Page 1 of 1

PF final score question?

Posted: 28 Feb 2010, 08:23
by jonp
Just looking at the scores in the Prizefighter final and see that one judge gave it 28 27 iv wracked my brains how this could be but even with the knockdown cant see where the missing point is?

Anybody got any ideas?

Re: PF final score question?

Posted: 28 Feb 2010, 08:34
by pnejon
i noticed that too......maybe they scored it Round 1) 9-9 .... Round 2) 9-9 .....Round 3) 10-9. That adds up but can you score like that?

Re: PF final score question?

Posted: 28 Feb 2010, 08:36
by jonp
No they ue a ten point must system some one ha to get ten,unles maybe a point is taken but i dont think there was

Re: PF final score question?

Posted: 28 Feb 2010, 08:40
by STEVE WOOD
Hi Jon ,

Been thinking about thisto and Jamie Moore has come up with the only logical solution that we can think of.

10- 9 Brett, 10 - 9 Brett and the 10 - 7 Aron for the last round.

Mad but may be the answer ??

steve wood

Re: PF final score question?

Posted: 28 Feb 2010, 10:16
by jonp
yeh i think yr right Steve but no way was that lat round 10.7 i thought brett was winning it till the knockdown possibly a case for a ten.9 even with the knockdown,I think that judge whoever it was realy wanted a Arron win

Re: PF final score question?

Posted: 28 Feb 2010, 11:10
by alexpaterson
Was thinking the same when it was announced. Maybe a mistake by the MC or Steve your seems the most logical

Re: PF final score question?

Posted: 28 Feb 2010, 15:25
by maninthemiddle
10-7 can only be awarded when "the winner was virtually all over the opponent who was sent down for at least 2 counts."
I think there is an issue with avoiding draws in PF, but I leared on Friday thet the referee has the deciding vote so there isn't a problem really.
I think in this instance 10-7 must have been awarded but i'm not sure why. Sky could have been a bit clearer on this issue, hopefully BN will clear up on Friday.

Re: PF final score question?

Posted: 28 Feb 2010, 15:38
by damianhucker1
i noticed this too , couldnt figure out why so just put it down to me being thick :DDD

Re: PF final score question?

Posted: 01 Mar 2010, 10:07
by Wales
maninthemiddle wrote:10-7 can only be awarded when "the winner was virtually all over the opponent who was sent down for at least 2 counts."
.
Why at least 2 counts? You can have an opinion that the round was a 10-8 due to dominance, then another point off for one knockdown.

there wasnt enough dominance for a 10-8 to begin with though.