BoxRec

Chauncy Welliver is the only real boxer who has took part in BoxRecSim and he actually managed himself! Should he be inducted into the Hall of Fame on the back of this?

My vote is no. He didn't achieve anything in the game (the real boxing if you ask me), there is no history of anything he did to refer to and to put it bluntly isn't all that great as a boxer and GREAT is what you have to be to get into the HOF.

My vote is NO and here is why:

Neri wrote:He didn't achieve anything in the game

Nuff said really.

Neri wrote:Chauncy Welliver is the only real boxer who has took part in BoxRecSim and he actually managed himself! Should he be inducted into the Hall of Fame on the back of this?

My vote is no. He didn't achieve anything in the game (the real boxing if you ask me), there is no history of anything he did to refer to and to put it bluntly isn't all that great as a boxer and GREAT is what you have to be to get into the HOF.

I strongly disagree with the first part he is not the only "real" boxer that has taken part

p4p1 wrote:

Neri wrote:Chauncy Welliver is the only real boxer who has took part in BoxRecSim and he actually managed himself! Should he be inducted into the Hall of Fame on the back of this?

My vote is no. He didn't achieve anything in the game (the real boxing if you ask me), there is no history of anything he did to refer to and to put it bluntly isn't all that great as a boxer and GREAT is what you have to be to get into the HOF.

I strongly disagree with the first part he is not the only "real" boxer that has taken part

p4p1 wrote:

Neri wrote:Chauncy Welliver is the only real boxer who has took part in BoxRecSim and he actually managed himself! Should he be inducted into the Hall of Fame on the back of this?

My vote is no. He didn't achieve anything in the game (the real boxing if you ask me), there is no history of anything he did to refer to and to put it bluntly isn't all that great as a boxer and GREAT is what you have to be to get into the HOF.

I strongly disagree with the first part he is not the only "real" boxer that has taken part

Don't listen to what Kevo tells you, that "15 round slugfest with Butterbean" was actually just a drunken shag with some fat bird from Runcorn.

Marlin wrote:

p4p1 wrote:

Neri wrote:Chauncy Welliver is the only real boxer who has took part in BoxRecSim and he actually managed himself! Should he be inducted into the Hall of Fame on the back of this?

My vote is no. He didn't achieve anything in the game (the real boxing if you ask me), there is no history of anything he did to refer to and to put it bluntly isn't all that great as a boxer and GREAT is what you have to be to get into the HOF.

I strongly disagree with the first part he is not the only "real" boxer that has taken part

http://boxrec.com/list_bouts.php?human_ ... &cat=boxer
Might disagree with you, He is by far the best boxer to compete in the Sims.

I vote yes

Yes

yes.

yes

yes....Welliver should be an honored participant by all means.

ben k wrote:

Marlin wrote:

p4p1 wrote: I strongly disagree with the first part he is not the only "real" boxer that has taken part

http://boxrec.com/list_bouts.php?human_ ... &cat=boxer
Might disagree with you, He is by far the best boxer to compete in the Sims.

I wasn't disagreeing that he wasn't the best only that he wasn't the only "real" boxer to j
have competed in the sim

p4p1 wrote:

ben k wrote:

Marlin wrote:

http://boxrec.com/list_bouts.php?human_ ... &cat=boxer
Might disagree with you, He is by far the best boxer to compete in the Sims.

I wasn't disagreeing that he wasn't the best only that he wasn't the only "real" boxer to j
have competed in the sim

I wasn't agreeing either. Mr Maskiell is by far the best fighter that manages in the sims.

Oh yeah!

p4p1 wrote:

Are you Mr. Maskiell?

you know it

So doesn't this make the whole vote for Chauncy void? The vote was started on the assumption he was the only real boxer to have competed. Or are we placing the importance and real motive for the vote on the fact he was the only real boxer to manage himself in the game?

Neri wrote:So doesn't this make the whole vote for Chauncy void? The vote was started on the assumption he was the only real boxer to have competed. Or are we placing the importance and real motive for the vote on the fact he was the only real boxer to manage himself in the game?

Or I could get in by default ya know cheat my way into the sim HOF

DetroitHxC wrote:

Chauncy wrote:Oh yeah!

Did you manage yourself? What was your record?

Poor, at a guess.

Kronkpride's continual Chauncy tubthumping makes me vote no.

Chauncy is in then I suppose.