Page 3 of 8

Re: Dodson v Smith - who wins this one?

Posted: 28 Feb 2010, 18:09
by doyouknowwhoiknow
avidlemon wrote:
doyouknowwhoiknow wrote:
teddy007 wrote:I did feel Dodson did take the easy way out in the Froch fight. Smith PTS.
world champ are you havin a laugh .tony got done fair comment but ....do you think paul could take the same .paul smith would take out carl froch did you like the sound of that. .....good .... thats the closest smith will get to a world champ. come on tony dodson . bring it on
what on earth are you going on about?
sorry did not explain .....you all go on about the froch fight... he is a world champ tony has been there. tell me is paul going to bring what carl did .

Re: Dodson v Smith - who wins this one?

Posted: 28 Feb 2010, 19:24
by $wifty
doyouknowwhoiknow wrote:
avidlemon wrote:
doyouknowwhoiknow wrote: world champ are you havin a laugh .tony got done fair comment but ....do you think paul could take the same .paul smith would take out carl froch did you like the sound of that. .....good .... thats the closest smith will get to a world champ. come on tony dodson . bring it on
what on earth are you going on about?
sorry did not explain .....you all go on about the froch fight... he is a world champ tony has been there. tell me is paul going to bring what carl did .

haha.....just coz Froch is now a World Champ means nothing! I could get in with a World Champ tomorrow and spew it, no problem! Thats the whole point....people think he spewed it. And...does Paul have to bring what Froch did? Did Quigley bring that? Did the others that also stopped Dodson? Nope! I dont mind a bit of banter at all....its part an parcel. Just pointing out a few things myself thats all.....entitled to my opinion like the rest surely :OhYes: Not long to go now....AND STILL 8)

Re: Dodson v Smith - who wins this one?

Posted: 28 Feb 2010, 20:32
by doyouknowwhoiknow
$wifty wrote:
doyouknowwhoiknow wrote:
avidlemon wrote: what on earth are you going on about?
sorry did not explain .....you all go on about the froch fight... he is a world champ tony has been there. tell me is paul going to bring what carl did .
and new .................. my opinion of course

haha.....just coz Froch is now a World Champ means nothing! I could get in with a World Champ tomorrow and spew it, no problem! Thats the whole point....people think he spewed it. And...does Paul have to bring what Froch did? Did Quigley bring that? Did the others that also stopped Dodson? Nope! I dont mind a bit of banter at all....its part an parcel. Just pointing out a few things myself thats all.....entitled to my opinion like the rest surely :OhYes: Not long to go now....AND STILL 8)

Re: Dodson v Smith - who wins this one?

Posted: 01 Mar 2010, 06:02
by avidlemon
doyouknowwhoiknow wrote:
avidlemon wrote:
doyouknowwhoiknow wrote: world champ are you havin a laugh .tony got done fair comment but ....do you think paul could take the same .paul smith would take out carl froch did you like the sound of that. .....good .... thats the closest smith will get to a world champ. come on tony dodson . bring it on
what on earth are you going on about?
sorry did not explain .....you all go on about the froch fight... he is a world champ tony has been there. tell me is paul going to bring what carl did .
that's not the point mate. The point is that Tony went in with a future wold champ, and was found out. Paul beat quigley, who dodson lost to. Quigley lost to paul, and paul didn't have the problems with quigley that dodson had with quigley at some points in the fight (although i would concede dodson fought well against quigley) and by that i mean, paul didn't get put down, and wasn't troubled in terms of his punching power etc.
All of that doesn't neccesarily mean anything, as each fight is different, but it is a good indicator as to how things will pan out.
And as i have stated before, dodson seems to be relying on what he sees as a size advantage in this fight. He has got height on paul, and that is about it to be honest.
smigga will win this. no doubt

Re: Dodson v Smith - who wins this one?

Posted: 01 Mar 2010, 07:53
by Samuel Brooks
doyouknowwhoiknow wrote:
forcefraser wrote:Great fight. Both up for it and in top shape.

Controversial points decision for Smith
again
MUG!! Smith beat Quigley fair and square, and will smash Dodson within 8

Re: Dodson v Smith - who wins this one?

Posted: 01 Mar 2010, 18:32
by leeharding
terrdilk wrote:
diggler wrote:who would you want to fight and who do you think youve got a better chance of winning
I would fight either of them and I think I would beat both of them but styles make fights an I think me an pauls fight would gel better being a war! But wot sort of fighter would I be if I didn't believe in myself I now pauls a favorate of yours but believe me I'm well capable of beating them both hopfully on of them will give me the opportunity to prove it
i personally think smigga would do u some serious damage nothing against u but i do really think that mate i rekkon u would have a gd night against dodson tho :TU:

Re: Dodson v Smith - who wins this one?

Posted: 01 Mar 2010, 18:55
by terrdilk
leeharding wrote:
terrdilk wrote:
diggler wrote:who would you want to fight and who do you think youve got a better chance of winning
I would fight either of them and I think I would beat both of them but styles make fights an I think me an pauls fight would gel better being a war! But wot sort of fighter would I be if I didn't believe in myself I now pauls a favorate of yours but believe me I'm well capable of beating them both hopfully on of them will give me the opportunity to prove it
i personally think smigga would do u some serious damage nothing against u but i do really think that mate i rekkon u would have a gd night against dodson tho :TU:
Mate everyone entitled to an opioninon but why would he cause me serious damage? :shame: Mate honestly get a grip I'd beat Paul and I beat dodson an get your head out of smiggas arse I don't understand how u could make that comment based on wot? Like I said everyones entitled to an opinion mate but to dismiss me like that is a big mistake :shame:

Re: Dodson v Smith - who wins this one?

Posted: 01 Mar 2010, 19:19
by leeharding
to fight and who do you think youve got a better chance of winning[/quote]
I would fight either of them and I think I would beat both of them but styles make fights an I think me an pauls fight would gel better being a war! But wot sort of fighter would I be if I didn't believe in myself I now pauls a favorate of yours but believe me I'm well capable of beating them both hopfully on of them will give me the opportunity to prove it[/quote]

i personally think smigga would do u some serious damage nothing against u but i do really think that mate i rekkon u would have a gd night against dodson tho :TU:[/quote]
Mate everyone entitled to an opioninon but why would he cause me serious damage? :shame: Mate honestly get a grip I'd beat Paul and I beat dodson an get your head out of smiggas arse I don't understand how u could make that comment based on wot? Like I said everyones entitled to an opinion mate but to dismiss me like that is a big mistake :shame:[/quote]

wo wo wo lad dont think for one minute ide dismiss u im a fan of ures we have something in common AL basra shithole so i do want to see u do well lad i really do i just think its abit to soon for u 2 mix it up with paul at this moment in time, people say pauls lazy but ill tell u what it is lack of motivation and now he has that lonsdale belt i think were gonna see the best off smigga but theres no reaon y u cant be up there i just think not now bit more experience needed . :TU:

Re: Dodson v Smith - who wins this one?

Posted: 01 Mar 2010, 19:24
by liamsmith88
here we go, another 1 jumpin on the ban wagon, id beat paul an dodson, u openin ur mouth now to get a shot? seems like uv only opended it since u done wel with that crab adamu, which to be fair, thought u easy won it, but i really think, u no deep down ur not ready 4 any ov paul dodson or quigley.

Re: Dodson v Smith - who wins this one?

Posted: 01 Mar 2010, 19:36
by leeharding
liamsmith88 wrote:here we go, another 1 jumpin on the ban wagon, id beat paul an dodson, u openin ur mouth now to get a shot? seems like uv only opended it since u done wel with that crab adamu, which to be fair, thought u easy won it, but i really think, u no deep down ur not ready 4 any ov paul dodson or quigley.
didnt wonna be so blunt kid but well said i get enuff stick on here with gary davies being my brother because im like u defending all day.

Re: Dodson v Smith - who wins this one?

Posted: 01 Mar 2010, 19:43
by terrdilk
liamsmith88 wrote:here we go, another 1 jumpin on the ban wagon, id beat paul an dodson, u openin ur mouth now to get a shot? seems like uv only opended it since u done wel with that crab adamu, which to be fair, thought u easy won it, but i really think, u no deep down ur not ready 4 any ov paul dodson or quigley.
Liam I'm not opening my mouth to get a shot I'm just putting my opinion across! I was willing to box groves for an eliminator for it so it's not like I'm going to say I'm not goog enough to be in there class is it! I think in my opioninon that I will beat both of them there's no malice or the big I am intended just an opinion which your untitled o your obveously showing loyalty to Paul fair point?
An yes I have started opening my mouth because if u don't ask you don't get! Again I'm prepaire to fight the best to get my opertunity! An on the adamu fight your propably right but you now that kid has been in with some good operators an I dealt with him wih ease it going to give you confidence isn't it. So like I said I'll earn my shot don't want it handedto me but I believe I can win why is that so wrong

Re: Dodson v Smith - who wins this one?

Posted: 01 Mar 2010, 21:39
by jBacca
I'd fancy Carl to stop Dodson.

Not sure about Smigga, would be a close fight though, points victory either way.

Re: Dodson v Smith - who wins this one?

Posted: 02 Mar 2010, 06:21
by leeharding
jBacca wrote:I'd fancy Carl to stop Dodson.

Not sure about Smigga, would be a close fight though, points victory either way.
i rekkon hed smash dodson not smigga yet tho few more fights then would be a decent fight.

Re: Dodson v Smith - who wins this one?

Posted: 02 Mar 2010, 06:30
by teddy007
liamsmith88 wrote:here we go, another 1 jumpin on the ban wagon, id beat paul an dodson, u openin ur mouth now to get a shot? seems like uv only opended it since u done wel with that crab adamu, which to be fair, thought u easy won it, but i really think, u no deep down ur not ready 4 any ov paul dodson or quigley.

What a stupid thing to say :roll: , he has fought(and in both our opinion won) for the commonwealth title but he aint ready for Dodson, Paul and Quigley. I think he is ready and if he aint he will never be ready.

Re: Dodson v Smith - who wins this one?

Posted: 02 Mar 2010, 06:35
by righthook
Both smith and dodson would k.o u, u talk a good fight but if u did get a chance to fight 1 of them you'd probibly 5hit your pants the same way you did when you were offered to fight bellew. Your awfull and that's being deadly seriuos. I'd bet good money you'd pull out of a fight with any of the fighters if mentioned. Like the time against bellew and you said your not really a light heavy. Hahaha at the time you'd fought over 80% of your fights at that weight, even now it's still over 70%

there are some class fighters coming out of Liverpool but your far far from there level

Edited by mod

Re: Dodson v Smith - who wins this one?

Posted: 02 Mar 2010, 06:39
by teddy007
righthook wrote:Dilks you talk utter shite! Both smith and dodson would k.o u, u talk a good fight but if u did get a chance to fight 1 of them you'd probibly 5hit your pants the same way you did when you were offered to fight bellew. Your awfull and that's being deadly seriuos. I'd bet good money you'd pull out of a fight with any of the fighters if mentioned. Like the time against bellew and you said your not really a light heavy. Hahaha at the time you'd fought over 80% of your fights at that weight, even now it's still over 70%

there are some class fighters coming out of Liverpool but your far far from there level

Edited by mod

Re: Dodson v Smith - who wins this one?

Posted: 02 Mar 2010, 06:46
by jBacca
righthook wrote:Dilks you talk utter shite! Both smith and dodson would k.o u, u talk a good fight but if u did get a chance to fight 1 of them you'd probibly 5hit your pants the same way you did when you were offered to fight bellew. Your awfull and that's being deadly seriuos. I'd bet good money you'd pull out of a fight with any of the fighters if mentioned. Like the time against bellew and you said your not really a light heavy. Hahaha at the time you'd fought over 80% of your fights at that weight, even now it's still over 70%

there are some class fighters coming out of Liverpool but your far far from there level
Bomber is a different prospect though fella. He's hard as nails and and hit like an ox.

Dilks stops Dodson. Dodson will get picked off as he comes in, and will eventually collapse.

Smith and Dilks could be a scrappy affair with the styles of both, can't pick who'd win.

Re: Dodson v Smith - who wins this one?

Posted: 02 Mar 2010, 07:30
by 15829
carl as you no am a smith fan but don't think there's anything wrong in believing in yourself I think you'd beat dodson but woukd struggle with smith

Re: Dodson v Smith - who wins this one?

Posted: 02 Mar 2010, 09:17
by black panther
A lot of Smith fans on here it would appear. Smith posts on here occassionally as "Smigga" and Dodson used to post on here as "WARRIOR".

Re: Dodson v Smith - who wins this one?

Posted: 02 Mar 2010, 11:20
by liamsmith88
teddy, read my post u idiot, who sed he isnt ready? i sed another shouten id beat this,id beat that, i sed is this shoutin to get a shot. an ye, i thought carl beat adamu, but i think most ov the super middles in britain would beat adamu, hes shit, not a patch on wat he was against froch, an that was all heart an toughness, no abillity. an carl, nothin rong with with it at all, just thought as ur the fighter, u cudda put ur statemeant out in a better way, seen as u didnt mention nothin to pauls face wen use did the interveiws be4 the adamu fight.

Re: Dodson v Smith - who wins this one?

Posted: 02 Mar 2010, 11:26
by teddy007
I said if he aint ready he would never be. To say he aint good enough for Paul Smith is laughable.

Edited by mod

Re: Dodson v Smith - who wins this one?

Posted: 02 Mar 2010, 11:58
by righthook
Teddy stop acting like u know anything about Liverpool fighters, your an arm chair fan who knows fornicate all about fornicate all,

Dilks is no where near the level of smith dodson and bellew, infact I'd go as far to say he's not in the top 10 fighters in Liverpool , people like the 3 names above, Selkirk, price, and swifty, are allot better already than dilks will ever be.

Now this is my opponion and I'm entitled to it, especially with me being a scouser and having a vast knowledge about fighters in my own city. so Teddy don't go on like you know anything about the Liverpool fight scene you muppet,

Edited by mod

Re: Dodson v Smith - who wins this one?

Posted: 02 Mar 2010, 12:02
by johncollins
so much bias in this thread.

Re: Dodson v Smith - who wins this one?

Posted: 02 Mar 2010, 12:04
by teddy007
righthook wrote:Teddy stop acting like u know anything about Liverpool fighters, your an arm chair fan who knows eff all about eff all,

Dilks is no where near the level of smith dodson and bellew, infact I'd go as far to say he's not in the top 10 fighters in Liverpool , people like the 3 names above, Selkirk, price, and swifty, are allot better already than dilks will ever be.

Now this is my opponion and I'm entitled to it, especially with me being a scouser and having a vast knowledge about fighters in my own city. so Teddy don't go on like you know anything about the Liverpool fight scene you muppet,

get back to your mums basement nerd

Edited by mod

Re: Dodson v Smith - who wins this one?

Posted: 02 Mar 2010, 12:05
by teddy007
righthook wrote:Teddy stop acting like u know anything about Liverpool fighters, your an arm chair fan who knows eff all about eff all,

Dilks is no where near the level of smith dodson and bellew, infact I'd go as far to say he's not in the top 10 fighters in Liverpool , people like the 3 names above, Selkirk, price, and swifty, are allot better already than dilks will ever be.

Now this is my opponion and I'm entitled to it, especially with me being a scouser and having a vast knowledge about fighters in my own city. so Teddy don't go on like you know anything about the Liverpool fight scene you muppet,

get back to your mums basement nerd

Edited by mod