Page 3 of 6
Re: The Official PSP Rankings - week 1
Posted: 26 Aug 2010, 11:41
by hitman09
jBacca wrote:hitman09 wrote:I'm going to stop arguing now, because we are going in circles. All I can say is, everything you have said seems to support the statement that I made earlier, that
hitman09 wrote: you aren't rating "who is the best?" but rather " who has overachieved the most?"
IMO, rankings should be solely based on who has beaten the best opposition, not the best opposition in relation to themselves, but the best opposition full stop.
That could have been done, but then the rankings will hardly be competitive and fun for the lower drafts, will they?
As a bit of fun and a kudos system, these are a great idea and a very nice addition to the sim.
I was arguing under the assumption that these would challenge or replace the commish rankings, where the idea is to rank the fighters in order of who is the best, not to make them fun for the lower drafts.
Re: The Official PSP Rankings - week 1
Posted: 26 Aug 2010, 12:12
by jBacca
hitman09 wrote:jBacca wrote:hitman09 wrote:I'm going to stop arguing now, because we are going in circles. All I can say is, everything you have said seems to support the statement that I made earlier, that
IMO, rankings should be solely based on who has beaten the best opposition, not the best opposition in relation to themselves, but the best opposition full stop.
That could have been done, but then the rankings will hardly be competitive and fun for the lower drafts, will they?
As a bit of fun and a kudos system, these are a great idea and a very nice addition to the sim.
I was arguing under the assumption that these would challenge or replace the commish rankings, where the idea is to rank the fighters in order of who is the best, not to make them fun for the lower drafts.
That solves that then.
Re: The Official PSP Rankings - week 1
Posted: 28 Aug 2010, 18:22
by jBacca
BIG piss up tomorrow, so will update this Mon.
Re: The Official PSP Rankings - week 1
Posted: 28 Aug 2010, 23:00
by BoxBuzz
Crease wrote:jBacca wrote:Buzz, match your fighters against hard opposition
oh, GOD FORBID!!! (you should even think of it)
Buzz and a hard fight = surely not.
You have a point, Honeyghan was just too easy for the Mickster.
Re: The Official PSP Rankings - week 2
Posted: 30 Aug 2010, 07:50
by jBacca
Updated.
Re: The Official PSP Rankings - week 2
Posted: 30 Aug 2010, 08:47
by Sweet P
As with last season. the Cream will rise to the top. Cotto being watched over By Raf Marquez is headed for greatness.
It is only a matter of time.
Re: The Official PSP Rankings - week 2
Posted: 30 Aug 2010, 08:54
by jBacca
I thought that too
What are you feeding your fighters Ben, and why don't you share it with your other one?
Re: The Official PSP Rankings - week 2
Posted: 30 Aug 2010, 09:12
by Sweet P
Re: The Official PSP Rankings - week 2
Posted: 30 Aug 2010, 17:33
by BoxBuzz
IF there is a new "run of luck" it will likely be another management team. It's like lightening, it don't strike twice in the same place too often.
Re: The Official PSP Rankings - week 2
Posted: 30 Aug 2010, 21:43
by Sweet P
I put it down to shrewed management, Cotto is on his way to greatness.
Re: The Official PSP Rankings - week 3
Posted: 31 Aug 2010, 06:29
by jBacca
Updated.
Re: The Official PSP Rankings - week 3
Posted: 31 Aug 2010, 18:00
by jBacca
DetroitHxC wrote:Luis Manuel Rodriguez knocked out Lloyd Honeyghan in the 6th round this week, FYI Jai.
Rodriguez has looked impressive so far.
Re: The Official PSP Rankings - week 2
Posted: 31 Aug 2010, 18:20
by Crease
Re: The Official PSP Rankings - week 3
Posted: 31 Aug 2010, 18:44
by jBacca
DetroitHxC wrote:jBacca wrote:DetroitHxC wrote:Luis Manuel Rodriguez knocked out Lloyd Honeyghan in the 6th round this week, FYI Jai.
Rodriguez has looked impressive so far.
I was just pointing it out because next to his name it says 2(0)-1-0 but he should have one KO, that's all.
Also, his loss was a DQ, not a KO, so can you please change those two things?
Do dq stoppages not count as a stoppage in the record bit? I'm not qualming your point, am just unsure.
Will fix Rodriguez now.
Re: The Official PSP Rankings - week 3
Posted: 31 Aug 2010, 18:51
by jBacca
Also, does winning by dq give you the stoppage in your record bit?
Re: The Official PSP Rankings - week 3
Posted: 31 Aug 2010, 19:00
by Marlin
jBacca wrote:Also, does winning by dq give you the stoppage in your record bit?
Nope, only KO/TKO. I think you might have to change a few. I know Ike hasn't been KO'd...
Re: The Official PSP Rankings - week 3
Posted: 31 Aug 2010, 21:19
by BoxBuzz
DetroitHxC wrote:How the hell are Fritzie Zivic and Benny Paret ranked higher than Marlon Starling?
Pure essence of Jbacca VooDoo magic!
Re: The Official PSP Rankings - week 3
Posted: 01 Sep 2010, 07:53
by jBacca
Marlin wrote:jBacca wrote:Also, does winning by dq give you the stoppage in your record bit?
Nope, only KO/TKO. I think you might have to change a few. I know Ike hasn't been KO'd...
Yeah, fortunately this won't effect the points as the record bit is only for show.
Re: The Official PSP Rankings - week 3
Posted: 01 Sep 2010, 07:57
by jBacca
DetroitHxC wrote:How the hell are Fritzie Zivic and Benny Paret ranked higher than Marlon Starling?
Monsieur Starling had a big, big defeat against Collazo, and his two draws have done little for his points total.
Zivic has lost 3, but his first was an unlucky dq whilst ahead on all cards. I can't remember Paret's results, but it's all good baby.
Re: The Official PSP Rankings - week 3
Posted: 01 Sep 2010, 11:33
by jBacca
DetroitHxC wrote:jBacca wrote:DetroitHxC wrote:How the hell are Fritzie Zivic and Benny Paret ranked higher than Marlon Starling?
Monsieur Starling had a big, big defeat against Collazo, and his two draws have done little for his points total.
Zivic has lost 3, but his first was an unlucky dq whilst ahead on all cards. I can't remember Paret's results, but it's all good baby.
Paret has been KO'd three times in a row. You got some 'splanin to do.
Paret has been in with 3 guys who, without giving anything away, are very commendable opponents. Yep, he has been stopped in all, but he has been fighting out of his depth. Starling on the other hand, well, he wont live that Collazo loss down
D
Re: The Official PSP Rankings - week 3
Posted: 01 Sep 2010, 11:45
by jBacca
DetroitHxC wrote:jBacca wrote:DetroitHxC wrote:
Paret has been KO'd three times in a row. You got some 'splanin to do.
Paret has been in with 3 guys who, without giving anything away, are very commendable opponents. Yep, he has been stopped in all, but he has been fighting out of his depth. Starling on the other hand, well, he wont live that Collazo loss down
D
That was a thin decision, and HE WAS ROBBED!!!!
Can only go on the judges scorecards
Re: The Official PSP Rankings - week 3
Posted: 01 Sep 2010, 15:33
by The Irish Assassin
#1 and #5? What's with all this talk of me taking B.S. fights?
Re: The Official PSP Rankings - week 3
Posted: 01 Sep 2010, 16:08
by jBacca
The Irish Assassin wrote:#1 and #5? What's with all this talk of me taking B.S. fights?
No idea, you should take out a lawsuit.
Re: The Official PSP Rankings - week 3
Posted: 01 Sep 2010, 17:10
by The Irish Assassin
jBacca wrote:The Irish Assassin wrote:#1 and #5? What's with all this talk of me taking B.S. fights?
No idea, you should take out a lawsuit.
Indeed, there have been a lot of libelous statements thrown out there.
Re: The Official PSP Rankings - week 3
Posted: 01 Sep 2010, 17:18
by allworld80
Sadly the libel thread was lost when Shep had too many margaritas and deleted the forum.