Page 3 of 4
Posted: 09 Nov 2007, 14:13
by n1ebf
Calzaghe could go to the states and beat Hopkins for the big money, then come back and whup Froch and probably not get marked.
The question is what would be Calzaghe's motivation. Sure he could probably bank another million against Froch but I don't know if the desire would be there given the potential dangers. If you make a bad investment in business you lose money, make one in boxing and you're talking about your health. I don't know if he wants to shut Froch up all that much, given what he's already achieved.
As for a Hopkins fight I think it will take ages.....when some fighters are gonna get beat (Hopkins) things have a habit of being very slow in the pipeline.
I'd tip Froch to win tonight against Reid on power and more regular appearances of late but I'd love some of them Reid odds.
On a side note i reckon there's no guarantee Froch will even achieve what Reid achieved in boxing, wasn't Reid a world champ of some sort when he beat Nardi - yellow

(that's not fair of me I know !)
Posted: 09 Nov 2007, 14:28
by silkov
I think this could be a one sided drubbing for Reid depending on Frochs mood. Reid hasnt looked any good since the Ottke fight, and I dont think he can pull much more out of the bag now even if he wants to, unfortunately it seems that he frittered much of his prime away making those dodgey movies!... :x 8)

Hard to see what Carl will gain from this fight really, a onesided win shouldnt really surprise anyone after Reids recent showings, while if Carl struggles then that would really damage his credibility at this point and his chances of fighting Calzaghe..... he really has to win impressively to keep his career going imo...
Posted: 09 Nov 2007, 14:30
by n1ebf
I might pack my job in and "fritter away" some of my time banging MILFs for money
![[icon_e_biggrin.gif] :D](./images/smilies/icon_e_biggrin.gif)
Posted: 09 Nov 2007, 14:33
by silkov
Posted: 09 Nov 2007, 14:42
by n1ebf
Those MILFs are dirty bitches.......obviously going the 12 round distance must have helped Reid

Posted: 09 Nov 2007, 15:07
by tony3
I'll be amazed if this turns out to be anything other than a bloody sacrifice to further Froch's ambitions at world-class.
Reid was class in his heyday and was unfortunate to rise in an era when boxing's popularity was in decline, thus robbing him of the exposure enjoyed by Benn, Eubank and Watson.
An upset isn't beyond the realms of possibility but if Froch is beaten then that just about kills off any foothold that the British might hope to claim in the future of the supermiddleweight division.
Posted: 09 Nov 2007, 15:16
by stujones
Ian 'Mr' McNeilly wrote:And unlike most of you, I was ringside to see Reid-Pretorius and let me tell you, light-middle or not he was one hard bastard. One of the most gutsy (and surprising) efforts I've seen. Reid underestimated him - as did we all.
No-one has said anything different - always wanted to see how Peterious would have got on after the Reid fight. For some reason, not sure why, he never got a chance at his weight (or Middle) - it was a very gutsy effort.
Posted: 09 Nov 2007, 15:17
by steve689
I must admit i have always liked Reid as a fighter, a solid pro, decent skills, good chin and a reasonable overhand right. Had a soft spot for him since the Calzaghe fight as well, thought he had maybe done enough to derail the Welshman.
Posted: 09 Nov 2007, 15:29
by silkov
I liked him as fighter and thought he was underrated at his best but after the Calzaghe fight he just seemed to fritter away his career imo, till the Ottke fight, which I thought he'd won. Since the Ottke fight Reid it must be said has been just awful in his fights, I dont think his heart is in the game anymore and his skills and ability have just rusted away with age and inactivity. I cant see an upset anyway I look at it, besides everything else Froch has a very good chin himself, it would take a hard puncher with speed to really trouble Carl and Reid moves as if he's underwater these days. Personally I think its a shame this fight has been made, Carl should be having big fights now not facing a fighter like Reid who is so obviously past it, and it'll be a shame to see Reid perhaps beaten up, I just hope he goes out with more dignity than he did in the Lacy fight, if anything Froch is a harder fight for Reid than Lacy was...
Posted: 09 Nov 2007, 15:37
by stujones
Ian 'Mr' McNeilly wrote:
Yes, I've seen stu come on here before and explain that if the judges scored it as the ref wanted them to, there wouldn't have been much in it.
But if the ref had have been fair, the very least Reid would have got is a points win and I actually think he'd have sparked him.
And well said Autobarn with your 'glass half full' approach. I get sick of some of you miserable twats on here. Reid was a bloody good pro and a genuine world champ to boot and all some of you can do is say he was no great shakes.
F*ck off and watch Strictly Come Dancing or whatever is on the other side.
Not sure you can say that categorically Ian regarding what might have happend in the Ottke vs Reid fight? Though I can see why you think that. However, you don't think not having the point deductions and the general attitude of the Ref (stopping Reid's work) would have altered Ottke's approach? I'm of the opinion that Ottke knew that by moaning and holding, the Ref would pull up Reid - so continued to "fight" that way... Had the Ref just told Sven to shut up, then he would have fought different. Surely, a point deduction would have made Reid more determined to KO Ottke - than if things were remained to be going "honky dory" in the early aspect then he surely just would have carried on and not seeked the KO. He just seemed to give up at the end, and that was dissapointing... Just for the record, I had Ottke 1 round up, so the point deduction prevented it from being a draw - The KD that was never scored would have then given Reid the win.
Yes, that was a good display - up there with the Wharton approach. Yes, I am guilty of having a "half empty" approach - but two fighters the IMO have had world titles due to fantastic management rather than awesome ability - yet, years since they done anything decent still get mentioned (albeit loosely these days) in the World class bracket - is Hide and Reid. For me, Reid was the worst of the geniune World Super Middleweight champions from the UK.... Good no doubt, but 1 decent performance in 8 years (a losing one) isn't the kind of form thats worthy of the amount of coverage he gets on these forums.... Only my take mind.
A bit of a difference between the terms "Overated" and "no great shakes" and I think that Rob being consider/ed at least fringe World class for over 10 years is overating him.
He was good, but not great - well managed.
Posted: 09 Nov 2007, 15:44
by chesh
NorthEastBoxingFan wrote:Those MILFs are dirty bitches.......obviously going the 12 round distance must have helped Reid

I think Reid's in too deep this time, though.

Posted: 09 Nov 2007, 15:49
by n1ebf
just when this thread looked in danger of cleaning itself up eh?
seriously tho' having read a couple recent posts on this thread i'm beginning to reckon Froch might win in the first half....depending on what is/ isn't coming back, he might just go for it.
I watched him in the flesh against Tatevosyan and he cut the ring off really well I thought......and the power was there for all to see.
Posted: 09 Nov 2007, 16:04
by WildWaylon
chesh wrote:NorthEastBoxingFan wrote:Those MILFs are dirty bitches.......obviously going the 12 round distance must have helped Reid

I think Reid's in too deep this time, though.

Do I detect this is a naughty post, rather than a boxing comment.

nice one!!!
Posted: 09 Nov 2007, 16:06
by chesh
NorthEastBoxingFan wrote:just when this thread looked in danger of cleaning itself up eh?
seriously tho' having read a couple recent posts on this thread i'm beginning to reckon Froch might win in the first half....depending on what is/ isn't coming back, he might just go for it.
I watched him in the flesh against Tatevosyan and he cut the ring off really well I thought......and the power was there for all to see.
I wouldn't be surprised if it was a short fight. If Reid's saying it's his last fight, he's clearly no ambition left.
Posted: 09 Nov 2007, 16:14
by Autobarn
Ian 'Mr' McNeilly wrote:And unlike most of you, I was ringside to see Reid-Pretorius and let me tell you, light-middle or not he was one hard bastard. One of the most gutsy (and surprising) efforts I've seen. Reid underestimated him - as did we all.
It was a terrific scrap, and a great night's entertainment. You could tell Reid wasn't going to be top notch champ material, but for every bad showing he's given us good 'uns like that. Good that he's managed to come back from the Lacy fight. It must have been depressing losing to such a mouthy snarling braggart.
Posted: 09 Nov 2007, 16:18
by WildWaylon
I think John Murray is on the undercard, that should be worth watching.
Posted: 09 Nov 2007, 16:20
by WildWaylon
Autobarn wrote:Ian 'Mr' McNeilly wrote:And unlike most of you, I was ringside to see Reid-Pretorius and let me tell you, light-middle or not he was one hard bastard. One of the most gutsy (and surprising) efforts I've seen. Reid underestimated him - as did we all.
It was a terrific scrap, and a great night's entertainment. You could tell Reid wasn't going to be top notch champ material, but for every bad showing he's given us good 'uns like that. Good that he's managed to come back from the Lacy fight. It must have been depressing losing to such a mouthy snarling braggart.
Isnt he going to lose to another mouthy snarling braggart?
Posted: 09 Nov 2007, 20:11
by Wales
DavidPayne wrote:Reid plans to retire after the bout according to comments attributed to Brian Hughes.
Does that suggest a motivated fighter to anyone here, or a payday.
.
What are tomorrows lotto numbers Senior Payne?
Posted: 09 Nov 2007, 20:20
by stujones
Autobarn wrote:Ian 'Mr' McNeilly wrote:And unlike most of you, I was ringside to see Reid-Pretorius and let me tell you, light-middle or not he was one hard bastard. One of the most gutsy (and surprising) efforts I've seen. Reid underestimated him - as did we all.
It was a terrific scrap, and a great night's entertainment. You could tell Reid wasn't going to be top notch champ material, but for every bad showing he's given us good 'uns like that. Good that he's managed to come back from the Lacy fight. It must have been depressing losing to such a mouthy snarling braggart.
Yeah, I remember Warren's comments (well I have the fight on Video also) and I did think he was a bit unjust. Reid was a young champion, fighting on a massive bill with a rival champion. He got a bit careless (plus he had a great chin) and took more risks than he should have - but it made for a fantastic little scrap. Surely its what you would expect from an inexperienced fighter - just dramatically elevated to championship level.
That was a wreckless, but overall good display - At least he showed a work rate and spirit that IMO he lacked in most of his fights after. Had he continued to fight in that vein, he might have lost earlier - but I think he would have been more popular anyway.
Big problem I have with him is that in the 10 years since the Petrious fight there have been 3 good displays and the majority of the rest haven't just been below average - they have been foul filled and awful.
Posted: 10 Nov 2007, 05:51
by dondada
I just didn't realise how far Reid had fallen to be honest until last night. It was hard viewing.
Posted: 10 Nov 2007, 06:44
by Autobarn
WildWaylon wrote:Autobarn wrote:Ian 'Mr' McNeilly wrote:And unlike most of you, I was ringside to see Reid-Pretorius and let me tell you, light-middle or not he was one hard bastard. One of the most gutsy (and surprising) efforts I've seen. Reid underestimated him - as did we all.
It was a terrific scrap, and a great night's entertainment. You could tell Reid wasn't going to be top notch champ material, but for every bad showing he's given us good 'uns like that. Good that he's managed to come back from the Lacy fight. It must have been depressing losing to such a mouthy snarling braggart.
Isnt he going to lose to another mouthy snarling braggart?
Froch has some charisma. Lacy certainly didn't. I needed to see Lacy get humbled after that display and Cazlaghe delivered with a million punch beating.
Posted: 10 Nov 2007, 07:33
by Controversial
Ian 'Mr' McNeilly wrote:I just didn't realise how far Reid had fallen to be honest until last night. It was hard viewing.
I agree, he had totally lost his punch resistance...its a shame as he was a good fighter in his day.
Posted: 10 Nov 2007, 20:24
by punchers chance
If Reid doesn't need the money (which he claims he doesn't) then what the hell did he come back for? That was awful.
Posted: 13 Nov 2007, 11:04
by THEBUTCH
I wasn't as impressed with Froch's job on Reid as I was with Lacy's, but what struck me more so, was how much more Froch looks to have in reserve.
He's ready to box for and win a world title now. Don't agree with those saying Froch is stagnating, not true...it's called earning your title shot and not sitting around and collecting dust.
I'm confident he'll be a world champion by 2008.
Posted: 13 Nov 2007, 11:38
by josh fg
THEBUTCH wrote:I wasn't as impressed with Froch's job on Reid as I was with Lacy's, but what struck me more so, was how much more Froch looks to have in reserve.
He's ready to box for and win a world title now. Don't agree with those saying Froch is stagnating, not true...it's called earning your title shot and not sitting around and collecting dust.
I'm confident he'll be a world champion by 2008.
Isn't he supposed to be up for a European title? That would certainly make him more likely to be world champ.