BoxRec

great list!
but isnt magee is British?

Londonirish wrote:

Horse wrote:If Smith had fought again since then then he would probably still be in the rankings, but he hasn't because he is injured. When he fights again I can re-enter him.

What even if he gets beat

Probably not.

$wifty wrote:Thanks for all the support on here everyone!

Im back out next month against Simpson again for the British and Commonwealth Titles, this will give me the chance to prove a point, win well with both hands and maybe re-enter the p4p list

Thanks again for all the support, the hand is back 100% and im feeling great and looking forward to being back in the ring

Horse wrote:

bengulnaci1 wrote:Fantastic list, again mate

Can't really have any issues, maybe I would have Rhodes ahead of Murray and Macklin but that is a minor point.

Bang on, as usual.

Thank you, bengulnaci1.

There isn't much in it between Macklin, Murray and Rhodes. I just think Macklin and Murray have done slightly more recently.

you *could* argue the Jamie Moore win for Rhodes is better than any result either Macklin or Murray have ever had.

wrimc wrote:

Horse wrote:A win against Smith is a lot better than a win against Lomax.

Agreed im not arguing for Gavin's inclusion but its obvious that you have have rated Degale higher not because of the individual win on its own but by his talent where you have not taken into this account with other fighters

DeGale won the first 9 rounds against Smith and then stopped him, he also stopped Dilks in the first round in his fight before that.

I don't think I am taking his ability into account much more than other fighters. I think his recent results measure up well to the other fighters in the bottom 10 of the rankings. DeGale has done enough to qualify for a place in the rankings, Gavin hasn't.

kingfinn wrote:great list!
but isnt magee is British?

I think he considers himself to be Irish.

Counter-puncher wrote:you *could* argue the Jamie Moore win for Rhodes is better than any result either Macklin or Murray have ever had.

That could be argued, but Moore losing his next fight to Khomitski took away some of the luster from that win, in my opinion. That win was over 16 months ago now and I think Macklin and Murray have done just a bit more in that time.