, if he writes it, is going to be called "1,000 Rounds with Jack Dempsey, or Did You Think I Got This Ear Answering the Telephone?" If you doubt Dempsey's punch, Marty will take your hand and press into what once was a chest bone, but what is now a depression deep enough to hide letters. Dempsey did that with a single hook. Marty forgets what kind of punch it was that used to break his nose regularly.

Marty began to train with Dempsey well before the Dempsey-Willard fight. The two of them toured the tank towns of New Jersey and Pennsylvania where Dempsey's manager, Doc Kearns, posted a ritual $500 fee for anyone who could go the route against the tigerish Dempsey. Doc used to post himself behind the curtain with a bung starter in case any of the tank palookas got lucky, but Marty recalls the few who squared off against Dempsey went out on a stretcher. Marty had to take up the slack and keep the show going.

One night, when his nose looked like a pomegranate and his ear had grown so far it looked like a second head, Marty mildly suggested to Dempsey that he take off a day to heal. "Oh," soother Dempsey, "I'll take it easy with you, Turk -- just a few body taps." The first part of his body Dempsey tapped was his nose -- with one of the hardest rights he ever threw. "Jack just didn't know the meaning of 'take it easy' when he got into the ring. You had to be alert out there or you'd find yourself looking around for your head."

One time, Marty sparred six rounds in one week with Dempsey, and then fought 15 with Gene Tunney for the American light-heavyweight championship. "The six rounds with Dempsey were worse than the whole 15 with Tunney." In fact, Burke says, his tow fights with Tunney -- he lost both -- were easier than any single vaudeville fight with Dempsey with 16-ounce gloves.

Marty's next-hardest fight was with Harry Greb. "He hit me so often, I actually turned around to see who was helping him. With Greb, it was a good thing he couldn't hit hard because he hit often. With Dempsey, it was a good thing he didn't hit often because he hit hard."

At 6 feet 3 inches, Marty had altitude going for him in most fights. Also, he presented a slim target. He weighed as little as 154 when he first began to tour with Dempsey. He fought George Godfrey, on of the great Negro fighters of the '20s, only after the boxing commission told him to put on four more pounds on the afternoon of the fight. Marty spent the rest of the day draining down bootleg ale and Guinness Stout. He not only made the weight, he almost made the drunk tank. This was the first time they ever had to give a fighter a shower BEFORE the fight. Marty showed up at 175 pounds, singing "Mother Machree." Godfrey, a two-bottle man himself, just looked jealous.

Marty even won the fight. At 220 and cold sober, Godfrey was no match for him, and this was at a time when all the ranking heavyweights were ducking behind the color line and keeping Godfrey, known variously as the "Baron of Leiperville" or the "Leopard of Leiperville" and other alliterations, at bay. In time, Godfrey came up to Marty after the bout and allowed, "Turk, you're the first fighter I met in a long time didn't ax me to handcuff myself."

After Dempsey, Burke didn't see any need to ask anybody to handcuff himself. In fact, he was the first to know it when Dempsey began to lose it all. "I told him before the Tunney fight, 'Jack, you know you can't fight anymore. Tunney shouldn't lose a round.'" It turned out, Tunney didn't. Not even the one he was knocked down in for 14 seconds in the second fight.

Marty drifted around the fight game for several more years after that -- or until he got knocked out in one round by Young Stribling. "Five years before, Stribling couldn't have hit me with a handful of birdseed."

Back in New Orleans, Marty opened a French Quarter saloon so tough the shore patrol used to walk it in platoon strength. Some of Marty's last fights were with longshoreman half his age and twice his weight and one night when business was good, Marty sat down after he had stacked a few customers in a neat pile outside the front door, and reached in his mouth and extracted three teeth by hand which had already been loosened by fists.

He spoke in a lisp as he inspected the bloody molars. "I wonder," he questioned, "how Dempsey missed these?"

This column originally appeared in The Los Angeles Times. Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved.

Jim Murray, the long-time sports columnist for the Los Angeles Times, won the Pultizer Prize for commentary in 1990. He died Aug. 16, 1998.

Jim Murray is the finest sports writer I ever read.
I agree Rick, I was a fan. I may have some old clipping of some of his articles. If I can find them I'll post them. Like boxers of old, a good sports writer, especially boxing, is a dying breed.

Randy

Re: Classic American West Coast Boxing

Posted: 27 Jul 2010, 22:34
by Randyman
Rick Farris wrote:Motown thru the eyes of Calvin . . .


When I arrived in Detroit, I was introduced to a local studio Teamster who would be driving our 40' production van that was packed with lighting equipment and cable. The man's name was Calvin, a slender, elderly black man who was on the quiet side, choosing his words carefully when engaging in conversation, rarely speaking unless spoken to.

Something drew me to Calvin. I suspected he was a sports fan, always wearing a Detroit Tigers baseball cap. I had a feeling that Calvin just might be a boxing fan. I rarely tell people that I used to be a boxer, but somebody on my crew will usaully let it be known. One day, I approached Calvin and made the comment, "You know, Detroit has one helluva boxing history. Some great fighter's came out of the Motor City." Calvin's eyes widened and a smile came to his face. "Yes it was. Joe Louis was from Detroit."

I wanted Calvin to know that my knowledge of Detroit's boxing history went deeper than Tommy Hearns and Emmanuel Steward's top-notch Kronk stable of a few years back. I asked Calvin if he knew of the Brewster Recreation Center, where Louis began boxing and our driver immediatly came to life. "I used to swim at the Brewster Center when I was a kid, and it's still there today."

I shared my knowledge of Brewster, and how when Joe Louis was boxing amateur, there was this small kid who used to carry the future Brown Bomber's gym bag for him. That young boy's name was Walker Smith, and he would one day become the great Sugar Ray Robinson. I also told him of trainer Eddie Futch, and how he and Louis would train together, and how Futch claimed the greatest pure boxer he ever saw was former light-heavy contender, Holman Williams. Futch claims that he would rather watch Holman Williams shadow box than watch others fight.

We talked of Futch's 60's-70's welterweight, Hedgeman Lewis, who came from Detroit to make a big name for himself in L.A. And we talked of Henry Hank, and others.

However, Calvin and I shared an interest in another Detroit product beyond boxers, and that was Motown Records, founded by another California Boxing Hall of Famer, Berry Gordy Jr.

"I'm gunna take you around Detroit to a few places off the beaten path, and show you where Berry Gordy and many of his future music legends came from. I'll show you where it all started, places you won't read about, places that only we in the neighborhood know", our driver promised me. Calvin had grown up less than two blocks from the home where Berry Gordy had lived as a child, right off of 12th Street. Today that neighborhood is like an overgrown ghost town, burned out and boarded up, a sad memory of better days in Detroit.

On my only day off while in the Motor City, Calvin kept his word and picked me up at the Motor City Hotel-Casino, where our crew was lodged. A few minutes later we were parked in front of the Brewster Recreation Center, and he pointed toward one of the building's windows. "That's where the boxing gym was, that's where all the best of Detroit worked out back in the day", Calvin told me. "I don't know what is in the room today, but it ain't boxing no more." The Center was closed that Sunday, so I was unable to look in.

About fifteen minutes later we were in front of the home where Berry Gordy grew up. Today it's pretty run down, over grown with plants, looking as if the grass had not been cut in decades, and it hadn't been. The house next door had partially burned down several years back, and was just left abandoned, charred remains crumbling around a brick chimney and cement front porch. The house on the otherside was boarded up. "That's just a crack den today", Calvin explained. "These drug addicts find shelter in these abandoned houses during the winter when it's bitter cold outside. The make a fire to keep warm and often end up burning the place down."

We moved on down 12th Street to "Berry Gordy Jr. Avenue", and we turn left. A few blocks down the road we come to a small, well maintained wooden building with a big sign out front, "Hitsville U.S.A." Calvin smiled proudly and pointed to the building. "That is where Berry Gordy started Motown Records, that was his first recording studio. That's where the Surpemes, Smokey Robinson, Marvin Gaye, The Temptations, Stevie Wonder, The Four Tops,and all the rest got there start."

I mentioned to Calvin that I'd heard Gordy sold the Motown label a few years back for a conservative $100 million (It had greater value, I'd heard?). Calvin began to laugh, "That ain't bad, considering he started it all with an original investment of $500."

Today "Hitsville U.S.A. is a museum honoring the Motown legends, however, it was closed on the day we passed by."

As we drove away, Calvin pointed at an old hospital on a corner, "That's where Aretha Franklin's father worked as a doctor, he delivered my younest sister, came right to our house and delivered Geraldine right on sofa in the den."

We drove on, and as Calvin relived his memories of the Motor City, I just sat and listened. It was a special day in my life, it was a day of history, the good history of a town that's best days are behind it.

I truly loved my 15 days in Detroit. I did the lighting on the pilot for ABC's new tuesday night police drama, "Detroit 1-8-7". I could have stayed on thru April, and completed the following 22 episodes, but I was not looking forward to spending months filming outside thru the Detroit winter. I was offered a Tom Hanks-Natalie Portman feature film, "Parthanon", which will begin production in two weeks in L.A. where we will film for four months, followed by a six-week location in Greece. It was an offer too good to refuse.

I liked my brief stay in the Motor City, and I pray for the City and it's people. The City and State of Michigan are bankrupt, and there is little hope for the future in the eyes of many. I'll keep my fingers crossed for the Motor City, where I have a great new friend in Calvin.


-Rick Farris
Rick, my friend, that was straight from the heart. What a great experience! Thanks for sharing that with us.

Randy

Re: Classic American West Coast Boxing

Posted: 27 Jul 2010, 22:40
by Randyman
Obituary
Jim Murray, 78, Sportswriter And Winner of Pulitzer Prize
By RICHARD SANDOMIR
Published: August 18, 1998

Jim Murray, whose humorous, vinegary and graceful columns for The Los Angeles Times made him one of only four sportswriters to win the Pulitzer Prize for general commentary, died Sunday of cardiac arrest at his home in Los Angeles, the newspaper reported. He was 78.

Mr. Murray filed his last dispatch on Saturday from the Del Mar race track, a column about a victory by the thoroughbred Free House, who barely fell short in all three Triple Crown races last year.

''The bridesmaid finally caught the bouquet,'' he wrote. ''The 'best friend' got the girl in the Warner Bros. movie for a change. The sidekick saves the fort. Free House just won't fold the hand.''

Despite eye problems and heart surgery in past years. Mr. Murray was still writing his column regularly, puncturing a subject's pomposity or skewering cities. ''Detroit,'' he once wrote, ''should be left on the doorstep of the Salvation Army.''

The sportswriter Frank Deford said: ''He could be brutal. But there was so much humor, people didn't get mad about it.''

Well, some did. Indianapolis 500 officials were not amused that he dubbed the race ''America's Earache'' and suggested they start the annual car race by saying, ''Gentlemen, start your coffins.''

Mr. Murray joined The Los Angeles Times in 1961, after stints with The New Haven Register, The Los Angeles Herald-Examiner, Time and Life magazines as their Hollywood correspondent, and Sports Illustrated, which he helped found in 1953.

The Times hired him as a sports columnist, and he won numerous awards for his writing, but in a business known for bravado and hyperbole, Mr. Murray was revered for his modesty.

''There was no bluster in the guy,'' said Bill Dwyre, the sports editor of The Times. ''I have agate clerks with more ego than he did.''

When he won the Pulitzer in 1990, Mr. Murray said he thought a winner had ''to bring down a government or expose major graft or give advice to prime ministers.''

He added, ''Correctly quoting Tommy Lasorda shouldn't merit a Pulitzer Prize.''

Mr. Murray joined Arthur Daley, Red Smith and Dave Anderson, all of The New York Times, as the only sportswriters to win Pulitzers for commentary.

Mr. Deford recalled an award ceremony several years ago in Los Angeles. ''Ronald Reagan came,'' he said. ''He did a 10-minute standup. Not for many sportswriters would an ex-President show up to pay tribute.''

In his autobiography, Mr. Murray described his vivid approach to writing. ''People need to be amused, shocked, titillated or angered,'' he wrote. ''But if you can amuse or shock or make them indignant enough, you can slip lots of information into your message.''

In 1979, a detached retina in his left eye left him nearly blind; his right eye had a cataract. ''I lost an old friend the other day,'' Mr. Murray wrote after failed surgery. ''He was blue-eyed, impish, he cried a lot with me, saw a great many things with me. I don't know why he left me. Boredom perhaps.''

He continued to cover sports for The Times with a companion to describe what he could no longer see. But surgery in early 1982 restored some sight to his right eye, allowing him to observe sports unaided.

Later that year, Ricky, 29, the youngest of his three sons with his first wife, Geraldine, died of a drug overdose. In 1984, Mrs. Murray died of cancer. ''I don't mean to inflict my grief on you, but she deserves to be known by anyone who knows me,'' Mr. Murray wrote after her death. ''She has a right to this space more than any athlete who ever lived.''

Mr. Murray is survived by his second wife, Linda McCoy; three children, Pam Skeoch, Ted and Tony; two granddaughters and a stepson.

Re: Classic American West Coast Boxing

Posted: 27 Jul 2010, 22:42
by Rick Farris
Chuck1052 wrote:Jim Murray was a fine sportswriter, but his column contained some factual errors when the subject was boxing at times. For instance, he once wrote that Fidel La Barba was a fair featherweight as a professional fighter, but nothing about La Barba being a world champion and an all-time great as a flyweight. In a column about Tony Zale, Murray wrote that the former middleweight was a boxer-type during an early period of his career. Despite having some ring skills, Zale never would have been mistaken for Willie Pep at any time during his career.

- Chuck Johnston

Boxing History 101 . . .

I think of a well known boxing historian who shares history by validating his stories with direct quotes from his sources (i.e. Nat Fleischer, Ring Magazine, Nov. 1932, pag 14, paragraph-3, etc.) That makes it true in the eyes of this historian, whom you know Chuck. However, many of these so called quotes are written by men with an agenda, writers who are writing things not so much out of accuracy, but to serve their purpose. This historian often quotes writers who were on the take, paid to write their views in the favor of the promoter. Murray wrote about boxing from the past, but never claimed to be a historian. His stories, for the most part, were accurate historically and written with a style that I consider second to none. I know that La Barba was best known for his brilliance at flyweight. He was an Olympic gold medalist and a great world champ. After attending Stanford and obtaining his college degree, he returned to boxing as a featherweight, and was less successful than before. I agree, La Barba should be recognized for his success prior to College. There is nothing more irritating to me than a historian who shares history based on the writings of a journalist with an agenda. Nat Fleisher's writings were often extremely biased in favor of Madison Square Garden. A great historian was Fleischer, but also one with an agenda who not always tells the history as it really was. When contemporary "historians" quote Fleischer,they are often spreading BS, not actual history.

Re: Classic American West Coast Boxing

Posted: 27 Jul 2010, 23:16
by Expug
Randyman wrote:
Rick Farris wrote:Motown thru the eyes of Calvin . . .


When I arrived in Detroit, I was introduced to a local studio Teamster who would be driving our 40' production van that was packed with lighting equipment and cable. The man's name was Calvin, a slender, elderly black man who was on the quiet side, choosing his words carefully when engaging in conversation, rarely speaking unless spoken to.

Something drew me to Calvin. I suspected he was a sports fan, always wearing a Detroit Tigers baseball cap. I had a feeling that Calvin just might be a boxing fan. I rarely tell people that I used to be a boxer, but somebody on my crew will usaully let it be known. One day, I approached Calvin and made the comment, "You know, Detroit has one helluva boxing history. Some great fighter's came out of the Motor City." Calvin's eyes widened and a smile came to his face. "Yes it was. Joe Louis was from Detroit."

I wanted Calvin to know that my knowledge of Detroit's boxing history went deeper than Tommy Hearns and Emmanuel Steward's top-notch Kronk stable of a few years back. I asked Calvin if he knew of the Brewster Recreation Center, where Louis began boxing and our driver immediatly came to life. "I used to swim at the Brewster Center when I was a kid, and it's still there today."

I shared my knowledge of Brewster, and how when Joe Louis was boxing amateur, there was this small kid who used to carry the future Brown Bomber's gym bag for him. That young boy's name was Walker Smith, and he would one day become the great Sugar Ray Robinson. I also told him of trainer Eddie Futch, and how he and Louis would train together, and how Futch claimed the greatest pure boxer he ever saw was former light-heavy contender, Holman Williams. Futch claims that he would rather watch Holman Williams shadow box than watch others fight.

We talked of Futch's 60's-70's welterweight, Hedgeman Lewis, who came from Detroit to make a big name for himself in L.A. And we talked of Henry Hank, and others.

However, Calvin and I shared an interest in another Detroit product beyond boxers, and that was Motown Records, founded by another California Boxing Hall of Famer, Berry Gordy Jr.

"I'm gunna take you around Detroit to a few places off the beaten path, and show you where Berry Gordy and many of his future music legends came from. I'll show you where it all started, places you won't read about, places that only we in the neighborhood know", our driver promised me. Calvin had grown up less than two blocks from the home where Berry Gordy had lived as a child, right off of 12th Street. Today that neighborhood is like an overgrown ghost town, burned out and boarded up, a sad memory of better days in Detroit.

On my only day off while in the Motor City, Calvin kept his word and picked me up at the Motor City Hotel-Casino, where our crew was lodged. A few minutes later we were parked in front of the Brewster Recreation Center, and he pointed toward one of the building's windows. "That's where the boxing gym was, that's where all the best of Detroit worked out back in the day", Calvin told me. "I don't know what is in the room today, but it ain't boxing no more." The Center was closed that Sunday, so I was unable to look in.

About fifteen minutes later we were in front of the home where Berry Gordy grew up. Today it's pretty run down, over grown with plants, looking as if the grass had not been cut in decades, and it hadn't been. The house next door had partially burned down several years back, and was just left abandoned, charred remains crumbling around a brick chimney and cement front porch. The house on the otherside was boarded up. "That's just a crack den today", Calvin explained. "These drug addicts find shelter in these abandoned houses during the winter when it's bitter cold outside. The make a fire to keep warm and often end up burning the place down."

We moved on down 12th Street to "Berry Gordy Jr. Avenue", and we turn left. A few blocks down the road we come to a small, well maintained wooden building with a big sign out front, "Hitsville U.S.A." Calvin smiled proudly and pointed to the building. "That is where Berry Gordy started Motown Records, that was his first recording studio. That's where the Surpemes, Smokey Robinson, Marvin Gaye, The Temptations, Stevie Wonder, The Four Tops,and all the rest got there start."

I mentioned to Calvin that I'd heard Gordy sold the Motown label a few years back for a conservative $100 million (It had greater value, I'd heard?). Calvin began to laugh, "That ain't bad, considering he started it all with an original investment of $500."

Today "Hitsville U.S.A. is a museum honoring the Motown legends, however, it was closed on the day we passed by."

As we drove away, Calvin pointed at an old hospital on a corner, "That's where Aretha Franklin's father worked as a doctor, he delivered my younest sister, came right to our house and delivered Geraldine right on sofa in the den."

We drove on, and as Calvin relived his memories of the Motor City, I just sat and listened. It was a special day in my life, it was a day of history, the good history of a town that's best days are behind it.

I truly loved my 15 days in Detroit. I did the lighting on the pilot for ABC's new tuesday night police drama, "Detroit 1-8-7". I could have stayed on thru April, and completed the following 22 episodes, but I was not looking forward to spending months filming outside thru the Detroit winter. I was offered a Tom Hanks-Natalie Portman feature film, "Parthanon", which will begin production in two weeks in L.A. where we will film for four months, followed by a six-week location in Greece. It was an offer too good to refuse.

I liked my brief stay in the Motor City, and I pray for the City and it's people. The City and State of Michigan are bankrupt, and there is little hope for the future in the eyes of many. I'll keep my fingers crossed for the Motor City, where I have a great new friend in Calvin.


-Rick Farris
Rick, my friend, that was straight from the heart. What a great experience! Thanks for sharing that with us.

Randy
Great stuff Rick.
What an experience to get a tour like that from Calvin.
Good luck on the up and coming production. Greece is gonna be a great time.
Your description of the tour given to you by Calvin of Detroit got me thinking. You saw the history and character of Detroit and had great appreciation for a very tough gritty place.
Maybe it takes a fighter to see things this way. Lots of folks wouldnt want to leave their hotel room while in "The Motor City".
Not you,you wanted to experience it. That says alot.

Re: Classic American West Coast Boxing

Posted: 27 Jul 2010, 23:30
by Rick Farris
Expug wrote:
Randyman wrote:
Rick Farris wrote:Motown thru the eyes of Calvin . . .


When I arrived in Detroit, I was introduced to a local studio Teamster who would be driving our 40' production van that was packed with lighting equipment and cable. The man's name was Calvin, a slender, elderly black man who was on the quiet side, choosing his words carefully when engaging in conversation, rarely speaking unless spoken to.

Something drew me to Calvin. I suspected he was a sports fan, always wearing a Detroit Tigers baseball cap. I had a feeling that Calvin just might be a boxing fan. I rarely tell people that I used to be a boxer, but somebody on my crew will usaully let it be known. One day, I approached Calvin and made the comment, "You know, Detroit has one helluva boxing history. Some great fighter's came out of the Motor City." Calvin's eyes widened and a smile came to his face. "Yes it was. Joe Louis was from Detroit."

I wanted Calvin to know that my knowledge of Detroit's boxing history went deeper than Tommy Hearns and Emmanuel Steward's top-notch Kronk stable of a few years back. I asked Calvin if he knew of the Brewster Recreation Center, where Louis began boxing and our driver immediatly came to life. "I used to swim at the Brewster Center when I was a kid, and it's still there today."

I shared my knowledge of Brewster, and how when Joe Louis was boxing amateur, there was this small kid who used to carry the future Brown Bomber's gym bag for him. That young boy's name was Walker Smith, and he would one day become the great Sugar Ray Robinson. I also told him of trainer Eddie Futch, and how he and Louis would train together, and how Futch claimed the greatest pure boxer he ever saw was former light-heavy contender, Holman Williams. Futch claims that he would rather watch Holman Williams shadow box than watch others fight.

We talked of Futch's 60's-70's welterweight, Hedgeman Lewis, who came from Detroit to make a big name for himself in L.A. And we talked of Henry Hank, and others.

However, Calvin and I shared an interest in another Detroit product beyond boxers, and that was Motown Records, founded by another California Boxing Hall of Famer, Berry Gordy Jr.

"I'm gunna take you around Detroit to a few places off the beaten path, and show you where Berry Gordy and many of his future music legends came from. I'll show you where it all started, places you won't read about, places that only we in the neighborhood know", our driver promised me. Calvin had grown up less than two blocks from the home where Berry Gordy had lived as a child, right off of 12th Street. Today that neighborhood is like an overgrown ghost town, burned out and boarded up, a sad memory of better days in Detroit.

On my only day off while in the Motor City, Calvin kept his word and picked me up at the Motor City Hotel-Casino, where our crew was lodged. A few minutes later we were parked in front of the Brewster Recreation Center, and he pointed toward one of the building's windows. "That's where the boxing gym was, that's where all the best of Detroit worked out back in the day", Calvin told me. "I don't know what is in the room today, but it ain't boxing no more." The Center was closed that Sunday, so I was unable to look in.

About fifteen minutes later we were in front of the home where Berry Gordy grew up. Today it's pretty run down, over grown with plants, looking as if the grass had not been cut in decades, and it hadn't been. The house next door had partially burned down several years back, and was just left abandoned, charred remains crumbling around a brick chimney and cement front porch. The house on the otherside was boarded up. "That's just a crack den today", Calvin explained. "These drug addicts find shelter in these abandoned houses during the winter when it's bitter cold outside. The make a fire to keep warm and often end up burning the place down."

We moved on down 12th Street to "Berry Gordy Jr. Avenue", and we turn left. A few blocks down the road we come to a small, well maintained wooden building with a big sign out front, "Hitsville U.S.A." Calvin smiled proudly and pointed to the building. "That is where Berry Gordy started Motown Records, that was his first recording studio. That's where the Surpemes, Smokey Robinson, Marvin Gaye, The Temptations, Stevie Wonder, The Four Tops,and all the rest got there start."

I mentioned to Calvin that I'd heard Gordy sold the Motown label a few years back for a conservative $100 million (It had greater value, I'd heard?). Calvin began to laugh, "That ain't bad, considering he started it all with an original investment of $500."

Today "Hitsville U.S.A. is a museum honoring the Motown legends, however, it was closed on the day we passed by."

As we drove away, Calvin pointed at an old hospital on a corner, "That's where Aretha Franklin's father worked as a doctor, he delivered my younest sister, came right to our house and delivered Geraldine right on sofa in the den."

We drove on, and as Calvin relived his memories of the Motor City, I just sat and listened. It was a special day in my life, it was a day of history, the good history of a town that's best days are behind it.

I truly loved my 15 days in Detroit. I did the lighting on the pilot for ABC's new tuesday night police drama, "Detroit 1-8-7". I could have stayed on thru April, and completed the following 22 episodes, but I was not looking forward to spending months filming outside thru the Detroit winter. I was offered a Tom Hanks-Natalie Portman feature film, "Parthanon", which will begin production in two weeks in L.A. where we will film for four months, followed by a six-week location in Greece. It was an offer too good to refuse.

I liked my brief stay in the Motor City, and I pray for the City and it's people. The City and State of Michigan are bankrupt, and there is little hope for the future in the eyes of many. I'll keep my fingers crossed for the Motor City, where I have a great new friend in Calvin.


-Rick Farris
Rick, my friend, that was straight from the heart. What a great experience! Thanks for sharing that with us.

Randy
Great stuff Rick.
What an experience to get a tour like that from Calvin.
Good luck on the up and coming production. Greece is gonna be a great time.
Your description of the tour given to you by Calvin of Detroit got me thinking. You saw the history and character of Detroit and had great appreciation for a very tough gritty place.
Maybe it takes a fighter to see things this way. Lots of folks wouldnt want to leave their hotel room while in "The Motor City".
Not you,you wanted to experience it. That says alot.

Brian, what I was also looking forward to was meeting up with you in Detroit when the Black Hawks came to town. One of my favorite pictures is the one of you hoisting up the Stanley Cup after Chicago whipped the Red Wings. Maybe we'll have a chance to do that some place, some time in the future. And you are right, most of the crew was too intimidated of Detroit's reputation to venutre out on the town alone. I know where I do and don't belong, you have to use common sense. But I refuse to be a part of a life that I cannot live.

Re: Classic American West Coast Boxing

Posted: 27 Jul 2010, 23:35
by Rick Farris
This is Detoit, past & present . . .

Requiem for Detroit
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yIgC5whSP8E

I now understand why men who build aircraft, like Randy, are members of the United Auto Worker's union.
Lots of history in this documentary on Detroit.

Re: Classic American West Coast Boxing

Posted: 28 Jul 2010, 00:11
by CNorkusJr
As a former NYC firefighter, it is well known that Detroit has in its history, the "Hell"or "Devil's" Night fires which encompassed the entire city every Halloween night for decades. This is not your usual reckless burning of certain properties during riots, but rather an institutional ritual which would include dozens of random burnings throughout the night on Oct 31. It went on for years, and even with beefed up patrols could not be prevented.Many perished over the years from this event.

I think that this unfortunate blight on Detroit history has ended today, but I remember various firefighters from major cities that had off on their own time would volunteer and get to Detroit by hook or by crook to assist their "brothers" where needed.
I have not heard about the "burnings" for some time now (10 yrs ?), but mainly because there is little left to burn.
Rick,I am sure you seen many of the charred ruins blocks which still stand today.

On a different note, in my father's boxing scrapbooks, are a few articles from San Diego's Jack Murphy. Having read them a few times, I felt he had a nice old style boxing writing language. Nothing out of the ordinary, and I am not too sure if he accepted payola for the boxing bylines, but he was informative and made good points about the fighters and their up and coming West Coast bouts. Not too much fluff. I would have to assume that his credentials were noteworthy to have a stadium named after him for awhile.
His brother Bob Murphy announced many years as a NY Mets legend here in NY until he passed away. Still announcing is another California resident HOF, Ralph Kiner, who still does about a dozen color commentary casts a year for the Mets.

Re: Classic American West Coast Boxing

Posted: 28 Jul 2010, 01:12
by Chuck1052
Nat Fleischer was a very energetic individual who was in his element as an editor and publisher of Ring Magazine, boosting the sport of boxing during many decades. It is true that he was interested in the history of boxing, writing numerous books on the subject. But I must say that a number of his books were loaded with factual errors, especially his "Black Dynamite" series, which contained biographical sketches of many top black fighters who were active before the late 1930s.

The records of oldtime fighters in the early Ring Record Books often were incomplete or inaccurate. Many of such records were often culled from earlier record books, notably the ones put out by T. S. Andrews. But it is my understanding that Lew Eskin did a terrific job in making sure that the records of active fighters in the Ring Record Books ca. 1950.

- Chuck Johnston

Re: Classic American West Coast Boxing

Posted: 28 Jul 2010, 01:22
by Rick Farris
CNorkusJr wrote:As a former NYC firefighter, it is well known that Detroit has in its history, the "Hell"or "Devil's" Night fires which encompassed the entire city every Halloween night for decades. This is not your usual reckless burning of certain properties during riots, but rather an institutional ritual which would include dozens of random burnings throughout the night on Oct 31. It went on for years, and even with beefed up patrols could not be prevented.Many perished over the years from this event.

I think that this unfortunate blight on Detroit history has ended today, but I remember various firefighters from major cities that had off on their own time would volunteer and get to Detroit by hook or by crook to assist their "brothers" where needed.
I have not heard about the "burnings" for some time now (10 yrs ?), but mainly because there is little left to burn.
Rick,I am sure you seen many of the charred ruins blocks which still stand today.

On a different note, in my father's boxing scrapbooks, are a few articles from San Diego's Jack Murphy. Having read them a few times, I felt he had a nice old style boxing writing language. Nothing out of the ordinary, and I am not too sure if he accepted payola for the boxing bylines, but he was informative and made good points about the fighters and their up and coming West Coast bouts. Not too much fluff. I would have to assume that his credentials were noteworthy to have a stadium named after him for awhile.
His brother Bob Murphy announced many years as a NY Mets legend here in NY until he passed away. Still announcing is another California resident HOF, Ralph Kiner, who still does about a dozen color commentary casts a year for the Mets.
Hell's Fire . . .

Charlie . . . Thanks for this information. I recall Calvin describing the riots of 1967, and how in later years the burning would continue randomly on Halloween, but I was unaware of what he was referring to. Yes, we filmed in a number of residential and commercial areas that have buildings burned out. They are not torn down, or rebuilt, just left to decay for decades. Detroit is also the murder capitol of the nation, thus the subject of this TV series. While we were filming in Highland Park, a Detroit suburb where the Clint Eastwood movie Gran Torino was filmed, we witnessed about a half dozen police cars rushing thru the neighborhood with sirens screaming. A grandmother had just attacked her daughter-in-law with an ax, killing her in front of the woman's 3-year-old grandson. A hostage situation had taken place before the police captured the grandmother and rescued the 3-year-old. I was unaware what the commotion was about until I'd returned to my room and watched the evening news. This took place about two blocks from our film set. About every other home in the neighborhood was either burned out or boarded up. Henry Ford had created Highland Park during the heyday of the auto industry, and in it's best years was home to 50,000 people. Today, less than 10,000 remain.

In my opinion, no public servant is more courageous than fire fighters. Unlike police, you men step into harms way unarmed, often the targets of shooters in riot situations. And never was this more evident than what your crew did on 9-11. We talk a lot about courage on this thread, but fire fighters are true heros. :TU:

Re: Classic American West Coast Boxing

Posted: 28 Jul 2010, 01:53
by Rick Farris
Chuck1052 wrote:Nat Fleischer was a very energetic individual who was in his element as an editor and publisher of Ring Magazine, boosting the sport of boxing during many decades. It is true that he was interested in the history of boxing, writing numerous books on the subject. But I must say that a number of his books were loaded with factual errors, especially his "Black Dynamite" series, which contained biographical sketches of many top black fighters who were active before the late 1930s.

The records of oldtime fighters in the early Ring Record Books often were incomplete or inaccurate. Many of such records were often culled from earlier record books, notably the ones put out by T. S. Andrews. But it is my understanding that Lew Eskin did a terrific job in making sure that the records of active fighters in the Ring Record Books ca. 1950.

- Chuck Johnston
Thank you, Chuck. Your historcal knowledge & input is greatly appreciated here.

Re: Classic American West Coast Boxing

Posted: 28 Jul 2010, 10:29
by raylawpc
Chuck1052 wrote:Jim Murray was a fine sportswriter, but his column contained some factual errors when the subject was boxing at times. For instance, he once wrote that Fidel La Barba was a fair featherweight as a professional fighter, but nothing about La Barba being a world champion and an all-time great as a flyweight. In a column about Tony Zale, Murray wrote that the former middleweight was a boxer-type during an early period of his career. Despite having some ring skills, Zale never would have been mistaken for Willie Pep at any time during his career.

- Chuck Johnston
Many columnists are like that - how well the story is told becomes more important than whether the facts are absolutely correct. Taking "poetic license" seems to apply to sports columnists, too. They seldom write blatantly incorrect things, but they will stretch the facts if it means they get to turn a particularly memorable or witty phrase.

Sometimes even in academia. Your comments make me recall a professor of ancient history, who was known for his story-telling ability and eloquence in the classroom. During one lecture, he was waxing along describing some event in Roman history and a student in the back of the classroom raised his hand.

"Professor - is that really true?"

"I dunno," the professor responded. "But it sure sounds good."

Some sports columnists have adopted that philosophy. But that doesn't mean I don't enjoy reading their work. Jim Murphy was a great wordsmith - even if he occasionally got the facts wrong.

Re: Classic American West Coast Boxing

Posted: 28 Jul 2010, 10:57
by raylawpc
Rick Farris wrote:
Chuck1052 wrote:Jim Murray was a fine sportswriter, but his column contained some factual errors when the subject was boxing at times. For instance, he once wrote that Fidel La Barba was a fair featherweight as a professional fighter, but nothing about La Barba being a world champion and an all-time great as a flyweight. In a column about Tony Zale, Murray wrote that the former middleweight was a boxer-type during an early period of his career. Despite having some ring skills, Zale never would have been mistaken for Willie Pep at any time during his career.

- Chuck Johnston

Boxing History 101 . . .

I think of a well known boxing historian who shares history by validating his stories with direct quotes from his sources (i.e. Nat Fleischer, Ring Magazine, Nov. 1932, pag 14, paragraph-3, etc.) That makes it true in the eyes of this historian, whom you know Chuck. However, many of these so called quotes are written by men with an agenda, writers who are writing things not so much out of accuracy, but to serve their purpose. This historian often quotes writers who were on the take, paid to write their views in the favor of the promoter. Murray wrote about boxing from the past, but never claimed to be a historian. His stories, for the most part, were accurate historically and written with a style that I consider second to none. I know that La Barba was best known for his brilliance at flyweight. He was an Olympic gold medalist and a great world champ. After attending Stanford and obtaining his college degree, he returned to boxing as a featherweight, and was less successful than before. I agree, La Barba should be recognized for his success prior to College. There is nothing more irritating to me than a historian who shares history based on the writings of a journalist with an agenda. Nat Fleisher's writings were often extremely biased in favor of Madison Square Garden. A great historian was Fleischer, but also one with an agenda who not always tells the history as it really was. When contemporary "historians" quote Fleischer,they are often spreading BS, not actual history.
It depends on how you define history, I suppose. It is important to differentiate history and historiography. The first refers to the events that have taken place in the past, and the second, to writing about events. To ask whether a book is historical or not is a complex question. It could refer to the intention of an author or to his success in achieving his intention. A book may intend to be historical, but not be a history textbook in the modern sense of the word. In other words, historical writing is different than a videotaped representation of the past in that it involves a historian who interprets these events for his audience. All history writing is subjective in that it owes its shape to its author’s activity in selecting, deleting and communicating material. I don’t think this subjectivity invalidates historical intention; rather, the interpreter of the historian must take into account the author’s perspective on the past. So, for example, with Nat Fleischer you have to take into account his perspective – which you correctly believe was to promote boxing at Madison Square Garden and which I believe was also to promote boxing generally (after all, he had magazines to sell worldwide). Jim Murray’s primary purpose as a columnist was to write columns that were entertaining, and would sell newspapers. But that doesn’t mean you necessarily ignore what they have written. To do that would be to throw out the baby with the bath. Buried among Nat Fleischer’s pro-boxing/pro-Madison Square Garden “BS” are some valuable historical nuggets. You just have to analysis what he has written to find it.

Re: Classic American West Coast Boxing

Posted: 28 Jul 2010, 12:28
by Panzerfaust
Great story on your meeting with Calvin and your trip through Detroit Rick :TU:
this combined with Charlie telling bout the fires made for great informative reading.


Ill be changing plane in Pittsburgh , unfortunatly i only get one hour there so no time to look around :witzend:
though i bet ill get to see more than enough in L.A. These last days at work are just so slow :lol:

Re: Classic American West Coast Boxing

Posted: 28 Jul 2010, 14:24
by Rick Farris
raylawpc wrote:
Rick Farris wrote:
Chuck1052 wrote:Jim Murray was a fine sportswriter, but his column contained some factual errors when the subject was boxing at times. For instance, he once wrote that Fidel La Barba was a fair featherweight as a professional fighter, but nothing about La Barba being a world champion and an all-time great as a flyweight. In a column about Tony Zale, Murray wrote that the former middleweight was a boxer-type during an early period of his career. Despite having some ring skills, Zale never would have been mistaken for Willie Pep at any time during his career.

- Chuck Johnston

Boxing History 101 . . .

I think of a well known boxing historian who shares history by validating his stories with direct quotes from his sources (i.e. Nat Fleischer, Ring Magazine, Nov. 1932, pag 14, paragraph-3, etc.) That makes it true in the eyes of this historian, whom you know Chuck. However, many of these so called quotes are written by men with an agenda, writers who are writing things not so much out of accuracy, but to serve their purpose. This historian often quotes writers who were on the take, paid to write their views in the favor of the promoter. Murray wrote about boxing from the past, but never claimed to be a historian. His stories, for the most part, were accurate historically and written with a style that I consider second to none. I know that La Barba was best known for his brilliance at flyweight. He was an Olympic gold medalist and a great world champ. After attending Stanford and obtaining his college degree, he returned to boxing as a featherweight, and was less successful than before. I agree, La Barba should be recognized for his success prior to College. There is nothing more irritating to me than a historian who shares history based on the writings of a journalist with an agenda. Nat Fleisher's writings were often extremely biased in favor of Madison Square Garden. A great historian was Fleischer, but also one with an agenda who not always tells the history as it really was. When contemporary "historians" quote Fleischer,they are often spreading BS, not actual history.
It depends on how you define history, I suppose. It is important to differentiate history and historiography. The first refers to the events that have taken place in the past, and the second, to writing about events. To ask whether a book is historical or not is a complex question. It could refer to the intention of an author or to his success in achieving his intention. A book may intend to be historical, but not be a history textbook in the modern sense of the word. In other words, historical writing is different than a videotaped representation of the past in that it involves a historian who interprets these events for his audience. All history writing is subjective in that it owes its shape to its author’s activity in selecting, deleting and communicating material. I don’t think this subjectivity invalidates historical intention; rather, the interpreter of the historian must take into account the author’s perspective on the past. So, for example, with Nat Fleischer you have to take into account his perspective – which you correctly believe was to promote boxing at Madison Square Garden and which I believe was also to promote boxing generally (after all, he had magazines to sell worldwide). Jim Murray’s primary purpose as a columnist was to write columns that were entertaining, and would sell newspapers. But that doesn’t mean you necessarily ignore what they have written. To do that would be to throw out the baby with the bath. Buried among Nat Fleischer’s pro-boxing/pro-Madison Square Garden “BS” are some valuable historical nuggets. You just have to analysis what he has written to find it.

Agreed, Tom. My words relating to Nat Fleisher were not intended to discredit his writing, only to point out that things were at times slanted in favor of his agenda. With regard to a number of sports writers of eras past, false information was passed freely in a way that has altered the truth with regard to boxing history. With regard to this, Jim Murray is not guilty of such writing, however, as Chuck pointed out, he may not have represented the boxers entire career correctly.

Re: Classic American West Coast Boxing

Posted: 28 Jul 2010, 15:42
by raylawpc
Rick Farris wrote:
raylawpc wrote:
Rick Farris wrote:
Boxing History 101 . . .

I think of a well known boxing historian who shares history by validating his stories with direct quotes from his sources (i.e. Nat Fleischer, Ring Magazine, Nov. 1932, pag 14, paragraph-3, etc.) That makes it true in the eyes of this historian, whom you know Chuck. However, many of these so called quotes are written by men with an agenda, writers who are writing things not so much out of accuracy, but to serve their purpose. This historian often quotes writers who were on the take, paid to write their views in the favor of the promoter. Murray wrote about boxing from the past, but never claimed to be a historian. His stories, for the most part, were accurate historically and written with a style that I consider second to none. I know that La Barba was best known for his brilliance at flyweight. He was an Olympic gold medalist and a great world champ. After attending Stanford and obtaining his college degree, he returned to boxing as a featherweight, and was less successful than before. I agree, La Barba should be recognized for his success prior to College. There is nothing more irritating to me than a historian who shares history based on the writings of a journalist with an agenda. Nat Fleisher's writings were often extremely biased in favor of Madison Square Garden. A great historian was Fleischer, but also one with an agenda who not always tells the history as it really was. When contemporary "historians" quote Fleischer,they are often spreading BS, not actual history.
It depends on how you define history, I suppose. It is important to differentiate history and historiography. The first refers to the events that have taken place in the past, and the second, to writing about events. To ask whether a book is historical or not is a complex question. It could refer to the intention of an author or to his success in achieving his intention. A book may intend to be historical, but not be a history textbook in the modern sense of the word. In other words, historical writing is different than a videotaped representation of the past in that it involves a historian who interprets these events for his audience. All history writing is subjective in that it owes its shape to its author’s activity in selecting, deleting and communicating material. I don’t think this subjectivity invalidates historical intention; rather, the interpreter of the historian must take into account the author’s perspective on the past. So, for example, with Nat Fleischer you have to take into account his perspective – which you correctly believe was to promote boxing at Madison Square Garden and which I believe was also to promote boxing generally (after all, he had magazines to sell worldwide). Jim Murray’s primary purpose as a columnist was to write columns that were entertaining, and would sell newspapers. But that doesn’t mean you necessarily ignore what they have written. To do that would be to throw out the baby with the bath. Buried among Nat Fleischer’s pro-boxing/pro-Madison Square Garden “BS” are some valuable historical nuggets. You just have to analysis what he has written to find it.

Agreed, Tom. My words relating to Nat Fleisher were not intended to discredit his writing, only to point out that things were at times slanted in favor of his agenda. With regard to a number of sports writers of eras past, false information was passed freely in a way that has altered the truth with regard to boxing history. With regard to this, Jim Murray is not guilty of such writing, however, as Chuck pointed out, he may not have represented the boxers entire career correctly.
Yes, I was not disagreeing with you either - just expanding upon your comments. All historians have an agenda.

Re: Classic American West Coast Boxing

Posted: 28 Jul 2010, 15:53
by raylawpc
But I hasten to add, even Jim Murray had "an agenda." His was to sell newspapers. That meant he was selective in his writing. For example, he may have known about LaBarba's outstanding flyweight career (indeed, he may have known a lot about it), but he chose instead to write about LaBarba's featherweight activities because that's where the more interesting story lay. - a story his readers would find interesting and, thus, would buy newspapers to read.

Re: Classic American West Coast Boxing

Posted: 28 Jul 2010, 17:52
by Rick Farris
raylawpc wrote:
Rick Farris wrote:
raylawpc wrote: It depends on how you define history, I suppose. It is important to differentiate history and historiography. The first refers to the events that have taken place in the past, and the second, to writing about events. To ask whether a book is historical or not is a complex question. It could refer to the intention of an author or to his success in achieving his intention. A book may intend to be historical, but not be a history textbook in the modern sense of the word. In other words, historical writing is different than a videotaped representation of the past in that it involves a historian who interprets these events for his audience. All history writing is subjective in that it owes its shape to its author’s activity in selecting, deleting and communicating material. I don’t think this subjectivity invalidates historical intention; rather, the interpreter of the historian must take into account the author’s perspective on the past. So, for example, with Nat Fleischer you have to take into account his perspective – which you correctly believe was to promote boxing at Madison Square Garden and which I believe was also to promote boxing generally (after all, he had magazines to sell worldwide). Jim Murray’s primary purpose as a columnist was to write columns that were entertaining, and would sell newspapers. But that doesn’t mean you necessarily ignore what they have written. To do that would be to throw out the baby with the bath. Buried among Nat Fleischer’s pro-boxing/pro-Madison Square Garden “BS” are some valuable historical nuggets. You just have to analysis what he has written to find it.

Agreed, Tom. My words relating to Nat Fleisher were not intended to discredit his writing, only to point out that things were at times slanted in favor of his agenda. With regard to a number of sports writers of eras past, false information was passed freely in a way that has altered the truth with regard to boxing history. With regard to this, Jim Murray is not guilty of such writing, however, as Chuck pointed out, he may not have represented the boxers entire career correctly.
Yes, I was not disagreeing with you either - just expanding upon your comments. All historians have an agenda.

True. I have an agenda. :OhYes:

Re: Classic American West Coast Boxing

Posted: 28 Jul 2010, 18:48
by Rick Farris
raylawpc wrote:But I hasten to add, even Jim Murray had "an agenda." His was to sell newspapers. That meant he was selective in his writing. For example, he may have known about LaBarba's outstanding flyweight career (indeed, he may have known a lot about it), but he chose instead to write about LaBarba's featherweight activities because that's where the more interesting story lay. - a story his readers would find interesting and, thus, would buy newspapers to read.
I was always partial to Jim Murray's column when it came to boxing. However, I loved what he'd write about USC Football when the trojans were at their best. I remember an article he wrote when top reanked Oklahoma came west to take on the Trojans at the Coliseum. It was the early 80's if I remember correctly, and SC's tailback was a senior named Marcus Allen. I attended the game with my wife with tickets Bob Seagren had been given but couldn't use. Great seats, Oklahoma favored and when my wife and I walked across Figuroa Street to the Coliseum, the OK crowd was rowdy. The walked proud, with their chests puffed out, cocky what they were going to do with SC in their front yard. After Marcus Allen ran over Oklahoma, thru them, around them for TD's and lots of yards, USC sent Oklahoma home with a loss. I recall as we crossed Figuroa on our way back to our car, we saw the OK fans, their red caps and T-Shirts, walking down Fig with a shell-shocked look in their faces.

I couldn't wait to read Murray. Something told me he'd comment on the deflated Okies. If I remember correctly, he did.
Tom, no disrespect toward Oklahoma as my beloved grandfather was an Okie.

However, Murray was at his best when the Trojans faced Ohio State in the Rose Bowl. It was back in the early 70's. Woody Hayes was OSU's head coach. John McKay was the Trojans leader.
Murray would describe the Buckeye fans who made the journey to Pasadena as a "strange lot". He wrote, you could always tell the Buckeye fans, they all sat in a little sction on the far end of the stadium, their hair parted in the middle, anxiously looking thru the crowd, hoping to see Bessie Love, or the Gish Sisters walk thru the crowd. He could be classicly brutal, and he did it with so much class you never took it that way.

I loved it, he was on the right side when it came to local coverage.

Re: Classic American West Coast Boxing

Posted: 28 Jul 2010, 20:08
by raylawpc
Rick Farris wrote:
raylawpc wrote:But I hasten to add, even Jim Murray had "an agenda." His was to sell newspapers. That meant he was selective in his writing. For example, he may have known about LaBarba's outstanding flyweight career (indeed, he may have known a lot about it), but he chose instead to write about LaBarba's featherweight activities because that's where the more interesting story lay. - a story his readers would find interesting and, thus, would buy newspapers to read.
I was always partial to Jim Murray's column when it came to boxing. However, I loved what he'd write about USC Football when the trojans were at their best. I remember an article he wrote when top reanked Oklahoma came west to take on the Trojans at the Coliseum. It was the early 80's if I remember correctly, and SC's tailback was a senior named Marcus Allen. I attended the game with my wife with tickets Bob Seagren had been given but couldn't use. Great seats, Oklahoma favored and when my wife and I walked across Figuroa Street to the Coliseum, the OK crowd was rowdy. The walked proud, with their chests puffed out, cocky what they were going to do with SC in their front yard. After Marcus Allen ran over Oklahoma, thru them, around them for TD's and lots of yards, USC sent Oklahoma home with a loss. I recall as we crossed Figuroa on our way back to our car, we saw the OK fans, their red caps and T-Shirts, walking down Fig with a shell-shocked look in their faces.

I couldn't wait to read Murray. Something told me he'd comment on the deflated Okies. If I remember correctly, he did.
Tom, no disrespect toward Oklahoma as my beloved grandfather was an Okie.

However, Murray was at his best when the Trojans faced Ohio State in the Rose Bowl. It was back in the early 70's. Woody Hayes was OSU's head coach. John McKay was the Trojans leader.
Murray would describe the Buckeye fans who made the journey to Pasadena as a "strange lot". He wrote, you could always tell the Buckeye fans, they all sat in a little sction on the far end of the stadium, their hair parted in the middle, anxiously looking thru the crowd, hoping to see Bessie Love, or the Gish Sisters walk thru the crowd. He could be classicly brutal, and he did it with so much class you never took it that way.

I loved it, he was on the right side when it came to local coverage.
It's hard to offend me when it comes to OU . . . I'm not a fan. (Now my wife on the other hand . . . be careful!! :shame: :shame: )

That said, as I recall the 1981 game was a close one, and USC won in the waning minutes of the game and then only by three points, I think.

Re: Classic American West Coast Boxing

Posted: 29 Jul 2010, 09:56
by kikibalt
Antonio Margarito applies to California for reinstated boxing license
July 28, 2010

Margarito_250 Disciplined boxer Antonio Margarito on Wednesday filed an application to have his license to fight reinstated by the California State Athletic Commission, more than 17 months since it was revoked when officials confiscated "loaded" hand wraps from the Tijuana fighter before his failed world welterweight title defense at Staples Center in January 2009.

Margarito's promoter, Bob Arum, told The Times, "We've asked for this to be heard on an expedited basis," before the commission's next scheduled meeting Sept. 20 in Los Angeles.

Margarito has agreed to fight Manny Pacquiao Nov. 13 at a site yet to be determined. Arum doesn't want Margarito to fight Pacquiaio in California, but when the promoter sought to have Margarito re-licensed in Nevada earlier this month, commissioners there ruled to table their decision until Margarito first attempted to have his appeal heard where the license was originally stripped.

A Pacquiao-Margarito bout would challenge the May Floyd Mayweather Jr.-Shane Mosley bout to emerge as the most lucrative fight of the year, and Arum said he feels obliged to give his home state Nevada a shot at landing the bout.

However, the promoter said Wednesday that "a half dozen states have said they will grant us a license without a decision by California," not including Nevada. The favorites among other U.S. destinations are believed to be Texas, where Pacquiao drew a crowd of 51,000 for a March bout against lesser-known Joshua Clottey, and Atlantic City, N.J., which would cater to the big gamblers who've descended upon Las Vegas in Pacquiao's prior fights there.

Margarito, who returned to fighting in May in a bout in Mexico, has since fired his suspended trainer, Javier Capetillo, who claimed at the February 2009 California commission meeting that plaster-coated pads ended up inside Margarito's hand wraps accidentally, and that the former two-time world welterweight champion had no knowledge of wrongdoing.

--Lance Pugmire
latimes.com

Re: Classic American West Coast Boxing

Posted: 29 Jul 2010, 11:11
by Chuck1052
While doing research, I learned not to trust newspapers or boxing books completely when it comes to historical accuracy, especially when the content was not about contemporary events. Unlike many historians or researchers, Nat Fleischer, ghostwriters, newspapermen often didn't have the resources or time to do the in-depth research or fact-checking needed to make articles or books as accurate as possible.

But I will say that I used many unreliable sources of information as leads, notably Wikipedia. Then I try to verify such leads with what I consider more reliable sources.

- Chuck Johnston