BoxRec

LancashireLoyal wrote:Thats the problem,when a top 10 fighter gets beaten its too easy to drop them right out of the picture based on that one defeat,when you take this into conparison withhow a fighter got there in the first place its not balanced.Example,Wladimir was in most peoples top 5 or at least top ten now hes had one defeat hes pretty muchout of ppls lists alltogether.

DannyMCR wrote:Amir Khan?

Stuarty30 wrote:

Horse wrote:

Stuarty30 wrote:Same complaints as last month but not much can be done since August is a barren month for boxing. Frampton should be number 1 and the overrated Khan is too high etc...

Khan is underrated.

He's had a great career.

Very overrated. He's not held any version of a world title in 5 years. Hasn't won a fight in well over a year and even then that was a struggle against a limited Chris Algieri. He's a good fighter and could've been a lot better but he's too high as usual.

If he does comeback and manages to beat Danny Garcia like he said he's going to do then perhaps he'd be worthy of his lofty position on the list.

fightfan95 wrote:

Stuarty30 wrote:

Horse wrote:Khan is underrated.

He's had a great career.

Very overrated. He's not held any version of a world title in 5 years. Hasn't won a fight in well over a year and even then that was a struggle against a limited Chris Algieri. He's a good fighter and could've been a lot better but he's too high as usual.

If he does comeback and manages to beat Danny Garcia like he said he's going to do then perhaps he'd be worthy of his lofty position on the list.

I wanna see Stuarty30's list! I think I will agree with everything!

Stuarty30 wrote:

fightfan95 wrote:

Stuarty30 wrote:
Very overrated. He's not held any version of a world title in 5 years. Hasn't won a fight in well over a year and even then that was a struggle against a limited Chris Algieri. He's a good fighter and could've been a lot better but he's too high as usual.

If he does comeback and manages to beat Danny Garcia like he said he's going to do then perhaps he'd be worthy of his lofty position on the list.

I wanna see Stuarty30's list! I think I will agree with everything!

I've not got the time for lists man. I just like complaining about Horses lists To be fair to him they're usually pretty decent but he's a stubborn fornicator when it comes to his favourites.

Fitzy901 wrote:If Crolla beats Linares then personally, I believe he should be in at number one with Frampton second.

Fitzy901 wrote:Do not know how the eff you can have Groves and Khan in the top ten when neither are world champion's or beat any solid fighters in there weight catogories for the last five years.

Fitzy901 wrote:If Crolla beats Linares then personally, I believe he should be in at number one with Frampton second.

mickey1975 wrote:

Horse wrote:

mickey1975 wrote:Murray too low.

When he gets another win or good loss then he'll climb back up the rankings.

Good lad. A few more good hidings and he'll be number one.

Fitzy901 wrote:Do not know how the eff you can have Groves and Khan in the top ten when neither are world champion's or beat any solid fighters in there weight catogories for the last five years.

Manchester Massive wrote:Correct, unfortunately you cannot reason with stupidity

Fitzy901 wrote:I don't think Khan belongs in the top ten to be honest, he has had one decent win in the last five years, of which was againt's a Devon Alexander who was massively on the slide.

Horse wrote:

Fitzy901 wrote:I don't think Khan belongs in the top ten to be honest, he has had one decent win in the last five years, of which was againt's a Devon Alexander who was massively on the slide.

Khan has plenty of decent wins in the last 5 years.

They are not that impressive by Khan's standards, but that is only because Khan is so impressive.

sammy95 wrote:The only change I would make is dropping Khan down two or three places, purely on recent form.

Fitzy901 wrote:Impressive when mate?

Beating Collazo who lost to Hatton in 2006? Going life and death with Algeri?

Horse wrote:

Fitzy901 wrote:Impressive when mate?

Beating Collazo who lost to Hatton in 2006? Going life and death with Algeri?

Khan's only been disappointing in recent years, because we all know that he could have done so much more.

Khan is a fantastic talent, but he's not living up to his potential.

Ian1973 wrote:

Fitzy901 wrote:If Crolla beats Linares then personally, I believe he should be in at number one with Frampton second.

No offence but that is just nonsense.

Fitzy901 wrote:I don't think Khan belongs in the top ten to be honest, he has had one decent win in the last five years, of which was againt's a Devon Alexander who was massively on the slide.

Tomasino wrote:

mickey1975 wrote:

Horse wrote:When he gets another win or good loss then he'll climb back up the rankings.

Good lad. A few more good hidings and he'll be number one.

Naandrew wrote:

Ian1973 wrote:

Fitzy901 wrote:If Crolla beats Linares then personally, I believe he should be in at number one with Frampton second.

No offence but that is just nonsense.

Yeah that's stupid Linares is just being overhyped by matchroom when really his resume is not that good plus Crolla is favourite to win the fight Franpton was a 2-1 underdog against LSC.

End of argument.

Naandrew wrote:

Ian1973 wrote:

Fitzy901 wrote:If Crolla beats Linares then personally, I believe he should be in at number one with Frampton second.

No offence but that is just nonsense.

Yeah that's stupid Linares is just being overhyped by matchroom when really his resume is not that good plus Crolla is favourite to win the fight Franpton was a 2-1 underdog against LSC.

End of argument.

Fitzy901 wrote:Thanks for that nerd. I think you missed the bit where i put ''personally''