BoxRec

SaadOffTheDeck wrote:Pulev to #9, Joshua to champion, the rest remain the same.

A Proper idiot

Rob3_142 wrote: 100% agree, but the WBC are not on their own. I mean Parker is just about to fight Cojanu for the WBO. Granted a late replacement for Hughie, but how on earth is he in the WBO top 15? All governing bodies have their own embarrassing group of hopeless potential world title challengers.

You're right of course but the problem the governing bodies have is that once you take out the Champions and the #1 contenders for the other belts (which most of them do) it's really quite hard to put together a list of 15 good heavyweights!

the_doctor wrote:You're right of course but the problem the governing bodies have is that once you take out the Champions and the #1 contenders for the other belts (which most of them do) it's really quite hard to put together a list of 15 good heavyweights!

Definitely worth a go! My top 15;

1. Wladamir Klitschko
2. Kubrat Pulev
3. Luis Ortiz
4. Dominic Breazeale
5. Dillian Whyte
6. Christian Hammer
7. Andy Ruiz
8. Dereck Chisora
9. Carlos Takam
10. Tony Bellew
11. Johann Duhaupas
12. Mariusz Wach
13. Gerald Washington
14. Izu Igonoh
15. David Haye

I've included a few guys who are #1 in the rankings as the likes of Pulev and Ortiz are ranking in numerous lists.

If Parker narrowly beats #78, then shouldn't he go backwards?

Was it a narrow win? Im yet to see anyone score it closer than 9-3, and most have it wider

Fight happened after the thread was started btw...Parker will come up for a vote soon.

crusader wrote:Was it a narrow win? Im yet to see anyone score it closer than 9-3, and most have it wider

Fight happened after the thread was started btw...Parker will come up for a vote soon.

Parker won every round very comfortably, and Cojanu had a point deducted in one of the middle rounds. Should have been 120-107.

The disappointment was that Parker couldn't really load up on him and get him out of there. I think question marks over his power and timing are starting to be asked.

Votes have been tallied, Joshua is instated as the BWH Champion, Wlad remains at #1, Pulev rises to #5 as a result of Joshua's promotion, Wach enters at #15.

Champion: Anthony Joshua
1. Wladimir Klitschko
2. Alexander Povetkin
3. Deontay Wilder
4. Luis Ortiz
5. Kubrat Pulev
6. Joseph Parker
7. Carlos Takam
8. Andy Ruiz
9. Dillian Whyte
10. Dereck Chisora
11. Bermane Stiverne
12. Christian Hammer
13. Dominic Breazeale
14. Hughie Fury
15. Mariusz Wach

Hypothetically, if another fighter were to KO Wlad and Ortiz, could they be voted up to champ, or is there a 'beat the champ to become the champ' requirement once the spot is filled?

Incidentally, did you change your vote because it was split 10-10?

crusader wrote:Hypothetically, if another fighter were to KO Wlad and Ortiz, could they be voted up to champ, or is there a 'beat the champ to become the champ' requirement once the spot is filled?

Incidentally, did you change your vote because it was split 10-10?

Hypothetically yes, it could happen - there isn't a 'beat the champ t become the champ' requirement - Wlad wasn't champ when Joshua beat him. I wondered if anyone would notice - I was 60:40 in favour of having Joshua at #1 rather than champ, but I'd be lying if I said the 10:10 tie wasn't a factor in me changing my vote.

jezzamundo wrote:Votes have been tallied, Joshua is instated as the BWH Champion, Wlad remains at #1, Pulev rises to #5 as a result of Joshua's promotion, Wach enters at #15.

Champion: Anthony Joshua
1. Wladimir Klitschko
2. Alexander Povetkin
3. Deontay Wilder
4. Luis Ortiz
5. Kubrat Pulev
6. Joseph Parker
7. Carlos Takam
8. Andy Ruiz
9. Dillian Whyte
10. Dereck Chisora
11. Bermane Stiverne
12. Christian Hammer
13. Dominic Breazeale
14. Hughie Fury
15. Mariusz Wach

Down as far as Takam it is really solid but from 8-15 none of those fighters are really deserving and in fairness there is no one else outside of those who absolutely stakes a top 10 place. It really is a dire set of heavyweights at the moment, the only real fights are the unifications, don't really think Takam is worthy of a shot and with Povetkin perhaps suspended it looks grim.

Lennox wrote:

jezzamundo wrote:Votes have been tallied, Joshua is instated as the BWH Champion, Wlad remains at #1, Pulev rises to #5 as a result of Joshua's promotion, Wach enters at #15.

Champion: Anthony Joshua
1. Wladimir Klitschko
2. Alexander Povetkin
3. Deontay Wilder
4. Luis Ortiz
5. Kubrat Pulev
6. Joseph Parker
7. Carlos Takam
8. Andy Ruiz
9. Dillian Whyte
10. Dereck Chisora
11. Bermane Stiverne
12. Christian Hammer
13. Dominic Breazeale
14. Hughie Fury
15. Mariusz Wach

Down as far as Takam it is really solid but from 8-15 none of those fighters are really deserving and in fairness there is no one else outside of those who absolutely stakes a top 10 place. It really is a dire set of heavyweights at the moment, the only real fights are the unifications, don't really think Takam is worthy of a shot and with Povetkin perhaps suspended it looks grim.

I have the opposite perspective. There are a sh!tload of good fights to be made on that list as well as including some of the next ten or twenty HWs.

How about Whyte v Takam and Fury v Ruiz Jr. on the same card in the UK? Maybe throw in Chisora v Breazeale. I would love a card like that. Start ferreting out who belongs and who does not.

I wouldn't mind seeing Gerald Washington v Ruiz Jr. on the 3G v GingerHead undercard. Actually, Ruiz Jr. v anybody below Parker on that list would work on that undercard.