granberry wrote:scartissue wrote:
My opinion of Jimmy Young... I never felt he was a body puncher,
Tell that to Lyle, Ali and Foreman. LOL
strictly a head-hunter with absolutely no punch whatsoever.
Ali had a broken eardrum after his fight with Young.
The doctor who examined Foreman after his fight with Young said Foreman had a concussion.
I'd hate to see what condition these guys would have been in
if Young had been able to punch.
.
G-Berry, I'm totally stymied at your assertion that Jimmy Young was a body-punching banger. I can think of no other fighter in the annals of pugilism which that description contradicts than Jimmy Young. Unless of course you're also going to try to convince us that Rocky Marciano was a smart boxing southpaw or Jack Sharkey was a cool-headed strategist or Roberto Duran was a cross-dresser on weekends when he would wait for ships to come in at the Panama canal.
Jimmy Young was a very nice boxer with a great jaw who had a sharp punch (not hard) in his prime that turned into a slap after the Norton fight, his last fight where he was in shape. I don't want to knock Jimmy Young, I liked him very much when others found him dull. I saw the thinking brain he utilized in fights and appreciated his skill, but he was no body punching banger!!!!
Here is a quote from the well respected boxing writer Dick Young after Young's fight with Joe Roman. "Jimmy Young didn't take out Joe Roman. Jimmy Young couldn't take out Mrs. Young for dinner. He can't punch. He hit Joe Roman all night, closed both eyes, and at the end of 10 dreadful rounds, Joe Roman was doing more punching than Jimmy Young. Jimmy Young got the decision, but he was the worst looking winner since the 1950 Phillies. In the end the crowd booed Jimmy Young. Jimmy Young had powder-puffed himself out of the title shot. However, there were two dissenting votes. Muhammad Ali and Don King. And those are the only two votes Jimmy Young needs." Now, if you think Dick Young had an axe to grind against Young (since you are the conspiracy theorist on this group), this is what Dick Young had to say after the Ali fight. "Ali is still the champion this morning thanks to 3 hero worshipping judges." Indeed, Dick Young scored the fight for Jimmy Young.
G-Berry, you see, it's not just Dick Young, Rick Farris or myself that think Jimmy Young couldn't skin a peach with his punch (an apt description used many times by boxing writers calling Young's ability), it's the rest of humanity as well. I love reading your posts but your description of Jimmy is simply contrary with reality.
Scartissue