BoxRec

1. Hatton
2. Calzaghe
3. Haye
4. Witter
5. Woods
6. Arthur
7. Maccarinelli
8. Froch
9. Moore
10. Rees
11. Lynes
12. Khan
13. Thaxton
14. Jennings
15. Cook
16. Pryce
17. Macklin
18. Johanneson
19. Mitchell
20. Dunne

Emerson Poncey Name Ghent wrote:

Coco wrote:1. Calzaghe
2. Hatton
3. Haye
4. Witter
5. Woods
6. Maccrinelli
7. Rees
8. Arthur
9. Froch
10. Nicky Cook
11. Lynes
12. Elcock Bernard Dunne
13. Earl
14. John Duddy
15. Hunter
16. Moore
17. Khan
18. Pryce
19. Thaxton
20. Francis

10-20 was hard to do, i've ommitted Alexander and McCulloch thru inactivity, Skelton, Lockett, Mitchell, and Jennings were close to the list to

Could you clarify number 12 please Coco, Elcock or Dunne?

Bugger! Dunne no12, put Elcock no14, and move everyone else down one so then Francis is ommitted, Earl stays at 13

Emerson Poncey Name Ghent wrote:

Coco wrote:1. Calzaghe
2. Hatton
3. Haye
4. Witter
5. Woods
6. Maccrinelli
7. Rees
8. Arthur
9. Froch
10. Nicky Cook
11. Lynes
12. Elcock Bernard Dunne
13. Earl
14. John Duddy
15. Hunter
16. Moore
17. Khan
18. Pryce
19. Thaxton
20. Francis

10-20 was hard to do, i've ommitted Alexander and McCulloch thru inactivity, Skelton, Lockett, Mitchell, and Jennings were close to the list to

Could you clarify number 12 please Coco, Elcock or Dunne?

Bugger! Dunne no12, put Elcock no14, and move everyone else down one so then Francis is ommitted, Earl stays at 13

Emerson Poncey Name Ghent wrote:

Coco wrote:1. Calzaghe
2. Hatton
3. Haye
4. Witter
5. Woods
6. Maccrinelli
7. Rees
8. Arthur
9. Froch
10. Nicky Cook
11. Lynes
12. Elcock Bernard Dunne
13. Earl
14. John Duddy
15. Hunter
16. Moore
17. Khan
18. Pryce
19. Thaxton
20. Francis

10-20 was hard to do, i've ommitted Alexander and McCulloch thru inactivity, Skelton, Lockett, Mitchell, and Jennings were close to the list to

Could you clarify number 12 please Coco, Elcock or Dunne?

Bugger! Dunne no12, put Elcock no14, and move everyone else down one so then Francis is ommitted, Earl stays at 13

3 votes, are you mad.

Only 4 days left to get your picks in lads.

1. Calzaghe
2. Hatton
3. Haye
4. Woods
5. Arthur
6. Enzo Mac
7. Witter
8. Moore
9. Elcock
10. Rees

11. Khan
12. Frotch
13. Hunter
14. Earl
15. Dunne
16. Pryce
17. Matthews
18. Duddy
19. Skelton
20. Thaxton
21 Johannesson

Surely i'm going blind.... REE's ???

TOP 10 P4P in Britain ?

His combined list of opponents read as follows:-

W269 - L711

I appreciate he won that Hatton-discarded title from the Frenchman who inherited it, in what i can only say was a very weird fight indeed.

Im not a hater and would love him to do well - but i cannot see him above Jamie Moore or Carl Froch based on achievements so far as M'Baye was a load of pony anyway who lost against Kotelenik in my opinion in that 'draw'.... i wouldn't put him even above Colin Lynes or Ted Bami.. let alone Hunter or some of the others.

Dirk Kelly wrote:1. Calzaghe
2. Hatton
3. Haye
4. Woods
5. Arthur
6. Enzo Mac
7. Witter
8. Moore
9. Elcock
10. Rees

11. Khan
12. Frotch
13. Hunter
14. Earl
15. Dunne
16. Pryce
17. Matthews
18. Duddy
19. Skelton
20. Thaxton
21 Johannesson

Johannsson vote will be ignored.

1 Calzaghe
2 Hatton
3 Haye
4 Witter
5 Maccarinelli
6 Woods
7 Froch
8 Duddy
9 Arthur
10 Rees
11 Dunne
12 Cook
13 Khan
14 Mitchell
15 Lee
16 Eastman
17 Skelton
18 Thaxton
19 Hunter
20 Johannesson

Only 3 days to go.

Where's the BBN votes. C'mon lads!

8)

Yeah come on a lot of effort has gone into this over a number of weeks now so we know you are out there about the other topics on the form come on give us your top 20 and let's do this thing right!

(there's some real shockers mind you, if your list is embarrassing don't worry, I guarantee there'll be a worse one somewhere!)

You have until the end of tomorrow.

Chop chop.

1 Calzaghe
2 Hatton
3 Witter
4 Haye
5 Woods
6 Arthur
7 Maccarinelli
8 Lynes
9 Froch
10 Rees
11 Moore
12 Pryce
13 Thaxton
14 Hunter
15 Napa
16 Cook
17 Elcock
18 Williams
19 Matthews
20 Lockett


I'm sure it would be different tomorrow. McIntyre, Johannson, Jennings, Khan, Francis, Lockett et al....are worthy candidates. . No Eastman seems hard to fathom too, but he's not a winning fighter poresently. If he beats Duddy he could crack the top 12. Cook is hard to place too.

DavidPayne wrote:1 Calzaghe
2 Hatton
3 Witter
4 Haye
5 Woods
6 Arthur
7 Maccarinelli
8 Lynes
9 Froch
10 Rees
11 Moore
12 Pryce
13 Thaxton
14 Hunter
15 Napa
16 Cook
17 Elcock
18 Bami
19 Williams
20 Matthews


I'm sure it would be different tomorrow. McIntyre, Johannson, Jennings, Khan, Francis, Lockett et al....are worthy candidates. Bami arguably lucky to be there given his activity. No Eastman seems hard to fathom too, but he's not a winning fighter poresently. If he beats Duddy he could crack the top 12. Cook is hard to place too.

Bami cannot be included as he isn't Bitish, Irish, or has fought for a British or Irish title. The decision was made earlier in this thread to exclude British Residents, as it could change at any time and was too complicated to maintain.

Please let me know what you want to do.
Sorry mate.

sEE ABOVE

Cheerz

Last day guys.

Emerson Poncey Name Ghent wrote:Last day guys.

whens the deadline? Im busy till 5

1. Calazage
2. Hatton
3. Haye
4. Witter
5. hmmmm finnish later

Phenomenal-Nutrition wrote:

Emerson Poncey Name Ghent wrote:Last day guys.

whens the deadline? Im busy till 5

1. Calazage
2. Hatton
3. Haye
4. Witter
5. hmmmm finnish later

Midnight tonight mate. I already have yours.