BoxRec

1 vic
2 mundine
3 katsidis
4 bika
5 meehan
6 soliman
7 ndou
8 geale
9&10 dib or kickett
st clair,pittman and zappa just missing out
alot of room for movement though with hopefully some big fights for alot of these boxers on the horizon


only threw this list together quickly

My list:

Darchinyan
Katsidis
Geale
Mundine
Meehan
Ndou
Bika
Dibb
Soliman
Porky

Voting has now closed.

Marlin wrote:My list:

Darchinyan
Katsidis
Geale
Mundine
Meehan
Ndou
Bika
Dibb
Soliman
Porky

Voting has now closed.

no Kickett?

I dont rate Kickett!

The Official Australian Boxing Forum P4P Rankings
As voted by forum members.

1. Michael Katsidis
2. Vic Darchinyan
3. Anthony Mundine
4. Daniel Geale
5. Lovemore N'dou
6. Sakio Bika
7. Sam Soliman
8. Kali Meehan
9. Billy Dib
10. William Kickett

toppity wrote: no Kickett?

Of course not and I can't believe he still made the top ten.

I think the more startling omission was Darchinyan from unleash, cost him the number one spot...

I think thats a bad list.

How Vic is #2 is beyond me.

Who has Katsidis beaten? Thats better than who Vic has beaten.

Vic just knocked out a title holder in 5.

Ultimateboxa2 wrote:I think thats a bad list.

How Vic is #2 is beyond me.

Who has Katsidis beaten? Thats better than who Vic has beaten.

Vic just knocked out a title holder in 5.

How did I know you would be the first one to have a whinge...

Marlin wrote:

Ultimateboxa2 wrote:I think thats a bad list.

How Vic is #2 is beyond me.

Who has Katsidis beaten? Thats better than who Vic has beaten.

Vic just knocked out a title holder in 5.

How did I know you would be the first one to have a whinge...

I just thought it was common sense. Vic has to be #1. Katsidis struggled to take down a veteran, defending his interim title. Vic has taken down two title holders recently. 1 was scored a draw, poorly.

sorry big fish, didn't include vic as he is listed most places as armenian, even on boxrec ratings. he isn't listed on a lot of aussie ratings either. as a matter of fact either is geale in last two fist magazines. wonder what nationality he is??

Ultimateboxa2 wrote:

Marlin wrote:

Ultimateboxa2 wrote:I think thats a bad list.

How Vic is #2 is beyond me.

Who has Katsidis beaten? Thats better than who Vic has beaten.

Vic just knocked out a title holder in 5.

How did I know you would be the first one to have a whinge...

I just thought it was common sense. Vic has to be #1. Katsidis struggled to take down a veteran, defending his interim title. Vic has taken down two title holders recently. 1 was scored a draw, poorly.

champ, of all people you should know, common sense is not very common. That verteran is one of the best LW fighters in the last decade.

big thanks to Marlin for compiling the list.

8)

how often will it be reviewed? or will it be on an as needed basis?

unleash06 wrote:sorry big fish, didn't include vic as he is listed most places as armenian, even on boxrec ratings. he isn't listed on a lot of aussie ratings either. as a matter of fact either is geale in last two fist magazines. wonder what nationality he is??

No worries mate, your list is your list and that is fine. When one of the fighters has a fight we can vote to adjust the rankings anyway...

c'mon topp, boxing has only been going on in this kid's world for the last 6 months.

toppity wrote:big thanks to Marlin for compiling the list.

8)

how often will it be reviewed? or will it be on an as needed basis?

It will be on an as needed basis, each time one of the ranked fighters or fringe fighters has a fight we can vote on moving them in the list. Only the fighter that fights can move (apart from one place up or down to accommodate a move).

Pretty much following the rules from Current Scene...

Liver Crusher wrote:I dont rate Kickett!

didn't think so..... couldn't find him on your list. come to think of it...I couldn't find your list.

unleash06 wrote:

Liver Crusher wrote:I dont rate Kickett!

didn't think so..... couldn't find him on your list. come to think of it...I couldn't find your list.

:P

adamheight , im not a hater of mundine but some people think he is such a better fighter than soliman because hes 3-0 up on him when the scorecard could quite easily be 2-1 solimans way. iv always been a big soliman fan so im probly being biased ranking him ahead of mundine but hell solimans always chased after the best fighters in his division, and mundine still chooses to fight guys he knows dont stand a chance just to keep his record intact.

Edited.

I suggest you stop dribbling sh*t trying to big note yourself...

Marlin wrote:I suggest you stop dribbling sh*t trying to big note yourself...

Soliman didn't win either of 3 fights.

Dying to hear about this big opponent!!

Probably a rematch with Crazy Kim.

Liver Crusher wrote:Dying to hear about this big opponent!!

Probably a rematch with Crazy Kim.

No. Its Pac Man.

Who Manny??

Yer that would be right! he would go for someone half his weight!!

Liver Crusher wrote:Who Manny??

Yer that would be right! he would go for someone half his weight!!

Yeh its Manny Pacquaio.

Otherwise he may give Rico Chong Nee a rematch.

Or potentially Rashid Matumla "Snake Boy".

All 3 are very worthy.